← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5091/2017allowed

M/S Jindal Impex & ANR v. Malayan Banking Berhad & ANR

2018-02-16Mr. Justice Arun Monga10 pages

  

      



!" #$% &'() *+,&+- ./

$12&345/6708/ 9&6:/ (& '/;,29&&#&'9+  ''+ :+, $&&-&&<=+9&2/8 068 8/2 +/&& ,2,6

/>,&& ;,34,+/$&&-&#&'9+  42' 



 ! "#$%&!&%'

+') $+?,3'$&9&@&/?+2(&'A'9 $+3'>9&+/2(&'/ +'94''+ $+@&-$=&/2(&'# $+ &+&$--&/2(&'/ ++42' BBBBB &%' ("

''+6$12&345/'9+,=9'? +4+'+?9+ >,242&/A9A&'2'*34&22&22&' '9,' ''2&C$&&-&&<=+9&2:+,?'&'&<2&D2*- <='94+?('EEE:'92 +(2,+/ 9&&44+&(92'9,+'<=''=6&2'9+2+2&'2.!

!

"5,+ %/A9+*-&44(&'32,2+ +2+  ,

  9&*232 +  &2+'=  '  '9  +&  (''    '9  +4(' (,+'94&+'''9/'A,2*&4''=*+4+&('9 3&''+

  4+'9&+3''9&44(&'/'94''+,=9'' *34&22&&4&+'-//22&' '94''/'9&* '&'2'9&''94''+'+2'&&=+3'A'9$1?$?44+ ?//$&&-&"?+%+4,+(9& $(44+ +

?  7/!7/7 787  F,&'  '  /7/ 0/

.

  +  '9  4,+4   &('&'=4&-3'4+(=2/&&=+3' 2&'2 

"5,+ %A&'+2'*'A'94''+&2'9+ 94''+*'&2&;''++2'2&'2 8

"5,+  6 %  '9+,=9  ?'&'  &<    2&/    ;/ ;,29&&1+42' 9&+3'2;''++2'A&2,- (33,(&'2  *-  '9  ?'&'  &<    2&6+42'    '  '9 ='&'=&<//'9+42'64&'9943'A&54('2 '+&(9&'9&&?9& +'/$,3*&"2&%'9+'A<&,&+-/

94''+&(F,+2'9<A2='9&''9+9&2+=2 &+,  2(,3'/  (,2=      ;&2=   

 A'9  '9 (&('94&'6*&</+/'9+'A<&,&+-/

/ ?'&'&<2&+32'94''+'9&''92(,3',2+'9 &+3'2  ;''+    +2'  A+  +(2  +  &((4'&(  9 2(,3',442*-'9?'&'&<2&&(,22'9 ;&2=&=2'9&*,2*-'9?944==(- 92(,3',2+;''++2'A+&((4'2*-'9 4''+7

/&'94''+/&''9&''3/9&23&'+- '9&,'9'('-'9;&2=&2'9+2(,3''+=='9 &((4'&(/ 4''+&44+&(92'9(&&='?944==(-/ &3-/54 +=9' ';'29&='(&';,29&&&29&22 +'9(4-'9;&2=2&'2

9?944=='

 ) ,=9'3'3'+-'9;&2=A+/'9+3&' 4+22  *-'9  &+3'2  ?944= ='    

 '  '9 4''+&=9&'&'A&,2'*+=22(,3'94''+ 332&'-  &44+&(92  '9  +42'6&<  &2  +32  &*,'  '9 +3&'  +(2  A'9  +=&+2  '  '9  +=2  2(,3'  &2  ,+'9+ +F,'2''3&<4&-3'&=&''9;''++2'''94&'6 &<94''+&,*3''2A+''+F,'"5,+ 8% 2&'&25,+ '9'3&'+(2*-'9(&&='A'9 +=&+2''9+=2;&2=9(&?944=='+42'  +32'94''+'9&''9&+3'2=29&&=2- *2+2'3(34&-;=" ?%&2E&3"9&% 4-'9''+2&'27 

,2*-'9?944==(-A'9 +=&+2''9+=+-'9;&2=5,+ 6. 93&?944==(-2=2&(34&'&'?&=+ "$&&-&%  A'9  '9  $&&-&  (  &=&'  '9  +  +  9&= (33''2+&,2*-+=='9;&2=2&'2

4- '94(+4+'2&'2 ! 

9&*+++2'*-&5=& 5,+ 6!94''+/9&='A'9'9+4'/332&'- '','2'9(,'*&+=782&'2  

+@,('&=&'

+42' &2 A'9,+'9++'+&'&=&'+42' + 3&<=4&-3''+42' &=&''9&+3'2;''+ +2'/&=A'9&&44(&'+'+3@,('9&+3'2 ,'42=&2@,2(&'A+/&&44(&'+&323'A& 32A9(9 9&*+@('2/A9(9,2+(9&=  008

.

42' &32&&44(&'++@(''9

 * 4&',2+ +2+! ,

 9@,('&44(&'+&(92' '9,+'2 !0 

7&2'9,+'/2+2+ 2&'2 

/3&'&2'9+2+'9'+&,+'2&'2  

/ A9+*-'9@,(',=9'+*+'9,2=A&+'+29 +42'6&<'','2'9,'7

&=&''94&'6*&< ++(+-'9&3,'&=2'9&*4&2''9?+//$1 ?$?+4(''9=2'9&+3'2,'/'9&<&44&+2 &232&&44(&'<=&'22*-'&<=*@(' ,'*=*&++2*-6@2+(&+-4&+'94''+/ 9&=  &(F,+2  '9  <A2=    '9  &+3'2  ,'/  32  & &44(&',2+ +2+  ,

 2&'2

."5

7%+*= 34&22&&4&+'-9&3A&442*-+42' 64&' *&<*-=+4-2&'2 8!

."5,+ 8%/A9(99&* 232*-'9 33+(&,+'122'&'+(',2=/;,29&& 234,=2+2+2&'2.!

!"5,+ % $+?,3'  $&9&@&/  &+2  ?+  ,  &'2  *- $+3'>9&+/2(&'+4+'='94''+,*3''2'9&''9 +2+'9,+'','&&*'9-&A&'9&(33''2 =+&+++'&44+(&'='9&(''9&''94+('94''+ (&+-  &  '  A,2  94  '9  ,+'    2'+3=  '9  +&  3&''+1 ('++-24,'/+/'9,'9=,454&&''9+&,2 &=2-(33''2*-'9+(&(A'9'94&'6*&< 92(,3'&+3'2&++F,+2'*4&(2+(+29+ &+&&44+9'9&''9&<3&-'('''9,'94''+ 9&2&&(F,+2'9<A2='9&''9&<9&2/&('/'3&2'9 4&-3'''9+/*,'-&2&(2&&<A&C 9+ +=

   ,++(-  ;&  "

;%D/  A9(9  &('    2'  +3  2(,3'  2&'2

"5,+

%9&+3'22(,3'9A2'9&''9 4&-3'A&'3&2/*,''9+9&2*&2&(2&&/'9++/ '94''+9&&2+(''+''9,*@('3&''+'9,',44+' 9(''/99&+2,4'9@,2=3'+2+2*-'9G* ?,4+3,+'%+ , -.& /0 1/ 2.3 043/. & 1 .- 1/ 0 / 1+.()   5 '('2'9&'

(434&23'&4&+'-A9'9+(&+-+4+4+9&*2,- 54&2'9&+3'2@,2=3'&2'94+'(&,(9 <2  A9+  34&23'    '9  4''+  &  22&'      '9 &+3'2  ,'    '&  &2  (&+-  +  &2@,2(&'    '9 ('++-

+  ('+&/  $+@&-  $=&/  &+2  (,  +4+'= +42' 14&'*&<,*3''2 '9&' '9+=&'-+ 4++'-'9+2+,2+(9&=9+2+(&'*&2'9& *4&2A'9,'@,+2('&'9+42'64&'  

9+A&4+'-('+&('*'A'9+42'64&'*&<&2 '94''+9;''++2'9&'*9,+2*-'9?'&'&< 2&23&2*=+&2*-'9+42'64&'*&<&'&/ '9+A&&*+&(9('+&('*'A'94''+6&44(&'&2'9 +/  '9  +32-    A9+/  /  242'  ,'/  *,'  '   *- 34&23',44+'9(''/99&&2&349&'(+&( ,4'9@,2=3'+2+2*-'9=9,+'9 3!

1.6. 2.3$1010 4 7 .0 / .

()8 % '('2 '9&'A9+'9*&<=,&+&'('&=,F,(&&2,(2'& '+3  (,2  *  '&-2  +  '  (&92/  @,('  A&  22  '  '9

 9 4&'2+A'9&''''9,+'' &+& &2

'9&2 @,2=3''('2'9&'&-++(&*&2,(2'&=,&+&' +F,+2'*(&92&&2A9(&2,4*-'9&<'4&-& *=2,&2,''&2=9&&('2'9@,2=3'+2+2:  3,'.- 1/ 2.3%+$101%.0/ ; .6 .01   & /0 1/ / 1+.(  $  * '('2'9&''93&''+ 4+'&= '  &4+3&'  @,('  &=&'  '9 += 34&- + 9,+='9;''++2'+&(92,4''9G*?,4+3,+'&2 'A&92'9&''9,+'3,'*A=+&'=&+2+@,(' +'+&='9+&&'&*&<=,&+&'+;''++2',*@('' '95(4'(&+2,''9+/+/'A,2'*,=9+&4&+'-' &=+&,2*,''9+9&'*&(&+2(*'9&''9&('+&,2 &A&''9*&<G<A2=,(9+&,2&+2,4'9 2(+2+2 </.00 4 1/ 2.32  " ;!

; . ;

1/ 0 / 1+.($36., 3.1099)'('2'9&' 3&+  /  '9  G*  ?,4+3  ,+'/  A9  '(=  '9  +3 33+(& +&('((,3'&+-+2'"

07%"

 %/92'9&''9 &<(&'*@,('2+9,+=*&<=,&+&'1;''++2'/ 4&+'(,&+-'9=+,2*+&(9('+&('*'A'9*,-+&2'9 +/+/ ('+&('  *&< =,&+&' + ''+ (+2'    &A&-  & 242''93&('+&('&2'9*&<(&'+,(&93' &2/'9,/,+=2 '9 ,+' + ,492= '9+2+*-23= '9 +4'' 9&9&+2'9&+2(,+'94&+'/&44+&2'9 4&4+*<&2'9A'9&''9++(&23+''9,*3 $+$&9&@&/+/'94+'(&''9A9+'9,+'9&

  * (&2 ,4 '2(2'9@,('3&''+//+'+&'&=&' (&93'&++(&*;''++2'/A9(99&2&+&2-&''&2 &'-/&'(2&* 9-F,'A9(99&'*42+2&22(22*-3 &'A9'9+'9(+(,3'&(&2'9&('54&2&*/A9(9 &+  -'  '  *  4+2/ 

/  '9  4''+6&44(&'  A,2  *  & (&+-+'&'*34&22&22&' +' 9 4+(4+34&23'4+4+&2(&+-4&+'-9&2*4' 2*&'&2(2+&'3&-,+'/(,2='9?,4+3,+'/*,' +('-%+ , -.& /0 1/

=036.0('9,+'9&2& ((&'(&+,''9A=4+(4 &+& +'94,+4 34&23'&4+4+&2(&+-4&+')6      

  

      

 

                   

                 !

 "

#               !         

 $  #

            

             

       

  

            % &    

    

                       '

&!         

 5                      #

     

    ( ) 

      *         

                

  

      

  

    

         #

         

   

   

+ 2,*'/'9&+3'24+(49&2*(&+2,' +4('&24,'&++2&'&,'<=4((4++3&('9 &=+3''A9+&*&24,+(9&+/A99&24+'-'& ('+&(''+2*'A'92+&2'92/A&&A2'* 34&22&&4&+'-/*,''9&(''93&''+/'9(+(,3'&('(2 &*/'9&''9&*+4+'2'9&';&2=/&4+'9''+ "5 .%+=2&2&65'=2(,3'&3/'9++/'9A '9&''A,2*'9''9=(&'94''+&A2'* 34&22&22&' &'A,2&*'9,+''&2@,2(&''9 24,'/4&+'(,&+-A9'9+&,29&2*4&22 +'9&< *+'-/'9(''''+2&'27 

"5,+ 6.%,2*-'9 +=9'=("$%?292+&2&,2+)6 C   #,-.! /

012&3* 4    + 3  5 &06!&-!6"67778'

$ 0  "7" 9&: #;&-2< 2$=%>& 0 

  ;%77 & #

5-

?  9  !  

 

  

4     

               #,-.! /

      0&@"%"A7%0&@ ""B7%%=     */;) 

  !

 ! /

4         

?   !

 !/        

C    1C3 C   

+ A+/'9&+3'22(,3'A,2*,*@('''9 32    4+  *+  '9  ,+'  *A/  *,'  +  &2@,2(&'    '9 &44(&'/'(&&A&-*'&<'(2+&' 9+&'9+&4(''93&''++'94''+ (,2='9&((4'&(7

/'9+42'64&'*&<'&'2 '9&3&24&-3'

''9,44+/*,'=='9+,=9 '92(,3'/A9(99&2*+++2'2,+='9(,+'99&+=/ /5,+

/'9+42'64&'*&<9&2&(2'9&3,' +&4+2

2&-''9+//F,&'&3,'7/!7/7 787

?*-'+3=''* 9+ +=,++(-;&"

;%&('- '9&'&'3&-/&3'9A'9&',(9(&+&2*&(<2+4'9 3&''+/'94''+&4+4+&2(&+-4&+'-'*34&22& 22&' '9,'

 

,'&'-/'934,=2+2+'6&2&(F,( '9+/'9&44(&'32*-'94''++34&23'&A2 +&,+'2+('2'&+2&44+','-''94''+''9 A+'''&'3'&((+2&(A'9&A

4'''&2&A2 <>.30.79(5  &%'  .0,+ "#8?!

'+1+.604 ;:.0 / @:

'+1+.6 .10>

@: