Surinder Gupta v. Satish Kumar Gupta & ORS




   



   



   



    
  
  
  
 







  !""#$%$&'(  !""#$%$&'(  !""#$%$&'(  !""#$%$&'( )*+$&,"+*-!  .$ %)*+$&,"+/*0 +11 +2 .

)*+$&,"+*-!  .$ %)*+$&,"+/*0 +11 +2 .

)*+$&,"+*-!  .$ %)*+$&,"+/*0 +11 +2 .

)*+$&,"+*-!  .$ %)*+$&,"+/*0 +11 +2 .

 "!$!$&"+  "!$!$&"+  "!$!$&"+  "!$!$&"+ 3"+%*% 3"+%*% 3"+%*% 3"+%*% ) !$%4/*0 +*-! 5$..  &,!4"+% ) !$%4/*0 +*-! 5$..  &,!4"+% ) !$%4/*0 +*-! 5$..  &,!4"+% ) !$%4/*0 +*-! 5$..  &,!4"+%  "%-&,"&!%  "%-&,"&!%  "%-&,"&!%  "%-&,"&!%  '

 '

 '

 '

 67

 )
  )
 67

 )
  )
 67

 )
  )
 67

 )
  )

+"%"&!'

+// +18,9# !"+!4"-"!$!$&"+

+/) ,2 .8,9# !"+!4"+"%-&,"&!% :::

 )",$8

 )",$8

 )",$8

 )",$8 4$%$%-. $&!$6%+"9$%$&-"!$!$& 1 $&%!!4"+,"+, !", ;;- %%",<=!4"." +&",,,$!$& .$%!+$#!*,1"8%4$ +-*+ ..2$&1!4" --" .,""&, &!%>+"%-&,"&!% 1 $&%!!4"+,"+, !", ?- %%",<=!4"." +&",$9$.*,1" +$9&8%4$ +-*+ ..2$&1!4" --.$# !$&*&,"+ +,"+?@ *."% &, !+"%!+ $& !4",""&, &!%>+"%-&,"&!%+0+ $%$&1A#&!$&*$&12$!4#&%!+*#!$& 2+B$&!4" +" #00&%! $+%8C$&!2 ..% &,#00&+!4"$+ <*$.,$&1%   4"  -. $&!$>-"!$!$&"+  4 ,  $.",   %*$!  +  $&C*&#!$&  ! +"%!+ $&  !4"  ,""&, &!%>+"%-&,"&!%  $.."1 ..=  &,  +#"*..= ,"0.$%4$&1!4"#00&%! $+%8C$&!2 .. &,#00&++!# *%" &=, 0 1"!$..!4",$%-% .!4"%*$!  B$&1$&!#&%$,"+ !$&!4"0 !"+$ . 9 $. <."&+"#+, $&#.*,$&1!4"%$!"-.

&8#-=24$#44 % .%<""&-. #",&+"#+, %&&"D*+" >;8!4"--".. "*+!4 %- %%",!4"..2$&1+,"+'> E
4 9"#&%$,"+",!4"#&!"&!$&% &,4 9"1&" !4+*14!4"+"#+,4"- +!$"%!!4"%*$! +"$&"D#.*%$9" -%%"%%$&    !4"$+  -+-"+!$"%  "$&1  $&  "D#.*%$9" -%%"%%$&8!4"+"%-&,"&! %2".. %!4" --".. &!

>> >> >> >> +$14!  !  "&C=  !4"$+  -+-"+!=   2"9"+8  &"$!4"+  !4" --".. &!%&+!4"+"%-&,"&!4 9" &=+$14!!"&C=$&1 !4"$+-+-"+!=$&!4"2 =24$#4$%,"!+$0"&!!!4"+$14!% !4"+- +!=
!$% & ,0$!!", #!!4 !!4" --".. &!% +" $&"D#.*%$9"-%%"%%$&!4"$+%4 +"824$#4$%%42&$& !4"  %$!"  -. &  $.",  <=  !4"  +"%-&,"&!   4"  +"%-&,"&! .."1",!4"%! $+# %" &,2 ..%  &, !<"

#00&8  24"+" %  !4"  % 0"  $%  .."1",  !  <"  "D#.*%$9" -+-"+!=  <=  !4"  --".. &!%   F4"!4"+  !4$%  -+-"+!=  $% #00&  +  "D#.*%$9"  2&"+%4$-    !4"  --".. &!%8  !4" % 0"#*.,&.=<","#$,", !"+ --+"#$ !$&"9$,"&#"A !<".",<=!4"- +!$"%
+!4"% B" +1*0"&!%8$!$% -+"%*0",!4 !!4"%! $+# %" &,2 ..% +"#00&A"9"& !4"&!4" --".. &!%4 9"+$14!!"&C=!4"$+-+-"+!= &, 4 9"+$14!!+ $%"#&%!+*#!$&%-+9$,",!4 !!4"+"<"& , 0 1"%!!4"%! $+# %" &,#00&2 ..%  &,

  &,  !4"  -+-"+!=    !4"  +"%-&,"&!   4"  &.= --+"4"&%$&!4"+"%-&,"&!!$."!4"%*$!$%!4 !!4"+" 2*.,<", 0 1"%!!4"%! $+% %2".. %#00&2 ..% &,4"+-+-"+!=  &!4"< %$%0"+" --+"4"&%$& &"- +!=8!4"!4"+- +!=# &&!<"+"%!+ $&",A,"< ++", +0"&C=$&14$%A4"+2&-+-"+!=
!4" --".. &!% +" +" ,=  !  1$9"  &=  *&,"+! B$&1  %  #&!"&,",  <=  !4"$+ ." +&",#*&%".8!4"=# &<" ..2",!+ $%"#&%!+*#!$& $&!4"$+-+!$&2$!4*!# *%$&1 &=, 0 1"%!!4"%! $+%   &,  2 ..%    &,    &,  !4"  -+-"+!=    !4"

+"%-&,"&!4"+,"+%! !*%G*- %%",<=!4"!+$ .*+! $%8!4"+"+"8%"! %$," &,!4" --".. &!% +"8!4"+"+"8 ..2",!+ $%"!4"#&%!+*#!$&$&!4"$+-+!$&2$!4*! # *%$&1 &= .!"+ !$&$&!4"#00&%! $+% &,2 ..%

&,  &,2$!4*!# *%$&1 &=, 0 1"%!!4"% 0"
! $%*+!4"+,$+"#!",!4 !!4" --".. &!%0 =#&!$&*"2$!4 !4"$+#&%!+*#!$&2+B*&,"+!4"%*-"+9$%$&G* .$$", <*$.,$&1"&1$&""+4"=%4 ..%""B!4"-$&$&!4"% $, <*$.,$&1  "&1$&""+ &, %*<0$! !4"  % 0"  <"+"  !4"  !+$ . *+!<"+"+ $%$&1 &=!=-"#&%!+*#!$&8%!4 !!4"= 0 =&!<" &=, 0 1"%!!4"%! $+%82 ..%  &,  % 2".. %-+-"+!=!4"+"%-&,"&!
&# %" &=, 0 1"%

>?> >?> >?> >?> $%,&"!!4"%! $+%8#00&2 ..%!4"-+-"+!=!4" +"%-&,"&!8 !4" --".. &!%%4 .. <".$ <." + !4"% 0" 4*%8 --" .$%8!4"+"+"8,$%-%", -=+,"+<" -. #",2$!4!4"+"#+,!4".2"+#*+! &,.2"+#*+! $.",<"+"!*+&", "0#%!%<"-+"- +",--" .$."

<"#&%$1&",!!4"C*,$#$ .+"#+,+0H 7" +&",#*&%".+!4"-"!$!$&"+>-. $&!$4 %#&!"&,", !4 !!4"#&%!+*#!$&!4"4*%"!4"-"!$!$&"+$%#&&"#!",2$!4 !4"-+-"+!=$&-%%"%%$&!4",""&, &!%>+"%-&,"&!%$&%*#4 2 =!4 ! &=#&%!+*#!$&+9$<+ !$&A,$%!*+< &#"$&!4"4*%"!4" ,""&, &!%A+"%-&,"&!%2*., "#!!4"#&%!+*#!$&!4"4*%" !4"-. $&!$>-"!$!$&"+ *&%".+!4"-"!$!$&"+4 %+".$",*-& C*,1"0"&!    / +& ! B  $14  *+!  $& 3$. %  C + 0  $& 9"B + 

3$. %  C + 0  $& 9"B + 

3$. %  C + 0  $& 9"B + 

3$. %  C + 0  $& 9"B + 

&!4"+3%)0!*. <$  !4"+%8 ? / +& ! B &!4"+3%)0!*. <$  !4"+%8 ? / +& ! B &!4"+3%)0!*. <$  !4"+%8 ? / +& ! B &!4"+3%)0!*. <$  !4"+%8 ? / +& ! B  $& %*--+!  4$% #&!"&!$& !4 !#00&2 .. # &&! <" !*#4", <= &=<,=!!4","!+$0"&!+ 1 $&%!!4"2$..!4"!4"+0 &
!2 % <%"+9",$&!4"% $,C*,10"&!!4 !$,""&, &!2 &!%!#&%!+*#! 4*%"8  4"  %4*.,  09"  +  #&%"&!    !4"  !4"+  0 &  +  "D-. $& &"#"%%$!=#0-*.%$&4$%- +!!09"!4"*+!+-+-"+ &, &"#"%% +=,$+"#!$&%8<*!4"0 =&!%*0!* #!&4$%2&24$0% &, &#= &,!+=!$&!"+"+"2$!4!4"-%%"%%$&8%! *% &,%!+*#!*+" !4"#00&2 ..
4 9"#&%$,"+",!4"#$+#*0%! &#"%!4"# %" &,$&, !4 !  $!

 $%  &!  # %"    !4"  ,""&, &!%  !  + $%"  +"%4 #&%!+*#!$& ""#!$&1  !4"  #00&  2 ..  <"!2""&  !4"  4*%"%    -. $&!$  &, ,""&, &!%  <*!  !4"  ,""&, &!%  2 &!  !  $&,"-"&,"&!.=  "&C=  !4"$+ -+-"+!=<=+">#&%!+*#!$&8%$0*.! &"*%.=% "1* +,$&1!4"-+-"+!= !4"-. $&!$ .% &*&,"+! B$&14 %<""&1$9"&!4 ! &=.%% # *%",& ##*&!!4"#&%!+*#!$&$&!4"4*%"!4",""&, &!% 2*.,<"#0-"&% !", &,!4 !!4"#&%!+*#!$&2$..<"*&,"+!

>> >> >> >> *&,"+!4"%!+$#!%*-"+9$%$&!4""D-"+!4"--".. !"*+!24$." 1+ &!$&1  -"+0$%%$&  !  !4"  ,""&, &!>+"%-&,"&!%  4 %  ! B"&  $&! #&%$,"+ !$&!4"+$14!!4"-. $&!$>-"!$!$&"+ &,! B"&""#!$9" %!"-%!"&%*+"!4 !!4"+$14!%!4"-. $&!$ +"&!-+"C*,$#",
&9$"2!4" <9"% $,#$+#*0%! &#"%8
,&!$&, &= 0"+$!$&!4"-+"%"&!+"9$%$&-"!$!$& &,!4"% 0"$%8 ##+,$&1.=8 ,$%0$%%",

=(8

=(8

=(8

=(8

 )

 )

 )

 )
B &#4 &