← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4520/2018dismissed

Brahm Parkash v. Azad Singh (Since Deceased) Thr His Lrs And ORS

2019-02-04Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan5 pages



 

   

!"# $#%&'&() 

*

+!,-!+.!',  #"&"&(#+ /#+'0'

1!$2&(3,",+03,4'!($",#+'

 #'5($#("'

 ) 6 42 4  2 +#'#(") '20(&"!!-7&!+8 $/%!"#8

+",#5#"&"&(#+ +229,!+!78 $/%!"#8

++#'5($#("'( " 

4  28+!: (;

*8",# ::<&(3+$#+<!'5!''#$)=      >?&$#  ",#  +$#+  $!"#$ 

 5!''#$  &(  ",# !%%-5!(A&(3 5#"&"&(8%0('#:  +",#5#"&"&(#+,!$7##( $&+#%"#$"5:!%#(+#%+$",#+$#+'5!''#$7A",##B#%0"&(3 0+" +- 

@"&::

,#+#!

"#+8#/#("&::",# (#B"$!"# ,#!+&(38&#;

8",#(##$ 0:,!$("7##( $(#8<&",((#,!/&(3!55#!+#$ +",#5#"&"&(#+85''&7:A 7#%!0'#$#'5&"#(",!/&(3&''0#$!(A("&%#8",&'0+",!$ 5!''#$!(&("#+&-+$#+&( !/0+ ",#5#"&"&(#+$&+#%"&(3",!"

& 5!A-#(" %-5#('!"&(,!$("!:+#!$A7##(-!$#8",# #B#%0"&(30+"<0:$("$&'70+'#&""&::",#(#B"$!"#

,#!+&(3  !"  ",!"  '"!3#8  &#  "&::  ;

  ,#  5#"&"&(  ,!$ ",#+#!

"#+7##(!$C0+(#$"&::"$!A

    $!A8:#!+(#$%0('#: +",#5#"&"&(#+,!''"&::("

%-5:&#$  <&",  ",#  +$#+  $!"#$ 

8  <&",  ",#'# !55:&%!"&('' ; =!($ ;

=

*,!/&(3 &( !%"7##( &:#$7A+#'5($#("'( "8"<,-("&%#,!$ ("!%"0!::A7##(&''0#$870"7/&0':A",#A7#&(3!

#%"#$7A ",#'!&$+$#+8,!/#6%-5:&#$6<&",&"87A(<'##.&(3"5:!%# (+#%+$",#&("#+&-+$#+'5!''#$7A",##B#%0"&(0+" 7#"<##( *

@"&:: **

,#!55:&%!"&('!+#!::<#$'07C#%""!::C0'"#B%#5"&(' !($%5&#' ",#&("#+&-+$#+'5!''#$7A",!"0+" +-

*

@" **

!+#+$#+#$"7#"!.#((+#%+$!'

((#B0+# = %::#%"&/#:A   ,#!55:&%!("'=+#'5($#("'!:''##."5:!%#(+#%+$ %5&#' +$#+'5!''#$7A",&'0+"%+$&(!"# #(%,#'&(   

!($+''=7C#%"&(' =

&(",#'!-# &+'"!55#!:8",#'!&$+$#+'7#&(3 ",#$!"#'



;!($ @

@+#'5#%"&/#:A 5&#' ",#'!&$+$#+'!+#!:'+$#+#$"7#"!.#(( +#%+$'07C#%""!::C0'"#B%#5"&('8!' ((#B0+#' = !($ =;

<&",",#!%%-5!(A&(35#"&"&(

D,!"",&'0+"7/&0':A-&''#$0"(

<,&:# 3+!("&(3!(&("#+&-'"!A"",#5#"&"&(#+8 +!',+"$!"#8 ",!"",#+#&'(+$#+5!''#$&(!(A+#/&#<!55:&%!"&(7+03," "",#("&%# ",&'0+"8&(#&",#+",#!

+#'!&$ &+'"!55#!:+

;

",#$#%&'&((",#%+''7C#%"&(' &:#$",#+#"  #(%#8!'",<",##B#%0"&(0+"<0:$37#A($ <,!"<!'!<!+$#$"",#+#'5($#("'%:!&-!("'/&$#",#+$#+ 5!''#$&(",#%+''=7C#%"&('!

+#'!&$8&''-#",&(3<,&%, :#!+(#$  %0('#:  +  ",#  5#"&"&(#+  <0:$  (##$  "  !$$+#'' !+30-#("'(       ,&'&' 0+",#+(<"7#'##(<&",<,!"+9,!+!78 :#!+(#$%0('#: ++#'5($#("'( "8'07-&"'8",!"!'!

-!""#+ !%"",#'"!"#-#("'"!"#$",!/#7##(-!$#7A",# +#'5($#("'%:!&-!("'!'<!'+# #++#$"7A:#!+(#$%0('#: + ",#5#"&"&(#+(

!'+#%+$#$&(",#+$#+ ",!"

$!"#8  <!'  !%"0!::A  (#  -!$#  &(  #B#%0"&(  5+%##$&(3' 5#+"!&(&(3"",# <!+$ %-5#('!"&(-!$#7A",#+&70(!: "&' 0+",#+'##( +-",#+$#+5!''#$7A",&'0+"( @

@  &(  ",#  !

+#'!&$  %+''=7C#%"&('8  ",!"  ",# %-5#('!"&(!<!+$#$7A",#+&70(!:"",#+#'5($#("'<!' ' @8;

E= #'5($#("'( !($,#+#&(,!$-!$#!'"!"#-#("(

 

;  5!+"   ((#B0+#  =;  %::#%"&/#:A  7# +#  ",# #B#%0"&(0+"'#&1#$ ",#5+%##$&(3'50+'0!(""",!"

<!+$8",!"",#A,!$+#%#&/#$!(!-0(" ' 8* 8

E=&( ",'#  #B#%0"&(  5+%##$&(3' 7/&0':A8  ",!"  !-0("  7#&(3 ,&3,#+",!(' @8;

E=8!(A%-5+-&'#-!$#<!'(:A( ",#F0!("0- &("#+#'"<,&%,5''&7:A-!A,!/#7##(,&3,#+ &  !"  !::  '8  ",!(  <,!"  <!'  !%%#5"#$  /&$#  ",#  ! +#'!&$

 '"!"#-#("8  <,&%,  <!'  -!$#  !:-'"  G  A#!+'  7# +#  ",# %-5#('!"&(<!'#(,!(%#$"'8*8

E=87A",&'%0+"

/&$#",#+$#+$!"#$  @

@,0'8",#'"!"#-#("-!$#(

;  7#&(3  (#  &(  5+#/&0'  #B#%0"&(  5+%##$&(3' '##.&(3  #B#%0"&(    ",#  <!+$    ",#  +&70(!:8  <&",  &"'

'5#%& &%!::A'"!"#$&(",!"'"!"#-#("",!"&"<!'7#&(3-!$#(:A &(",#%("#B" ",'#5+%##$&(3'8",#%("#("&(-!$#7A :#!+(#$%0('#: +",#5#"&"&(#+(",#:!'"$!"# ,#!+&(38 <0:$  ("  '##-  "  7#  %++#%"  ",!"  (  #(,!(%#-#("  

%-5#('!"&(<!'7#&(3'03,"7A",#5#"&"&(#+ ",#+",!(",!"8"+#5#!"8:#!+(#$%0('#: +",#5#"&"&(#+ <0:$  !$$+#''  !+30-#("'  !'  "  ,<  ",&'  5#"&"&(  %!(  7# #("#+"!&(#$<&",",#+$#+5!''#$7A",&'0+"&(",#! +#'!&$ +''=7C#%"&(' &:#$&( = =

("#/#+,!/&(37##( +#/&#<#$7A",&'0+"8<&",(!55:&%!"&(,!/&(37##( &:#$

+",!"50+5'#8!($&(!(A%!'#( 0+",#+!55#!:,!/&(37##(

&:#$  $C0+(#$" 

* 7#',<(&(",#0+3#(":&'" 2&(%#( +-!:("&%#<!'#/#+&''0#$&(",&'5#"&"&(8&" &'(<&''0#$8<&",+#'5($#("'( "7/&0':A'#+/#$8 ",#A!:+#!$A7#&(35+#'#("",+03,%0('#: ,#%!'# &:#   

8&(%:0$&(3",# +''=7C#%"&('",#+#"87#50"05!:(3<&",",&'5#"&"&(H $!A8'!-7&!+8:#!+(#$%0('#: +",#5#"&"&(#+8'07-&"'

 ",!"",#5#"&"&(#+(:(3#+<&',#'"50+'0#",#5#"&"&( &'-&''#$!'<&",$+!<(  

*  

 5.

   D,#",#+'5#!.&(3E+#!'(#$

#'E D,#",#+#5+"!7:#

#'E