High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/513/2017dismissed

R.S. Bahlan v. Rakesh Satija & ANR.

2017-04-25Mr. Justice T.H.B. Chalapathi15 pages

!"#"$% &

' () $ "

"$* +# ,#('

"- $ $ (* #.$ $ # /% 01/'/'2'/13

/'2'/134516

!

"

#

$ % & '

( ) * "

+, , - .

/ 0 / & " " '1""1 * 2# )( + - , ( + )

# -

3

4

# 5#- 31+ -

+ +$,

!( ) 7$ *+#*7)8"97+"#:# * #:

8";+8.) $ (*#4

5<6 ' 5'64 "* ( *" 1 ) +# "

#( / ( - $ $

$ (*4

5&65"=")6 &> #-"

'"$9( $ $ (*+#*8 *-"

'"$9( $ $ (*4

565"=")6&4+-

( 5

# -# 3 +-

2# ) ( + - ( + )

##

- - #

+ )( + 31+ -

+ -# +

3 , # -# #

+-

5 # -# - - , #,

# ) 5#- 31+ - "."$'( $ ") ) $!( )+#'

7- *

4

5 6'4 6 7

5#- 85 3#

'( (* ?(7 ##(:

* #+#.

*!$*# -"$

"$ 7

8")@ '( ((9""

)

( ) ) $ (*#4>A<57- *

6 5#- '8 #:

$ 3 7* +# '

"#( 378 * 99 *:

) $ (*#4

A5&61A 3 , -

3#

+ # ## # -# , #, 5

+#

, - + - # -

- -

# ( + )

##

- /% %9 % &

, + ( + )

,

, -# -

- ( +# -

) +5

, + 2 ) + -+, - +- , # ( +# -

, # - , ( +

#

+, -

- ( + +5 ) + -+, ( + -

#, , " :# ,

; # # , ( + - , - 3#

&

5 -# -

+ )

, ( +

-

#

- )

'

( )<* .

/ 0 / & "" 2# )( + - , ( + # .

/ 0 / & "" , - )

! "

#

$ %

=

+# '

( )<*

+ .

/ 0 / & ""

# , +# - .

/ 0 / & ""

- -+,

; - 2 )

'

( )<*

-+ . '

( )<*

-+ --

# -# - " + # -# # , (-

+ - -#

) &

'

(

)

)

(

( *

A

"

+ "

*

, #- , # "

% 5#- + + - 3 5#- -

+ ,

+# # +

-

(- + ,# , 5#- -- - -2

31+ - 7#7$ * $ $ (*+#'

8") 7 $ (*#4

5 6' 4$"$ $ "

+#8*"

1 )/ $!( $ $ (*#4

&5 6' 4'

*"## +#/ ))"@ #4

A56'

'

- # ( $+' $#("1 )4

<5 6'

=

2 +, + - 3>+ -

5#- $#("1 )> '* # 2 8*"

)/ $!( $ > '* /( ))"@ #> '*

#, )

## #./ 0 (

(

&

1

'

$

$ 2

& "

3

&

$

3

3 &

4

*5*

6

* *( )

6 &'0#789*8!: ; ' 6 < < 6 #7788 *!!

&

$

& +

'= >

#7?# &!7@A > 1 A >

<

4

+

>(&

+

>( &

+

>(&

1 **

6 B ) ' .??8 #*.:@

.9.

#.

#.

#@/

6

1 2

(

$

( $

>

3

' >C

<( > B A

#7@#&:D:

:8# > ) <

5&''10

#!"< E

$

&

+

E #8 'A 6 < F #7:?. &10.7! > 0

&10

.7:" E> & (2

'

4 4

E)

$* A > B *

, . #7:# # >0#?8. 5&''10

#.:!" E6

0 > $ & +

E&A

G 0 G #7:.. >0@D: > )

5&''10

:8# E

#:

(

<

#@ > <

5& H '&'0 #78.*89?

E1

I

E E+

(

(

)

(

1 *;' B &

> ) .??! D *:@

9D"9!

#@"#9

- - - - -, - -2# ( + -

:

31+ - )"@ +# '

/ (@ * #(4

5 6' <4# 2

-+ 5 +

#

,

'

( )<*

#

-#

-

,# , # +

'

( )<* - .

/ 0 / & ""

-+

- - +# +, + .

/ 0 / & ""

; 5 , 2

+

-#

+ # -# ? - #,

5 # -# -

+ 2 - # 5#- 31+ - 3#

" # " ) !"#$ %&'(

) *+,"$ -- " -$ . / ) )' 0 .11"$ --" -$ 2%' 3)% ).1"1$ --4,+" -$

5 )) ) )6 ' - 7

% ))/) 8 )

)* +9"0 $ . "0 7)-

$ , :6 2 ' )2 96

).1

"5$ & ." ;7$ 31+ -

$ 5#- "."$'( $ ") ) $!( )1 '*

, ) &

4

(

'

G

5 *

'

4

"

(

'

(

(

*

"

5

(

(

(

'

(

'

A

(

J

&

J

(

*

"

(

% 0#

, # 31+ - 3#

" # "

+

'

( )<* - .

/ 0 / & ""

-+ -- ,

# -# -

- # 5

, # ,# , # -, # -#

#

#

#

,

# + ;

+ #

, ,- , - "

-

-# - #-

"# - +

- -#

+ # - , #, -

# +

, - + -

, + - #

+ - + # + , ( # , 0,

+ + - -

B/'2'/13C $ %< % !

= 2#@ A@ = + A@