← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5267/2015dismissed

Gaurav Gupta v. Gurdeep Singh

2015-12-17Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih4 pages

  

      

 !"# $#%&'&()  

 !*+!,*-"! .#"&"&(#+ /#+'*' *+$##-0&(12 .#'-($#("  ) 3 4 0  44 +#'#(") + 2!,5!$##-6!7&!8 $,%!"# +"2#-#"&"&(#+ +04(1&!8 $,%!"# +"2#+#'-($#(" 999

 62#"2#+ +#-+"#+'   7%!7 -!-#+' :!5 ;# !77<#$ " '##"2#=*$1:#(">  ;#+# #++#$""2#+#-+"#+'+("> ? 62#"2#+ "2# =*$1:#(" '2*7$ ;# +#-+"#$ &( "2# $&1#'"> 999

 44 +!7 /&$# +$#+ $!"#$





@8 "2# #(" ("+77#+8 !"&!7!8 +$#+#$ #,&%"&(   "2# "#(!("-#"&"&(#+ +: "2# $#:&'#$ -+#:&'#' &# ! '2-8 ( !%%*("   -#+'(!7 (#%#''&"5 ' "2# +$#+   #,&%"&( <!' !

&+:#$ #,#( ;5 "2# !--#77!"# !*"2+&"5 ,&$# =*$1:#(" $!"#$ ?



8 "2# "#(!("&';# +#"2&'%*+",&$#"2&'+#,&'&(-#"&"&( (;+&# 8"2#%!'#'#"*";5"2#7!($7+$<!'"2!"2# 2!$!,!'"#A-#+&#(%#&('#77&(1'-!+#-!+"' "+*%B'!($!' "2# $#:&'#$ -+#:&'#' <!' '&"*!"#$ &( &+! !128 !"&!7!8 <2#+# "2#+# <#+# :!(5 '2-'   "+*%B'3 '-!+# -!+"'8 "2# 7!($7+$&("#($#$"'#"*-!'&:&7!+;*'&(#''&("2#'2-&( C*#'"&(

 ($# #(%#8&"<!'$#(&#$"2!""2#7!($7+$!%"*!775 (##$#$ "2# $#:&'#$ -+#:&'#' " '#" *- !(5 '*%2 ;*'&(#'' *+"2#+82#<!'&(-''#''&( "2#;!'#:#("!'!7'"2# &+'"

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

"':!( 6 '"!"#$ &( 2&' #,&$#(%# "2!" "2# 7!($7+$ <!' &( %%*-!"&( !;!'#:#(" "2#$#:&'#$-+#:&'#'!($<!'! -+-#+"5 $#!7#+8 ;*"8 %(%#$#$ &( 2&' %+''#A!:&(!"&( "2!" 2#!%"*!775$&$("B(<"2#7!($7+$!($2!$(#,#+#,#(:#" 2&: "2&(1 %*7$ ;# &($&%!"#$ #&"2#+ "2!" "2# !%%::$!"&(;!'#:#("&(%%*-!"&( "2#7!($7+$<!' '*&"!;7# +"2#;*'&(#''82#&("#($#$"'#"*-(%#$#$758 ("2&(1 <!'D&' %('"+*%"#$ ( "2# &+'" 7+   "2# $#:&'#$ -+#:&'#' #&"2#+8 %("+!+5 " "2# %7!&:   "2# "#(!(" &( "2#

? <+&""#( '"!"#:#(" *+"2#+8 (%# "2# 7!($7+$ 2!$ '#" *" ! -+&:! !%&# %!'#8 "2# -+#'*:-"&( "2!" <*7$ -+#,!&7 &' "2!" 2&' +#C*&+#:#(" " %%*-5 "2# -+#:&'#' <!' "+*# !($ ;(!

&$# ($8 ("2&(1 <!' ;+*12" ( +#%+$ " +#;*" "2# '!&$ -+#'*:-"&( +8 "2# #,&$#(%# ( +#%+$ -+,#$ "2!" "2# 7!($7+$ <!' &$7# !($ *(#:-75#$8 "2*'8 2&' (##$" %%*-5 "2#-+#:&'#'<!' *($";#"+*#!($1#(*&(#2#!+1*:#(" "2!" &' ;#&(1 !$,!(%#$ ;5 7#!+(#$ %*('#7 + "2# -#"&"&(#+E "2!""2#7!($7+$2!$("$&'%7'#$&("2##,&%"&(-#"&"&("2!" 2# <!' &( %%*-!"&(   "2# ;!'#:#("   "2# $#:&'#$ -+#:&'#'8 "2*12 :!($!"+5 &( "#+:'   "2# -+,&'&('  0#%"&( ?   "2# !'" *(=!; +;!( #(" #'"+&%"&( %"8

F@F +'2+"8G"2# %"38!($"2*'8"2##,&%"&(-#"&"&(<!' 7&!;7# " ;# $&':&''#$ ( "2!" '%+# !7(#8 7!%B' %(,&%"&( !($ %!((" ;# %*("#(!(%#$ 4&B#<&'#8 "2# +#7&!(%# -7!%#$ *-(               8 

H@?F 8!($   

    8 

   #(" ?F8 $ (" !$,!(%# "2# %!'#   "2# -#"&"&(#+!;&"8!'&';#&(1$#:('"+!"#$2#+#&(! "#+ (%#$#$75"2#-+#:&'#'&(C*#'"&(&'!'2-!($ &( "2# #,&%"&( -#"&"&( "2# 7!($7+$ 2!$ -7#!$#$8 &( ( *(%#+"!&("#+:'8"2!"2#<!'(#&"2#+&(%%*-!"&( !("2#+ '2- &( "2# '!:# 7%!7 *+;!( !+#! (+ 2!$ ,!%!"#$ !(5 <&"2*" ! '*

&%&#(" %!*'# ($8 2# &($##$ 2!' ((# &( "2# '!:#7%!7*+;!(!+#! '+#1!+$'"2#;!'#:#("8%#+"!&(75&"&'

@ (" ! '2- ;*" =*'" !("2#+ !%%::$!"&( "2!" <!' &( 2&' %%*-!"&( ($8&(!(5%!'#8(-+#=*$&%#&''*

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

 !=!(  +*(!77&  *$1#