Manisha Maheshwari v. State Of Haryana And Others




 





  
 






















 !"#
$%
  








!$%$&%'#
$%


 
 

   

 

 



(
)*
(
+ 
++ ,
 -







 



 
 
   



!
   


"
# 
$%
 

 &''
   
(
)


&
$
   




*

( !
   
+

,

---- ++ ,
 -
.


/'0&/1
/'23!$&%# .

/



! !
'

 
0


1 !
 

'' 
 '
!




2
+

,
  '
'!

 
 

 
'


#


 343.

#252.)42343.

/
 
  
 
! 67

' 67
 
!
 
0

 
2 (
+

,
'

 


 
'
!
 8&34.9
 '

'







2



(
)
/


 
!
 

 !

2

(
)

 


 

 


 
2
(
)
 
 
'



 ! &
/

'



!':

.4 34.9
 
' 

!':
 
'


 
&

 
 
; 
2)8.

 


'

!

2
(
)
; 
2)8.

!'

2

(
)


 


 


 



*
!


!

2
(

)

' 


 '


!


 
 '






 

; 
2)8.







'





  

!

!


'
 
! 
 !
#

  
 



 

! 

'"

  


!'

!

' 8 !

/
 

; 
2)8.
 ;


 

      

              



   

        

  

      !       



         

 "          

   

 



 



!   # $ %"

"

  "

  !  

 !

  &' &' 



<

  



! 

 '
 

2

+

,


 


#





 
 

!



#

 !

!





'

2 (
+

,

)

#2
+

,
!

 

 !
 !

2
(
)

 

 





 

'
!

2
(
)
  ; 
2)8.

/




"
 


!



!




!

 !

!

! 2
(
)
  

!
'
 
8&
34.9
/


!

 


!


 


 

'

= 


' !
 
!


 


'
!


!
 ; 
23
; 
 
 '

 


'!'
!  
  
; 
2+8<

2+8)
 
 
 !

 

!

 '



'


!'

 !


    )

#2
(
)
!
 

!
 



 !' 
* 


!'
 

'2  

> 
'!

  
 



 
'

' 

 
2
+

,
  


'
"





' !

 
' 
 '
!

2
+

,


 

 ' '

'

'

!



 

'



  
 


>


 


2 (
+

,
 !

!

 

 

'"
 ; 
2)8.

/
 !
!





 '





!

2 (
+

,



"


' !




' 
 

'
!

2
+
 ,

 

 '

'

'


!

'

 
 '
 '
  





   







'
!

2 (
+

,

!!

 !


  


  +

5

'


! 
 

#


 3?

4.

343.

 
;


 
 
'


  

 
  

 
#



4.

343.

(      "

 !

   

#

 

     

 

  

 "

 "





 ) 

 ( *+*,,*,+- ,

@
4.

343.



2! 
  #



 
;


  
 
'


  # #    

    ,.*+,*,+  

     

  / # 

#   "



#

 # "

 



  0

 

1#     # 2

3#

 



0  

   

 

4



#   

# 

    

      

 

#

   

    

      





#   

# 2

# #

#   

#    6   )



 

4

  5     

# 

 

  0 





# 

#  





#   # 

 #   

"

 "#! 5   "7 # 



  0  ( "



  +8 "

 "





 ) 

 # "

  

 9 3

4 

#   5 

 

 7  "



 7

 #

#2

 



0   

    #  "

      

  :; ( ,,*,,*,+- /%#5%3
$"!
06
5%0!57
'& 0$#8
06!$&36
/%
$!#!
7/#
98
065

$&!0
$%
   ?





 
;


  

!


#


'
  

 '
 
 
>
  


 
 '
 


!' 
  
' 


 




 






 
 

!

  






/
 
  
 ' '


 '


#



  !!
  


 

 
 

!


"











!



" 


  

; 

 
 
 


'
 !



'

!!



/
 
!  
 
  

  


#


 



 '
 


! 


 
 
!

#




 
 '




'
!




 
 '


!

2
+

,

#> !

 

! 

 '  

 
'


#


4.

343.
 

#

 
 
 '

!

2 (
+

,
 !
 

 !
 



' !

; 


  

 



 !  




2
+

,

 

'  ''
 
 

!

!



 ' !
 

'
!

; 
  !!


 

 


'

2 (
+

,
'



 
 

#

 4.

343.

!!
'



  !
!









  


#!
5! 
#''


   
 
 
;


 

    

 
 



 8+*+,*,+#   



# 0  

 

"

  2 <  



0=0   "#  / #  >



,+;  13     ,?*+,*,+       2

#  "



#

 '  " #   #

"

 

 # 2



 

 



      0=00 

 

"



#

 *+8* 1    

  

 0=0     #     # 



 / #  $"# 

# %  @   "           



 

"



# ## #   / # 

    #



"  

 

7

5

=  "



  

# 

"

 !

"

"

"

  # "

  "

 



  

# 

)

    #  

A 



# 

  )

   #  

 

 2

#  #          

0  / #      

  3 ! #   

"#



#   

"

   



 "

 # A 

   

 "   "

      

 

#  # 3 ) 

B0# 

 )  6 0       

  



# 

# # - &' &'  



"

/
'! !

 '
 
 



  

!

!

; 
2)8.

 
2
(
)

 

 
 ; 

'
' !

' 

!

2

+

,



 '
'

'

'


!!


> 


 

'
 
  '
 '
  
/


 

!


:

'
!

 '
 
 '

!





 
 
!

!





#!
5! 
#''

  
 
 
 
;


 
'

 
'

 

 

'

 
<.


& !
&  
6# 




#! 7
 
34.+
6


B 
 B7
  
 
;


  


6 7

'" ; 


!

!


'

2 +

,
/
'



;

  





 
' 
 

'

!

2 
(
+

,

!




  
 !






'  
!

 

 ' .4



'





 
;

  

!
' 





!

2
(
)

2
+

,

 '


' 
 


 


 

 

!
 
#



 
 '

  

!

#

/  

#!
5! #''


 


'"

 ! 

'

 
<.


B 
 B
>

!




 

 

( !
 

#


4.

343.

 
! ;! 


'



 
'  
!

2
+

,
/
 '  




 !

#





!

 

 

 


 
 

 

  

'
!

2
+

,
 

'
 !
; 


  
'


#


4.

343.




"


!




!

 " #
 $+% # 

  #

     #   "

  #   "



 

0



"

 

 

 

 CD$%   # #

   #7   #     0 = 

1# 3#

  #

   #  0   1  #  E      #   

 "   



"

 # F$%

"#

F$%0  

#   



'



     #   "

# "



 



F$%0 = 

3#

  "#

F$%  # !

  "#   #G F$%"



# 

F $%   

  #   

        



  



C1   

#   "

 # "





0



   

"  



 '  )#



 #

 

7 

$,%2

 





!

 #       #   



 "



 

0







    

# # 

H

 #  

 

# "

  





4

- +&975 5$%
$;
06
1/!%#
'$&% 1
;$!
06
<0505$%!

..

.7 /
! 
!
 

! 

! 


*'  


B!
;
#


 
!



$%&' ("



 & )& *   +, &

&

$' 

 &

*
 -  .

! 

/  0


  C
6# !

7
(
.,?+

34.A
 '



' 




 !


 


 



! !
!
 '
2
+

,
'

"



!!

 !
 



  

!
' 





! !
'


!

'

' 

 


!

 !



! !

!


!

'

 !
! 

 

'
  
  ' 

' 
 
' 
 
 '

  !  $="!.
;$!
06
!/ $%
0$
9
/ 53%#
6!5%/;0!
065
$&!0
#$ %$0
/3!
=506
06
/9$"
&975 5$%

.3

/

 * 

 
'

 '! '


 
 .7 /



!

!


>
 
 
; 
2)8.

 

!!
; 
2)8.


!

 
 ' 
  

2

(
)
  

!

!



'  
! 
 !
#

  
 




 


! 

'"

  

!'

!

' 8!
 


37
  

 
2
(
)

 

'"

; 
2)8.

 

!
 '


 

!




 


 !

2
(
)



' !

!

2
+

,

/


 

2
(
)

 




'
>

!

2
+
 ,



 '
'

'





 
"
 

!

'

!!




 

 '
 '
  



<7 D
 
!

2
(
)
!!



  



 

!
 
' !
 


 

'



 


 !

!


  
 
2
+ 
,
!  

'!'
!  
 
 ; 
23

2)

 





' !
 
 

!


!





 


  

!

 '
  
 
 '
 
/
 '
 
 


 

 
; 

)7   



  


'

!
 
#



4.

343.

 
;


   
  

!

#



 
'   

'
!

2
+

,
#> !


#



 

 

 '
!


 
 !!






 
; 
 
 


2
+ 
,
 

 ! 

  '

 
 

!
  
  

E


; 
' 

'
!

4.

343.





'

2 
(
+

,



 ; 
 
 






#!
5! 
#''

  
/  
 
 

#

 '
 
 '

 
'
 !


#



4.

343.
 


#



 
 '
 
! !
! 

2
+

,

.<

/


'"

 
 !

 '!



 


 '



6 7
!
 !
 
'

! 

"


  







 
 

!
 
 
' 


 '
 

 '

!
  
!'

  B
'
 
 '
 
!

' 
 '
  
 

  
<)



6 7  
 
 '
;


  



   !! !

!


 

! !
 
 

!


 

!


 
! 
  


! !
 


!

  



! F892





#   "

 

   

# # # #  # # 

#  #!

 # # 



# 

 

    

" 

#    

#       #2

# # #

 #    



  

   !

#



#   





 "

# 

  "



 !

#



#   





#



#  

#  

# 

    

 

  !

#



#  )#  #  

 

   !

#

 

# 2

 

  

#

   



 

  



 " !

#



# - .)

/  

 # 


6 7



  
 '
 
 




' 
>

!
 '


 '
 

! 

 





! !
 


 !

 
 '


#

 

!

!

 !!
*

'


! !
 

; 

 


'


 



 

 '
 
'
 

'

/


   '


! !
 
 '

 !
   '
 .+

/
 !
 
  

!  


 # 

'



6 7
 


!
! 
2 +

,

!

 '
 
  





> 
 !
 
 
!



/

 !
 





!

 '  
  




 
 !
 

> 
!  



 
 !

'

B!
;
#


*'
6 7
/
 !


! 

 '
 
 


'


!






! !
' 
2
(
) 



!

2

+

,

 
 

 '

!
 



2
(
)
!

!
 
 
 '  



 !

 '


!

2 
+

,

 
* !
;  

#!
5! 
#''


 

!


#





';''
 
 


'
!



!   
'




/




 



!

 
 '
 

 '

 

 


'
!



; 



 67

 



'' !


  '
 
'


!

!'


! !

 
'

' 
 


.,

  


'


' 8*'

8  

6.7
Manju Tiwari versus Dr. Rajendra Tiwari, (SC) AIR 1990 SC 1156
637
Syed Saleemuddin Versus Dr. Rukhsana 2001(2) RCR (Criminal) 591, 6<7
Roxan Sharma versus Arun Sharma (SC) 2015(2) RCR (Civil) 93
6)7
Eugenia Archetti Abdullah versus State of Kerala 2005(1) RCR (Civil) 259
6+7
Surabhai Ravikumar Minawala versus State of Gujarat 2005(2) RCR (Civil) 822
6,7
CRWP No. 68 of 2017 titled as Kirandeep Kaur versus State of Punjab and others' decided on 7.3.2017

6?7
Gippy Arora versus State of Punjab and others 2012(4) RCR (Civil) 397 (PHHC) and which but cast therein an expostulation of law that restoration of interim custody of the minor child to the ablest person, is yet to last only till a decision with respect to his/her ultimate custody rather is made by the Family Court concerned.

17.

Thus, the handing over the interim custody of the minor child but after confirming the order made by this Court on 01.02.2021, is made subject to the determination of the ultimate custody of the minor child rather being made by the Courts or authority hence holding the able vested jurisdiction to do so.

18.

Disposed of with the above observations.

.A

( 


 
!!

 


; 
 



' 








! 
Courts or authority rather holding the able vested jurisdiction to '" 
*  


!


 



!
 

4



>++ ,
 -?

 


 " 



,606!
</25%3@!/ $%# 

 @$ ,606!
!<$!0/91 

 @$