Govinda v. Staet Of Haryana And Another
! " # !$ %"
&
%'( )
"
*!$ +
* , -./
$0-
11 2// , 3 - 4
/1-/
5(6#
'%"!# ! ("
! "
### ! ("7 '
$
%& '( $)* +", ('-('% &+ , $./.
& 0 0 $"
1$ "1")& ( 2'0
& &
' ( )3/ - - 0 & 0'456 78$1.
$"
"1"" 0 '( 397+",+,5-( 3+",+,(-:(% ( '&
"
; ' 456&0 &
& :
<=
1.
$"
"1"" 0 0 > 0 ''&'&'$? 0 &'
0 ' & 0> 0 ( 0 "1"" >' '&&
@''
6 "1111:* 1$ "1"" 0 0
&' 0 ( 0 * 0 & 0 ' 0
0'
A0 456&0
0 00 00 0 & & -'
( 2'0
&' &
'0 $"
1$ "1") 4 000
'0'
'0 ' & 0 ( 2'0
0
&&
0
"1"$0 ' 6 81111:*6 71111:* "1"$"1"" (
0 '
+
6 38111:*
'' 0
'&0 &
' &
'@'6 91111:* '
% @'&' '0
&
$8 $1 "1""
5 '&
' ( $3/ 0 & 5'
B & ' ' &'* 0 &'&@' 5
0'' 0 @'
%0 456& (-:(% & ' 0 %
' C & '&
0' & &0 & *&
)
('& & *( (' & ' 0' '0 0
> 0'&' 5 ' ( $7) - -
0
' 0 @'
'0 0 5
0' &'( $/(-:(% 0 &
& & '0 &&
'
": '0
&' &
5' & 00'0 '
% & & 0
' &'( 397+",+,5- 0 "> 0''&' && 0 %<= '( 398 5- 0' '
6'
'
'& 0 >'
'
'
B> *"( 398<= '@'
' 0 & 0' & &
'
'
0 >' 5
&( .15- <=0 & ' ' '
0 & 0 @''
5 <=
( 398 5- ' 0 '
@' %
( 398 '
&
0 & ": 4560& ' > 0'&'
8
&'
0 &
&'$? & ('0 & & 0& 0 > 0 &' '&@' & > & &
A'
& & '( $3/ 5 0 ":
&0 0456 %
&&
0
&
' &@''
6 98111:* & ' & ' & '' 0 0 &
456
'& %
>' *$ *3 &'
& : 0&
' 0 "1"$*""
0 & &
0 ' % &
&
0 0456 %
'
0 &' )" %'0 0 0 0& -' ' '' 0 0 ' '0 ' && 0 &&
9
& &> 0
6
'@''
6 98111:* ' & '
0 0 &0 0456 ' :456' 0' 0'
& & ":
@'& '& '( $3/ 5 00 && 0 0 0 ' & -' '& &&@' '( 397+",+,5-& '0
/
4' ' &' ( 3+",+,(-:(% '
' 5-' &
$1 &
0 :
& ('-('% & ( @'
' &'( 397+",+,5-
&&
' &'( 3+",+,(-:(% &&
' & 0 & ' ( $/ (-:(%
0 ' '
&>& *&
.
0 % 0 & '& ' '&5 0 0A :
0A
' 5 0 0 A :
0 A
& ' 0 :' & & ''& ':
: ' '
% &'&
0 * + ,%
0 &
@'
+
, '
@'
'
: 0' -' A
+
,
&
$1
5 & ' -'&
$$
5 & & ' 0 & '>
(MANISHA BATRA)
JUDGE Whether speaking/reasoned Yes Whether reportable Yes