High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/553/2023disposed of

Tara Singh (Deceased) Through His Legal Heirs v. The Collector Land Acquisition Industries Department Punjab And Others

2026-03-19Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

* ,(&*) ,(&*) ,(&*) ,(&*) *) *) *) *)676 676 @! @! @! @! &:1 1*'" &:1 1*'" &:1 1*'" &:1 1*'"B B B B7676 676 676 676

CC CC CC CC33&..,'( 33&..,'( 33&..,'( 33&..,'(

& 3*'4&'( & 3*'4&'( & 3*'4&'( & 3*'4&'( !" !" !" !"

%& &'(" !% )*% !% !% )*% $! $! $! $! # !

$ # !

$ ! ! ! ! $,+.*'4;*:,(& (+&,33&..,'( $,%-'& +$,- +,.

(( -'/,0 +1 + &%2,4;*:,(& %& 3*'4&'(* >>>> %,. %,. %,. %,. !* !* !* !*5 5 5 5 *)676 *)676 *)676 *)676 8 9,8*)3%& &'(,33.1:,(1*'3%, ,8&%+, 0&&'2,4&)*%:*'4*'

'1'< (+&4&.,8*)7 74,8 1')1.1'<(+&3%& &'(,33& &,. '3 3-% -,':&*)'*(1:&*)(+&,33.1 1:,(1*'1

-&4*'7676 + +*%( %&3.8+, 0&&')1 )1.&4*'0&+,.)*)%& 3*'4&'(* (+& ,2&1 (,?&'*'%&:*%4 + +,;& +&,%4 .&,%'&4 :*-'

&. )*% (+& 3,%(1& ,'4 <*'& (+%*-<+ :*'(&'( *)(+&, ,33.1:,(1*' *'

':&4&4.8(+&*(+&% (-,(&4.,'4*9'&% 3&%(,1'1'<(*

,2& ,:=-1 1(1* ' 3%*:&&41'< +,;& ,.%&,48 0& &&' +&.4 &'(1(.&4 )*% (+& &'+,'

,2*-'( *) :*2 23&'

,(1*' 3&%(,1'1'< (* (+& ., ,'4 1(-,(&4 1' %&;&'-& & (,(& 1& ;1..,<& ,'13-% &+ 1. ,(+,'?*(1 (%1:(-% %4, 3-%'*9 ,(+,'?*(,.*'<9 91(+

*.,(1-2,'4*(+ +&% (,(-(*%80&'&)1( 1';1&9*) )/-4<2&'(4,(&467D67B3,

&4 08 (+& (+1 *- -%( 1'

*666 *) 67

*666 *) 677 @! 91(+ A *6 @! 91(+ A *6 @! 91(+ A *6 @! 91(+ A *6 *) *) *) *)

67E 67E 67E 67E(1(.&4F -'

'/,02,..'4- (%1& @G3*%( '/,02,..'4- (%1& @G3*%( '/,02,..'4- (%1& @G3*%( '/,02,..'4- (%1& @G3*%( (*%3*%,(1*'

+-+,%1'<+ (*%3*%,(1*'

+-+,%1'<+ +@ +@ +@ +@ % H % H % H % H ,

&4(+&%&-3*','4,33.81'<(+&3 3%1':13.&*)3,%1(80& 14& <%,'( (*) /- (,'4),1%:*2 23&'

,(1*'(+&.,'4*9'&% L,3 33.1:,'( 0&1'< 1(-, ,(&4 ,%& &'(1(.&4 )*% <%,'( *) 121.,% ,2*-'( *) :*2 23&'

,(1*' +*9&;&% 91(+*-( , ,'8 3,82&'( *) 1'(& &%& ( )*% (+& 3&%1*4 *) 4&.,8 1'

' )1.1'< (+& 3%& &'( ,33&,. ' ( (+1 %&<,%4%&.1,':&:

:,'0&3.,:&4-3*'(+&4&:1 1*'

'*)*'H0.&-3%&2&*-%(1':

:, & *)I1'<,33,+ I1'<,33,+ I1'<,33,+ I1'<,33,+ +*(,33, +*(,33, +*(,33, +*(,33,'<,41&,4(+%*-<+ '<,41&,4(+%*-<+ '<,41&,4(+%*-<+ '<,41&,4(+%*-<+ +

3&:1,. 3&:1,. 3&:1,. 3&:1,. 1(1*' 1(1*' 1(1*' 1(1*' ))1:&%,'4'* ))1:&%,'4'* ))1:&%,'4'* ))1:&%,'4'* *(+&%J *(+&%J *(+&%J *(+&%J%&3*%(&4, I6767B 6767B 6767B 6767B BB BB BB BBJ,'4(+&.,(& (&G3* 1(1*'

'*) .,9 .,14 4*9' 1' !*+,% 1'<+ !*+,% 1'<+ !*+,% 1'<+ !*+,% 1'<+ &,4 +%*-< &,4 +%*-< &,4 +%*-< &,4 +%*-< -<+ % @ %

-<+ % @ %

(,(& *)

((,%

%,4& + *..&:(

%,4& + *..&:( (*% @ %

(*% @ %

(*% @ % %&3*%(&4 , I676 676 676 676 7BJ 7BJ 7BJ 7BJ 9+&%&08 4&.,8 *) ) 6 8&,% ,'4 4,8 9, :*'4*'&4 (* ,::*%4 4 3,%1(8 0&(9&&' 121.,%.8 3., .,'4*9'&% ,.0& &1('*1'(&%& (9, ,9,%4&4)*%4 4&.,8&43&%1*4+&%&.&;,'(3*%( (1*' (+&%&*)1 &G(%,:

:(&4+&%&-'4&%" I6 6 ,;1'<+&,%4.&,%'&4&'1*% *-'

&.)*%(+&3,%(1& ,'4*'3&%- %- ,. *) ( (+& 2,(&%1,. 3.,:&4 *' %&:*%4 9& & ,%& ,(1 )1&4 (+,( (+& ,33&..,'( ,%& &'(1 (1(.&4(* &&?3,%1(891(+(+&1%:*;

;1..,<&% 1'(+&<%,'(*):*23&'

,( ,(1*' )*% (+&1% ,:=-1%&4 .,'4 +1 *-%( +, :*'

(&'(.8 +&.4 1' , :,(&', , *) 4&:

:1 1*'

(+,((+&1'*%41',(&4&.,81') )1.1'<,33&,.1':*23&'

,(*%82,(( (&% 3&% % &2,8'*(0&),(,., (+&%1<+( , ,'4&=-1(1& 0&(9&&'(+&3,%(1& :,'

'0& 9&.

.. 0,.,':&4 08 4&'81'< (+& (,(-(* (*%8 0&'&)1( -:+ , 1'(&%& ( )*% 4&., .,8&4 3&%1*4 K& ,%& (+- *) (+& :*'

14&%&4 *31'1*' (+,( (+& 4&.,8 8 1' )1.1'

1'<(+&)1% (,33&,. :*-.40&:*'4 4*'&4 -0/&:((*(+&:*'41(1*'(+,( ( (+& ,33 3&..,'( 9*-.4 '*( 0& &'(1(.&4 (* &'-%& -'4-& 0&'&)1( )*% (+& 4&.,8 ,8&4 3&%1 %1*4 K& <%,'( -:+ 1'4-.<&':& 1'

1' (+& ,33&..,'(# ),;*-% ,.

* )*% %&,

, *'(+,(,0,(:+*))1% (,33&,.

,( (+&1'

(,':&*)*(+&%.,'4*9'&% 9 9,

(1..

..3&'41'<:*'

14&%,(1*'0&)*%&(+& &1<+*-%(..(+,((+&1<+* *-%( *-< <+( (* +,;& &23+,(1:,..8 4&'1&4 ( (* (+& .,(&:*2&% 9, (+& 0&'&)1( 1( *) 1'(& &%& ( 1':.-41'< *' (+& *.,(1-2 - -'4&% &:(1*' D *) (+& :( )*% 3&%1 %1*4)%*2(+&4,(&*)3,

1'<*)(+& &,9,%408(+& &)&%&':&*-%((1.. . (+&

)1.1'

1'<*)(+&)1% (,33&,.

J ';

;1&9*)(+&41 :-

1*'2,4&+&% %&1',0*;&, 9&.., :*'(&'( *) ,33.1:,(1*'(+&

,2&1 ,..*9&4,'44&.,8*) 74,8 1')1.1'<(+&3%& &'(,33 3&,. +&%&08:*'4*'

'&4

* *) *) *) *) 676 @! @! @! @! MN 8 9,8*)3%& &'(,33&,.:+,..&'< <&+, 0&&'.,14(*(+&9,%44, ,(&4 76773,

&408(+&.&,%'&444.1 (%1:

:(-4<&-%4, 3-%:-2 &)&%& ':& *-%(9+&%&08

&)&%&':& &(1(1*'-'4&%&:(1* *'5*)(+& 1(1*' :( 5BD 3%&)&%%&4 ,( (+& 1'

(,':& *) ,33&..,'( L.,'4*9'&% 9, 3,%(.8 ,..*9 9&4 9+1.& ,9,%41'< < (+&2 :*23&'

,(1*' O

67L 3&% ,:%& )*% ,%,'1 *2 *2&

7777L 3&% % ,:%& )*% &+%1

677L 3&% ,:%& )*% ,'/,% ,412 , ,'4

67L 3&% ,:%& )*% ,1% !-2?1' ., ,'4 ,.*'< 91(+ *(+&% (,(-( (*%8 0&'&)1( L1'(&%& ( 1'(+&1%),;*-% M6N

&, ,%'&4 :*-'

&. )*% (+& 3,%(1& ,%& ,4 14&2 (+,( -'4&% 21.,% :1%:-2 (,':& , ,'4 3&%(,1'1'< (* (+& .,'4 )*%2 21'< 3,%( *) (+& ,2& ,:=-1 (1*' 91(+1'(+&%&;&'

'-&& (,(&*);1..,<& ,'13-%& &+ 1. ,(+,'?*(1 (%1:(-%4,

3-% '*9 ,(+,'?*( ( (+& 2,%?&( ;,.-& (,'4 1':% %&, &4 (*

7777L 3&% ,:%& & ,( -'1)*%2%,(&08 8(+1 *-%(;14&/-4<2&'(4,(& &467D67B1'

*666

*666 6*) 6*) 6*) 6*) 677 @!9 677 @!9 677 @!9 677 @!9 91(+A *6 91(+A *6 91(+A *6 91(+A *6*)67E *)67E *)67E *)67E E(1(.&4F -'/,02,..'4- (%1&

-'/,02,..'4- (%1&

@ @ @ @ G3*%(*%3*%,( G3*%(*%3*%,( G3*%(*%3*%,( G3*%(*%3*%,( ,(1*'

+-+,%1'<+@ % H ,(1*'

+-+,%1'<+@ % H MN ::

:*%41'<.8(+&3%& &'(,33&,.1 4 3* &4*)1'(&%2 *)(+&4&:1

1*' %&'4&%&41' -'

-'/

-'/ '/,02,..'4- (%1& @G3*%( '/,02,..'4- (%1& @G3*%( '/,02,..'4- (%1& @G3*%( '/,02,..'4- (%1& @G3*%( *%3*%, *%3*%, *%3*%, *%3*%,(1*'

(1*'

(1*'H :, & -3%,,'4 ,33&..,'( ,%& & +&.4 &'(1(.&4 )*% 121.,% ,2* -'( *) :*23&'

,(1*' , +, 0 &&' ,9,%4&4(**(+& &% 1(-,(&4.,'4*9'&%

,.*'< 91(+,.. (,(-(*%8 0&'& &)1(

,'41'(&%& (,;,1 1.,0.&-'4&%(+&,2&'4&43%*;1 1*'

*) 1(1*':(5 5BD , ,33.1:,0.& ( (* (+& 3%& &'( ,:=-1 1(1*' 1':

:.-41'< (+& 1'(&%& ( *' *.,(1- -2 *9&;&% (+& ,33&..,'( +,.. '*( 0& &'(1( (.&4 (* 1'(&%& ( *' (+& &'+,'

:*23&'

,(1*')* *%(+&3&%1*4*)4&.,81')1.1'<(+ &,33&,.1&74,8 MDN

'41'<,33.1:,(1*' 1),'8 +,.. ,.

* (,'441 3* &4*) !,%:+ !,%:+ !,%:+ !,%:+B B B B676 676 676 676 (1? $! $! $! $! K+ K+ +&(+&% 3&,?1'<L%&, *'&4 &

+&(+&%%&3*%(,0.& &