High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4928/2015allowed

H.S. Dhillon (Retd) v. Akhilesh Kumar Sinha

2022-09-22Mrs. Justice Manjari Nehru Kaul34 pages

! " $% &# ! "# $ $

% # ! '$ ( & $ ) ( '*# + ,'+-.$ ) '

/#0 $ ) '$& 1

% #& / 2

#3 3 -# 3 4565

7$$# 7

3 )

(

)

# 68 9 !#-:

$ 6; <$ = +

3 # (# ) # ( # >66> () (

( ( 86 ) (

>66)

(

$ (

3 /

(

7 = # # )

>664

$?;4@@?4 <" #)) : A

=B6664

( ) 7 ()

( 3 7)

)

# 68

$ ( ( (

(# ( ( (# # # # C#7@@ #

37 ( # )

6 (

( (

)

7 2 / 7

/ #3 )

3 ) % # .65> 65?

3 3#

7 $

( # .65> 65?

3/ % 3

7 3# ( 3 $ )

*#3 E

( C# ) (

3 C#7 C#

# (# )

( C# 7 #7

( # 7 7 52? D #

)

7 3 7 64 / ( )

D 7 7 3 0#76>()(( % 7 $ 6>)

7 #

-# 3 )# 3#

( ( ( ) 3 / ( (% 3 '3A # *#3

C# )

3 7

(

% ( #

# .7

?( ( (%

' .)7 # #

#3 # A( # #3 (

3 6F 7 8 7 )7 / # ) ) (

# (

3 ) 7

(# )

(C# 7 -

D ( # ( C# 7

#3 A ( # ) C# )

# (

7 (

#7 7

3 7) 7 #

3( #7

$ G#?7 3 # 7

0#6> / ( 66@ (

( # C#7 76/ 3

7 ?-

7 = ( ( # 7

# (6;64'76>/

?# 7 7( D 7( 0#76> 7

( 6;64 # # )

8864 / A

(

# C#

$ 64 = ) 3 )/ # ( (7 ( 3 7 3 0#6> 86>6@

>6@ ( #3 7 ( 3#

?7 # ( # ( 7

D/ (

# (

# -# 3(

# B 8 # 6 !3 (

( #

# # # 3 7

-# -# ( 3 )

;>6> ()

( ( #7

7 7 # (

# B 8 #?$!( 7 3 A( # 3 )

(

( )

% (

(

# 3

#- # # C#

#3 )

3# C#

#3 () # C# C#

)

#33#

= ) ) )

3 *#3 / #3 %

# = # # .6 ;

3 . 7

3 (

7 #3 & # (

( C#

( D

)

# ( ( 7 # #) #

3 # ( ( # # &# (

; ( 8

) ( 3?

3% 3?# ( #3

7 ( ( )

D / # 3 7

D 5H # .686@ 65?

#3 (#

3 3# (

)

#3 C#

377

( :

)

7 )

3C#

33#

() $$# 7( )

3 7 C# ( 3#

)

# 3 )7 #3

7 # ) # ( # 3

$ $# 7 7

)

#3 # 3 (

( 3- 3# C# )7 3# $$# 7 -#

#( # ( 3#

3 ( ( 3# ( # D

)

# ( ( 3

# ) 7 $ $# 7 #3 -# 3)7 # $$# 7

() I)# # )

J ( 7 3 +#

!#-,7 ( +#

3 # 7 3 ) # # # # # 37

3 $ $# 7 I)# # )

(

3 -# 3 A # (

3 7 ( ( 3 (

3 ( 3 ) 3

3 # 7

)7 3 # 3#

C# # 68 $ 7 # # # #3 $ $# 7 ) )

3 73#

3 () #

3 $ $# 7

( (

3 (

(

# # D

# 3 #3 -# 3 (

K )7

# 3

C# 3 # # 3

7 )

7 (

# 7

# # C# C#

# 7 #3 (#

C# 7

C# (

# # 68 $ )

#3 # D )

( 3 # 7#

( ) # 3# #

7 3

( ( 3 #3 C#7

)

3 % # # 3# ((

L) 3 )

( )

( #3 3 ?

(

( # #

(

# (

# # ( )7

3 ) 7$$# 7

( (

#3 & #

(

( #3

3# #

D # )C# 7 # $$# 7# 7 7 K?4 - $(

(78 3#

) # (

7 # 3# # #

# ( 3# # 7) 3( 7 (

( # )

#3 # 3# ( ( 3 3

)# ##)77 )

( #3 )

7 (

) (7(

7() $$# 7 # 37 # ) #3 (# 7 ( )#3 ( ) #

7 # )

3 7 $$# 7 ( # 3 3 -#

)

# $$# 7 7D -#

( )

3( -# 3

(

) $$# 7 ((

#3 ( ( # (# D )

7( 3 3 ( # 7 4 # C# # ) ( 3

C# 7

( ( )

# #

% ( ##7 # )() ( ()

(

( ( (# ) 3 # 7#3

L( ) A

$7#3#

- D 3

7 (7

7 (# #7 ( C# 7 (

#3 3 ?

() #33 3 5 7 -# 3 %

(

73 # # 7 (

3 3

# # ( ) 3

# # #3

7 # 3 ( 7 (#( # 3 I $ J 57 ) 3

7 )

) # (

# 7 #

3 3 ) # 57 A # # #'()*+(,+-$).*//+/+- 01 ,+- 2,3+" 4

5.3 67 '+-8+.3 $).*/ 01 $295(1/+.%2:+("$ .-).5$7'$+1)%2:+(01 $2.9+(+(+;+." $7'5/:9+2-1/+.01+0+)9 211+).+.*-" < $467'$/+=2.3+-++)01+(+>+. +1" $ <<7 '$)99+-).*+::+ 01 +:3/+ $/5.>"

$ 47'

+(?+3) 99+(01()**).95($).*/"5-/) )*/2(3 7'@1$)-05(35*01$:3 1/+$)" 5-/) )*/ 2(37 'A% %2:+(51+. 01 +>+155)+." +9(+1 )*/ 2(3 67 '$8553> 01 +=51/ %2:+(" 4 $ .-).5

7'% /,(+01+.;)3.95(%+2("6 $ .-).5

7+.9'+3/+B558+.011/=%2:+(" 4$ .-).5

<< ! )7

# #

# 3 # #3

7 $ $# 7 #

)

( (

# ( ( 3# 7

7 7

( #

# # = #

3 )

3( D 5H # .686@ 65?

3/ # )73# 3( # (

# ( # # )73# C# (

( )

( -# 7

3 -

7 % 7 %

( )

(

7 3 (

(

7 ( #

)

/ # 3# 3 #

#3 ( (

(# # # ( )7

( C#

#3 () 37

)

(

DA( 3# $$# 7 37 ) # #3 ( ;(

( )7 ? 65 # (

#3 7 = # 65

3 / # 3# ) (

; ( 3(

#3 ) # #

# (7 3 %# ;(

( ?7 ( ( # ( ( ( - # #

(

( 37

7$$# 7 # $$# 7( 7-#

7 ) 3

3 % 3

3 73

# =

K ( 3

# C# )7 #3

( ( ) #3 & # ) 3 # # ( # (

) 73# )

3 7 #

7 7

# # %3#

( 37 (

3( # C# ( % 3

7 )

# # C# #3 )

3# ( C#

3 ) )

% 7

C# #3#

(

3 ( ( # 3 3

#3( # % 3 #

73 ( 3

) D A( )73# 7

( 3##

3(7( 3 # #

# .7

# 3 7 )

C# 3# D

A( 73# 7

)

(

# # )# ?

)

# )#

3 $ $# 7 (

# 7 3 7)

7A # #'+>+ +.) +.3/5(01$/+??)( /:59"

5.3 64 7 ').9213+. 53(-52: (, #39 01 )-?+/+( $).*/" $ <& ' $/+.:2*+: 01 ()>+ %1/+3()>+ +;+=2-+ A+:1+3/2 +9+-+>+ +.9/+0+.+

+(),+-+.+) $+.*+: 5,(515.359 ?> )31 (51)95.3 53C" 6

67'();/21/+. +.3/5(01$+.;+>+(;+) +.3/5("

7 +.9 '@1 %+)3/+- (0)1). $3(5 01 $+.;+> +.1+- +.3/5(")0)-,,5+-< 4<

A ) # 2 ) # ) $# (# )

)

# (

3 # ( = # # ).9213+.

53(-52:(,#39"1C+15 12,(+ & $ ( 3 # (

3 #

3 ) # 3

3 -#

A( # # ?

! ""

#! ""

$""

# %

(

$""

)

( 7 =$D#

3 7 $ $# 7 3

7 # ) 3

3 )

# ( / #3

( ( #

)

( / $ $# 7 ( 3# 7 ( # E 7

3 ( D 5H # .686@ 65?

#3 ) 3

3 7 7 3 )

# A(#

$ (

++++

,- ,-

" $

, -

" .

( 1"

234

$ #

3 )

7 % 3)

C# # I

#7 3J 7

72 ( # /# C# (

# 7 / 3

# (

# D

#7 3J (

I( J A

#7 3 7 #

3 3 )

#7 3 7 #

# ( =

D 5H

# # .686@ 65?

3 (#

C# M (

) % 7 C#

3 ( #3

)

#3 (

#3(

# = # $# )

# (

) )#7 #33 C#)

# 3

?D 3D3#

7C# (3

3 )7

3 ( K?4 - $)

3 ) 7

(3 /

6 ( #

3 6 # 7 K?4 #

8 # 3 65=D6= 65=D68= 68=D6= )73#

6 )= )

# 368=D6=( 3# # 77 (

) ( 7

/ ) ( )$$# 7

3 ( 3# 7 # ) 7

3 )

/$$# 7 37(

# C# %

7 3# - (

/ # C# ( # 7> ( C# (

= = ) (7( ()

/$$# 7 % # C# (# ) 3 ( # # ( 3

# ) (

( ( ( 7 / 7

3 -# 3C# 7 - # $ $# 7 37

37 )

I)# # )

J 7C#3

# 7 (

% ?

()#

3 7 7 ( I)# # )

J 7 37 (# ) 3 C#

#( 7D

7 / 37 )

) 3

# (

7 7

# # %

( -#

A (# # D ) #

3 # $

( 3#

(

)

#3 # /

3 ( 3 77 -#

#3#

(

3 (

3( ') #-

3 # (#

3 # $ $$# 7( -#

C# 73# (

3 3 7 / $ $# 7 ( 3 # 3 ( )

#3 ( C#

( C#

(

D # =

/ = $D # '2-(+; $).*/ (58+- 01 +(?+.1$).*/" 6 $4&( D 3C# ( ?

3# ?D (

( #3) (

)

?D (#

E# = # # ( 3 )) ( '%+(2.+=+(+.0155.+=1/)" 6$ & # ? 5

$ &

)

(

)

(

E# 7 '5/:9+ 2-1/+." 12,(+ = # # ?

) (7

37 # D

7( #

# ?

3# (

3# /

7 $ $# 7 )

( .( 3 #

( ( ) #3# # 3 & ) 3; 3?# #3 3( #

?# / $ $# 7 3

)

3 7 ) 3

( ) 7 $ $# 7 7 # A

)

C# C# 7 (

) ( =$D# +-8+.3$).*/"1C+15 12,(+ &

(# (# C# # #

)#) #33 ) ( (# C#= ## # C# 7(

) ( #

) 7 = $D # '$/)0 $+(2, 2,3+ 01 ( +/51/ /+.9 2,3+" 6 4 ( ( (

)

(# 3/5-+8951.3 C::+.9 ( C:,5- 3/5 -+.9-(9 3 1D255E5 /):15- +.9 -)05 ). -5115(1,+C51+13,(35C33/535.+.3"1C.3).259CC2,+3). 3/5 35.+.359 ,(5:)151 E# = # #

(+3)0+50)01A%()1/.+."< &

)

(

(# % 3

( 7 (

#3 3

)

(

)

C#7 / (

7 C#

# (# )) D

E# # 8 3# 6 )= $ 7

# 7 % 3

7 (

#7 3( 7 7

7 (

% ) (

) 7 A

## (

7 3# )

3 # )

/ 7 % -#

7 3?# )# 77 # # 7 (

)

C# D

C# 7

/ #

D )

#3 3 # = #

C# 3 3

) 3 #

)

7 ) - A

3 $ C# -# 3

# D

3 A (#

) C# 7 D

# - A

( %( D

;

# -#

/ = # # $+1) %2:+("1 C+15 )?)9 3 # 68 $ C# #

( #7)

3# -

) 7 -#

3 # A ( # )

C# 7 #

# #

3 -#

#3 7 # 7

# -#

3 ( (# 7 #3 3

3 A '+>+ (+1+9 0 (+955,

$()0+13+0+" $ & =##

7 # 2=

)

(

)

" "

)

1 >

)

(

" " "

(

)

( "

"" '

++++

( "

)

++++

)

(

)

++++

)

A ( >66> (

( D

(# 7 ) 7

( C#

#3 / 76>(

(

7 76/ (

7 $$# 7 7 65 )

)

#/ 3

7 =## +>+ (+1+9"1C+15 12,(+ (

)

# C# ) #3 3 3# #

# 3 7 )

(# C#

/ 3 #3 ( 7

# # # C# 7

D 3

#3 3( ( C# )

# . 7

( 3

7 7

( ( 3

#33( 7 7% # % # /

3 )7 3# 3/ D # ((7 (

#3 # )

# ) #

. # % -

3 )

# % 3#

# 3

)

()

# 3 ) 7

) # 3)

# C# #)

7 (#

/ )

(

3 (# 7

3 (

# C# 7 37 37 $ $# 7 ) # 3 7

3 (

# ) ( # # ( 3 D

3 ()

7 $ $# 7 ( (

# # A (# # D )D 6 (

0 ;

(

25$

/$$# 7 (

#( ) # 6 @

0 "

# $ $# 7

)7 #

C#C# 3#

# ) 7 ) 3 #

7 C#

3 ) $$# 7 7 # 7

(

7 / = # ##3 ) # # 3

3# C#

7 ) )

# 3# 3 A 3

( C#

-# D )

3C#

70# 3 7

( ) ) 7

7 (

#C# #3 ) # ( - C#

A $$# 7 -# 3 ) ( ( # 3

((

# 7 #

#3 (

) ( #7

) 3 ( 7-# ( ( ( %

)

/ (

(

L (# #7 %

( 7

7 #3 3

()$$# 7 #

)

3 % # # )

7 # ( /

# 3(

3 7

3 3# #

3 D# )

/ ( # 7 2 (#

# #3 #

3 7

7# / #3 3)

3 $ $# 7

3 )

# 3)

3 -#

( ( C#7 #3

7$ $# 7

>56

/ 2

3 8668 ))

( ) + 3 (

# (# % ) 33

3 57 ( # # #

) 3 # # ) )

# )

$$# 7( )

3( -# 3 ) #

)

( #

( 7 $ #

# 7

# )

(7 # ## 3

% # $5,35:?5(& " K % 32 N 2. K N 2.