High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4572/2018dismissed

Vinod Kumar v. Chanderwati @ Suman Devi And ORS

2018-11-29Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary5 pages

!"# $#%&'&()

+&($,-.!/ 00#11!(" +#/'-' 2!($#/3!"&!1&!'4-.!(#5&!($!("2#/ #'0($#("'

/#'#(") / (&1,-.!/42!/.!6 $5%!"# /"2#0#"&"&(#/ / (.1!""!(4&$2-64#(&/ $5%!"#3&"2 //!$##042!/.!6 $5%!"#!($ /44!&(&6 $5%!"# //#'0($#("

2#0#"&"&(#/7"#(!("&'!88/&#5#$ 9-$8.#("$!"#$

0!''#$ :; -"2/&";6 !/&$!:!$6 32#/#:; 9-$8.#(" $!"#$

=0!''#$:;#("("/11#/6!/&$!:!$2!':##('#"!'&$##(" 0#"&"&( &1#$ :; "2# /#'0($#("71!($1/$ 3!' $&'.&''#$ :-" "2# 1#!/(#$

-"2/&";32&1#'#""&(8!'&$#"2#'!&$$#%&'&(2!'/$#/#$#5&%"&( "2#0#"&"&(#/7"#(!(" /."2#$#.&'#$0/#.&'#'

/&# !%"'!'(!//!"#$&("2#0#"&"&( &1#$:;"2#1!($1/$-($#/ 4#%"&( < !/;!(!/:!(("/1 #("5&%"&( %"6 * <!/#"2!" "2# $#.&'#$ 0/#.&'#' &# "2# '20 &( >-#'"&( 3!' "!?#( ( 1#!'# (

* < :; "2# 0/#'#(" 0#"&"&(#/ +&($ ,-.!/ ( ! .("21; /#(" ' 7@ 32&%2 3!' 1!"#/ #(2!(%#$ " ' 7@ !/1&#/6 ! 0#"&"&( '##?&(8 #5&%"&( "2#0#"&"&(#/7"#(!(" &1#$:;/#'0($#(" 3!'!113#$:;"2# 1#!/(#$ #(" ("/11#/ ( = * 00#!1 0/# #//#$ :; "2# 0/#'#(" 0#"&"&(#/3!'!1'$&'.&''#$( = *#5&'&(0#"&"&(0/# #//#$:; "2# 0#"&"&(#/ 3!' $&'.&''#$ :; "2&' -/" (

* 3#5#/6 "2# .!""#/ 3!' %.0/.&'#$ $-/&(8 "2# 0#($#(%; 40#%&!1 A#!5# #"&"&( :# /# (B:1# "2# 4-0/#.# -/" #"&"&(#/ -($#/"? " 0!; /#(" !" "2#

/!"# '=

7@0#/.("23#

*/#'#("0#"&"&(3!' &1#$( "2#8/-($"2!""2#0#"&"&(#/ !&1#$"0!;!//#!/' /#("3#

" <

:#'&$#'2!5&(8'-:1#""2#$#.&'#$0/#.&'#'3&"2-"%('#(" "2#1!($1/$"/#'0($#(" (&1,-.!/6323!'!5#//#$":#/-((&(8 2&'"&.:#/:-'&(#''-($#/"2#(!.#!($'";1# C&""!1&.:#/'64&2&!"#6

!11!:8!/2B #/'(!1 :(!

&$# (#%#''&"; 3!' !1' 01#!$#$ :#'&$#' '"!"&(8 "2!" "2# $#.&'#$ 0/#.&'#' 3#/# -('!

# !($ -( &" / 2-.!( 2!:&"!"&(

//#!/' /#(" 3#/# $#0'&"#$ :; "2# 0#"&"&(#/ 2-'6 "2# '!&$ 8/-($ ( 1(8#/ '-/5&5#$ A#!/(#$ #(" ("/11#/ $&'.&''#$ "2# 0#"&"&( 32&1# %(%1-$&(8"2!""2#1!($1/$ !&1#$"0/5#'-:1#""&(8 "2#0/#.&'#'/"2!" "2#; 3#/# -('!

# !($ -( &" / 2-.!( 2!:&"!"&( " 3!' :'#/5#$ "2!" "2# 02"8/!02' 0/$-%#$ :; "2# 1!($1/$6 "2-82 !$.&""#$ :; "2# 0#"&"&(#/ %!((":#/#1&#$-0(!'"2#/#3!'((@%.01&!(%# 4#%"&(= "2# ($&!(5&$#(%# %"C5&$#(%# %"B /'2/"

00#!1 3!' &1#$ :; "2# 1!($1/$6 32&%2 3!' !113#$ A#!/(#$

-"2/&"; /$#/#$ #5&%"&( "2# 0#"&"&(#/ /. "2# $#.&'#$ 0/#.&'#'("2#8/-($ "2#0/#.&'#':#&(8'-:1#""/#'0($#(" "&' :'#/5#$ :; 1#!/(#$ -"2/&"; "2!" "2# 0#"&"&(#/7"#(!(" !$.&""#$ 02"8/!02' "2#$#.&'#$0/#.&'#'32&%2/# 1#%"#$"&.:#/:-'&(#'':#&(8 %!//&#$ ( "2#/#&( 2#/# /#6 '-:1#""&(8 "2# 0/#.&'#' " "2# 0#"&"&(#/B' :/"2#/3!'%(%1-$#$"2!5#:##(0/5#$

88/&#5#$"2#/# /.60/#'#("0#"&"&(2!':##( &1#$ / "2# 0#"&"&(#/ 5#2#.#("1; !/8-#' "2!" '-:1#""&(8 "2#0/#.&'#'2!'3/(81;:##(%(%1-$#$":#0/5#$("2# :!'&' 02"8/!02'01!%#$(/#%/$:;"2#1!($1/$"&'%("#($#$"2!" "2# %#/"& &%!"# &( "#/.' 4#%"&( =@ "2# 5&$#(%# %" 2!' (" :##( 0/$-%#$ 2#/# /#6 "2# '!&$ 02"8/!02' !/# %1#!/1; &(!$.&''&:1# &(

< #5&$#(%# A#!/(#$ %-('#1 /#1&#' -0( "2# 9-$8.#(" (B:1# 4-0/#.# -/" 0!''#$ &( (5!/ + +' , !'2##/ !($ "2#/'6

4 </#5#/6'%!11#$!$.&''&(("2#0!/" "2#0/#'#("0#"&"&(#/&'(" /#1#5!("!'"2#'!&$02"8/!02'!/#("0/5#$(/#%/$"&'6"2-'60/!;#$ "2!""2#0/#'#("/#5&'&(0#"&"&(:#!113#$!($&.0-8(#$9-$8.#("$!"#$

0!''#$ :; 1#!/(#$ -"2/&";6 !/&$!:!$ :# '#" !'&$# !($ 9-$8.#(" $!"#$

= 0!''#$ :; 1#!/(#$ #(" ("/11#/6 !/&$!:!$:#-02#1$ / /#'0($#(" 7%!5#!"/ /# -"#' "2# '!&$ !5#/.#("'32&1#'-:.&""&(8"2!":"2"2#1#!/(#$-/"':#132!5#!//&5#$ !" ! 18&%!1 %(%1-'&( !

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

$-1;#D!.&(#$!'E E !?#'2 2!"&!6 4"/-%"-/!1 (8&(##/7 +!1-#/6 32 0/#0!/#$ "2# /#0/" /#8!/$&(8 "2# '"!"-' "2# '"/-%"-/# "2# "#(!("#$ 0/#.&'#'6 0/5#$ 02"8/!02'E7 "E7"!?#(:;2&. 11"2#'#02"8/!02'/# 1#%""2# /-((&(8 !"&.:#/'"/#!($"&.:#/%-""&(83/?'20&("2#'!&$0/#.

!($(" 88!/3!1!1#0"#'0($#("+&($,-.!/6E &(2&'%/''@ #D!.&(!"&(2!'%!($&$1;!$.&""#$"2#'!&$02"8/!02'632&1#0!/!$D&%!11; '"!"&(8"2!":!/$ &""!1&.:#/'&'(""2#/#2#(B:1#4-0/#.#-/" &( 42!

2& 2!..!$ +' 2# 4"!"# &.!%2!1 /!$#'26 4A /&.&(!1 <

$#%&$#$(<

62!'%1#!/1;2#1$"2!" -/(&'2&(8 ! %#/"& &%!"#&("#/.' 4#%"&(= "2#5&$#(%# %":#&(80/%#$-/!1%!( :#/#1!D#$:;-/"632#/#5#/&("#/#'" 9-'"&%#'9-'"& &#'2-82"2#%!'# 42!

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

* !($ !11#8#$1; '"!/"#$ !

/#'2 -($#/ "2# (!.#!($'";1# C,/&'2(!("#/0/&'#'BA#!/(#$%-('#1 /"2#0#"&"&(#/ '-82" " /#1; -0( "2# &(%.# "!D /#"-/(' ,/&'2(! ("#/0/&'#' / "2#

''#''.#(" #!/

D 6 :-" "2# '!.# &' ( !5!&1 !' "2&' &(%.#"!D/#"-/($#'("&(!(;.!((#/&($&%!"#:-'&(#'':#&(8%!//&#$( :;"2#0#"&"&(#/ /."2#0/#.&'#'&(>-#'"&(4&.&1!/1;6"2#/#&'(.#/&"&( "2#!/8-.#("/!&'#$:;1#!/(#$%-('#1 /"2#0#"&"&(#/"2!""2#1!($1!$; 2#/'#1 $&$("'"#0&(""2#3&"(#'':D6"2-'6'2#&'("#("&"1#$"!(;/#1&#

2&'&'' /"2#/#!'("2!"E 4!("!/?!'2!(8&!2!$$-1;"#'"& &#$ :# /#"2#1#!/(#$#("("/11#/#&'!$.&""#$1;"2#2-':!($ 1!($1!$; 4-.!(#5&#3!' -11;!3!/# "2# !%"' "2#%!'#!($3!'%.0#"#(" " $#0'# ( :#2!1 2&' 3& # ( "2# :!'&' 0#/'(!1 ?(31#$8# 2#/# /#6"2#0#"&"&(#/%!(("$#/&5#!(;:#(# &"(!%%-(" 1!($1!$;(" "#'"& ;&(8 2#/'#1 A#!/(#$ -"2/&"; 2!' /&82"1; '#" !'&$# "2# 9-$8.#("!($$#%/##$!"#$

=632#/#:;"2#0#"&"&(-($#/4#%"&(

< !/;!(!/:!(("/1 #("!($5&%"&( %"6 * <3!'$&'.&''#$ 2#/#'0($#("71!($1!$;2!'&($##$'-%%##$#$&('-:'"!("&!"&(82#/%!'#( "2#:!'&' "2##5&$#(%#(/#%/$ "2#/!/8-.#("2!':##(!$$/#''#$ / "2# 0#"&"&(#/ &' -(!:1# " 0&(" -" !(; &11#8!1&";60#/5#/'&";/&( &/.&";&("2#&.0-8(#$9-$8.#("$!"#$

0!''#$:;1#!/(#$ -"2/&";6!/&$!:!$32&%2%!11' /&("#/ #/#(%# :;"2&'-/"&(#D#/%&'# &"'/#5&'&(!19-/&'$&%"&( #"&"&(&'!%%/$&(81;$&'.&''#$3&"2(/$#/!'"%'"'

'23!/ E2#"2#/'0#!?&(87/#!'(#$)@ #'7 E2#"2#//#0/"!:1#)@ #'7