High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5489/2015dismissed

Kamla Devi v. Mukesh And ORS

2018-05-25Mr. Justice Arun Monga4 pages

!"##$%&%'(!)* +!,-!#.% #"%"%'#/ 0#/&1& 12#&3 "3#/& #&4'5#'"&

!"#$$#%

/#&#'"( /#-*5.$!"#* /"3#4#"%"%'#/ /!.'##"6%'73*5.$!"#* /"3#/#&4'5#'"& 88888 $#% &

3#4/#&#'"/#.%&%'%&5%/#$"#5!7!%'&""3#%,417'#5/5#/ 5!"#5 9 *:3#/#;)"3#!44-%$!"%'&1;,%""#5;)4#"%"%'#/<5##'5!'" / /#=#$"%' "3# 4-!%'" &##2%'7 5#$-!/!"%' !'5 4#/,!'#'" %'=1'$"%'*3!&;##'5%&,%&&#5

#&4'5#'"<4-!%'"%& %'&"%"1"#5 "3# &1%" / 5#$-!/!"%' !'5 4#/,!'#'"%'=1'$"%'$-!%,%'7"3#--:%'7/#-%#(< >

#!"

&'(

&) (

&* + &

,% &

-. & '

/+"0 &

. &

. " !

1&(

2 '"3#!/#,#'"%'#5&1%"*4#"%"%'#/<5##'5!'"%-#5!' !44-%$!"%'1'5#/ /5#/9 1-#

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

#/$'"/!*/!.'##"6%'73*-#!/'#5$1'&#-//#&4'5#'" & !'5&1;,%""#5"3!""3#/#.%&%'4#"%"%'%&-%!;-#";#5%&,%&&#5%' .%#:"3#5#$%&%'/#'5#/#5;)"3%&1/"%' '()*(+(+

, -.+ / +0 1*2(3 0*4(2*& 5-/.

5( 0 (6728* " 671*2 (69(" 67: +7*& -/.

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

( 4

+ 5

,67-'/

& & .

(+( . +

&0 & " & 0 + &

" + & 0 &

8 &

(+( +.

& 2 "%&)#"";#5#$%5#5:3#"3#/"3#4/%'$%4-#&3!5;##'!53#/#5

"/'";)"3#/#.#'1#!1"3/%"%#&'&1$3$%/$1,&"!'$#&*!5.#/&#4!/") $!''"&##2"3#/#=#$"%'"3#4-!%'"1'5#/ /5#/9 1-#

*/* :1-53!.#!/%73""5##'5"3#&1%"%'"3#,!''#/!'5,5#!&&173"" ;#4/=#$"#5%'"3#4/#&#'"/#.%&%'4#"%"%'*/*/5#$%5%'7"3#!44-%$!"%' 1'5#/ /5#/9 1-#

*'-)"3#4-#!5%'7&%'"3#4-!%'"3!.#";#&##' &!'14&3""3#!/#,#'"%'#5;&#/.!"%'&*"3#/5#/ 1'5#/$3!--#'7#5#&'"$!--/!')%'"#/#/#'$#/$!''";#&!%5";# :%"31" =1/%&5%$"%' 3#/# %& ' %--#7!-%") / 4#/.#/&%") %' "3# &!,#

#&1-"!'"-)*"3#/#.%&%'4#"%"%'&"!'5&5%&,%&&#5 (= & -$#% / *()7 !>?

%7+7*9(@ 6'*( 0 A'