← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1628/2002allowed

Ajay Sondhi v. Bishnu Dev And ORS.

2019-08-13Mr. Justice Kuldip Singh9 pages

  

          

 !"!#$% &#"&#$$# '()

!!!!!!++,, - .

/0



* 12 *0

!!!!!!! + - . &#%&#$$# 3 1)

!!!!!!++,, - .

/0



* 12 *0

!!!!!!! + - . & $&#$$# , 4)

!!!!!!++,, - .

/0



* 12 *0

!!!!!!! + - .

3  563 ! ) 7 6)  0 & 30!'() 8++,,

+0 0* , *0++,, &!& &!& 6) !-

6.

*,9(0 0:



;0490<!

(*

0089 ,,

+ :2 *0++,

,:(++,, 0 4 4+

;

*90 #!%!#$$+

:(0 ,8   0 4!



  0* =!=!%%>8+0 , '( ) , ;9 **

0 3 1) , 4) 89

&#& ;

;  04  ;0*    40 0 

 * 0  0  :0

;

! & &?> "%8:

;0 2 :('() -, .9* , 3 1) , 4) 90



; 00 !@*

*(0* 0 ,9( 0

;8710, :1!A$380 9 ++,

0! *4 9* ,801<:0

;

! $#=>==404:*

  01<;

0! 0 1,9* *81+ 0 10 0 1

'10 ! 09

,,( *!* <+,10 *  ;, ; 0

; 0 2001< -0 + !.! 01<

9 :( 0 + !#4+ (!*01<9

109 *0 + ! 

(! + !  ++0:0 0 , +0;

B+0! + !#  *920  , !  90  4 80 + !#<+0,

0( :' *,

: 1   '

0



0(+0 !!30 !3&&&#%>#9* *9 ,

2,2

 !9 

* <+,1 0 *  ;, ; 0

;:(01<0 20!

(,

, :

(!

04+,

;

8,,9

;

1 9004& !

@**0  *  ,    

 

'10

    30 /* ,      1   :( 0 *     ;, ;   0

;    01< ! &$&&=>==:(0 + ! ,,;C 

#!

@**0*,

 ,, 44+

!

8*941* 049* **4C 

@**0*0 + !#* : +0+0,( 1!

& &   C  =!

@**0  *  , 4  +

 :  0   '

0  



0(+0 C  A!

@**0*,

:00:(,* ! 8

C  !

@**0*0 200! &$&?&> "%* ,9

;1 ,( 0 :10( ;, ;   8 C  >!

@**0*,

011, 8:;1 4, 8

,,;,

,9 ,,;C  "!

@*

*+0,

0(:' !#

*  4 0 + !C  %!

@*

*+0,

0(:'

! 

*  4 0 + ! C  $!

@**0*0 + !9 *,

;*2, 0

;,  * 4 C  !

, !

@* ,<

;1+

1 ! # 

0

;

 014   8 9 *,* <+,10 *

;, ; 0

;:(01<0 20

9* *'() *0





'10

4

;    4+

   :  908  '(  )

3  !  D%%>8 9 1 *,04, & ++,, 9 4+1 +! , &++,, 10*0 * 0 ;*(9 :,(4; *1 09 +,  10;0( 04  !  , &++,, 9 4 

8 61* =!=!%%> 

*0;  !A!%%>!, , 4**9

+0 861* !* +(

!#8$$8$$$D&0

&=& 04 ! , +,   00:

B!># 1 

!$D&!, , 4**, 2

*

0 ;*( 0 9 0

+, ,0 !9 0 ,0:1$ ( !  9 90<

;  0 *3 ;0

 1+4,  40 0!

1 

'10(8*1,  *

1 *

02   90  04

!   98  * 

 1 4+,(!     1    09

!#A$$$D&+04 *

,1

2,,,,9  

 2

,



9 * 4+

 * ++000 + ++, 

   (0  #$$#!     *2  *0  '(  ) ++,, 0* , *

0 *2

0 :* +0 *2, 01,,(; *01;* ,! &#"&#$$# 42 9*0 ,00

;0

;,14+ 4+

  

!  A$$$$D&    '(  )  9 *1  4

1,( B4

;4; 10:(, ! *

 8, 9 #> (0    ;    *   4     !    9  ;

;  ,0(  

!A%A$D&+,1

!"$$$D& +02:( ' *1<0,-@ .!,

4, 9

!# %A$D&! 

,   ,*, 04

 ,20  =4 * 1, 4,(8*

02  90 04

!     

,049 4+1 +! 04

 4 

861* 80%( !   6



40= 4 *

!%A"$$D&-# %A$B=.!

1 4+1 , 0480

;+ ( ,

, <,(:01!  9

90<

; 0 *3 ;09 * 1+4,  840 0!

02  9004

:( 4+ (!42 9*,



&A&

4 1 4+1 ,04

,1,A$E 9* *4 

!%>AD&!

0

;*,



4

0 9*,, 84+

:;0 :(++,(

;41, +, 0 4*! 

0

;; , 841, +, 0>

++, 8 41  4+

4 

!#=8=#8%$$D&-%>AB#B>.!

*1;*, * +014 ,:



! #A=>D&8*9208 1,   B+

 +10*

;  4 

 04  1

   0

+0 *2 : ,,9! *:

4 ,:

:(9(;1

8 441  1 +10* 4 

041

0:,,9! *008 14

!>A$$$D&

4 ,B+

0 ,,9! )

8,  9 (1 ;4

** , 29 * 04   1, *01;*1, 8

!  #8$$8$$$D&  0  ,

    '(4     ,   0  ,,9!   0 0

+0 8   *04

,, 1 *0; 8

!A$$$$D& 0,,9!,41 4+

4 

!#"8 8>$$D&!

 4+

*,,:+ :(

(9 *>!AE +0  

14 

0   04  *      

;    , 4  +   0, F ! &#"&#$$#

0

;,(,,9!

& $&#$$# 984

; , 4) 89* ,++0

;

@A8 *, 4* *04

4 

 0A( )* +

!8$$8$$$D& *004 !0'99 010!)* , +014 ,:

B!# B!= 8,9* *4

:1

! =#D&!)*10*0 * *9 * 

61* ! )*9 +0*0!  *0+0 9  

0;0

;*0 <1,,!)*9 , 0:( , 10; !

&& 1  <1,,

'10 8 *,  14:

*0* :

;10  1   

'10 !    0!  / '( :  -@>. +   * ,  9 4 

   61*  "!=!%%> 9

*0;  $!=!%%>!)*+ 

!#$8=#AD&!0!1; * +, * -@".+ *, 4) 9 +0 "!A!%%> ;,

+  * 090042!10*0+ * * 20 04



0+   * +

!#%$$D&!*

:

( 0 -B!. *9 *4 ,:0

*0

:

( #$E

0, 0 ;*1++0, 4:!*0 ,90,14+

144+



!>$$$$D&!

42 9*

;

2  014   890,14+

144+

1 '1 !

, * , 4

++,* 9 *

#A(0

;!)** 4+,,9 1 9 +0

; 2

1 ': 0(  ;* 10

 :0%%>!0400 ; +0 + 90

*;0B !*

*0;4 ,

1440(  61*  -B!==. *9 *, 49 # (0 ;* 4 !)*9 000 !)** ,0  <1,,80104 :, 010,2 , 41, +, ,,0

!10*0 *9 * *9 4 

* + , "!=!%%> 9 

*0;  $!=!%%> !!0 ( 10*04 ,00-B!=A. ;0*3 , 0*

: +01!*00 , 0B!=* : +01 9* * *9 * 4*9000

'10  

;9

 ! +0

:

(0 B!8 * 10#$E

:

( 0 ;*1++0, 4:!4 ,(8, , 4) 9

&>& 400 !)*9 #(0 * 4 !1010 4 2, ,2 ,  ,,0

8 **1 0;, +

 10

; 

409* *

, <,(

10 9*,, !141, +, ,,0 8

, , <,(

;10 4B ,2

;+04  0  9* *0 <,(20 ,(+0 + 400 ;!*0080 , 00 

 ;0

;  ,14+  14  4+

  

!  >$$$$D&    * , !04

 (

* + ,84+



!#$$$D&+0(0 + , 8  8+

 10

;!

9* *  4    

!  #$$$D&  0  ,,9!   0  #$E  

:

(8 4+

1 

! $$$$$D&

,,9!0,

+0 +

400 ;8

!$$$$$D&

,,9!

!A$$$$D& 4 ,B+

0 ,,9!, 4+

4 

!=>$$$D&! )



(9 *,, :,8*008 4+

*,,:+ 9 *>!AE+0

14

0 04*

; ,  ,,0, F ! 4+

*,,:+ :(

(9 *>!AE+0

14

0 04*

;,  ,,0, F ! & $&#$$#

,,9! &#%&#$$# 94

; 3 1) 89* ,++0

;

@8 *+ **0

9 010  *9 042  9*0 *04

4 0A(  *9 2

 0 09< !)*10*0+ * *, 04



049*0 *9 0002  + ,!)*, 4*

* +

!A$$$$D& *004 !92084 ,:

&"& B!=>B!A#*1 

!A%A>&A$90+01!)*, +01

:

(0  B!  9* * *9 

:

(* B #$E!*0 ,90,14+ 144+



! $$$$D&9 *1;

;

 

'10(!*

;,0,(

*9 **09 0106#!)*9 *2

;9<

:* ,90, 4:

41 ,+90 !   @ * 1*<



:

( 

, 04,,  * ,9( <+01

!10*0 : <   , *9 **09 0106# *0 9 010,(; 

0

 !)*9 2

 :

,1:0 09< !*0106#9 +

: ;

02 2,(! +04 ,008;,

4 :#=(0  * 4 ! )* 04

 4 

61* 04"!=!%%> $!=!%%> !!0 ( ! *++,8

, 4*, 



!0 : 4;!0400 ;+0 + *2, : 4;!

*008

1 '1 90 ,14+ 144+



! $$$$D&   :(0 ,!  0 ( 4

61* 8 4+

0   8 + , 

!#$$$D&+0(0 ,,99* *4 

!#$$$D&!0#$E

:

( 1 

'10  +

, 084+

  1 

! $$$$$D&

,,9!0,

+0 + 400 ;8

!$$$$$D&

,,9!

!A$$$$D&04 ,B+

0,,9!,4+

4 

!=>$$$D&!   4+

*,,:+ :(

(9 *>!AE+0

14

0 04*

;,  ,,0, F !

&%&  2 9:28++, !! 0,,9!)



(

, :,+(4+

8 *008 4+

*,,:+ 9 *

 4 * *>!AE+0

14

0 04

;,

 0, F ! -7 6) .

    !"!#$%

'<  @**0 +<

;00 

 @**00+0:,