High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5530/2015dismissed

Gurinder Singh & ANR v. Kuldip Singh & ORS

2015-08-27Mr. Justice Arvind Singh Sangwan3 pages

!"#"$%&%'()

*+%'#"+,%'-. '# '!."+ "/%&%'%&!& 0"+&*& 1*2#%3,%'-. '#!."+& "&3'#"'!&

( 45 , 1 5, +"&"'!(6

+%'"&. . 7 '8#/$ !"8+!."+"/%&%'%&!& 9."!."+!.""3+!"+&2$ 2'":&3 3"+; <=" 22:"#!&"" !."7*#-;"'!> ="+""++"#!!.""3+!"++'! 9."!."+!."7*#-;"'!&.*2#="+"3+!"#%'!."#%-"&!> 66 66 5, 8

5 ;3*-'"# %' !." 3+"&"'! +"/%&%' %& !." +#"+ # !"# )8 3 &&"# =< !." 2" +'"###%!%' 2 %/%2 *#-" ,"'%+ %/%&%'81. #+, .%=8/%#":.%$.!."2" +'"###%!%' 2 %/%2 *#-" ,"'%+ %/%&%' +"/%":"# %!& +#"+ # !"# ?@

''"A*+"66 '#+#"+"#!. !!."#""'# '!&:%223+#*$"!." +%-%' 2 %# /%! '#!."+" !"+'2<!."$;3 +%&'&%-' !*+"& $ '="#'" +%"2<&! !"#8/%#"+#"+# !"#?@ ''"A*+"668 3 &&"#=<!."2" +'"###%!%' 2 %/%2*#-" ,"'%+%/%&%'8

1. #+, .%=8!." 332%$ !%'!."3+"&"'!+"/%&%'%&!&! 33%'! . '#:+%!%'- "A3"+! :%!. !." #%+"$!%' ! -"! !." &%-' !*+"& #""'# '!$;3 +"#:%!.!."& ;"'!." %# /%!-%/"'! !."32 %'!%&+"- +#%'-& 2"!*=":"22$''"$!%'%'#%&3*!"8: & 22:"# 5 !"+'8 +"/%": 332%$ !%': &%2"#=<!."33&%!" 3 +!<8%':.%$.%!: &=+*-.!!!."'!%$"2:"+ *+!!. !!."

%# /%!8':.%$..%&&%-' !*+"& +"&*-.!!="-!$;3 +"#8%& '2<!."3.!$3< '#8!."+"+"8'$;3 +%&'&%-' !*+"&' !."3.!$3<$ '=" 22:"#."+"+"8!."2:"+ *+!+"/%":"# %!&+#"+8&! !%'-!. !!."&%-' !*+"&$ '="$;3 +"#'2<:%!.!." +%-%' 2#$*;"'! ."$'!"'!%'!."2" +'"#$*'&"2+!."+"/%&%'%&!& %&!. !!."%;3*-'"#+#"+ ;*'!&! 22:%'-!." 33" 2 - %'&! %!&:'+#"+ '#&"$'#2<8!."+"/%":: &!%;"= ++"# ;!."/%":!. !!."+#"+%&3"+"$!2<%' $$+# '$" :%!.2 : '#"+,"$!%'@ #" %/%2+$"#*+"8B8%' 33" 22%"&+;!."+#"+8!." *+!$ '+"/%":%!&+#"+ 9."'

+#"+# !"#?@: &3 &&"#8!." $!!. !!." %# /%!8' :.%$.!."#%&3*!"#&%-' !*+"&"A%&!%&'2<!."3.!$3<8"&$ 3"# +;!."'!%$"!."2:"+ *+!8!."+"+"8!."$;3 +%&': & 22:"# :"/"+8:."'!.%& $!$ ;"!!."'!%$"!."2:"+

*+!8%!: &+#"+"#!. !!."$;3 +%&'$ '=" 22:"#'2<:%!. !."+%-%' 2#$*;"'!!:*2#22:!. !!."+#"+ 22:%'-

66 "A ;%' !%'. '#:+%!%'-"A3"+!&!%22&! '#&8=*!!."$;3 +%&' !."&%-' !*+"&#""' '!$ '=" 22:"#'2<%%!%&!=" #'":%!.!."+%-%' 2#$*;"'!."+"%&'%22"- 2%!<%'!."& ;" ."+#"+8:.%$.%&3 &&"#' $$*'!&;" $!&8"&$ 3%'-!." '!%$"!." *+!8$ ' 2: <&="+"/%":"#"/"'*'#"+,"$!%'

8+"2 !%'-!!."%'."+"'!3:"+!." *+!!="%'-&8!."+"

%&'%22"- 2%!<%'!."%;3*-'"#+#"+:"/"+8%!&. 22 2: <&=" 3"'!!."+"/%&%'%&!&!-"!!."+%-%' 2#$*;"'!&3+#*$"#%' !." *+!+;!."$'$"+'"# *!.+%!<++"-%&!"+!."'! +< 3*=2%$:."+"!."+%-%' 2&%-' !*+"&#""'# '! +"3+"&"'! '#-"!!."& ;"$;3 +"# ."+"/%&%'%& $$+#%'-2<#%&;%&&"#

) &7C&