Manjit Singh v. Sham Singh
!"#$%&'()* $%!+(,!-) ...
/ /121 ,)%3,!-) ...
!( 55555 /-2 6&"# $/70% )/%* 8 %(
/() / $/,$%9:%* 8 %(
/() !(
()1 89 / 81! 4 ((! !8;!- 124 /81/& +2/1 (!()12/(2!
//( '() !1((2(!! %*()
! %!(%11%91/ / %( ' <!!
=2/ #>4%11 6& 9:
2/(8 :) )%3 !(12-)(6&() !(#49%!(!
49%!(*:%1%99:
(1 9%3 ()%(%( //%3!-() 112 1*%3 29 !()%8 6
!%99:
%! ()21*() / /1!
/8%9 !/9 -%9 ? 2!1 !(*!() () /)%! *)%12/- ()%( :) !(12-)(/!
)%!- 1() !%(2/ 12(!/ 6/!-1!% (1/3!-!
: %21 % (!*%! /%() /1/ /
/3!!-() %9@2 1(!1! !(/8 /1&6 (:
4%/( 1%! /
142( *() 1%3 1(6 2/!-() 2/1 %/-23 !(1% / 6& 2!1
4%/( 1* 4 /21%9 () 4%4 / 6; %! !1 /%(! () %(( ! !-
1/ %91()%( 2/!-() &() 12(/411 11!
9 6&() !(A49%!(* 2!+%68 /!3 !()% % 4%/( 12( 9%! / !1(/2 (! 12() 6& #4%11 !/3%(! %62( % @21(!:%1/
6&() 49%!(!9&! ?
:) !) :%1 %1;
( 99
(() :%/ %32!(1%1 9(()1% @21(!*1)%/ 49%!(!() ((%9%/ %/:) )() 49%!()% 9 12(*)%
( :%1 ()21 %! 34/(%!( 1261 !( !( ! %
2!( % @21(!1)%/ 49%!(!9%! ()%(() !(!() 49%!( )% 6
3 !
11%/&
%() ! %!(()%(() %449 %(!)% 6
9 +21(( 9%&%! 9%( 4/
!-1*:) %1() !(:%1 / !
11%/& !/ :%1 / / % +2 %(! () 3%(( / !
!(/8 /1&*1!(( !%69 B (()11(%- */
3%&6 3% ( ' / /0 :) )4/81!// % &/
*1%44 %16 9:"
!"#$!"#% &'"($)#*+,-"./%!(0(%(#0 +%(*" %-"&/1""$)#*+(''2")%-"/&(/%0%('%"//(!"#$ -)+&'"($)#*+)#+.1-!(##"/(#$#+.1-%"/!+(+!(03"4.+%5 (#$(''+.1-(!"#$!"#%++-(''3"!($"(+!(03"#"1"++(/0
/%-"&./&+" $"%"/!)#)#*%-"/"('6."+%)#+)#1#%/7"/+0 3"%2""#%-"&(/%)"+
/7)$"$%-(%#(&&')1(%)# /(!"#$!"#%+-(''3"(''2"$ %"/%-"%/)('-(+1!!"#1"$5.#'"++%-"1./%1!"+%%-" 1#1'.+)#%-(%)#+&)%" $."$)')*"#1"5%-"&(/%01.'$#% -(7"/()+"$%-"!(%%"/3"
/"%-"1!!"#1"!"#% %/)('8 ' C) !(12-)(/6&() !(#49%!(!
9 49%!(112 )%!%(2/ ()%((- 1(() /(() 142( %! 1%91 !((9!-() 12(*(6
3 1!
11%/&(%99:(/4/4 /*
%!
142( (1(6 !( ()%(()
%3 !(12-)(/1!
11%/&6
%21 "
<> (:29 %8 329(49 (&4/
!-1) 1
)%!-
1 %( / 9!- () 49%!( %(2/ %! =( !(12(9%! )%1 )%!- !1 !( 24!% @21(!4%/((6&() 8 /!3 !(
2!+%6D <> 349 %! :)9 13 % +2 %(! :29 6
3% !9& :) ! %3 !( 1 %// 2( ! ()
49%!(D <> 3 !( 1!(%9( /() )%/% // %21 % (!!() 12(D <8> 12/4/1 16 !-14/2!-!() 441( 4%/(&D%! * <8> !+21(
/4/ +2
1-!-(6 %21 (()
! %!(1 E ! % (! ( () %68 #3 !(!
4!(1* ( 1%91 ( 6
!(
()%(() 2/((1 9)% 9((!
11%/&(!(/ 2
!( 49%!(F/4/4 /% +2 G !8 :() 1 211!%1%68 *:() 2
(()
9%: 9% :! ! () %2()/(& %1
!"#$ % ()%( %( 33
!(() (/%9 %( //%3!-112 1%! =%3!%(!
() :(!
1*!%3 !(!%:/(( !1(%( %!6 *%!
!( /%
4
29%/
1()1 * 1!(1244/(()
%21 /
2!1 !(#49%!(*!() () /)%! *)%1 12-)(1244/(/3
&
'
($ % ( !( ! ()%(() 2/()%1 1 (!( %99:%3 !(!49 % !-1:) (1()2-)(!
11%/&/
% +2 !()1 *() 2/((1 9)% 1(/!-9& 9(()
/!(/ 2 (!%3 !(!() 49%!(/F4/4 /% +2 %(! G
! )
*
(
('
$ *!H69 4 =2/()% ) 9 ()%(()
4:
/%3 !(1)29 6 = !() 9%/- /!( 1( !-299 %! +21(
6 (:
! () 4%/( 1 ! $% +
),
# #"($ )9 !-()%( /(1() %8 /3 !(112-)((6 !
/4/%( 6&:%&%3 !(*%/
!((6 +2 - %(() 1(%- %99:!-4/%& //%3 !(*(:%1 61 /8 ()%((%8 329(49 (&9(-%(!*%3 !(*!
11%/&* 1)29 6 8 !! $ + $
*,
$ &(
-!$ *!H69 4 =2/()%1) 9 ()%( %3 !( 1)29 6 %99:
() 1%3 1 !
11%/& / !- ()
+21(
,244/( ! ()1 / -%/ )%1 %91 6
! 12-)( /3 $ , &
.
/ %%+ #
(-( 01 $ &2+,$ &
$ & # "- 4/ 0+
5 ( ! 4/ 03
6 + !
" 4/ 0$
$
% # #
4/ 0 & , ,
, " )7
1 0) .16 $,3
.
+ $ !
(' 8
) . + )&&.
$ 3'
(- 4/ $, 9 :: & &
93; 9
# #!- !%99() %2()/( 1*()%16
) 9 ()%(() !(!
/4/%( 1() 1261 !(1/
() /:1 1!
11%/&/ %!
3%(( /* 1%3 1)29 6
!1 /!-() 3%(( //3%99%!-9 1*49 %() ! %!(* /) !*()%(() !(%99:
6&() 9:
2/(:%1!
11%/&!// *12! (6 8 3 /(
?
4!- ! 8 : () ((%9(& % (1 %!
1 %1 %/9 /*() %449 %(!/%3 !(:%1/-)(9&%99:
6&()
9:
2/(8 342-!
/ / %( '
, 99&* %/3!- () 342-!
/ /*()1 4 ((!* 6 !-
8 %!&3 /(*1 1311
%/( 1%/ /
(%44 %/6 / 9:
2/(!! 29&*
I%-2((J
C)
4/( /19 %94%4 /13%&6 (1
+2 -3 !(K 1 C) /(6 // (()
4/( /1/!(K ? C) /() +2 -3 !(1)29 6 4/( !() - 1(K 1