High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4664/2018allowed

Malook Chand v. Mohinder Singh

2026-04-23Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl8 pages

"# $#% !# &'!

(

# )* &!#*+ ), # ! (#

# & & &#+ ),+ -! .!+ ), # / !%'!+ ), # ! #(

-! (( # ## ! #, ( 0!! 0 (

1# ! # ! (( 0!! %((# 23 ,+ ! (( 0 ! ##

# ! * ( ## 2 ## #' %*2#

-! , , " %# )# ! % # ' ! ## 4 ( 23 ! , .%' 5.# , 6+ 1!'#! &!2

7# % # ! (# ! %2* ! ! (# + ! ** 0!! %'! % 0!! !, *#' # ' ! % 0!! 0 3 ! 3# 8 %2* ! ! #' %+ (#3# # (#* 9% 0 * # ##' ! #* ##' ! (% % 93* ! ( ,# ! (' 0!! 0 !0 23 # ) : 1 ; ! ( # %# %2* ! ! ! (#( ! *2#+ + ! ! 2 ! (' (#* !'!'! ! + ## ! 2 * (!'#(! 0!! ! 2 < )<%# " %2* ! ## % ! %2=% + 0!! # #3 # ! (#(# 9% ! + ! (# ! *, (( %# >## % " 0!!

! 2 * 23 ! # %# %#* 9%# %#!# %2* ! ## ! % 23 ! (# 0 * 2% ! )(( %# , ## ! #* ! 0! ( # #* #! % ! #,# (' ! # #* % ((#% !, 2 ', 2!

! (# # #3 ( , %((# ! * %2* ! ! *(%' ## 2 ! (( 23 ! (# 2 0

7# % # ! #(+ ! !# !+ ! %2* ! 3 ! % 0!! 0 23 ! (# 0 # (#* 9% ! % 0 * , 9%'* 8 %2* ! !## (( 0 23 ! (# ! 3# ! 0 #* %2* ! (# ! #* ##+ ! 0 2 ! 2 (' ! (# 0!! 0# #3 !# !%+ ! (# % !, %'! ** ! ( ! *(%' ## # 0! 0 #, 2 %(!

-! %# ! !# # % # ! (# ! (#% ! ((# 2 ! ( ! ! *(%' ## 4 ' 0 #, 2 ! (# #, ( #, 2 0 # ! # !##

-! (# 0! ! ( ! % # (#* 9% 0! ! 0' (#3#

!"# $"%%&"%%$ '

()"

"#%* +

#",- .#

$"%

-$",'

$ $"

. ", $.

$.#, "$% %% / $ * %

+ "$&#$ $ ( , % # 0 "

-# -$

& . ) #

$" ( !" % , %%&" () ') # %

& ) )" - % #.-

!"# $"%0" #

) $"#0

"# #- () "&) #

) $"#0

"#1 ) (#% ! 2, 0% !0 ! ## ## 0 %'! ' ! #* ##' ! (% % 93* ! ( ,# ! (' 0!! 0 ( # ) : 1 ; # %# ! ( ! ! ( -! % 0 * , 9%'* # 8

(% ! ! (# ! (( ' ! 9%'* # , 9%'* + ! (( 0 0 0! ! 0' 2#, #

$, #"-

$"- .# #0"#"%$ %%."% $"-

# !"#% ",

&% "# #,

& #"% (" # .

) $" #

"% ,,.-" $"

##"%"-

!""!

#"%"- $"

#",

&% $"- .# %$,2., - ". $"0

"##"%$# 0# 0"& ,- . %"- %# %", ,-

"% ",

"#$""$#%

&'() ! *#") ! "$#%+ ) (#% ! 2, 9%'*+ 0!! *3 !

! 3+ 0% !0 ! ! ! 2 #* ! # %# 0! # #* #! % ! #,# (' % ((#%3 0 #=%# 2 ', ! (# % !# , #( ! ('

*# 0 ! 0! #*+ ! # %# #=%# # ! # 0! 0

(% 2# ! %# ! 2# ! #! % 0# #*+ (%#% ! 9%'* + ! (# (( 5)<%# "6 # ! ** ! ( ## #(# %2=% , ! %2=% , 0 0! #( ! ! ! ! 2 ! (' ! 0 ! #3 0# ! !% ! (# 23 #' 0 #% #'3+ ! ( 0 (#'#(! ) 0 ! (#3# # *#3 9%

"#'#(! ! (( # ** 0!! * ## ! 2 * ! (#3# % #(#% !#20 , $

$"$",

& $"

"# $"' #,30

"#3 $" "

, $"

" $"%.

%'"%

$"#)"#-.%" "# $"' #, 30

"#3

44 $

"3 ,%.

# , #) 2.

, #"-

$",""

#"0 !" $""

-# -$0"

5- % #.-

# %",()$ 0 "

"#* %$ '

"/ 6/78 , "

"# %$ '

$""&",

"/ # ,.-",() $",""

6*74

$"%.

# "# )5%%&" %$ '

"# * +

", - .#

" / 6 /78 %

. ", &" $.

$.#, "$% %% / $ * %

+ "$&#$$ ( , #"% #" $"%0"

% # &

, $"

(" .

$" .%" , "

2 )0"

$" %0" % '

"#%3

## (#* !0 ! !# 2 '+ ! (# ! < ! (!'#(! )<%# " -! # %#+ !0,#+ ! * ! (( %# >## % "

1#* ! 2, + ((# ! ! (#3# # *#3 9% 0 * 0! #( ! * (' #'#' 0!! (#* 9% ! 2 %'! ! (#3# 0 * % %2=% , ! ** 0+ !+ % , ! (#( 2 2! ! ! ! #'! ! (' =% , # 0% 2 ', ! (# !# (#3# # *#3 9% ! ! (# ! (' ! 2 2 23 ! !% ((# ! ! ** #3 # ! (#(# 9% ! ! 2 #(3 ! ! #3 ** !% 2 0 ! %# #=%# ' *# ! ** ! * 0' ! *

# ! #'# 2 * ! 9%'* ! /?2 &%(#* %# ! 2"%$.0#&&#' 9 #% !% , 9 #% #(# 8::;8 !

<== -! #, (# ! 9%'* #(#% !#20

#-$" (2"- $"#." % $ .# %%$ ., #) $"0"#

% $"-%"

$ - 0"(" #" $"0 ,%$ .,- %">."

) '0"

,0"

$ 0)(" "-"%%#) #,"

"#0

& $"#">."%

# !"#%) ("

'""

$"#

"%# !

,",

, "%

... ... ...

#/?$ "- % ,"#

&'$"

$"# -

#0"

,0"

%$ ., # %$ .,

(" '", $" .# %$ .,

$"- ##"-

"%% # %

) $"-%"

$"0"

,0"

@"'

%$ .,

#"- #,

& $" 0"#

% $" 0"

,0"

, $" 0"#

% $" 0"

,0"

% .&$ ("

- # # ",()') 0"

,0"

(" ,2.,&", $" % &" '

& $" #)"# # 0"

,0"

$ % -#,

- " $%

(""

'", () $" &$ .#

-%" ... ... ...

-" $" .# $% "

"#",

, %-.%%

$" - ##"-

"%% # %

) $" -%"

$" 0"

,0"

'" $!" $"#

"#"#"'

$ $" #,"#%%",() $" &$ .#

%%"

",'

$ $"0"#

% $"0"

,0"

% .&$ ("

- # # ",()') 0"

,0"

(",2.,&", $"% &" '

&#)"# # 0"

,0"

$" #,"#%%",() $" &$ .# %

%.%

' % (%"#!", () $ % 0 $ .0# !% ))@

. ,

$"#8::8=<<A

-! ** ! (# + (# #* 2' #3+ !' ! %# ! % ! % (#*#3 0! #( ! * ('+ 0!! (# ! ! (+ ! % #,#+ ! , 2 ' ! (' %2=% ,+ !%+ ! ( % !, 2 ! * ! % %+ 0!! 0 ! 3# 8 -!%+ 2

! ! (# 0 ' #' ! ( ) 3 #+ (#9% 0% 2 % ! ! 0% !, ! #'! * 0# * # ( #2% ! ( # ! * (

12.

@(' ,0 ! 2, #%*+ ! (# #, ( 0 ! *(%' ## 4 ! (( # ** 23 ! (#( 0

3 ! % ((#%3 0% 2 ', ! * 0# * ! * ( * # ! ! %# ! ( ! *# ! ** 0% 2 ( 2! ! (# # ( %((# !# #(, (' %#' ! %# #

"#$ % &'() *+ 1

A!!# ( '

# B

A!!# #(#2 B