U.T. Chandigarh v. Satnam Singh And ORS.
!"
" # #$ !%"& "
&'
()!(*+ ,-)"./0 -/-102/ (*+ ,-)"./0 -/#--0)
!
" !#
$%% # "&
'
(()*((++,-
.#/ 0'
((*/((++,-
! 1% # "&
2%
# "&
.##,#/#3#4 +
# "&'1
-
!
# "&
.) *'
((*/((++,- 5555 /-102/3." &22"
& "
&# 26
7
& & # &2' - 2 & "
&2
' -
&
"
&# /+++,# . 0+**48 4***# 26
7
#
#
& &
&& 9
& 2 & /*#/+#3(#/04#+( :
#2
& 2 & /# 3 0 $; " 2 &&#*+4'
<&=-
7
& & # & &
& "
& (& "
&
"
(("
& 2 & /*#/04#/) :
> " # &( && 6 !
# 7
# 7
#
#?!
!#7
? #7
> 7
@ # &9
&
" # &
3+++,#
7
& & # & (& "
& ; &
!
"#
$% !
"
" &# '''() # "
# "
* !
"
"
&# '''() # "
#+
, 2" &
#
& &
6
26& "
&#
"
&# # & /4 # 2
2" 2 " &'-
# & "
& / && (& "
&
2&
"
2"
"
& & "
& #2
#2&
"
& 9 &'-
# #
2& # #26 & "
&
& & # # && &
2
.(( )*((++,> " #&& (& "
&
&
"
& & "
& # & 9 &'-
# #
3
&
2
.((*/((++,#%
& "
& && &
&
0 & &
# **3
#
# !2
"
&
2
# !2#
26 222.2 &&
& &
7
> 7
@ && &&&
& " #&&
"
7 7
> 7
@ &
7 #
#
! & !
#
6#?
A 2:
&
&& 2
#
"
#?
&&
&
"
7 # ,/**4#3**4 40**4
! & !
B
"
&" && 7
> 7
@
& 7 #
#
& 26
& 04 C
26 7
7 9
"
26
!
& 6"
&
26:%
&C
&'C-
& 2.
:? &
&
;
!
"
# 6 2 6
&&
&&
& " 26:?
!
9 6
7
>
7 #
# %6 ; "
7 # &2 7 # #&&
D &622&
& 6C 0**4# & 6 26:?
&
2 &
%2
&
! 2++ #&&
&& & 2;
2; &"
&&
! &
?E
F
?E
2 % ++
++ #&
&&
% &
& 6&&
"
?
&
"
&& &
&
&&
B )++ $; "2 & '?E-
&"
%
"
C
; "
++ &# &
% &
& 62& &"
&&
"
&&
& & 267
> !
; "2 &
2 &% &"
2 &% .0*/)3, !
B
2 C & &%#& 2
2 )
& &(&&
2" % & 6
:
2 #**)#7
&& &&
7
> 7
@ 7 #
#
&& ?!
! "&# & & 2 & & &
"
& & & & &# & 2
.*4/+*3)#2&
" #29 6
&& !
# 7 #
: %
"
&& 7
> 7
@ #&& ?!
! 7
2
& : & 1%
:
A2 6#**4#&& ?!
!
G
2 H
@ %# 6
# %
B "& 7
> ?!
G H
62 : &
? :? & 66 2 & 7
# 7
3#+++8(
7
: 7
& &2 # "
2 : & # 6 &&
& ?!# "&#
&
2
6 ;
A 7
% 3#+++8(
& ?!?!% 6 6
)#+++8( 2 7
# ? !
&2 2 & 2
: & .*4/+*3) *43+)4/3) "
&& & 2 2
: & .*3)
6
# # 2 : & .)4/3)
26 $;& " $ 6 $ 2 & & & 2 "
:? & 626 &:
2
2 2 : A2 6#**4 7
2&
"
6
&
& 26
& && ?!# "&#
1%
% 6
2 : & 2 1%
"
% 26H
@ %: && ?! 7
&& &
? C & 2
26>
B C.4# & #
?! ; &
&& % .4*/+*3) & &
&
&6 7 2 4 :
& 267
> &&#//#+++8(
!
B
& /+#
? #
H
#& /+(#
# " &&
& ; "
!
&& & " &
& "
> 267
> :
%
!
26
&
% ; "
&
"
7
& 7
> # "
2 ++()4)4/4,0
# ?
?
"
&7
% ?
&&
& 7
> & &
?"
%
?
?
6&&
7
> 7
@
D .
: &> & 2 & "
& & "
?
7
!
#
%
2 "
2 6 &
267
? #
?
7
7
? #
2 7
>
&&
> &
# 7 && 7
7
* & " #12
& ! #
& % &&&
2 7
#7
>
# 7 # 2 #**)
% ! 2 %&
&6 & 2 7
" & 6
&
2 &: A2 6#**412
7 & " 2
#7
> 7
#7 F #
& &
&
&6#2 7 #
#
%
6 2 %
! & && &
%
2
!
G& 2 %
&& # % 6 2?
"
#
! &
"
% &
#
!
2
;
!
&& & &
; " 2 & ?
& #A1#
A1
& && ; "2 &'
$.- " & && 2"& &
&6
&
& 7
> 2 7 # #&& 7
>
7
@ #6&& " 6
# 7 #7
7 F ? !# "& "
&( %& "
&& C &
&
#
& & 6 "
&& & & /*# /+#3(#/04#+(:
& /#3#I0 & + C &#& & &&
& & 26 4***4 & && &
2
7
#
&&
" &
& /*#/04# /)# :
&&
" &
& 3 &# && " &
& / &$;&
&& 26 0+**4 26 12#
7
#
# " &
& 0 & $$ %
&
& 2 & /#3 0 &# ;& "6
226 ##
& & & # & # & & & && &
2 & %
7
& & # & "
&
# 2!& " 6
6
#
&
2 6# &
&
&& # &
& & "6 2 & /*# /04#/) :
#2
& 2 & /#3
0 &
&
&& # &6 6# #&
, : &# & ; 0
# # 2 &
& & & # & & "
& & & "
&#
7
& & #
&
# & ,, # 2 #&& & &# #& & > " #6 /
&
2; '$
( )
( ) **
/ &
" & "
&(
2 # "
& & "
& # # & 9 &# 9
& > 2"2
# 2
& # # ( & "
& &
'$
( )
( +,&, )
) 3 C # &
2 #"
& & "
& # #& 9 &'- ' -#2& & "
&( #
# # 9
6

26 # ; !
& #
#
26 & "
&( # 2
> 2 && "2
6&9 &
6 && 2& "
&
&
&
$4 5 $$ 6 5 5
0
&9 &&
#
2 &&
&
=# &
2 6&
&&
#
&& 2&
+4+0**4#
# & & &&
+0**4
& 2"
& &6#
&
& =
&&
#2&
26 &
& & # && +4+0**4#
# &
&& 2&
+0**4# #
&#%
& 26&&
# +0**4#
& 9 &" 6 ; "
#
#2&
& +0**4#2&
" 2# 62
2
" && $
6
&" 6 +0**4# 7 # # 2
# &&
6
# 26 & 2 & &#& 6 & &# &&
# G ' -# %
& 6# 26 2 & 2 & &
& &6
&
&&
# 262
2 2&
&& & & 78
$4 5 $$ .95 #55 ) & #
&& "
&
7
' &
./-
?E 2
7 # &
2; #&# "
&& 7
? #& 2 " C &
.3 '12
- " " & " 2 && 7
&&
7
# #
6; && 7
? #2 &12
2; F(3
"
6
# & & 2 & "
6 F(3A # 26
7
&
&& & & #
2 %
7 # #22&& & 2
6#&9 "
(("
' -# &9
$4 5 $$ 5 25 4 & &#&& !
B " & " #
"
&&
#
&
.4'. 2 -# "
2;# # 9
6 & 2 &&
&& !
B 6#&9 "
(("
' -# &9
$4 5 $$ 5: * & &#&&
" ,%
?E&&
&
2 &(&& 7
? # && !
& 2 " # %& ' -
# &
2 &&
& 2 " : & & F(3 '12
-
"
! #&
& " &&&
&& 7
> #7
@ #
#
;
?E#2 &
2;
# #&
2 ' -# &
" 6#
&&
' -2& & & 2&& 62
$4 5 $$ 5 ) .: + & &&
&&&
&
&62 7 # #&& "
2
GG 2
? =:
# &
./ '>
-
& &
2;# 26
' -
2 &&
2& & "
$4 5 $$ .: #5 9 & &# && 7
" & 2
& # 2
1%
#
& &&
?!
!
&& # 2 2 " 26
#
&
"
& 2 " # & &2 & 2& &"
! #& & 2&& ' -"
(("
6
A # &
& & # &9
2 && # 2 " # , # -
"
"
"
"
.&/01
2
3 4# 5
!
"
6 7
"
" "
"# 5
/## &8 4 # # 3
"
# & "
"
"
9 $
: - '%#+ 6#2"
= %
&9 "
(("
&& ' - 9
2
26 : 6#
& 6
! 267
@ 7
> #
" %
&
%
&& &"
! ;
:
6# "
& & "
& & 26
7
& & # & "
&
# & & # & # 26
"
& & "
& & 9 & 9
2 #
" &&9
2
& & "
&
$ (
$ )
'
$*
$ - )
. ) / &
. ) 0 , , ?
& "
#2
A:#&&
#
& #
&$; F+8
& #
" 26&& " 2 ; &
( !
&( ; 3 /
# &
"
"
4 <
# = " < #
"
# 6
<
> # !
# + /
& ' -# &
# && & & :
& ' -#&&
#& %
; " 6 2 9 %
%
9 %
# #& &
#
" #
& %%
2 2
2&
%
# # "
&
&" 6 # "
& & & #
&
# #%
3
& 6# & 2 2 26 6
&& $; F+8 2 2 " " # & 2 2
2"
&2
" &" 6 &
" " #
&
& & 2
"
6 & 6 0
& 6 &%
& #26&& "
& & & # && & & # &" 6$; F+8#&
&" 6 ; "2 &
"
& & & 9 6#
&" 6
26 6& "
&2 &" 6 6#
& # "
&" 62
"
(("
' -# 26&& # "
& & & : 9#%
"
& #26&& & & # 2
& "
&" 6' -#26 && & & # "
& & & #
& &9
2 ""
) > " #6
"
& & 9 &"
#
"
&
& & 9 &"
"
&' -# 2&2
., ) !
26 > =2 ;
$ **
,
(
234 5$
6, ( 3 )- % )71
, #, # "
2&; & ?,# 5
" ?* : -
"
# 5
"
! %
5--
)
, 8$*
"
"
" 8
@
# 5 "
# ! "
"
8 # ?*
" # ?$# :
8
"
# " <
< " # ?
# 5
" )
" )
"
C 4< 8$*
, 9 3) )'-
) +# 0 ) 5$
, (
)
! <
!
"
A
,# D
"
"
# ?9# "
!
! )
5$
, ( 3 )- % )
"
)
?
# D
< # 5
"
7
# 5 "
# 5 "
!# 5 @
"
<
E 3 ; "
" <
#+ F= < 3 ; -
#G ?$# !
38
)
"
#H#
"
38 &#,'''#'' # -
" "
"
# 5
"
"
# =
"
#H# ?* : -
"
38
)
"
"
# ?*# = " 7
38>
7
I># 5
7
## = 9 $
$
"
7
I >
# 5
"
= 9 $
$# ;
7 "# 4 A # !
26 > =2 ;
$ **
, # (
4 / 3 6, ( 0-71
#,, # "
"
&
2&
0 #
2&; & ", =
!
#
"
! "
" "
# 6
"
# = "
:
;
B :
;
"
8 "
< B :
;
8
B :
;
"
8 :
;
"
! (
<
"
" "
"# .< & $ 5
, &) = %)
, ( 0-= ( 4 )
, & >
)$ % $ 5 ))
, ( 5;# * A # !
26 > =2 ; * 9
% : $ ;
,#"
( 1
2%$ 4 / %$ 6, 1 *, - ? * ( % 71
, , # "
"
2&
3 #
2&; & ??# 6 "
?*
: -
8 "
" 2
8
# 5 "
" " 8 <
" 8
# - " "
8
<
# 5
"
" 8
# 3)$
?-) # ( 3) ) ? ?*
: -
"
"
2 # 5
"
# - " <
# 5
"# C " "
"
"
" " 8
# &
# 5 I ">
I "> I "> I "> I <"># H"
"
# ?,# 5 "
"
"
" .1
"
.1 "
<
" "
# 5
"
"
# 5
"
"
# ?
# ?*
: - 2 " "
"
# 6
"
?*
: -
"
" # ?9# 5 )2 "
?*
: -
"
" "#
.: ),*1 "
J &8 K ?9#'
#?''%
" L& M# ?'
(?''% E 7 "
&8 # 6 2 "
L&# M#%'(?''%
"# 5 "+ ?*
: -
"#
" < "
# :
"
"
# ,+ .
&#
9
2 "
J
-
& & 9
&" 62
2
& & "
&" 6 &# &
& 26&& "
& #
&
#
&" 6
6 &J
- &
&" J
- : 6" 2 %J
"- : 2
& &;& "6
%
&& "- &" 6 &" 6
&%
& # 2
& & &
& 2&
#
9
# 6 A1& & # 2&
& & & #
2; "
" &" 6# &
!
&
"
!
# & 6 2# & & "
- & 9
2 &
# 2
& &" 626
# %%
# &"
& 26%
%
6 & # & & 26 "
& & & #
&6#
&
&" 6
&&&
"
& &" 6
6 &" 6'-2&
& & & "
- &
&
"
&;
2
%
& & 9
&" 62
# 26 &"
&" &# 2&
" # 6 26 "
&
, #
&'- 26 " # %
& 26 && & 9 &" 6# 2 2
& &6#
6 % &
6"
& "&
2 " %#"
&2 6
&& , 6#
& & 6
&& #6
& & #
"
6 " # 2&
& (; 26 2 &
& & & #!
& & & 2&&6
"
& & & #
& # 2
& "
6
# 26 2 &
266
& & #
"
6
,, " # & # 2" #2&
2
266
& & #
" # 6& 9 6
& & # &"
&
& 26 && #"
6 2&26 " #6 2662
& # # & 9 &"
"
6 & 6
!&%
# 2 2& 6
&#&
& & "
& &&
6
" # & "
2
#266
& & #
"
6
# #
! " &"
&
&& 6 "
& 26&& # 9
2
& & # "
6 & 626
& &" 6#& 6
62&26 "
2"
# 8
26 6
& & #
"
6 &
$ &6#
; 9
& " 62
,/ ;
& &
&&& #
& %#
6 6
&& ; ' -#"
( ("
& &2 6
&& 9 !
!
2&
2 6'
- & & # 2
9 " &"
&# 26#
& & 9 &" 6# 6 2 &
2 " "
6 "
# 2
&
& "
 %
& & &"
&&& # 26
&
& 9 &" 6#6
"
6"
$"
2& 6
&#
& &# #
& "
& " 6& ,3 > " # &2 &
& "
& 6
& 26&& & 9 &" 6# # 2"
# 266&9
""
6"
#& 6
"
& 2 &"
,0 %
& & 9 &"
# 2 2&
92#
6 % & &
& "
&: 2" &# &
"
2" &
#2& &2
6
&
# & 6 "
6 %#
6
& "
&#
&
&& ,) 9 6# & 6 "
& & 3 :
$"
& &# "
2& ; &
#
6 6 82
& 26 && #2 &
& #
&
#2 ;& # 2&
& ) :
$"
& &# "
2&; & # 26 6 &
6& ## 26 && 2 &
& #2 6 & # 26 && #2 &
& & & #22&
&& 6#
& # "
6 && # "
& &
&" 6#& # ;& "6
;& "%
!, ( * (( '
*
,JJM ) " # 0 , 0@ $) (
($
($
$- '
*
,JJ
"
2 "
" )
"
"
" #+ ,4
& 6# 2 &
6
& & 9
&" 6# 2 2"
#2
2& " 26 &
6# &
& & 9 &" 6 &
& "# 2"
6 2&& 62 %&&
" &
6#
&
2 "
6 % "
&
&& # 26 &
2"
6 %
& #
6 !&
#2 ! &"
&
62 & #&62 ,* . &
& # &
& & 9 &" 6 2&
&& 6 " 26 & " #
#
2& 96 & 26
"
6
2 "
2
&
#2
" &" ' -
&" 6 &
" &
# 6
;& "%
&& /+ &6#
& 2 2
& #2"
6
%
&& &" 6'
-# & && #
# &
& & & / 9 6# 262""
& 2" 8
"
&' - 9 6#2
& # #& 9
&"
# 2&
&& 6 " # 26
& "
6 & 6 2
;,9
/
'$; :-# 26 A1 & & # " G 2& ; 2
& &# "# ;
& & ; # 2
; " 2 &'-
; & $#
# 5
"
# 0 *# %* ( (A !
8%A& ; "
" "
) ? # 5
" A) .1 "
. :5M1 ) ?# .1 :5M ) *,#?
N
:5M )? *?#'
N#
A&8A -
!LC :0 C !6/#+
78
5
66
/, $
6 ?& 9
6
#&&
+4+0**4#2
& 6 G ?E%
&
! # +0**4
&&
# 26
' - 26: 9
6C
& # &9
"
6 & 6 6# 26
6 && & & # & 6 " G 2&; & ) 3$
( !
&( ; 3 /
# & 8
<
" .1
# 5
. 1 E
'' # L
.6 :1 ?(?
''( ''
?
"
* +# 5 ## ''
< " # 5
# -
<#+ // A # &
2"#2 2 6; & 6 G %
& +0**4 6# 26 &
6& & & !&
" #&&
+0**4 " # 26 &
&
&&
#26: "
C
& # +0**4
& 9 &" 62&
# 6
& ' - " # 26
& ' -
& & 26 # 26
& "
6 9
2
& "6
& & 9 &" 6#2
2& 6 /3 " # 26
6
&#
6 6
&(&& 2 6 "
6
& /0 6#
&: 9
6 ' -
26 ?& #2& "
& "
& 26 & 26 &# #' -&
2
- && 2&
+4+0**4
26# & & 6 && ' -#2&
# +0**4 2- 26 6 & 2 %
' - 26
& & #2&&6"
26 & & 2
&-2 & 6 #
&9 "
26 12
'
F(3- "
(("
&
% &2&;&
!
7
> #7
@ #
# 7
#
' -# &9
6"
6 #2
= &2& # && & & #
7 # #
&"
! # 2 6 % & & #
6 &
&6 & 2&
2 && & & #
"
&
& &
"
& /) 6# "
6 % &
6&
& &# #'
F(312
-"
! #&
%2 7
> #7
@ #
# 7
#
2
7 # > " # 6
2;# "
2" "
2 &
& & &
'- "
;& 6
&# & - F "
& & & #
2;# ; ( (& # 6%
& 12
> " # 2&& ( ; #
%
2& 2
"
6
&&6# && %
"
6 2 &
2
& & $"
2& > " #
6" & 6
 6
%
&&
& (; "
& & & #
&#
"
6 26 F(3# & &
29 62&
2;# %
&'-' -#2&29 6% 26 "
& & & > " # %
' -2&
26 "
& & & # 29 6
' -#
& &
& (; #2
&#
"
&
# 6 2"
6&
6 && & & &# &
& 26
7
& & # 22 6 && & 2- " # &9 26
7
& & #"
(("
&&
&2& &
&
& & #
& "6 "
6
" # &
& & # 2&
& 26
7
& & # 62&2!&
& (; 26 2
& & & # 6 # 6
% 6 %
#
26
& "; ( (& #"
( ("
#
& "6%
"
#2 &
& # & 2& 2
#
#
: 9# &
2"
&;
& &
&& & & #&
&6&&
2
7 # && & & #2&
/4 : #
"
2
! & & #
7
& & #
&
2 " # 2
: &
? & 6# 2& 6
267
H
%#
6 2 2&
A2 6#**4
? :? & 6# 1%
#
& && ?!> " # &" 6
2
! & & # 26
' - & & 2 2&
&
6 " ?
"
#
" ? & 2 & A & #
2 " 6 & & " %&# G
& #
&
6 "
&
2&%
: 6&#
&
&#
6 & " " G 2 "2 " "#&&
!
2 6 & 6 & "& & " &
"
& &
! && 2& &"
&"
! # 26 &
& " & 2 & & && " & & & # "
6%
! 26&& & & # " & 2& 6< 6 26&#"
& &9
& #
& & # 9
6
& /* 6#"
& & "
& & &&
&
& 2 & /*#/04#/) :
#
& &
2&2 % F(+#
&
&&
# $; F8/ $; F+80#
&
$;3
&& ' -# & $; F+80#
#
&&
!
# & & "6 $; F8/ $; F+80 2&
#
&&
#
" 2
&
2
& 6 & "
&2&
& 26 & & 26
>
$; '$; F/80-# 26 "
6 9
2
>
$; 6# & "
&2&
&
26 & && 26 >
$; # 26 >
$; # &9
"
6 : #&
' -#
&&
2 & 2&& 62 &# &
& "
& &
&
&
#2
& 9
&'- && ' -# &'- ;*,(#-
3+ : #
#
!
"
& &9 #2& 26
7
& & #
&'
3 "
& & "
& # #& 9
&# 2& & "6 & # #
# (& "
&(
#26
7
& & #
6
" 6# 2
6
( & # # ( & "
& & :
& 9 &#
# #
9 3 & 2 #2
6#
6#
9
#2
# # 6 ;
3,
& & '-#
6# 8 #
7/-102/8 ./#=- 7/#--0)8 %"& " ./#=- 5 1 9> < !
?<*
1 9
5 !
?<*