Sanjay Sharma v. Vinod Kumar
!"# $#%&'&()
*
+!(,!-+.!/0! 1#"&"&(#/ 2#/'3' 2&($430!/ 1#'5($#(" ) 6 7 + 77 /#'#(") /+!89!: $;%!"#: /".#5#"&"&(#/ /3<39-!9: $;%!"# /".#/#'5($#(" ===
>.#".#/ /#5/"#/' 9%!9 5!5#/' 0!- 8# !99?#$ " '##".#,3$@0#("A
8#/# #//#$"".#/#5/"#/'/("A B >.#".#/ ".# ,3$@0#(" '.39$ 8# /#5/"#$ &( ".# $&@#'"A ===
77 /!9 !;&(@ !/@3#$ ".# 0!""#/ !" '0# 9#(@".: 9#!/(#$ %3('#9 / ".# 5#"&"&(#/ '380&"' ".!" 9#" ".# 5#"&"&(#/ 8# (9-!
/$#$(&(#0(".'6"&0#";!%!"#".#5/#0&'#':!'.# $#'("?&'."5/#''".#5#"&"&((0#/&"' /!-#/ &' (" 55'#$ 8- 9#!/(#$ %3('#9 / ".# /#'5($#(": !' .# 0!&("!&(' ".!" (&(# 0(".6' "&0# 8# !
/$#$ " ".# 5#"&"&(#/"#(!(" " .!($;#/ ".# ;!%!(" 5''#''&( ".#'.5&(C3#'"&("".#/#'5($#("9!($9/$ .!" 8#&(@ ': ".# 5#"&"&( &' $&'5'#$ &( ".#
99?&(@"#/0')
& 5#"&"&(#/"#(!("'.!99%("&(3#"%%35-".# $#0&'#$5/#0&'#' /!5#/&$ (&(#0(".' /0"$!-&# 35"B
D && ".##("&/#!//#!/' /#(":& !(-:'.!998#5!&$ 8-".#5#"&"&(#/"#(!(""".#/#'5($#("9!($9/$?&".&( 3/ ?##<' /0"$!-D &&& 5#"&"&(#/ '.!99 %("&(3# " 5!- ".# 3"3/# /#("E0#'(# 5/ &"' 8- F". #;#/- 0(". " ".# /#'5($#(" 9!($9/$ ( ".# #;#(" #;#( ! '&(@9# $# !39": /#'5($#(" 9!($9/$ '.!99 8# !" 9&8#/"- " #G#%3"# ".# /$#/ #;&%"&(
/".?&".D &; 5#"&"&(#/ '.!99 8# 3($#/ 89&@!"&( " $# /!- !99 ".# #9#%"/&%&"- !($ ?!"#/ %.!/@#' / ".# 5#/&$ .# ?39$ %%35-".#$#0&'#$5/#0&'#'D ; 5#"&"&(#/ '.!99 ;!%!"# ".# $#0&'#$ 5/#0&'#' !($.!($;#/&"'!%"3!95.-'&%!9!($;!%!("5''#''&(: /##
/0 !99 #(%308/!(%#' " ".# /#'5($#("9!($9/$: ( / 8# /# ".# '"&539!"#$ $!"# &# B
: !&9&(@ ?.&%. /#'5($#("9!($9/$ '.!99 8# /## " #G#%3"# ".# /$#/ #;&%"&(!($8"!&(5''#''&(D!($ ;& 5#"&"&(#/'.!99 3/(&'.!(3($#/"!<&(@&(".# !8;# "#/0': &( ".# /0 !( !
&$!;&": ?&".&( ! ?##< /0 "$!-: 8# /# ".# #G#%3"&(@ %3/": !&9&(@ ?.&%. !@!&(
B /#'5($#("9!($9/$'.!998#!"9&8#/"-"#G#%3"#".#/$#/ #;&%"&(
3@3'"
:
!,!( /3(!99& 3$@#