High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/540/2023disposed of

Nanak Chand And Another Through Thri Legal Heirs v. The Collector Land Acquisition Industries Department Punjab And Others

2026-03-19Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

(

*&$(' *&$(' *&$(' *&$(' ?47 47(' (' (' ('676 676 B B B B $9/ /(%! $9/ /(%! $9/ /(%! $9/ /(%!3C 3C 3C 3C7676 676 676 676> D11$,,*%& 11$,,*%& 11$,,*%& 11$,,*%&

$ 1(%2$%& $ 1(%2$%& $ 1(%2$%& $ 1(%2$%& ! ! ! !

#$ $%&! '(# '(# " " " " *),(% 2@(9*&$ &)$*11$,,*%& *#+%$ )*+ )*,

+%-*. )/ ) $#0* 2@(9*&$ #$ 1(%2$%&( AAAA #*, #*, #*, #*, ( ( ( (34 34 34 3435 ('676 ('676 ('676 ('676

#* *8$# 0*2$/%&)$*11,/9*&/(%/ '(#/01,$*2/%:&)$*11,/9*%& * ,$:*,)$/# ('* *11$,,*%& %*0$,8*%*=)*% %2*%2*%:* *0 ;)()*@$2/$ $2

(# # &)$ #$* (% 0$%&/(%$2 /% &)$ *11,/9*&/(% &)$ *0$ / *,,(;

;$2

+.-$9&&(*,,-+

&$<9$1&/(% *%2&)$*11,/9*%& * 0$%&/(%$2/%1*#*:#*1) (6 (' &)$ *11,/9*&/ /(% *#$ (#2$#$2 &( .$ /01,$*2$ $2 * ,$:*, )$/# (' *11$,,*% %& %*0$,8*%*= )*%2*%2*%:* *02$9$*

$2/%(#2$#&(1+# +$&)$1#$

$%& 9* $ ( ( ( (3 3 3 3 5 ('676 ('676 ('676 ('676 8 ;*8('1#$ $%&*11,/9*&/(% 1#* *8$#)* .$$%0*2$'(#9(%2(% %/%: &)$2$,*8('>?7 7>2*8 /%'/,/%:&)$1#$ $%&*11$ $*, (& &/9$('&)$*11,/9*&/(%

% =/%:('&)$(+#& #*#+ +%$ )*+ )*,

&& +% %-*. *%2 # )/ )

$#0* 2@(9*&$*99$1&%(&/9$ (%.$)*,'('#$ 1(%2$%&( 3B B6 *%2#$ 1$9&/@$ $,8*%2(11( $&)$1#*8$#0*2$/ /%&)$*11,/9*&/(% ) )*@$ )$*#2 ,$*#%$2 9(+% $, '(# &)$ 1*#&/$ *%2 :(%$ &)#(+:) 9(%&$%& ('&)$* *11,/9*&/(% (% %9$2$2,8 &)$(&)$# /0/,*#,8 /& &+*&$2,*%2(;%$# 1$#&*/%/%:&(

*0$ *9E+/ /&/( % 1#(9$$2/%:

)*@$ *,#$*28 .$ $$% )$,2 $%&/&,$2 '(# &)$ $%)*% 9$2 *0(+%& (' 9(0 01$% *&/(% 1$#&*/%/%: &( &)$ ,* *%2 /&+*&$2 /% #$@$%+$ $ &*&$ /$ @/,,*:$ *%/1+#

$) /, *&)*%=(& / &#/9&+# #2* 1+#%(; *&)*%=(&*,(%:;

;/&)

(,*&/+0*%2(&) )$# &*&+&(#8.$%$'/&

/%@/$;('

'-+2:0$%&2*&$26?74673C1*

$2 .8 &)$ &)/ (+ +#& /%

(6366 (' 67

(6366 (' 677 B ;/&) J (36> B ;/&) J (36> B ;/&) J (36> B ;/&) J (36>5 (' (' (' (' 673 673 673 673&/&,$2F +%

+% %-*. %-*. %-*. %-*.0*,,%2+ &#/$ B<1(#& 0*,,%2+ &#/$ B<1(#& 0*,,%2+ &#/$ B<1(#& 0*,,%2+ &#/$ B<1(#& &(#1(#*&/(%

)+)*#/%:) &(#1(#*&/(%

)+)*#/%:) )B )B )B )B G G G G *

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

)

1$9/*,*%29E+/ /& 1$9/*,*%29E+/ /& 1$9/*,*%29E+/ /& 1$9/*,*%29E+/ /& /&/(% /&/(% /&/(% /&/(% ''/9$#*%2%( ''/9$#*%2%( ''/9$#*%2%( ''/9$#*%2%( (&)$#I (&)$#I (&)$#I (&)$#I#$1(#&$2* H67673C 67673C 67673C 67673C ?CC ?CC ?CC ?CCI*%2&)$,*&$ &$<1( /&/(% %(' ,*; ,*/2 2(;% /% ()*# /%:) $*2 )#(+:

()*# /%:) $*2 )#(+:

+:) # B #

&*&$ ('

&&*#

#*2$ ) (,,$9&

#*2$ ) (,,$9& &(# B #

&(# B #

&(# B # #$1(#&$2 * H676 676 676 676 373CI 373CI 373CI 373CI ;)$#$.8 2$,*8 (' ' 36 8$*# *%2 ? 2*8 ;* 9(%2(%$2 &( *99(#2 2 1*#/&8 .$&;$$% /0/,*#,8 1,* 9$2 ,*%2(;%$# *,.$ $/&%(/%&$#$ &;* *;*#2$2'(#2 2$,*8$21$#/(2)$#$,$@*%&1(#& &/(% &)$#$('/ $<&#*9 9&$2)$#$+%2$#!5

H36 6 *@/%:)$*#2,$*#%$2$%/(# (+% $,'(#&)$1*#&/$ *%2(%1$#+ #+ *, (' & &)$ 0*&$#/*, 1,*9$2 (% #$9(#2 ;$ $ *#$ *&/ '/$2 &)*& &)$ *11$,,*%& *#$ $%&/ &/&,$2&( $$=1*#/&8;/&)&)$/#9(5@ @/,,*:$# /%&)$:#*%&('9(01$% *& *&/(% '(# &)$/# *9E+/#$2 ,*%2 )/ (+#& )* 9(% / &$%&,8 )$,2 /% * 9*&$%* * (' 2$9 9/ &)*&&)$/%(#2/%*&$2$,*8/%'

'/,/%:*11$*,/%9(01$% *&(#80*&& &$#

1$# $ 0*8%(&.$'*&*,* &)$#/:)& * *%2$E+/&/$ .$&;$$%&)$1*#&/$ 9*% %.$ ;$, ,, .*,*%9$2 .8 2$%8/%: &)$ &*&+&( &(#8 .$%$'/&

+9) * /%&$#$ & '(# 2$,* ,*8$2 1$#/(2 L$ *#$ &)+ (' &)$ 9(% /2$#$2 (1/%/(% &)*& &)$ 2$,*8 8 /% '/,/% /%:&)$'/# &*11$*, 9(+,2.$9(%2 2(%$2 +.-$9&&(&)$9(%2/&/(%&)*& & &)$ *11 1$,,*%& ;(+,2 %(& .$ $%&/&,$2 &( $%+#$ +%2+$ .$%$'/& '(# &)$ 2$,*8 *8$2 1$#/ #/(2 L$ :#*%& +9) /%2+,:$%9$ /% /% &)$ *11$,,*%&"

'*@(+# *, ( '(# #$*

(%&)*&*.*&9)(''/# &*11$*, *& &)$/% &*%9$('(&)$#,*%2(;%$# ;

&/,, ,,1$%2/%:9(% /2$#*&/(%.$'(#$&)$ $/:)(+#&,,&)*&&)$/:)( (+#& (+:

:)& &( )*@$ $01)*&/9*,,8 2$%/$2 & &( &)$ ,*&$59(0$# ;* &)$ .$%$'/& /& (' /%&$ $#$ & /%9,+2/%: (% &)$ (,*&/+0 + +%2$# $9&/(% 4 (' &)$ 9& '(# 1$#/ #/(2'#(0&)$2*&$('1*

/%:('&)$ $*;*#2.8&)$ $'$#$%9$(+#&&/,, , &)$ '/,/% /%:('&)$'/# &*11$*, I %@ @/$;('&)$2/ 9+

/(%0*2$)$# #$/%*.(@$* ;$,,* 9(%&$%& ('

*11,/9*&/(% &)$

*0$/ *,,(;$2*%22$,*8('>?

?7>2*8 /%'/,/%:&)$1#$ $%&*11 1$*, / )$#$.89(%2(% %$2

(

(?47 47(' (' (' (' 676 B B B B M3N 8 ;*8('1#$ $%&*11$*, 9)*,,$%:

:$)* .$$%,*/2&(&)$;*#22* *&$2 3736771*

$2.8&)$,$*#%$222,/ &#/9 9&+2:$ +#2* 1+#59+05 $'$#$ %9$ (+#&;)$#$.8

$'$#$%9$ $&/&/(%+%2$#$9&/( (%3('&)$*%29E+/ /&/(% 9& 3C4 1#$'$##$2 *& &)$ /% &*%9$ (' *11$,,*%& K,*%2(;%$# ;* 1*#&,8 *,,(;

;$2 ;)/,$ *;*#2/%:

: &)$0 9(01$% *&/(% O

6?7K5 1$# *9#$ '(# *#*%/ (0 (0$

?7 777K5 1$# # *9#$ '(# $)#/

36 ?77K5 1$# *9#$ '(# *%-*# *2/0 * *%2

>6?7K5 1$# *9#$ '(# */# +0=/% ,* *%2 *,(%: ;/&) (&)$# &*&+& &(#8 .$%$'/& K/%&$#$ & /%&)$/#'*@(+#

M6N $* *#%$2 9(+% $, '(# &)$ 1*#&/$ *#$ *2 /2$0 &)*& +%2$# /0 0/,*# 9/#9+0 &*%9$ * *%2 1$#&*/%/%: &( &)$ ,*%2 '(#0 0/%: 1*#& (' &)$ *0$ *9E+/ /& &/(% ;/&)/%&)$#$@$% %+$$ &*&$('@/,,*:$ *%/1+# $ $) /, *&)*%=(& / &#/9&+#2*

1+# %(; *&)*%=(& & &)$ 0*#=$& @*,+$ &*%2 /%9# #$* $2 &(

3 777K5 1$# *9#$ $ *& +%/'(#0#*&$.8 8&)/ (+#&@/2$-+2:0$%&2*&$ $26?74673C/%

(6366

(6366 6(' 6(' 6(' 6(' 677 B ;

677 B ;

;/&)J (36> ;/&)J (36> ;/&)J (36> ;/&)J (36>5('673 ('673 ('673 ('673 &/&,$2F +%-*.0*,,%2+ &#/$

+%-*.0*,,%2+ &#/$

B <1(#&(#1(#*& <1(#&(#1(#*& <1(#&(#1(#*& <1(#&(#1(#*& *&/(%

)+)*#/%:)B # G *&/(%

)+)*#/%:)B # G MN 99 9(#2/%:,8 &)$1#$ $%&*11$*,/ 2 2/ 1( $2('/%&$#0 ('&)$2$9/

/(% #$%2$#$2/% +%

+%-

+%- %-*.0*,,%2+ &#/$ B<1(#& %-*.0*,,%2+ &#/$ B<1(#& %-*.0*,,%2+ &#/$ B<1(#& %-*.0*,,%2+ &#/$ B<1(#& (#1(#* (#1(#* (#1(#* (#1(#*&/(% &/(% &/(% &/(%G 9* $ +1#**%2 *11$,,*%& *#$ $ )$,2 $%&/&,$2 '(# /0/,*# *0( +%& (' 9(01$% *&/(% * )* .

$$% *;*#2$2&((&)$ $# /0/,*#,8 /&+*&$2,*%2(;%$#

*,(%: ;/&)*,, &*&+&(#8 .$%$ $'/& *%2/%&$#$ &*@*/ /,*.,$+%2$#&)$*0$%2$21#(@/ / ('*%29E+/ /&/(%9& 3 C4 *11,/9*.,$ & &( &)$ 1#$ $%& *9E+/ /&/(% /%9 9,+2/%: &)$ /%&$#$ & (% (,*&/+ +0 (;$@$# &)$ *11$,,*%& )*,, %(& .$ $%&/& &,$2 &( /%&$#$ & (% &)$ $%)*% 9$2 9(01$% *&/(%'( (#&)$1$#/(2('2$,*8/%'/,/%:&) $*11$*,/$>?7>2*8 M4N

$% %2/%:*11,/9*&/(% /'*%8 )*,, *, ( &*%22/ 1( $2(' *#9) *#9) *#9) *#9)3C 3C 3C 3C 676

676

676> &/= L) L) )$&)$# 1$*=/%:K#$* (%$2 $

)$&)$##$1(#&*.,$ $