High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/509/2014dismissed

Sardar Singh v. Surender Singh & ORS

2015-04-20Mr. Justice Harbans Singh Rai4 pages

!" #$%

!" #$% &' () ! &' () ! &' () ! &' () ! *&+,&+*-.

*&+,&+*-.

''+ ''+ ''+ ''+ /+0 /+0 /+0 /+0 *0+,+*-.&,'.+ *0+,+*-.&,'.+ *0+,+*-.&,'.+ *0+,+*-.&,'.+ 1,' 1,' 1,' 1,' 23 ! 23 ! 23 ! 23 ! &' () ! &' () ! &' () ! &' () ! ..'4& ..'4& ..'4& ..'4& ''+ ''+ ''+ ''+ /+0 /+0 /+0 /+0 *0+,+*-.&,'.+ *0+,+*-.&,'.+ *0+,+*-.&,'.+ *0+,+*-.&,'.+ 1,' 1,' 1,' 1,' $) $) $) $) 54$ *66 54$ *66 54$ *66 54$ *66

+') $+ &,&7,(&' +'.1''+ "

!% $++,608&+&,&7,(&' +'.1''+ " 23 !% $+$09.&,&7,(&' ++1,' $++,608&+&,&7,(&'

++1,'"

!% :::

66&&7 66&&7 66&&7 66&&7 . + 1'' &+ &-&' '. +,+ ,&',

;"<0+ =;%,8-&&11(&'>+0-.'>?

'. , ,&' + &8,8' '. @+'' '&'8' & '+ (88(8' '+& .0' ,>?

810--'.&

(',>?'. &'.+A, ,&' & 1&'.&''.1+1+'?.&>, ++&&(&,'. (,+&'.&>+&,&,,1',(+'&>&9 &((0'@'.'.1( (08>+ '.&((0'.@+''

== == == == '&'8' .& > , >? '. &'.+ (',- '.&' '. 1&'

9@&>0''.&&,,?-&'.&''.&80' @+,1','.1&+'(0&+&((0'+ ++,''.1&' '+'.((0 ,(

&, > + '. , ,&'5 ,( >-&7 '. , ,&' .& 0-.' ' >+- & &8,8' ' (', '.&' '. 1&'

1+0+B,'., ,&''(.@&',88?

+ .8 &,7 '.+ +7 & '+ '. 1+1+'? @& ,7 '. (,+&'@&+&,&,.&,,+''.1&'

. , ,&'(',,'.&''.@&8+?(&+ (&'+?&'0+ .&11(&' +&8,8'@&+C(',>?'.(0+'>@ ' +? @ 0,+', '.&' '. 0+' .& > >+&(,+-1& +&8,8' &@+'''&'8'

'.&@.&'1> +&8,8' '.1&' . (,+&''.&', ,&'.&81+-@.(.&1&'

,'.&'.&'(0,'.1&'.&'(''@'.& &+++1> +&, ,&'.0'8+?

@.'.+&(''+&'+&'1&,-1> . 0+'.&'<&8'.1&'.('<' '.&8,8'

'.&'.&>>+0-.'&>0'0,+ +,+3 0 D'.('!3

'., ,&'.&1+0?(',,'.&''.& @&8&,''.9@,-

&,.@@&'' 8&9&1&'.&''@&'8+?@'.'.9@,- '. 1&'

>0''@&,0''.1&'

5(8107'..80'

>&>+--&@, (-&7 '.&+++ @&'.&'..&,',1','.&(,+&'>&9

=;= =;= =;= =;= &((0' 1( , >? '. 1&'

&, @ . '+?- ' (', '.&' '. & (,+&' @& 8&, + ' '. 1&'

.8 .&,,-&@C0' (&'7@.(..0-.'' .&9@ 0(.(''@+'>'+0

.& > <&8,7 8+ 81+'&' &1(' '.&' & '. (&+? &('+,>?'., ,&'@+'>( +', ''.1&+'?7'.&''.+0+1+ '.'+&.1+&('( .&>., &+&1'/+0+,+&=

&+&1'/+0+,+&=

3 &(0''&;

3 &(0''&; @.(..&>+ ++,'&,&11+,>?

'.*01+80+'$ &8."%>?4+/6$/+&C $ &8."%>?4+/6$/+&C $ &8."%>?4+/6$/+&C $ &8."%>?4+/6$/+&C

+"%>?4+&,'.+7 ;"% "% ;

+"%>?4+&,'.+7 ;"% "% ; @.+'.?

>+, '.&' @.+ + '. 11' .& ,(, ' && .8 '.11+'0'?'10'.'&&,8&'+&(& (+=<&8&'7 ' 80' @ '.&' . >, '.&''. ''8? - (0, ' > ,10', &' & ' & +0

'&C0'(&''.'+& '., ,&'7'.+ +7.&,'

011+' ' '. 1&'

(+=<&8&' '.&'

(,+&' +&, + E;

&( @& .&,, + ' '. 1&'

& '+'.&7.(&'>1+8'','>+-&@1& @.(.80'?>'&9&>+--&-+&'0+1+ '.'+& .&8,8''.&'@&>+0-.''.?&+

7&8,'' +'&( +8+&F0&+'+(0,-'. >&+@&'0+'.1+-+ '+&@'.0''0' ?-&F0(9 ,1&@.&(''1&(0,>>+0-.'7' .0,''&,'. '' &8,,1+ +,+ 3

0 D '.&'&1+.&'>1+8'','&8, '.1&,-& '+(88(8' '+&7 &&1('@.(.

=!= =!= =!= =!= 0-.''>1&,,&'+@&@'.'.9@,- '.1&+'?

&,@.(.7 ,0,-(.&,>&11,7.0-.''.& '' +'.'.+-&'&'8'' ., ,&'@. (&8,'.&''.&@&,@'.'.('

(0,'.&8'','8&9&81+'&''&'8''.&'' @&'8+?&('>0''@&(810G'.&''@&' 8+?&(& ,1' &(,+&'>&9>0''@& &('0&?&(& .&,-+&(,+&' 8+'.&;

&(''.1&'

.8 ., ,&'@&'+&?'+?-' >+-&((9&,>0'+?'.+0-.&&8,8'&,+-.' 0?

+C(', >? '. 0+' >@ , (1 + '+'

1''&+,8, 1+ 7 1+ 7 1+ 7 1+ 7 "66% "66% "66% "66% 9&(.&