High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-A/1208/2019dismissed

Baljit Singh v. Harish Chander Chopra And Others

2022-09-08Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mr. Justice N.S. Shekhawat12 pages

"# # $ %

! # #

&' # ( (() * +' # (

#(# (*)

! " # $

#(# (*), # % &'()" "

# " # *+ ,- *,.(/0 . 1 /0 $12" # /

3 .)4*,,- *.( *.- &+& &+) &). &+5 &+' 5,+ 5.. .*,$6 % #/" ! " # /

"/0 "

/! ! " # 78 / ""

/ 2 " # 9

! # #! 1 0

! # #

" 0 /" " 1 0"" # # # *.( *.- &+& &+) &). &+5 &+' 5,+ 5.. .*,$6 1" /0

$# "

" 1 / " # 3 . :

;< 1 1"8"

.* ,+ *,,- /..

1 # #" " =# > %1 3 * 6

3 & 3 . # $ # # $

/ # 1 8 /0> =#$ 3 * 01

# .,'4.5.

"/0 / # 4 /0 1

# "" 1 " 3 .

% "/0 # ""!

%#%8 > # # 1 " "

# ! 1 1 #8 ! # "# " % / # 1 1 # 1 01# 1/ !! " 3;

0 # 1 1/ 1 // / 61 " 1 1 /0 " "

# !

% $# ##0#! ?8 @.4/" ;<

- # =# > 3 * 1 ! " " "! # .* ,+ *,,- "1 20 # ! #! " =# > 6

# "" /0 # #8 1 1 1 # 1 /" "

" ,5 ,- *,,- "/,&# "

" " 1/ 0" # .* ,+ *,,-?8 @.4 1 !/ # /0 # ##0 " .* ,+ *,,- % $# # &" "0" #/ /1 $

!"#!""$ %"&' () * + , - ,. & , +

,/ 0

1232 ,

1 + ) * 4,4 %56 3

4, - ,. & ,+ () *

+4 4

"78 9 +*+ 3

444

4 , ,

& 4

4 ' 3

44 , : 3

3 ,

3 ++

1# 1 "

;

85/ 0

1232 2!#!) ) !8"#8!""$< % 1 /" "

. / ! !! /" A#0 # / #"/ # 01#/0 6 ""

# / / !"" # "

# # / # 0 1 ! " # / /" % # 2! "" /0 1 " // 0" ! ##

"" "1 0 !/ 1

% B " #/" # "

!1 " 1 " ! ! " # 1 8 / ""/ 41/2

" " 2/0 # " 1 &'()

1 0 ! /"

@ ! " # $ 1 /

! ! !/

6 # 1 " #! " # 10#0 % 0! 10 / !11 # ##

// #!# "

#/ # 6 "! " # 1 " # ?8 @.4 1 1#!/0 # ?! " ! #" 2 # ""! 1 ! " # ,5 ,- *,,- # # " !/0 # B % $# 0" 1 /" / # 2 0 8

! % # ?8 @.4 1 0#! ##0"

/ 1 !&$)=# "

" " 1 /0 1 1/ .,'4.5.

" B # ! # # 1 1 1

1 !" 2 61 # ?8 @.4 "# !0## #" " 1 @ #! " # ?8 @.4 # 2 1/ # " #! ! # " # % $# # /..

.* ,+ *,,- 1 #"# " # $ # /

# "/0 ""! %# %8 =# >$ 3 * 0 1 # .,'4.5.

% 1 /0 1

# ""1 " / # @ # # " " #8! #"# " 18 /0 01# $# 1 !! # " 3;

0 # 01 1 // / "#

! 1! # /0 1 1 #0 # " ! " # ?! !/0 #

0 /!/ 6 / / # "#1 1 0*)"10"# % # 1 ! ;# 112 1 1 % " 0 "#

! 1! " #"" " # 6 /!/ / # 0 "/ #";

""4#" ;< 6

0 /!/ ""48$""1 0 "" "/ 01 "

/ ?!

0 # "# " 0 / $# # "# ## 01 ! ##0" " " " 1! #" # #" #!! 0# # "" " ;< / " # " ! 0

;; 0! " "B

# 1 1 # ! "

8# >

# ;@$.

2 1 "0 =# >$ 3 *! ; 1 ##1 "0! " # =# > 1 " # 0 / # # 1 1 /0 #

6 # 2 1 ! ?8 @.4 $# 1 1 /

//0 " 1 1 # 1

1 4# "# " 4 " 1 ##1 # / 0 # 8# " 1 # 8#

@$& ; 01

@$& 1 !1 /0 # ! /2 # ?! 1 ! "

@$& 1

0 /!/ " / #

?! "# " # 0 " @$+$

1 1 0" 0

#! ! 1 @$+ /" 10 " 1 ! 8 / /!/! # 1 1 0

# /#/0 # "# # 2 1 "/0 4# 1 #/2#! # " # 0/" 0 # $8# "# C

0 D " / 6 >"" # # 1# C

E D

1! / # 1/ # " ! " " # # 0 20 !/0 # # # 20 1 / 2 1" /" # 20 " #

" # """

;# 1 # 11B = ?!

# #"@$&

; / # 1 /0 # #! ; < " # #"@$&

; 1 # 1 # 4 #!/0 #

2 0 1 1 " /0 / # 0"@$+$

#0 # $ @$&

; 0 1 % 1 # $8# !1 # = 0*,,+$,'

# "# "(4.,0 " 1!

" # "# 0""1 # "# 0 0 "# 0 /

>"" # " "" # /0 # # 0 1 ## 1 2 "# 1/ ! 1 00 / # "# 0 #

"# """ ;# ; "# / 9#" # 0 ! 1 1 # 0//

F " $# /# =# >$ 3 * 1#0 >""" %1 1! " #80"1 "

0 2 0 =# > ! "1 /0 # ## "" /0 # 1! # /

0/0 /0

" 8# ;@$.>

" 2 1 ! ! =# > " #

!/0"> 0 1 1 " #8 " ! # > 0 1 ! =# >$ 3 *BB" 1 2 0 =# >$ 3 * " 1 # 1 0 ! # 8 1

"# ! 10"1 / !/ ""/ 4 " # %

0 # 1 " #! ! # / > " " ! !/ /# #/0 " $# 1" !1 # # "2 /0 // "# ! ! "1 # " 1 1 ! ! " /1 "1 "

2/0 / "1 0!1 0 / 0" " # "

/! " "! 1 0# " ## 0 " 0 /""1"80" "#

% / /B

# " 0 " 0 1(() *2

#(# (*)2

# # #B @ B 4 G?43> @ /

G?43>