Haryana Public Service Commission v. Parmila And Another



  
 


     
 8 8 "
(7  -8  "(.&

-8 ' )
  

 

    9.&&

  9'& * 

 

  



   !     9    9'& *       "

 !

 "
" #

$""

  ! " "
$

"
 +!,  - . +,% / -.- +.  )

-. +.!

,  -.-    

&&

:   +')

-. + -.-

0 

   +* 1  -.-

02 .3(   +  +-)& .

& 

&
 ./ -   


 4 %

 & %  2 .3(      

   -     %    

     6 %   & 2 .   3(    -  &&

;

;

    

  !

#   
  %   

 #

$ #

%% &       #   

  & %    &        



  & %  %%  # < # 



  

 % 3   

      

        &  ;  =    

% # &  

  

#    #    1

7 &    #   ;   % & # +%  

 

#   -& 

  !

# &     #  $ # % - %   &&

  &  + 
 ;2 .   8 &  #   !

#  # 6   & :& 
&&

      #  -% 



    &   8 6  %         #   &  

    

      >        ?   @A      (   3   B3  # 

 &&

   

#

   

# & 8&  /4>+A   .   3%  

 #&&

  

# &B8&  /4>+A +% 4 =    # #->
A"%&''()(* '+,- ";
 

 

 

   

 

  

 

     

   

  



  

      



 

      

 

   





! " #

 

  



 

 

   

 

  





     

  

"

 



!  $         

   



   



   

  

   

  

 



  "

  



!% >A 4# "-./'%,$(01'2*''+,3% & 

";
 $ 



 

 



 





 



  

   

 

        

    



& !

 $

 

"

  



  '(! !% >3A 4   #  
(,'&4)'05 #)467#%'3 %  &  

"; C$

 

 

 ) ! ! $         

"

 



 

* !%  4    %  %&&





 B 4% &  &% 6>6A #% #

% -

  % 

#   

   6>6A # 4  - % %      #  #;% - % 

  

!



 1% #    -  

 %   -  -  #  #1  #-%  %
 8-%

 & & # 

!1% # %

/ # -%  %
8 3   1    #  % 

%  & & -  - 

        1     / #:

# - #   # / #: &  

    #  4 %  & : &-  -  



   # # / ##  #  =   4   #  $ #  &    - 

 2  % & & 

 !

#&  & 
 


((  && >3A  
D     !
! "

## $ %$&(>8A
D
 '
&&

 &
> A8 D()' &
&&

 & 03B- !

#&   # $ #%   

& 

 ()'@  > &A %  @

   &      # 
  '*+> &A-  ";
&)! #+, !+ 

-!.! >
A 8 &/ 0 

    

       

  

   





    

    

    2 

  

    

    

  



    

          3 



    

    

         ! #     

    

       4    

 

    



 

  

 1

2

    

  

 

    



!$ 0 

  

     1  2   

    

  

         

 

   

 

        ! & ! $   

 

         + 

 5 .

 

  4             

     

  

6 7  

       

 

  

   

   

     

     

    

  

    

     

! 8     

        

   "    9   :



  



   

     

  

      

             



! &&! ;

  

 

     "    9  :

   "

  

   

   



 

   !$          

  

        6

<)!#  



   "    =   / :

        

     

  

 

   

  

    

  

 

       6

<)! $      

 "   > 0   

      

   "       

  

! &7! ?      

      "   !<)!

< &

  > 0 

=  

5.

 /; 8 @ ! )(<A

<



 



    

   !%

 2    

   -    #   #-  #%

 #& #

:  #1  #%



  &#%

 

#

& &  

!1% #



  # $ #  #   #& #   &#  #  %





&  # -% 

    

 ( 2        - %- 

  !

#& )  6    3
  
(;    
&&

  &    


(- %    %  

%   #   & # %  ";
#                  3    

    

  


 


  

 

     

             .          

  

    5; B   !#  

  



   

    

  !$   "               

 0  9  :+  6"

 9 :+       

 "            3

     

 

    "       

   

.

+ :+>

9:+ 3    

     

.

+ :+ 3



   



  

 

                    

    

      

  

        

            

 

         

   

             

      

   

     

         

   

       

 3 

  *   * 



! $  "   !

!.

+?  :+ 





 

>

9:+!$



         

 

   

   

   

       

       







C  

  

  

!%
 2    



)   6 !

#       2 . 
83   

 E +    


 

,   %   !
! "

##    &-   

(

-%  %  "; C#

" 

  

    

 

  

   

  



   

 

           

!$

    

 

   



    

  

        "      

  !%

 2          

   )  6!

#   

   B

  ; '  
"   &-   
3 - % 5  %    % "; CD! E



            

     



  

 

  

             

         

      !%
 2       

 

   !

#& $ & 6 +  #    9:;   <  )

# &   &  , "

&

 &  
3-  ";
)! $  

 



  

    

. B        



  

   

  



  ! )!) $     

       

  

     

      

  


 


       

   ! #           .  B     3

         





      "

 5 B   !$   "

   

 .  B        

     

 

    

  * 

   "

 5 B   

       

!$ 

  

   3

      



       

 B   ! # 

   

 

   ! $  5         



 

  

        

 

            

    

 3          

  3  ! )!

 $     

                      

   

    

 .  B           

 

     

! $    

       

           

      . B   ! )!&! #         

        

 

 

 .        

     

   

      

     ! #    

   



                   

 

 

  

 "

   

     

    

     



   !


 
 )A! # 

    

   

                   

           

 .  B           



   

*

! #   

 

      

  

 3

         

  

     

 

 5 B              

. B   

 !%
3 2     &   

  % 1  # (# - 
&&

 %&>3A23((-

% #!

# &  @

   &   "&&
, 
&&

%&.0'
(( 334%  
&&

 %&   #&
>
A'288
 2           1        )   6 $ #   '!  #  
&

  %& , "

&   )  & , & ,& +   & 3 >
A 2'

(- %   

  %   1  #   

    #    %  "6-&64 62642  > &A%

&&



# && 

  # #&

=  
8 

 

  %  
B 0  

   ( 
, .0' (   3 -  

  %/ 0   &&

        &   +<  /   ' # 



 4 -%& &%&  %&& #-   /  #       #   #  1 / # 

%&   #        #  - %     1   /  #  - &&   .   4

 - #-1 #

#/ #



  44

 

% &&

   

%%-@

 &     ";
)<! F                 

 

! $     

 

               

     

 

 

    



 ?0 !$

         

     

            

  ! #          

 ?0   

   

 3

              

   

 

    

      

         ! #     

  8   $

     

"          

  G  

     ?0              ! )) F  

  



 

     

    !%




 0 "&&
,@  > &A- @

   &    ";
)A! 8        

  

 C  ?0  +  +$        

      

       

      6 )&





  

 

 3     +   



 



  

   

   

 

 ) 

    

*

          5   ! #                

   

  !=

 

     

 

6  )&   ! # 

     . +   

   



     ) 



*

    

    



      5B   !%
   #     &- %    #   #  &

 =    

 #-  &  &       &&



         #   #  '

-   - %      && # #-& &  #    & &    : 

#

  & & #   #

   -1    #    & &   4

  &&#;% -%   -&,)  &

 #
( 0%-

--
&

 

#

& &

#- 6>6A#-  - -



 & # ##%

 

%& &    &- - / ,% #4 #-  - #%   &&

0 %  ##;%    & &      &-      # %   %

 &&



  4 -# 

 #  #-&  &   # %&

 
 

    %   1   &

 =   

 #   &- 1  #     & & 

       #  %  =      

 #       # 

1 #;%  4 -

  
 &   &

 #-      #%

 

 0      -     1   %    / #  -     /  #      

F  - %  / #%

   

   & &    #   # 4 / # %

      %   # #       # + #  -  -    &&

  &    %  %;

 #     =  :

 %-         - %  &  &   #   &&

-  ;

 ##



  4    =&    #   

 #  % % & 1 &       &

 # 4 #  -  -   

 &&

     

5  #  =    

!,% #4 %   3 0 "&&
,@  > &A-      % % =& D %- %

     #   &    # % %=    0
  '@  > &A- @

   & 

% %  

  && 0 %

# 



%   &&   F& # 4 

 /  # 

 & #%

 -%   -

= 4 -

  # ## 6>6A #- #1%

 &  &#     4  %  1 
  '@  > &A %

%#  @

 & 

,(, .&>
A 
  "; C)&! $        

 

      = 

6" 0 C"  - H  

  

    =  

 8  5 .

! 8

    

 



 



  

    = 

6"   C"   -    



   

        = 

85.

    ! )7! $    

       +  ,       

        # +   5 0  

   !#  

      

   

?0:F    

  :F  

       

             

-

 F  

   

   

!#          

-

 :F        



 



  



 

++$ ?0       


   %       

    

              !% II II II

&! $    

 + ,        

   4  

               

  +  +$   ?0  

                   

    



 

!

7! $ 

     =       

 

  

      !$ =            

     

   4  

     

       

 

   

  

    

   

  

   

     

 

!%



 .#  @

   &    !

#   # / .

 &
&&

 &  0B

- !

#&  #  +   #    ";
)A! #



  

  

     

+,:

    

++>:

        

       4   

   

     4   

    

     

     

   

 



      ! # 

  

             

  +*+$*?0   

  

  



 -6C+3  

   

  

   C+3 ! )(! #   

    

 

   

-6 

   

       

+*+$*?0*B;+

!8   

         

       -6 C+  

!#     

  

 -6C+  

  3  

  C   !% 8  #       !

#-%

    &

=  #  #  #&# 1&%   #   & & 

 &&    &

 #   

 #  %-  && # 

 

# -&#

 5




 
   = - %   

  - %     #      B 0  & - %

   &  & % & #  #       %   &    /  #

    #   -

     % #% % 

-% && % # 

/ #-% 0 %      %   % 
  '@  > &A % 5

  

% 



     #   - 

   &&% %

 

# 4 %    #!

# 
 '@> &A @

+$   ' 6  -%   "; C))!$    13 2    

  !+  6"

9 >    3 

 !#

    

 

J    8=  8"9! + 

 -.    5 .

 =    + 

5!.!!-+

 

  7

K  /!2  "  L   

 

       

 

 

 

 

    



   

 



 

    !$



 

M    

    

  

       

 

   3 

    !%   ,& #  % -%

 % %

        
&&

  & 
(


 
 "
( ;)-      % &  & 

% @

 & 
 '-

, (,  # / .

*  > &A 

 - 

% % $ & 6 +  #   

8 ; )

#&  & ,"

&

 & 
3D'@> &A +    
,@  > &A         %   !

# 
 '@> &A   0        %  =      1% #4 

G=   

 % 

    &41    &

=          & &         %-    #:&

=    - ;     &&     %    %

  

%  & &  =   ( 

 
& (#- @ > &A-=  # & #&   %  

    &   -%

& &  =  .      

   /  #    &&    #  -  

     %   #    # 4   

  

1 / #

  % 


 


1 6>6A#0%-%

&%

#   #-   

  & & #     =   #& 1#    # 3 0 &  - 

  %  % 1

   #1  # &     &- 

                -%

 

- 

%& &   =  0 &  - - %1 .&=  "&&
,@> &A-   %# % 

#  % % 
 '@> &A- -

   !

# &     #  $ #  #  %  &      & &   =      1 # -%  #  #-       !



 4 %  &  %

- -  & &  =   &%

 5

&&  

#  # -

    F& #    #  1   

   -      #  ; # 4 

 %

     &#&4

 # %

 

%    1   #  4    =  -    - 

   #      #   # 

  & &     =    &  ,% # 4

     & 

#   %  6$ #   


 

 
&&

 %
((8>A 8-%  % 

"; C! ;     



  

 

 

      





             

   

         



  

  

        

     

   

  

! ?    

  

 

   

  

     

     



              

       



  N NNN!!NN!>

 

    *

   

   

           N!!% 3
 0 %       3,='6>>'61)+ 2)+?)++'24!

#&   # $ # 

- 

   #  

&&  %    4

!,% #4

   # %

%

 &&  %       

   3 The writ petition was filed, which was placed before the Division Bench by the learned Single Judge on account of pendency of the aforesaid appeal. Since we have dismissed the appeal, we refrain from passing any order and direct that the writ petition be placed before the learned Single Judge, who would examine the issue in view of the



 observations made hereinabove. More so, no reply has been filed by the respondents in the writ petition till date.

33 .

 

 3  .

& #&&

 

 &  38 

"#

$""

   ,=>&)13; 

$

"
    &1 #: H: &

 H: