High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4659/2006allowed

(O&M) Harpreet Singh Chahal v. Gopal Gupta

2015-07-29Mr. Justice Harbans Singh Rai14 pages

! ! " & !!'" #$% #

" $( )*$ +,, $$$$

% ! &' &( %% )*& ' &

"+,-- %' .

&

' &( %# (/

&' &

"+,-- %

.

&' &

"+-0 %# &' &

"+-0 $$$$ 1 *2/

( ) * 3 4/ 3 5 1) * /

3 $$$$ -./0123422515622 4

"

+,--

6

) *

$$ *

/2 4 ( 2

*

--78-7 2 *

78574 (

2 /

2 * / 4 ( /2"

/

/2

4

"

+,-- 4

"

+- 0

( /2 2 * (( 8

( * *

"

+,--&/ 4 "

) *

* *4

/

"

+-0 -54748628/92-1.52/:

5 '* 2&2(

/2 & (

* 9 (

*

*

(

2 2

( /

( 2 2 /

/ (

2

$5$ (

2 2

/

:

* & ( 2

* ( * * * /

/ ( 4

"

2 2

8 2 *

--78-7 *(

2 / * 2

& (

( 2 (

/ ( /2 $( (

** 9(

/

2

2

2

(

/2 / :

* *

222-1.54858 , 4

& (

"

+,-- * :

* ( * 2

* (

*

2 / 7 ( :

* &/

(

$,$ ) * 4 2

/2 $(

( 4

(

* ( ( *

2-

2 , /*

(

/

) * *

*8

/ // 4 /

2

2 ( 2 * (

(

:

* ( / ; -12256/9242 4

/ ( 6* * 6

2

( 2

/

*

(

* 2

** 9 (

2 /2 &* 2&

*

2/ ( (

& (

2

&& ( 2(

2

/

$$

4

(

*

2 &

* /2 ;( ( (

(

2

(

/

- 4 & (

"

+-0( **

(

/2

& * 2&

*

*/2 2 (

2 /

2

&& ( 6

*4

/2(2

* 2 /2

(

2

'

*& (/ (

/

6 ( / ( 2

&( 8*

&

7 ( (

24

(

*6 *

2

* ( (

/

:

2

'

(&

(

$-$

( * (

( 6

) *

( & :

*

* /

2 5<5=<=<

= 4 :

2*

( 22(

* / 4

&

*&

&(( 2 / 2 2 *

&( / *6 * ( /

2 ( / 2 ( 4

(

!

"# $%& % &

(

(

/

2/

(

; 485<.5324858=>6124278 52.556565292475.82.612/48 4*

*

(* 2

8

*

* *

$$ 8

/

* 2

8

2 '

( /2&2

2& ( ( 8

2/

' * 2 /2 &

(

6

(

& / ** 2

:

* 8

* 9

* &

* 4 *

/

8

7 9

7 / *

*/

2 (

( */ 2 9

& & *

2 6

8 /

* 0 >* * ( (

2 :

/

&( *

((

2

/ /

9

8

29

2& :

& 2/

(

6

) * 2 &

9 &

$0$

&(

( 2:

/

(

)2 / 2 4

' "(

%"& ' )! "* +% &

,+& * (

6

68

2 2

6 * *

&& (

6 (

2

(

:

9

2 * & (

/(

* (

(

/

+

(

/ ?

& /

2

) *

*&

2/8*

* 8( 8

*(

( ) ; 2236248.576819542222/4 8=.3.2/152824858 4( *2 *

2 * ( ) * 9

( ) *

/2

(

* 9( 2

8

9 6

(

(

* (

$8*

*

$$

* * 7 (

9 ( 2

*

( (

&

* 4(

8 9(

8 ( * / 9(

6 / * / *

2 / ( *

6

) * '

*

2(

/ &/

*

2

7 &9(

2 ( 2

2

2 6 4

*4

2&&/

(

* 9(

&&

2

* ; 4.5224?1247429242-5242:- 542 @ * ( ( *

(

1 (

29 '( *6

/

9 (

4*

8 2

/ /

A (( *6

9

$$ 2/

/

* 9

&&

7 /

9

* &(( 8 *

* :

( 2( &((

2

* (

& (

* (( 4

1

) * *

/2 ( / ( *&

/2

(

"

+,--

* 2

/

; 42.5 6487 48 654121 52 125 65187 4

< =( :

9 * (

(

6

) * B

( C

2 2

*

2&:

* * / 5<5=<

= * /

89

*

9*6 *8

* 7 ) * &

2

* 2/

29

(

/( &( & * &

2

$$

/ :

* 4 *

*(4

8

* ) *

< =' * &*&

* / / 2 8 / / 2 4 / 4 /

A * (

*

1

((

(/ :

6

&4 /

/

*

/ 2 4 /

( (6 1 4 /

/ *

*

* 2 * &

& 9 * &

( * ( 4 **

(

**

(

9

(/

&

2

* (8

**

(

9 -

)/" " '

*

"

(

**

(

4

( /

2 &

(/

2

$$

2 (

5

*

( (

* /

7 & / /) /

* 4 /

2

:

"

8*

( 2 *

) *

) * &

/ ( 2

2

* / 9

&& 8

* / (

/

(

2/

2

*) * 9

/

/

2(

2 *) * & /6

/ 9(

&& ) *

< = /

( ( :

/ /2 )

(

: *

& )

$5$ @ .>24674:24122-14 ,

& ( 2

2

2 8

/

9(

/27 22( (

* / @ 2( (

/ (

(

)

2( (

2*4

( //

* /2 / (

8

/

)

29 ( (8

&

/

2( 2 /

2

)

2&( /

*(2/

( * *

) *

4

/

D2/

( 8 &8 A

2 (

2E

/

/ 6 8

/

4 A

*2

'

2 *

/ /6

/2 9

/ ( (

( ( /9 /

2 4 ( / *

$,$ @ 62 9

) *

( / / *

"

+,- -

(

"

+-0

*

*

- * *

/ ",,%

)