High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5325/2015allowed

Dharambir v. Yashpal And ORS

2015-08-20Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan3 pages

!"#"$%&%'() * + ,-%+ ".%&%'%&! /"+&0& &*1 2 '#!*"+& "&1'#"'!&

( 34 5 6 45 +"&"'!(7

+5* +, 8#.$ !"8+!*"+".%&%'%&! 9*"!*"+!*""1+!"+&2$ 2'":&1 1"+, ;-" 22:"#!&"" !*"<0#=,"'!> -"+""++"#!!*""1+!"++'! 9*"!*"+!*"<0#=,"'!&*02#-"+"1+!"#%'!*"#%="&!> 77 77 45 8

4 * + ,-%+7+".%&%'%&!* #%2"# 1"!%!%'0'#"+5"$!%' ?? !*" !+ /"*%$2" $!8 ))8 -"+" !*" !+ $$%#"'!

2 %,& +%-0' 28 +' 02 %' &*+! 3!*" +%-0' 23 + =+ '! $,1"'& !%'' $$0'! !*"%'<0+%"& +"$"%."#-; *%,%' !*" ,!+."*%$02 + $$%#"'!*"+%-0' 28.%#" : +## !"#@8 22:"#!*"$,1"'& !%'!!*"!0'"&8?8 7 2'=:%!* %'!"+"&! !!*"+ !"AB1"+ ''0,+,!*"# !"1"!%!%'!%22%!& +" 2%C !%' :"."+8 !*"+%-0' 2 +#"+"# !* ! B ,0'! $,1"'& !%'&* 22-"1 %#!!*"+".%&%'%&!%'$ &* '#+", %'%'=

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

+".%":!*"+#"+!*"1+"#"$"&&+!*"+%-0' 2 , !*" .%": !* ! !*"+%-0' 2 "22 %' "+++ :*%2" *2#%'=!* !!*%& 112%$ !%' ,0'!&!+".%":!*" : +# +#"+!

%&'!!*"2 :!* !% '; ,0'!%&+#"+"#!-"#"1&%!"#%'8 !* !$ ''!-"+"2" &"#+&0%$%"'!$ 0&"*"1+"&"'!+".%&%'%&! : & , <+"* #+"$"%."#%'<0+%"&%'!*" $$%#"'!"'""#"# ,'"; + !*" 1"+ !%' '# &0-&"F0"'! 1"+ !%'& !"+ !*" 1 &&%'=!*" : +#'!*%&$ &"8%!%& 22"="#!* ! !"+!*"1 &&%'= !*" : +#8!*"+".%&%'%&!* #!0'#"+=!*"1"+ !%'8+:*%$* *" &1"'! ,'"; *"+"+"8 !*" +#"+ +"2" &%'= !*" ,0'! %'."&!"#%'!*"$ ''!-"$ 22"#+".%":!*"+#"+*" : +# %& 2+" #;!*"+"%' .0+!*"+".%&%'%&!&&0$*8!*"%,10='"#

77 +#"+# !"#A ''"D0+"77%&&"! &%#"*"+", %'%'= ,0'!B#"1&%!"#%'!*"%& 2&+#"+"#!-"+"2" &"# !!*"+".%&%'%&!-;!+ '&"++%'=!*"& ,"%'*%&- 'E $$0'!8!*" #"! %2& :*%$* :%22 -" 0+'%&*"# -; !*" +".%&%'%&! -"+" !*" +%-0' 2 *"+".%&%'%& $$+#%'=2; 22:"#

) &<E&