High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4848/2012allowed

Suresh v. Priyanka & ANR

2015-12-18Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan11 pages

!" #"$%&%'(

) *+,"&- ".%&%'%&!

/",&+& ,%0 '1 "2 '#0!% ,3 "&4'#"'!& ( 5 6*76 * ,"&"'!( ,*7 ,3 ,8 ' 9*"'%, #.$ !"98%!-9 , ""4 1# 9 #.$ !"9 ,!-",".%&%'%&! , '+4 :+4! 9*"'%, #.$ !"98%!-9 , &-17+: ,9 #.$ !"9 ,,"&4'#"'!&

;-"!-",!-""4,!",& 2$ 2'"8&4 4",: 0<" 228"#!&""!-"=+#3:"'!>

<"," ",,"#!!-""4,!",,'! ? ;-"!-",!-"=+#3:"'!&-+2#<","4,!"#%'!-"#%3"&!> 76 *9 :4+3'"# %' !-" 4,"&"'! ,".%&%' %& !-" ,#", # !"#

9 4 &&"# <0 !-" 2" ,'"# ##%!%' 2 %&!,%$! +#3"9 +,3 '9 %,:%'3 !-" ,#", # !"# @

9 4 &&"# <0 !-"

2" ,'"# ##%!%' 2%.%2+#3" *"'%, %.%&%'9+,3 '9.%#"8-%$- !-" 442%$ !%' !-" 42 %'!% & ,"&4'#"'!& -","%'9 %2"# +'#",

,#",?A+2"& '# ," #8%!-*"$!%' ) #" %.%2 ,$"#+,"9 9 8 & 228"# '# !-" #" "'# '! 4,"&"'!

,".%&%'%&!8 &,"&!, %'"# ,:#":2%&-%'3!-"4 && 3"%'B+"&!%' %' '0: ''",!%22!-"#"$%&%' !-"$ &" -" $!& !-"$ &"98-%$- ,","B+%,"#!<"'!%$"# ,!-"4+,4&" #%&4& 2 !-"4,"&"'!,".%&%'9 ,"!- !!-" 42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!&$2 %:!- !!-"0 ,"$8'",%'4&&"&&%' !-"2 '#<" ,%'37-"8 !7- ! C%'9"$! 97%2

9!! 2:" &+,%'31 ' 2&!!-""D!"'! ?

!-&- ,"

%"C1 ' 2&

: ,2 & '#"$! 97%2

!!-"

"D!"'! ?

!-&- ,"%" 1 ' 2

: ,2 &-"!! 22 '# ,:

<!-!-"1%2 &$:"&!1 ' 2&9&%!+ !"#8%!-%'!-","."'+""&! !" .%22 3"* '47% '32%9"-&%2*-' 9 %&!,%$!+,3 '-"2 '# 8 &4+,$- &"#<0!-"42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!&9.%#"& 2"#""## !"#

-" 2 '# 8 & #"."24"# <0 '& 2 +&" '# '&!,+$!%'6%:%!"# '#: ,1"# &,$- ,#

+'#",!-"

2#"',$- ,#*$-":"-"0&2#!-"& %# ,:! &-17+: , '#!-",&9.%#"& 2"#""#<" ,%'3/ &%1 ) ?# !"#

@ '#- '#"#.",!-"4&&"&&%'!!-": &-17+: ,"!$ +,!-", &2#!-"& %# ,:!!-"42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!&<08 0 & 2"#""# # !"# ?@

-":+! !%'8 & $$,#%'320& '$!%'"#!8 & +,!-", .",,"#!- ! 4 && 3"8 & 22!!"# ,%'3,"&& '#"3,"&&

? !!-" ,:!8 ,#& &!",'&%#"98-%$-%&$''"$!"#!!-": %' , #-"42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!&- ."<""'+&%'3!-"& %#4 && 3"9 8-%$-%& 4+$$ 4 && 3" ! ,$2, #-"#" "'# '!,".%&%'%&! 8 '!"#!#":2%&-!-"& %#4 && 3" '#$ 22"#!-" : $-%'"9 '"$"&&%! !%'3!-" %2%'3 !-"&+%! -" #" "'# '!,".%&%'%&!9 ' !-" !-", - '#9 $2 %:"# !- !-"%&$8'",%'4&&"&&%' 2 '#<" ,%'3"$! 97%2

9 9

)A9

? )9!! 2:" &+,%'3 )1 ' 2& : ,2 &!!-""D!"'! ?,# &- ," %& !-",*-,% :%1-%& 8'",%'4&&"&&%'!!-""D!"'! ?,# &- ,"9.%#":+! !%'

<" ,%'3)# !"#

-"42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!&- ."' $'$",'8%!-!-"2 '# #" "'# '!,".%&%'%&! '#-%& !-", 7%2 &

'# A !-"#" "'# '!,".%&%'%&! 22&!8 ,#&!-" &!",' &%#" !-"2 '#<" ,%'37%2 &

9!-"4 ,! 8-%$-%& &! !"#!<"8'"# '#4&&"&&"#<0!-"42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!& -"," %& ' 4 && 3" ! !-" &4! -" 2 '# %' B+"&!%' %& ' 3,%$+2!+, 22 '# &4",!-"4,.%&%'& +'= <*$-"#+2"# #& '# '!,22"# ," & "&!,%$!%'& ',"3+2 !"# "."24:"'!

$!9 AC?9'4",&'&- 22","$!,,"","$! '0<+%2#%'3,: 1", "D!"'# '0"D$ . !%',2 0+!9 '0:" '&, $$"&&! , #%' $'!,22"# ," 8%!-+!!-"4,%,4",:%&&%' %,"$!,98' '# +'!,02 ''%'3."' &4",!-" 9!-","%&'4 && 3"

'!-" &!",'&%#" 7%2

-": %', #%&"D%&!%'3 ! #%&! '$" E1%2:"!",& ,:!-"& %#2 '# - ." -" ,# !-" 2" ,'"# &"'%, $+'&"2 , !-" #" "'# '!,".%&%'%&!9 !-" 2" ,'"# &"'%, $+'&"2 , !-" 42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!& '#- ." 2&$ ," +2203'"!-,+3-!-" %2" -"28",+,!98-%2" 228%'3!-" 442%$ !%' %2"#<0 !-"42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!&+'#",,#",?A+2"& '# ," #8%!- *"$!%' ) 942 $"#-" .0,"2% '$"+4'!-"=+#3:"'! '# #"$,""# !"# A

A9!%!2"# &

4 &&"#%'%.%2*+%!

9#"$%#"#<0!-"

2" ,'"# %.%2 +#3" +'%, %.%&%'9 +,3 '9 <"!8""'

4,"#"$"&&,%'%'!","&! !-" 4 ,!%"& -" 42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!& - #4+,$- &"#!-"&+%!2 '# ,:'" &-17+: ,98-- # +,!-", 4+,$- &"#%! ,: '& 2+&%'3 '#'&!,+$!%'6%:%!"#!8 & <&",."#<0!-"28",+,!!- !%'!-"& %#&+%!!%!2"# &

!-"$'!,.",&0,"3 ,#%'3, #%'

B+"&!%'- &<""'&"! !,"&! '#!-"4,"#"$"&&,%'%'!","&! !-" 42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!&- ."<""'3%."'!-",%3-!!+&"!-"& :" -"," ,"9!-","%&'3,+'#!,"4"'!-"& %# %'#%'3-" %,&! 44"22 !"+,!98-%2"#" 2%'38%!-!-"& %#: !!", '##%&:%&&%'3 !-" 442%$ !%'9: #"!-" 228%'3<&",. !%'&( F

!",-" ,%'3!-"4 ,!%"& !2"'3!-9!-%&+,!%& !-".%"8 !- !2" ,'"#!,% 2+,!- &$::%!!"#'%22"3 2%!0,%,,"3+2 ,%!0<0

) "'#,&%'3!-"=+#3:"'! '##"$,""# !"# A

A98-%$-- & '!<""'&"! &%#"!%22# !"<0 '0$+,! $:4"!"'!=+,%&#%$!%' -" &&",!%' : #" ' <"- 2 44"22 '!#" "'# '! !- ! =+#3:"'! '# #"$,"" # !"# A

A %& . 3+"9 $ ''! <"

&"!!2"# !!-%&&! 3" "'$"9!-","%&':",%!&%'!-" 44" 2%' - '# '#& :"%&2% <2"!<"#%&:%&&"# ,#","#9 $$,#%'320 -","%&-8".",9',#", &!$&!& A

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

<"2'3%'3!!-"42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!&98-%$-%&!8 ,#&!-";"&!",' &%#" 7%2 &

'# A98'"#<0!-"#" "'# '!,".%&%'%&!> '!-" 9'&+$-4 && 3"%&&-8'8".",9 !-","%& 4 && 3"!8 ,#&*+!-",'&%#" 7%2 &

'# A9 <"2'3%'3 ! !-" 42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!& '# #" "'# '!,".%&%'%&! ,"&4"$!%."20

C -"2" ,'"#&"'%,$+'&"2 ,42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!&- & ! 1"'!-%&+,!!-,+3-!-"42" #%'3&%'!-"4,".%+&&+%! &8"22 & !-"=+#3:"'! '##"$,"" !-"28",+,! -"42 %'! !-" 4,".%+& &+%! !%!2"# &

&-8&!- !%'!-"& %#&+%!9 '& 2 +&%'3 '# '&!,+$!%' 6%:%!"# - # $2 %:"# !- ! !-"0 ," %' 4&&"&&%' !-"2 '#<" ,%'3"$! 7%2

)A9

? )9!! 2:" &+,%'3 )1 ' 2&: ,2 &9!!-"

"D!"'! C!-&- ,"98-%$-$:"&!1 ' 2&: ,2 &9'!-"< &%& 3,"":"'! & 2""'!","#%'!<"!8""'!-"42 %'!% %" '& 2 +&%'3 '#'&!,+$!%'6%:%!"# -","%' !",," ",,"#! &5!-"

:4 '05 '##" "'# '! %'& %#&+%!9' :"2096 1-%-"& %# 6 1-%9- #"'!","#%'! 3,"":"'!$2 %:%'3!- !-"- # $B+%,"# $$+4 '$0,%3-!&%'!-"&+%!2 '# '#- # +,!-",$2 %:"#!- !-" %2"# &+%! ,#"$2 , !%'98-%$-%&2%1"20!<"#"$%#"#&-,!20-" 3,"":"'!8 &"D"$+!"#' ?@ AA@-"42 %'!% :4 '0- # 2&$2 %:"#!- !%!%&%'"D$2+&%."4&&"&&%' &%!"5

59+4'

8-%$-%!- #$'&!,+$!"#

""!8%#"4+$$ , # !%& 2& $2 %:"#!- !%!- ##"."24"#!8&$-":"&+'#",!-"' :" '# &!02" 52#"',$- ,#&5 '#52#"'"%3-!&5 '#!-" $$"&&! !-" & %# !8 ,: -+&"& %& !-,+3- !-" & %# 4 && 3", #

$$,#%'3209%!8 &4, 0"#!- !!-"#"$2 , !%': 0<"3, '!"#!!-"

@ " "$! !- ! *+,,"'#", ""# # !"#

AAA9 3! ,"3%&!","# <0 #" "'# '! %' .+, #" "'# '! %'& %#&+%! 2'38%!- :+! !%' '#!-",,"."'+""'!,%"&%' .+, #" "'# '! ,"

.%# <%'%!% -" 4",: '"'! %'=+'$!%' 8 & 2& &+3-! , ,"&!, %'%'3!-"#" "'# '!& ,:! 1%'3 ,$%<2"4&&"&&%',#%& 4&&"&&%'3!-"42 %'!% :4 '09%'!", ",%'3%' '0: ''",%'!-" 4" $" +2+&" '#"'=0:"'! !-"&+%!2 '#:" &+,%'31 ' 2& : ,2 & '# ,:$ +&%'3 '0&,! # : 3",<2$1%'3%' '0 : ''", !-" , # "D%&!%'3 !-","+4'9 &-8' %' 2"!!",& 5

!! $-"#8%!-!-"&+%! '!-"& %#&+%!9 ="&- %' #" "'# '! 98-%& &! !"#!<"4,"#"$"&&,%'%'!","&! #" "'# '! 9- #! 1"'

!-"42" !- !!-"42 %'!% :4 '0%&'!%'4&&"&&%' C!-&- ,"

!-"&+%!2 '# !8 & #:%!!"#!- !!-"42 %'!% :4 '0- & %22"3 220 '# ,$%<20$'&!,+$!"#!-", # <+!

""!8%#"8%!-+!

!-"'!%$" '#1'82"#3" !-"#" "'# '!& '# !!-"< $1 !-" #" "'# '!&2!%: !"209!-"28",+,!9.%#"=+#3:"'! '##"$,"" # !"# A

A9 4 ,!20 #"$,""# !-" &+%! !-" 42 %'!% <0 ,"&!, %'%'3!-"#" "'# '!& ,:#%&4&&"&&%'3,%'!", ",%'3%'!-" 4&&"&&%' !-"42 %'!% :4 '0.",!-"&+%!2 '#9:" &+,%'3 1 ' 2&: ,2 &9"D$"4!%'#+"$+,&" 2 8 -"!-",,"2%" ,"3 ,#%'3 3,"":"'!&""1%'3#"$2 , !%' *+,,"'#", ""## !"#

AAA98 &#"$2%'"# -" 4",+& 2 !-" =+#3:"'! '# #"$,"" # !"#

A9 4 &&"#<0!-"2" ,'"#%.%2+#3" +'%, %.%&%'9 +,3 '9 &-8& !- ! ' #%&$+&&%' 8 & : #" !- ! !-" 42 %'!% :4 '0- &$'&!,+$!"# , #5

5'!-"& %#&%!"', %!8 &#%&$+&&"#!- !8-%2"#"2%.",%'3!-"4&&"&&%' C!-&- ,"

!-"2 '#:" &+,%'3 )1 ' 2&: ,2 &9!-"4&&"&&%' &4"$% %$ 4,!%' 5

5 8 & #"2%.","# ! & %# '& 2 +&%'3 '# '&!,+$!%'6%:%!"#-"28",+,!3, '!"#,"2%" '20,"3 ,#%'3 !-"&+%!2 '#98-%$-8 & C!-&- ," 2 '#:" &+,%'3 )1 ' 2& : ,2 & %'#%'3&8",","$,#"#,"3 ,#%'34 && 3"5

5', '0 %'=+'$!%'8 & %&&+"# 3 %'&! !-" #" "'# '!& ,,"&!, %'%'3 !-": ,:#":2%&-%'3!-"4 && 3"5

5 -"%'=+'$!%'8 & '20,"3 ,#%'3!-"&+%!2 '#:" &+,%'31 ' 2&: ,2 &98-%$- & 4",!-"42 %'!%& C!-&- ," 2 '#:" &+,%'3 )1 ' 2&: ,2 & +,!-",9!-","%&'!-%'3' %2"!&-8!- !%'4+,&+ '$"!!-"& %# 3,"":"'!96 1-%".", $B+%,"#8'",&-%4.",!-"& %#&%!",-" "D"$+!"# '0& 2"#""#%' .+, '& 2+&%'3 '#'&!,+$!%'

6%:%!"#-"," ,"9!-",%3-! & %#6 1-%!!, '& ",!-"4&&"&&%' C!- &- ," 2 '# :" &+,%'3 ) 1 ' 2& : ,2 & ! '& 2 +&%'3 '#'&!,+$!%'6%:%!"#%&B+"&!%' <2" -"'9%!%&'! &-8' !- ! !-" & %# 6 1-% 8 & %' "D$2+&%." 4&&"&&%' &%!"

59$2 %:"#%'!-"& %#42 %'!89<!-!-"+,!&<"28",,"# %'$'$2+#%'3 &% #"$,""8 &4 &&"#%'!-"& %#$ &","3 ,#%'3 4 && 3"5

5-"#" "'# '!&- #$2 %:"#%'!-"& %#$ &"!- ! !-"42 %'!% :4 '0- # ,$%<20: #" , #'!-"&%!"5

%&"&! <2%&-"#2 8!- !,"2%" 98-%$-%&'!&4"$% %$ 2203, '!"#9%& #"":"#!- ."<""'#"$2%'"#-"," ,"9!-","2%" B+ 4 && 3"

5%&#"":"#!- ."<""'#"$2%'"#%'!-"4,".%+&&+%! -"2" ,'"#&"'%,$+'&"2 ,,"&4'#"'!&- &&-8' &:"4-!3, 4-& !-"#%&4+!"#&%!"!!-%&+,!8".",9 ,: !-"4-!3, 4-& !-"#%&4+!"#&%!"9%!$ ''!<": #"+!!- ! !-","%& 4 && 3"%'!-"2 '#<"2'3%'3!!-"#" "'# '!& '#!- ! !-"42 %'!% - &2 8 +2,%3-!!+&"!-"& :""."'8%!-+!8'%'3%! 89$:%'3!!-"& 2"#""# !-"42 %'!% ,"2%"#+4' %' !-%& &+%!9 #:%!!"#20 4 && 3" !8 ,#& &!",' &%#" %& :"'!%'"#+,!-",9!-"4,"#"$"&&,%'%'!","&! !-"42 %'!% 8 & '!!-"8'", '04,4",!0!8 ,#& &!",'&%#"-"4,4",!0 !8 ,#&!-" &!",'&%#"<" ,%'37%2 &

'# A%&8'"#<0 !-" #" "'# '! '# -%& !-", -" 42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!& 8"," ,"B+%,"#!42 $"' %2" 4&%!%."4,%: $%"".%#"'$"!- !!-"%, 4,"#"$"&&,%'%'!","&!- #2 8 +220$'&!,+$!"# '04 && 3" '# - #,%3-!!+&"%! 8%!-:+&$2"48",9!-"42 %'!% %'!-"4,".%+& &+%!9- #$'&!,+$!"#&:"4 && 3" ,$%<209%!#"&'!3"!,%3-!!

+&"!-"& :" '#!, '& ",!-" 22"3"#,%3-!&%'!-"& %#4 && 3"! '0<#0-"42 %'!% 8%22&!"4%'!!-"&-"& !-"%,4,"#"$"&&, '#8%223"!'20!-&",%3-!&98-%$-8","8'"# '#+&"#<0%!& 4,"#"$"&&,'!-","."'+","$,#9'4 && 3"%&&-8'!8 ,#& &!",'&%#" !-" ,:-+&" !-"42 %'!% 9',%!%&4,."#!- ! !- !42 %'!% ,!-"%,4,"#"$"&&,- #".",4+,$- &"#!-"&4"$% %$ 4,!%'5

5,- #!-"2"3 2,%3-!&!+&"!-"& :"-","2%" %'=+'$!%'%&"B+%! <2","2%" '#'20 4",&'$:%'3!!-"+,! 8%!-$2" '- '#&%&"'!%!2"#!!-"& :" *+$-#%&$,"!%'%&'! . %2 <2" , 4",&'9 8- $::%!& :%&$-%" '# !-"' $2 %: 4,!"$!%' 2 8 !-!-"+,!&<"28- .":%&%'!",4,"!"#!-" 4,".%+&=+#3:"'! '# #"$,"" # !"# A

A !%!2"# &

!<"%'3&9!-%&+,!%& !-"$'&%#","#.%"8!- !' 4,%: $%"$ &"%&: #"+!%' .+, !-"42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!& ' $!9 !-" %,&! 44"22 !" +,! 8 & %!&"2 '! &+," 8-"!-", !-" "D%&!"'$" 4 && 3" '#!-"2 8 +2,%3-! !-"42 %'!% !+&"!-" & :"9 %& 4,."# , '! -" 42 %'!% &,"&4'#"'!& - ." '! 4+,$- &"# '0,%3-! 8'",&-%4%'!-" #=%'%'32 '#!8 ,#&!-" &!",'&%#" ,:%!&,%3%' 28'", '&"B+"'!209!-"%:4+3'"# ,#",# !"# @)

9 4 &&"# <0!-"2" ,'"# ##%!%' 2 %&!,%$!

+#3"9 +,3 ' '# !-" ,#", # !"# @

9 4 &&"# <0 !-"

2" ,'"# ##%!%' 2 %.%2 +#3" *"'%, %.%&%'9 +,3 '9 ,"

-","<0&"! &%#" '#!-" 442%$ !%' %2"#<0!-"42 %'!% &+'#", ,#", ?A +2"& '# ," # 8%!- *"$!%' ) 9 &! '#& #%&:%&&"#

$$,#%'3209!-"4,"&"'!,".%&%'%& 228"#

76 *

) &=1&