← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5347/2015dismissed

Raj Kumar Singh v. Bhuri Devi

2015-11-30Mr. Justice Arun Monga5 pages

   

 ! "!#$%$&'(!)*!+

 ,-.)+/$&01 ! $ $&!+ 2!+%.% 1.+$ !($ !%3&"!&  4'564/476 +!%!& '8 4+$-.)+1.1& "(# ! + 1!3! $ $&!+ 4+ /9$ /!&$+"(# !:$ 1 4+)( + "( "(# ! + 1!+!%3&"!&  ;;;; 71! 1!++!3+ !+% 9#933!+%)<*!99:!" %!! 1!  ,."0)!& =

*!+!

!++!"  1!+!3+ !+%+& = 71! 1!+ 1!,."0)!& %1.9"*!+!3+ !"$& 1!"$0!% = 

  1!3! $ $&!+$%00+$!(!"  1!+"!+" !" >

?&&!@.+!8A ($"!  :1$#1  1!  339$# $&  %!!B$&0  "$%)$%%9    1!  339$# $&  $9!"  *<  1!

+!%3&"!& .&"!+/!# $&+!":$ 1!@39& $& .9! +"!+  "!

$($9+#!".+! +%! $&0%$"!  1!,."0)!& &""!#+!!" !" >C $& $($9/.$ 

1%*!!&"$%)$%%!"  $%) !+ +!#+" 1 4+$-.)+1.1& 9!+&!"#.&%!9 33!+$&0&*!19 3! $ $&!+%.*)$ % 1 %3!+ 1!9$*!+ <0+& !"*< 1$%.+ $& >C

C"!#$"!"&

 1!+!%3&"!& %:!+!  $9!& 339$# $&$&$($9/.$ 

++!#99$&0 +"!+" !"

&"& $&$($9/.$ 

"!#$"!"& >C :1$#1:%&!@3+ !

"!#+!!&"& #&%!& "!#+!! 1.% 1! +$9.+ #))$ !"$99!09$ <&" 3!+(!+%$ <$&"$%)$%%$&0 1!339$# $&! .+ 1!+%.*)$ % 1  !+3%%$&0  1!

+"!+$&$($9/.$ 

$ :%:$ 1"+:&:$ 1. &<9$*!+ < 1!

+!%3&"!& 1" $9!"#$($9%.$ C

:1$#1:%"$%)$%%!"($"!+"!+ " !" C

?&&!@.+! A*!$&0& )$& $&*9!%3!+3+($%$&% +"!+

.9!? A&"+"!+ .9! "! $($9+#!".+!! .+ 1!+%.*)$ % 1 339$# $&$&$($9/.$ 

:.9"& *!)$& $&*9!%"!#+!!" !"

:%& #&%!& "!#+!! 4+ /9$  9!+&!"  /!&$+  "(# !  &"  4+)  ( +  "(

"(# !

33!+$&0&*!19 +!%3&"!& %.*)$ % 1 3! $ $&!+1"* $&!"& !@83+ !,."0)!& &""!#+!!" !" >C $&$($9/.$ 

0$&% 1!  1!+:$ 1. $)39!"$&0 1!+*+ 1!+%&"%$% !+%%")$ !"9< 1!3+3!+ <$& 1!1&"%  1!  1!+ :%&#!% +93+3!+ <! .+ 1!+%.*)$ % 1  1$%.+ ($"!+"!+" !"

& &9<0(!9$*!+ < )(!&339$# $&$&!+9$!+ %.$ 

D*. 9% ($9%.#19!09+!)!"< #199!&0! 1!+"!+% 3%%!" +) $)!  $)!$&3+!($.%%.$ & 1!%!#$+#.)% &#!%  1!339$# $& :% $9!"$& 1!$($9/.$ 

 :!(!+ 1!:.9"*!9% B$&0 33+3+$ !+!)!"<*<)($&0&339$# $&$&$($9/.$ 

D$& ##+"&#!:$ 19:! .+ 1!+%.*)$ % 1 -+)1&"*+ 1!+ 3! $ $&!+ &"+!%3&"!& ".+$&0 1!3!&"!&#<  1!%.$ $&#99.%$&:$ 1 1!3! $ $&!+&" :$ 1. %!!B$&0:+$ !&$&% +.# $&% +)1.+$ !($8+!%3&"!& :$ 1"+!: 1!

$($9/.$ 

D&" 1.%3+<% +"$%)$%%9  1!+!($%$&3! $ $& 1(!1!+"9!+&!"#.&%!9 + 1!3+ $!%&"33+$%!" 1!33!+*B  $#$&0 1! +!)!& $&!" # $ :.9"*!33+3+$ ! +!3+".#! 1!

+"!+" !"

3%%!"$& >C

C'8  

 



     



 !

"

#$% $&

 

' 

 &  

(    

&

)*+  ,# #  

   - *

.&& & 

&     





  ,    ( 

( $   

 

  

 (       & &  &       (

      

   - *

.



 ,  

  & && 

  

 

  ($&  

  &

   

 

 / & $

 (  (

 

$           

  

  +0$123(   



4 /  5    

  

6  7

  8 &   ( 9 ( 

   $   



 & & 



 &  

:

  3!+.%9    1!  +"!+  %1:%  1  1$%  .+  1"  0$(!&  9$*!+ <   +!%3&"!& 81.+$ !($ )(!&339$# $&$&$($9/.$ 

+ +!#99$&0  1!+"!+" !"

:!(!+ 3!+ $(!+"!+:%9%)!& 1 9$*!+ <:%0$(!& 3! $ $&!+ ($9%.#19!09+!)!"<:1$#1:%($9*9! .&"!+ 1!9:1!$)3+   1! +!)!& $&!"+"!+  1.01"!%& "!*+ 1!

+!%3&"!&  )(!&339$# $&$&$($9/.$ 

*. $&)<($!:

$

:.9"*! +#$#9!@!+#$%!

$&3.+%.$&0 1!339$# $& $9!"$&$($9/.$ 

%$ :%&!@83+ !"!#+!!&"+!)!"<$ &< &!#!%%+$9< #199!&0!

%)!*< $9$&0$&"!3!&"!& %.$  1!+!%3&"!& %1.9"1(!)(!"&339$# $&$&##+"&#!:$ 19: & % +$# 9<#& $&$&0  1!3+($%$&% +"!+ *. &< 1!+3+($%$& + +!#99$&0  1!+"!+" !"

*<%  $&0.  1!+!%&%($E88($E 1!

. 1+$ <    0$(!  % +!&0 1    1!$+  3$&$&   1!  &5*9!  /.3+!)!  .+  $&  

                

 !

 " "  1% 9$" ":&  1!3+$&#$39!%+!0+"$&0 1!3:!+%  "(# ! + :$ 1"+:$&0 1!%.$ 1!%)!+!"% 1.%'8

# ;& &

     2;& 

 

&     <  

       4(



 

#  &( 



 =    (  (  ($(   

 (

( (            (  ( 1 (

# ;&



& < 

   4(



 

# 9   (    &    (%  

  &       2&

    $    

   

 

# 9 

  &(%



 &     $&

    (%



   1!+"!+" !"

9%+!"% 1.%'

F;  



( ( 

  &   

&      9 

(

 



$ 

    & &  8

             

(:

 1! +!)!& $&!"+"!+:.9"+!(!9 1 $& 1!%.$ 

$ 9!"%  # $%& '(

  #.&%!91"& %.01 &< $&% +.# $&% +) 1!39$& $

 :$ 1"+: 1!%.$ 1!3+$&#$39!%9$"":&*< 1! /.3+!)!.+ $%"$+!# 9<339$#*9!$& 1! # %&"#$+#.)% &#!%  1!#%! ##+"$&09<    "  &  $&"  &<  $99!09$ <  &"  3!+(!+%$ <    1!  +"!+  " !"

>

"!#9$&$&0 1!339$# $&%!!B$&0"$%)$%%9  1!339$# $& $9!"*< 1!+!%3&"!& $&$($9/.$ 

1!+!%3&"!& :.9"*!%!  9$*!+ < )(!&339$# $&$&!+9$!+%.$ 

++!#99$&0 1!+"!+" !"

$&##+"&#!:$ 19:3+ $#.9+9<$&($!:  1!#&#!%%$&0+& !"$& 1!+"!+" !"

$($9!($%$&$%##+"$&09<"$%)$%%!" ?476A   (!)*!+

&$9