High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/4947/2006dismissed

Kulwant Singh v. Bachan Singh And ORS.

2018-04-04Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan4 pages

!"#$#%&'&()* +,-.!("/&(01,-!21 #"&"&(#3 4#3','

!%1!(/&(01!($"1#3'

#'5($#("'

) 67 / + 7/ 3#'#(")8 3/!1&9!:$;%!"#:35#"&"&(#3 3/#$&:/#(&3$;%!"#:.&"1:

'/1,<3##"+!,3:$;%!"#:

33#'5($#(" =1#"1#3"1# #53"#3'-%!-(#.'5!5#3>!9<#!--.#$" '##"1#?,$0>#("@ <#3##33#$""1# #53"#33(" A =1#"1#3"1#?,$0>#("'1,-$<#3#53"#$&("1#$&0#'"@ 88 88 + 7/

7 >5,0(#$ &( 53#'#(" 3#;&'&( &' ?,$0>#(" $!"#$

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

3>"1#5-#!$&(0':--.&(0&'',#'.#3#3!>#$)8 =1#"1#3"1#3#!3#',&%&#("03,($'"'#"!'&$#"1##B5!3"# $#%3##$!"#$**&(',&""&"-#$!'+,-.!("/&(014'/.!3!(/&(01@

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

8A8 <!'&'!03##>#("'!-#$!"#$ *:53#'#("!55-&%!("85#"&"&(#31!'

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

&-#$(*!($.!' $#%&$#$(*A 1#3#3#:&".!' ("$#%&$#$1,33&#$-9 !> /&(01!""3(#95#"&"&(#3$&#$ (&#(#9#!3!($(&(# >("1'!"#3$#%&'&(!55-&%!"&(!($$,3&(0"1#5#($#(%9!55#!- 1#3#&'("1&(0(&-#"'1."1!" !>/&(01.!'&--.1#(#;&$#(%#.!'

<#&(03#%3$#$<#3#"1#"3&!- ,3"1#3#3#:>#3#-9("1#<!'&' !30,>#("':"1&(0' %!(("<#5#3',>#$&("1#.!9"1#'#!3#',01""<# 53?#%"#$ 1#-#!3(#$%,('#-35#"&"&(#31!'53$,%#$"1#!,"13&"9 "1&' ,3"&(

: !>"1#;&#."1!"&(53#'#("%!'#:!(553",(&"9.!'0&;#( "5#"&"&(#3"-#!$#;&$#(%#:<,"1#!&-#$"-#!$!(9#;&$#(%#1#3#3#: .&"1,"!(9#;&$#(%#:"1# ,3"%!(("5#3',>#"1#!;#3>#("'>!$#&("1# !55-&%!"&(!($3!,$!'%-!&>#$<#3#"1&' ,3""&'"<#("&%#$"1!"

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

+ 7/ * '?2' =1#"1#3'5#!2&(0 3#!'(#$ ) #' =1#"1#3 #53"!<-# ) #'