← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/196/2022allowed

Sushil Kumar And Others v. State Of Haryana And Another

2023-02-03Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil11 pages

 

       

 



!"#$$#   

      

        %"  &'(% $ ) ()((% ' ****  



   !

  

" 



# $%



 " !

  &'  )!*+% ,*-./$ ( !

     )  

 )   

+,+-'+''  )

 . */01! 2  !

 3 45

 &

.

  #!  )

  !  !

! !-,67-,879+':2!

;:&-<6

''-+'+-8 * ! 



5

 &

  !  &' =  !!



 ''-+'+-8!   $

  *

      

*     

> #   ?  # $

)    #  

   



  6 

*  #   *   !

    # !" # $

)    

* $

)   



) *   

     ''-+'+-8 !  !!

 "# /> 4#/>4 "* 

!

  

>/ 4

  V VISHAL 2023.07.14 18:41

- 2 -

!* 

>*

 )  # 

" !" *@#> 

"  * 

    

> #  

*  )  )  @@ # $

)    #  

 #  

 /!    @@ #4 &

 /  @@ #4/>4"# /> 4> /   4   /

4  ! )    $

)  

 )   ;: #  *  !-,6-,8 9+':2   ) @

     !    *   $

)  # !   )! 

* # "! &'

# !

! (   !

 2#   )!   

*  ! 

!

 ) #    * 

*    !

   @  # 1  



)  ?    *#  

  

>      )   # !

!

)!!   #    !!

! A

  !      !     ! )# 

 * * 

) #*

*    * * *!  ** *  ! ! !*  *     !  !      !    !

*@  A

  !       

*    !   !! !  *



- 3 -

  *    !    !             

* !  !! *    )   (2 )# # * !  !  !     "  ! 

  ! :  !  ! )#     > !     !

       @   # 1 C 

*   ! 7 !



 # ) 

    ! *      2 !

 ( 

;A   #!# *   ! !

*     !

   

* 

         

  !    &' )     )

  !  #     *    !        &' /#

4  

*   !! *  #       !

*! !-,6-,8 9+':2   !

! )!  !) * 

  *         )        !!

    # 

* 

 ) ) 

)# 1

/'9-+'+-8

--<< 4   # #,9D   

  #  *

 *#    !*  !

  

  9D     1

 ! 

- 4 - !!!

)

# *

*    ") ! )  #!#

   *  : 



 ! 

 * *

 =   ! * # 

       ! #  )!  !9-82 2#!



@

                                                                         (2=! 2 

 

 # *!! 9-82 2 # @

! "          #  $%&

'

          "      #  $%& '

  (               #                                           )     

    ((((  ((((  ((((

%* '  # $%& '

  ( +  (               +   (     ,  # -         

- 5 -   .                          (              %*/"      

                      0 (              "              (                   (                   +                  (     # $%& '

+# $%& '

          

       

            "        

 "         # $%& '

      :  

 /

4    2  E   #

F  !G!9-82 2 ))

 



#! ! ) 2 ! E  !

 )     /4 !

)

    !

 ) 2  !

!  H/4 1 !#  2H

/4 

 #

#! ' !

*

- 6 - : !

" 

 #    $      

  % ,  2 !!!1  # )#  2  2   @

%                                                                  

                      (         

  

                               ( 2 =!     *  #!  !  !   # # 1 !* #    ! 9-8 2     @ 12         # $%& '                                

      

        # $%&

' 3 12               #  $%& '      

                      " 

                3

- 7 - 12        #  $%& '    4   (         

                    4   (                                1    2  ?*     2 =!   

 /

4  !

" 

 #   /

4   2   &   # '    ( )   * E !

   50

%!+  6       # $%& '    (     (                                   # $%& '    6                                       6          

             +     

       # $%& '  4  :!  # 

* ! 9-82 2)1 !  

 1!    !

 

 

 #  #   E # 





- 8 - 2    !

*   

*           !

#! )   @I@ 

 # 

 !*  : )! !

)  !#  2 *) "  :    !

       ;: #  #    !!  )   )

        *

*   ) *   ) *    ;:    



 ) )  !!  # !*   :  *  *   /1  '4 *  #  )    !

 ) !      

 # ) $

#  

 )  ( 

  !

 !     !       !    # * 

    )  ) 

 )   

* #   !  #     *   

* * 

( !  !   !!     #  *   

  !

 )

#    !   !! *   ) *  !

     !

 )  )  #

    ( # *

 )  !  ) 2 #  # !

)  !!! #  



>

- 9 - (2 )# # *  " 

 !  ;A      !         ) 

$

) !!  *   !

*!  *

 ) 

 ;A 

+,-''+-8/1 <4#! )  3' 

=*$ 

) 

/1 ,4 0  # !*

 )

 )  !   @  #

>   



@@



  $

) : )!  !  !  ) *    !  1      !

  *  #   )! ) 2 & + !

 /

4  #  ) >      

     ! !

*  !

  :       !         !     *  ) 

  

> * #  !



 !



#*   )   

  !*     )!   !

)   !  #  2*) "   *  2 )  ! 

 !

*

 * 

#  

  !

#

 ) @ #C# #       

  7

 !! !  ! # 

   )  #  : 

C

- 10 -   # 

 !!   #   # 

   # "  * #*  ) ?

 *     > 

  #*  *

*     @@ #   @@ # )  @@ # @@ #/>>   

 !4

    * >  



     @ # #

 

 7 #  #!) ) *

:     1"! !

1    

     

"       * 

 #!

# "!

 !     ( 2 =!   

 /

4 !

" 

 #   /

4   !

    #   ! 9-82 2  !



  1

 #  #!   ) 1 ! 

* !

# ! !  ! !

#

 !

!  ! )  )   #!   !

 1 !  

* !

* )      !   1      !  *  ) # 

! !: 

 

  # #   E # 



  ! 9-82 2   !

 #  ) * > !

! 

 ) ( ! 

 *

!

) 

  

*               

 )

!

*  !     !   *  ) 

  

> * #  !

  

- 11 - !



#*   ) #



 !* : )! !

)  !#  2*) "  !!

*    #   

+,+-'+''    )  

   . * 5

  &

  #!  )

  !  !

 ! !-,67-,879+':2 )E   &* 1     

   )  "  )  1  # !

 +9+''+'9 77 0)!*+% ,*-.1 ,*-

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No