Kela v. Randhir Singh And ORS.
!" #"$%&%'()) * +", -"!%!%'". /".&0& '#1%.2%'31 '#!1".& -"&4'#"'!&
."&"'!( .&15 '%1 .#5 67#8$ !"
.!1"4"!%!%'". .21 %,"'#".1 '7#8$ !"
.."&4'#"'! %&40!"%'!1"4."&"'!$ &"%&."3 .#%'3!1"90 '!0:
"" 4 ; <," <; !1" 4"!%!%'".= 44",, '! 51%," %,%'3 44" , 3 %'&! !1" 60#3:"'! '# #"$."" 4 &&"# <; !1" 0.! 3. '!%'3 .",%"
&4"$% %$ 4".
.: '$" !1" 3."":"'! ! &",, 5%!1 ."&4"$! ! , '# :" &0.%'3 >* ? ' ,& '#: ., &44",, '!<"
."!1"," .'"#%.&!44",, !" 0.!%& !1" 4"!%!%'". %' !1%& 0.! 1 & $1 ,,"'3"# !1" #"$."" . &4"$% %$ 4".
.: '$" 3."":"'!!&",,<; %,%'3!1" %.&! 44" ,',;5%!1."&4"$! !
? ' ,& '#: ., & , '#$, %:%'3!1 !1"%&5'". !1"4.4".!; %"
? ' ,& '#: ., &40.&0 '!! ."3%&!"."#& ,"#""#"!%!%'".7 44",, '! <"
." !1" ," .'"# %.&! 44",, !" 0.!7
%@"# !1" ""7 $$.#%'3!!1"&0<6"$!: !!".!<"#"$%#"#%'!1" 44" ,7%"&)7A= B" .'"# %.&! 44",, !" 0.!1 &.#"."# !1"4"!%!%'".! 4 ; !1"
""751%$15 &
%@"# !!1"!%:" %,%'3 !1"&0%!'!1"3.0'#!1 !% !1" 44" ,%& ,,5"#7!1"#"$."" .&4"$% %$4".
.: '$"5%!1."&4"$!! "'!%.", '#0,!%: !",;&1 ,,1 8"!<"."8".&"#
;:"'! #=8 ,.": ""%&38".'"#<; 0.!""$!7 * '# !1" 2$1"#0," !! $1"# !1"."! .!%$," 2$1"#0," 4.8%#"& !1 ! 4, %' 5.%!!"' &! !":"'! 4," #%'3 &"!
. $0'!". $, %:.":. '#0: 44" ,. $.&&=<6"$!%'&! ';$%8%,. ."8"'0" 0.!"@$"4!!1&":"'!%'"#%'2"$!%')50,#<"."90%."# !4 ; ""'!1"&0<6"$!: !!".%'#%&40!"'!1"4."&"'!$ &"7 &0<6"$!: !!".%'#%&40!"<"
."!1"," .'"#44",, !" 0.!%&',;
? ' ,& '#: ., &.!%$,"2$1"#0," & 44,%$ <,"!2! !"
.; ' %&"@!. $!"# &0'#".(= 2. !0." #$0:"'!& :0'! / ,0" ) .4". "" %&'(' '( , %'!7 5.%!!"' &! !":"'!7 C1"'!1" :0'!.8 ,0" '".04"" 1."".04""&
%31!.04""& 4," #%'3 &"!=
. !1" &0<6"$!=: !!". %' $0'!". $, %: . #%&40!" #"& '! "@$""# :":. '#0: 44" , '" 10'#."# .04""&7 . '! !1".5%&" 4.8%#"# "8".; !"' .04""& . 4 .!
.%'!1%&$!. $.&& !1"." <6"$!%'4."&"'!"#! '; $%8%, . ."8"'0" $0.! C1"' &0$1 :0'! . "@$"4!!1&":"'!%'"#%' 8 ,0" "@$""#& '" &"$!%') 10'#."# .04""&7 <0! #"& '! "@$""# %8" 10'#."# .04""&7 . "8".; !5"'!; .04""&7.4 .!!1"." 7%' "@$"&& '" 10'#."# .04""& 04! %8" 10'#."# .04""& C1"' &0$1 :0'! . 8 ,0" "@$""#&
%8" 10'#."#.04""&7 ."8".;
% !; .04""&7 . 4 .! !1"." 7 %' "@$"&& %8" 10'#."# .04""&7 04!
!1.""!10& '#.04""& C1"' &0$1 :0'! . 8 ,0" "@$""#& !1."" 5"'!;.04""& !10& '#.04""&7 ."8".; '" 10'#."# .04""&7 . 4 .! !1"." 7 %' "@$"&& !1."" !10& '# .04""&7 04!!"'!10& '#.04""& C1"' &0$1 :0'! . 2"8"'!;= %8" .04""& 8 ,0" "@$""#& !"' !10& '#.04""&7 ."8".;
%8" 10'#."# .04""&7 . 4 .! !1"." 7 %' "@$"&& !"'!10& '#.04""&704! !5"'!;!10& '#.04""& '"10'#."# .04""& C1"' &0$1 :0'! . 8 ,0" "@$""#& !5"'!; !10& '#.04""&7 ."8".; '" 10'#."# .04""&7 . 4 .! !1"." 7 %' "@$"&& !5"'!; !10& '# .04""&7 04!
% !; !10& '# .04""& 510'#."# .04""& C1"' &0$1 :0'! . 8 ,0" "@$""#&
% !; !10& '#.04""&7 ."8".;
%8" !10& '# .04""&7 . 4 .! !1"." 7 %' "@$"&&
% !;!10& '#.04""& '!1"4."&"'!$ &"7!1"&0<6"$!: !!". #%&40!"%'!1" 44" ,%& ',; 5%!1 ."&4"$! !
? ' ,& '# : ., & 20$1 <"%'3 !1" 4&%!%'7 ," .'"#%.&!44",, !" 0.!$::%!!"#: !".% ,%.."30, .%!;%'8".,?%'3 !1" 4.8%&%'& 0.! "" $! !1"&0<6"$! : !!". !1" 44" , %&
? ' ,& '# : ., &7 44",, '! $ ''! <" .$"# ! 4 ; "" 5%!1 ."3 .#!"'!%."&0%!4.4".!;%">*? ' ,& '#: ., & ' 8%"5 !1"." 7 !1" ."8%&%' 4"!%!%' %& ,,5"# :403'"# .#".%&&"! &%#"B" .'"#%.&!44",, !" 0.!%&."90"&!"#!4.$""#5%!1 !1"#"$%&%' !1" 0.! )) * )* C1"!1".24" ?%'3A" &'"# ( "&A C1"!1"."4.! <," ( "&A