← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/497/2013allowed

Radha Kishan v. M P Vishnoi @ M P Bishnoi

2017-08-09Mr. Justice A.B. Chaudhari23 pages



    

!"#$ %& !

'( ("#) 

   

 

 

  

*# +,*  ---.,

     

  

    

 

--., /    

 

 !

!"

#    

 $%&'( )" *! &+  

, -

 (

$./0&  1

1(22  2  

  2    +   !

  !"    

    

  

 

  2   

 "!

!" 

+   4 $5 6'

76$$  !

 !"



  " $6 $6 76$7

  2     #"8

8 6$ 766/    " !" 

+  !" 2



 .6669# 8  

  75%669# 8 !"

#    2   

 " 

 

2   

8"

   2 8     2 2    2

8   " 2 

"

         2 



# "

        2   

 

   

  

) : 0'7

. 4  8 !  8"

2   

  

  2

 22 

 2 8     

   2  "!"  2! 

!

 2 !

   " 2!!

;8  

   2

 !" 

  "    

     84  "8

    .6669#   2 

$7<  8

 

 2  

   

 =  8

8"

   > ?6"

 2    2 2    8"

 $68 !   2

1 8"

   @   74  !

 2) : 5'/

' 4

!

  2



6$ 6?

766'     2 %!

8 

! 8 84

   2    28  A 4

    2  

 !"

  4 

      " 4

  !

  



  75%669#   $$8  06 6'

766/  !3

/ %< "

   "

8

  7'00/9# 8 

6$ 6/ 766/ 

 " 6$ 766/  

 B    4  4  4 8

4

 ! 8 

      

  

"

@8    

 "

 

  

   8  C !"766/       @      $66669#          '6669#  

6'96/96?

766/    #

@

  C !"766/   @ !

8 "8"!

   " 766/    @

 

  

 "8

!

  

  !" ! 4  

!

     !

   



 !  

  

      

 !

2 !

!" 2  

    4    4

  

4   4

 

  2 #    " 

8  75%669# 8 6$ 766/  86$ 6/ 766/ 7'00/ %6 8  ;

 

 2   

   2  2

!

     

 

   

   4

2   

   A 

2   

 "       2 $68 !

 2: 0.7

. 4    D

   2 2 

 8   

2

  2     8   !   8 2

   # # 

 

 " 88

   !

  

2

!

8   2

  8" 8 2 !  8 2

B   ! 

  2!

 

 #   D         2     

  

88    $68   

  



8"

  8"

8!

  

 "  



88    !   4  



  2  

8

  @   82    " 

  2

B  "    

  

  2 

  6% 766?    ;8 0

     

  

 28

 7.

6/ 766? 

 3    7?

6?

766?   

       

 2

  A   

  



  2

 @



 ;  "   "

  

 !3

   $6669# 

  

 

    !"    



4 2   

 .6669# 8   

 "766/  ) 

8  ?4

 67 6?

766/  

"!

!

3



"!

"  

 

 2 2

"8

 

;



  

08    



8 

 

 "

  

   8

 3

  7?

$$ 766/   2  +

+2 & D ( 4  B 

" 2

 2 #    

4

      

 

 $$8   

   

#

 " 2

!"

 

"

3

2 

"!

!"

 

 "8    " 

   

8   4 2 4

  ;



 2



    2   

 " 



2      2   2 

 ) : 0'7

. 4     @     

 " 

88  

!   4 )  2

# #

D

  

"

 8  2

  2 2 !       # #  2  



4   

"   

 2   2 #    # "  

"

   

    



! 

 " 2 8   2 



88  !

8 

8"  2   

  2 2

82 2   @   "    2

8 !" 

+   $6 $6 766?  

  

 $7 $$ 766.    

8    $ E

 

!

8

   2 

 

 F

E



   8  !

 

    

 FA  7 E



   8



8 ) 1!

+

 !

8   2 FA  7 E

2



$ ?

766'  2 "  8  2FA  

 

  ;8     8 "    % 

    

 ;8 8

2   !

 8 ;8  28       3        E#/  ,  E#?   

 "

  

 

 ;8 8 "%



 

 +      

  

   

  

 75%669# 8   2 

8  2



6$ 6?

766'&-;

#$(!

   $% 6.

766'  

  75 $6 766'

 

 2

  

;8  

2

!

;!

4#G  8 

        $?

6/ 766'    !

    !"     

  ) 2        

 2

   8   2  !

    !"



;8  2     2 ; E#/ 2   

2

! 2     

  8  

;

   8

  0 @

!

8

 8  7'6669#  

8  75%669#

   " ;   28

    

 

 !

  766669# 

 !

;!

-;

#$$   6$ $../ $/50'9#   

 8"      2

;



     4"

   6$ 6.

766% 

 

 

8       6'

6?

766%  8 "     2        2

   B 8  ;

 !



 

8  8

!

     

!



      2

 

 2



  

  75%669#     

        .6669#     8   !

 2  8

  !" 

  

B 

   ! 8

 ?4 

"   

   

    2 ;

    8 !

2          ;  



 

 &-;

#0(  " ;



  8    8  

;8  : "

!    8  ?4!



 

 8  



   " 8

 .6669#  "!

8 "

     

 84 "8

 

A     

   

   2    2

# #



 )8    # # 

  

 

  2   2 # 

 "      

     2

 !" + !

 !

    "       !   8  2  

 2  

 

  "  4



2  

#



 

   .6669#          

 ;



   6?

766/&-;

#0(      4   "!

 2



  

          8

  3

    

7?

$$ 766/    

  

      

   "   6% 766?

  B  

 

    70 6?

766?  !" 

 

#     !



" 

 2   !

 8

 

   

 $0 



  

B 



   

2



6$ 6?

766'

&-;

4#( 8 

  3 A  

 

!

;

0 

8 2 

!

 

!

 $/50'9#  7$%669#

-  +   !

 

   

 2

 

  6?

6'

766/ & ; #5(3

!"



 

2 !"       2 "

B   8



 

 

 

 .6669# 8 "!

  8   

+ 

  !" 2



  2

    

  @  74 

 2 %!

8 74

 8 8 !

 !" D   

   

2



6$ $../&-;

#$0( ;



8 $6"

  !

      G 1)2  !



 

 

!

  $/50'9#   $$8    8 !

 !" 



 

 !

;8  E#7   2 2 8   

  2"!

2   !"

+ !

!"  

 " 

  

  2

&-;

#$0( 2

 ;



 = 2      

 

 E#%# :

DA

 

 G )2 

76 4!

;8 

   2  

  

 

! 2 

76  = 2     

   > 8 2

  "

    ;!

    -;

#$7   )  

   2     

   2

 8"-;

#$$ ;



 6$ 766%



8 8 2  

 

  

;8  E#5 



 776669#  8

  

2

   

  6$ 766%    8           $?

6$ 766% 2   



  766669# 8  '!

8  28  28

4

 !!"    $$8  

 2"

E#5  8   8   2    

     

#!;       4  " 

 766669# 8    8

     2

   !

  !

 8    

#   8 !

4  

  !   2

&-;

#$$, #$0(

  2

!

2 ;



  8 !

   $?

766% 67 6/ $../  

;



!

 2   88

 

  "

76$6  !

 2"  !" + !

    

2    8

       0

@  8  2  7'6669#

  

   @    2 !

 D    "

@ !

 2     #"8

  ; !"  

-

  8

 

 !

 8 2 

!

  !"   !

    !

  3   2    

"8

 75%669# 86$ 766/   " !



"   2 

   

!"

  !

   3   !

   !

8  

2



6?

6'

766/ ;!

-;

#5 !"

2 8 

 .6669# 8 

  # 2 "  D#$ D#0 8" 2    

 

 67 6?

766/  !"     "

8

  4 8  ?4 

   2   H#$ H#7

   #

2 "!" ; #8  !

!"

   !

       !"  8     "   2

     

 2"

 "   67 6$ 766$!

 "   2

  8        2 "

         2   

2



6$ 6?

766'&4#G( 8     $?

6/ 766' 2     

2 #   !    #      2    7  !

8     7 ! 8 4#I   

8 

   $?

6.

766' 

 75 $6 766'

2   2 #     2 % !

8  

;

 75%669#

   !

 

 ; 6$ 6?

766'

2

&4#G(  

" "

 # !

" 2 #    

  

    #   " ;



  4

   " 2

!

;



&-;

#$(4#I  8 



 

;

   !

 2 

" 2 #     "

88

 ;   !

2 2 2  2

8   

    # 

     

 !

  ! @

8     $% 6.

766'  

 

6$ 6?

766' 3

!

2  !" + !

A    

 "   

;8 8

  # 

 2

#  3

 8  

 "  

  "

!

   2

# #

 2 )8   

   2  



   2   

 "



  2 8"   



!   + !

  3  !   2

  

      

   

   



  

  !

!

  #

 

2    

   

88    8

!    8  2$68    #   

     

       !

   !"  8    

 

     

  2

# #



 )8     !

  

8 8 !"   # ;8   



 2"   

 

8

  2  

   

   !

 2 !" + !

2 

   2 

  2 2

  8"

  

 

#

  2    

.  2 

  

   

  



B 8



   

.  

!"8! !" ) 

"   2

! #8

!    



!

2  !" + !

 



  

.

 

  

!

  #

;8     8

!"     

#

    8      !

   8    

  

!

4   2    

  

 

!

 !"8

  2 

 

 

"  

1

!

 24 

!"

      

 2 

 2

2

  

  ! # # 88  2    8 

    

8  2  

"     "



 B  



 

       2 8    2

  #=

;8    " 2   

.

4  "58  )

 2 

+ 2!

 2=  8

   



  

88    )   8

 

4      "   4     2

# 3  

    

             8         



  

88   "

" 2  

8 

 !   "!

8



8 

88   8 ! #8



  

8

   

. 4!"

 

  

!    8

 !  !! 8

4 

 2 "

 2 )8  8



   

!

   

 D  "D

8

D 

C,     2 

!

 2    ;"     2      8 !

 8

  )  



"  2



 + 2 

 2 2  8"8 8!

   

  2

  2

8   

 

. 4 8"          

. 4   # # 88  2

 B 

 

  2

88   2

8    2 

" 2  2   

8" !

  

 

   4 !"

  

 

88   

 

     2 

 

 

       8 

88  !

8  

     32 

   

  + 

      8     !

 

B  8  

  # # 88  2  

    8         2 

 8 8 !



 

8  

88  

!"8 -  





 2

  



 

2 

       

2 



  "2

! 4 

88  ;+     

  !

"#$%  &'

  

+    

8  

    B  + 

     3 8

8") 1!

 ;+  (")   *  +, - "

.

  &'

*/

4 2       

$0 -  3!*! 

 

 

$.5.    J75

    ;  1   1

 2 

 $0&0(&(&(



    "      ;  8  !

 2        !

     

  2  

 

     8

8

88    

 8 8

" "

"

 

8 8!



8"             8     

 

     !

 

   

B   

 

  !

        8

    !

 2  



         

 

  !   

  

 2 2

 

2

    



8 8!

 8" 

 4  4  

 KKK K

 



 2 

  # 28     

   

        

  



"  2    !

 2 8"!

!2     



    "

8 84 8

 8 " 

  8

 9     2  !2  

 8"

"  

  !

 

 

  B



 

 !"      8

 +       8

   @    &(

   

           !

 

   &(

  

  

"

;!

         "

 @ "

" 2

! 







" 

    1          

 B  8!2    



 

 

!

 !

  

 8 

 8 "   

 

   2 2

     2           

  

            

   



  !"

  !

  !"  8

        !

 !

!" 

 1

  @ "   

 

 $0&0(&(&( 

  

       JA   "    

&( 1   1

 2 

 $0 &0(&(&( -  3!*! 

 

 

 $.5.8

   !

 

8   2    

    

&(  ;    1  1   8   2 

"  !"

     "

   

    "  

  8

!   81 8   1         8





" 

   !"8 

  8   

        !"    8

     !

;  "  8 

 B  

"

 

#    

#

 8   !

       ! 42     # 2    8 !2  



" 2  "!

 2

&(  

    !

        &( 

 

   8" "!

2  1

F &(E



    8

 2



    !"      

!



!"  1 1

  F   

     &(

      2

        9  

!

   2

1      

" L&(

 8

  8  

 &(  

! " 8  

+    !

 2          ! "    

 8  2 88 



  1 8

&( E  2   3   

 +    

 8   2  2 !"

  

&(B 

 

  

 



  

 1   1

8   2 

 $0&0(&(&( M 8



  # .

  01

 ) & '



   8  ?6"



2     8



+  

    328

   J$%     

#  

!8

  2  !" 

+   



  "

 

  )2+ 3  

 2



"  2



 4 

 2

"



 2    

    +   4  

 

! @





#

  !

)

  

8  !" 

   " ! @



  !

 !2  8 "     

   + L

 " !

!2  

+

 

"   

 ! 2+ 4

      

     

 2   

  "     " 8

 2 ;  2 

L  "

! @



8  8

!

 2 2

 " "

E    #

! @



!2  

)2 +  + !"   

#  

: 8  

 

!    



  !"   !

)2+ 

  2  88   !

 





 





E

 " 8   

!   8 !" 

#2 

 +

 D 1 &(K   32



 



)  8

8 

8

B  

   

      8     !

8 

    K   )2+

  

  22  2 !

8 

   K  4      )2+   2   

2 !" )2+ 

                !



3"8

 "K  

     

)2+ 2   

  2

  !"

  !

 

"  ;

  3

 8"!

   

  M   "4

 2 

 !   

 ;+   *

, ,

 3 -  &  '





  

  + 

    8  

    

88   

   



!"  ;

+    )##  0#   "%  &'



4

 2  

 328

  , $ 4$   20   4$  & '

   

 4     ! @



   

 !"  

" 2  

  

" 2 

  

 2"       

  77 6% 76$/     



 

 + 

N +88   

 

 !"



  N +88 

  8 

% 568 !8

      

 2



! 7!

8    

"

" 2   4 "

"  

 8

 2   B  !"

 

8  !"8

  !

8  "!

 2 38 8 8  2 = =  

   8 8  2

 

88 8! 8!

 8 ! 4    2 2   8

       "8   8!

 2

    28 " 2 8    

!

 8  2:  8"   2 8 " 2 4

      " !

 8 2: % "   

! 4  

   ! 



4   8"

!"

   " 2

  #= "8   8 ! 4  

  



4  !

   2    8

! 4!



2       8 4

  2  !!"

    7!

8     

" 2        "8     !;

  2 2

" 2  2 

  

 8  

" 2



 +B BG   D  

 2  8

 2 8    2     

   4

    2 @

"!

2 D  

4 "     ;

   D 2

  8   N +88 

!

  8 "!

 24 

!"



4  

   2

    " 2 2  

     2     !

 2

88



 2" +     + !



8

 2 "  2 "!"     2

8



    

  8  

 

 4  

 

  !

2  8

   



     2  !



   " 282





 2 !



88   2  

2

8"     2      ! 1         2

1  8"



 2"    2    +   !

          !

  2 2 

 

!    

  



 2"   

    

    

   



    2    

 8

 ! "      

#

  "   

   

 

 75%669#  8  6$ 766/    0$ 6/ 76$/         

8 

3  2 !

 .6669#    

6.

6?

76$/  0--.,1