High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5430/2015dismissed

Shanti Devi Since Deceased Threough Her Lr Naveen Sharma v. Shree Mandir Pop Singh Sabha (Registered)

2015-12-17Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih4 pages

!"# $#%&'&() *

+,!("&#-&$#%#!'#$",./0,1' 2#"&"&(#. 3#.'/' +,.##!($&.4+&(0,+!5,!#0&'"#.#$ 2#'4($#(" ) 6 1 + 11 .#'#(") .##4!7+,!.8!9 $-%!"# .",#4#"&"&(#. :::

;,#",#. .#4."#.' <%!< 4!4#.' 8!= 5# !<<>#$ " '##",#?/$08#("@

5#.# #..#$"",#.#4."#.'.("@ ;,#",#. ",# ?/$08#(" ',/<$ 5# .#4."#$ &( ",# $&0#'"@ :::

11 .!< ?#%"8#(" ",# "#(!("4#"&"&(#. >!' .$#.#$ 5= ",##("(".<<#.9 85!<!9-&$#.$#.$!"#$ A

' #-#(!(!44#!<4.# #..#$!0!&('"",#'!&$.$#.>!'$&'8&''#$ -&$# ?/$08#(" $!"#$

9 ",# "#(!(" &' 5# .# ",&' %/." (5.&# 9",#$#8&'#$4.#8&'#'&#!',48#!'/.&(0

6B 6&'!4!." +,.##!($&.4+&(0,,#<!($<.$ &# +,.## !($&. 4 +&(0, +!5,! &' ! +%&#"=9 .#0&'"#.#$ /($#.",#+%&#"&#'#0&'".!"&( %",##-&%"&(>!'%<!&8#$ ( !%%/(" ((4!=8#(" .#("9 . ",# "#(!(" >!' &( !..#!.' '&(%# 4.&<

C D 4#. 8(", !' !<' ( !%%/(" 4#.'(!<5(! &$#,#!%%88$!"&(&(E/#'"&(

>!' .#E/&.#$ 5= ",# <!($<.$ . ",# $#-#<48#(" !($ #F4!('&( ",#!($&. ( $# #(%#9 &" >!' 4<#!$#$9 &("#. !<&!9 ",!" "#(!(" >!' &( 4''#''&( 8.# !.#! ",!( ",# !%%88$!"&( &( E/#'"&( !($ ",# 4#"&"&( . 4!."&!< #-&%"&( >!' (" 8!&("!&(!5<# ,# !<<#0#$ (##$ ",# <!($<.$ >!' (" %(%#&-#$&(0$ !&",!($",#.!"# .#(">!'(<= GD4#. 8(",9 .8",#-#.=5#0&((&(0 ( ! $/# !($ ",/0,"

/< %('&$#.!"&( ",# 8!""#. &( &''/#9 !($ ",# #-&$#(%# ( .#%.$9 5", ",# !/",.&"&#' %(%/..#("<= %(%</$#$ ",!" .#(" ("# F9 #F#%/"#$ 5= ,/'5!($ +,!("& #-& (

HG9 4.-#$ ",# .#<!"&(',&4 <!($<.$ !($ "#(!(" 5#">##( ",# 4!."&#'

($ ",# .#%#&4"' &''/#$ " ",# "#(!(" !' !<' ",# %/("#. .#%#&4"''&0(#$5=,#.9 /<<=4.-#$",!"",#.!"# .#(">!' D4#.8(",,#4<#!'#"/"5=",#"#(!("",!"",#'!&$ .#%#&4"' >#.# .0#$ !($ ,#. '&0(!"/.#' 8&0," ,!-# 5##( 5"!&(#$ 5= ",# <!($<.$ 5= 4<!=&(0 ! .!/$9 .#8!&(#$ /('/5'"!("&!"#$ . <!%7 %0#(" #-&$#(%# !",#.9 ( !( !(!<='&' ",#'&0(!"/.#' +,!("&#-&(",#.#(".#%#&4"' !'!<'(",#4>#. !"".(#=!($,#.>.&""#('"!"#8#("95= ",##("(".<<#.&"'#< 9&">!'%(%</$#$",!"",#$&'4/"#$ !'>#<<!'",#!$8&""#$'&0(!"/.#'>#.#!

&F#$5=(#!($",# '!8#4#.'( ($9",/'9",#.#(""#($#.#$5=",#"#(!("C

GD4#.8(",>!'',."!($&(-!<&$1!($<.$9&('/44."

&"' %<!&89 ,!$ #F!8&(#$ !-& +!.!( ;

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

&(",#'&"#4<!(F;

>!'/($#. ,#. "#(!(%= ($9 ",# +%&#"= ,!$#!.<&#. &<#$ ! '/&" !0!&('" <#0!<,#&.' !&4!<+,!.8!9>,&($##$>#.#&(%%/4!"&( ",# $#8&'#$ 4.#8&'#' ,!" 5#&(0 '9 &" >!' %(%</$#$ ",!" ",# "#(!(" %/<$ !<>!=' '/5'"!("&!"# ,#. 4<#! 5= 4.$/%&(0 ",# '&"# 4<!( ",!" >!' 4.$/%#$ 5= ",# <!($<.$ &( ",# '!&$ '/&" &# &-&< +/&" *+9 &<#$ !0!&('" ",# 1' !&4!< +,!.8!95/"',#$&$("!",#.9",#"#(!("%,'#">&",,<$ ",#5#'"#-&$#(%#!($9",#.# .#9#-#(",#'!&$4<#!.#8!&(#$ /('/5'"!("&!"#$ /.",#.9 +,!("& #-& !0!&('" >,8 ",# #-&%"&( 4#"&"&( >!' 4.# #..#$ ,!$ $&#$ !

"#. &<&(0 ",# >.&""#( '"!"#8#(" !($ ",# 4#"&"&(#.9 >, %<!&8#$ " 5# ,#. <#0!< .#4.#'#("!"&-# 4/.'/!(" " ! ;&<< !<<#0#$<= #F#%/"#$ 5= ,#.9>!'!..!=#$(<= .",#4/.4'# 4/.'/&(0",#8!""#.

1#!.(#$ %/('#< . ",# 4#"&"&(#. %/<$ (" 4&(" /" !' " ,> ",# %(%</'&(' ",!" ,!$ %(%/..#("<= 5##( .#%.$#$ 5= 5", ",# !/",.&"&#' >#.# #&",#. %(".!.= " ",# 4'&"&((.#%.$.'/

#.#$ .8!(=8!"#.&!<&<<#0!<&"= &("#.

#.#(%#&'>!..!("#$&(#F#.%&'# .#-&'&(!< ?/.&'$&%"&(9 /($#. +#%"&( G ",# !.=!(! .5!( (".< #("-&%"&( %"9 H* #"&"&(5#&(0$#-&$ 8#.&"&'!%%.$&(0<=$&'8&''#$ #%#85#. *9

!?!( ./(!<<& /$0#