← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5150/2018dismissed

Mahalaxmi Filling Station v. Mahinder Singh

2018-08-29Mr. Justice Arun Monga11 pages



      

! "#$ %& '() 

#%*%%+, -.&%&&*/0-* /1.0,%2%%  &&/ 3 #%*4/.-*  14& #(

   

     

 

 

 

  !!"  # $# %$&  !

) *" +  



! 

'

-!  ,,.

/  

0 01 2 

 32 4!!"

2

%  (  '

 !  !

 5

 "

  '!(   " 2



              !

 " #        $%%&    ' "

#(  &)6  *+



  ",#'-.-( 



   $%/$'$0( 

 '# #*(  12  34 5  66

3 "

3     -"7 3!

#8 #* +



$%%)'$/(

'# #*(12%



8 

  2 

    2

  



"  : 8 !!"

!2   !2 - : /  0 -:01

   ; < ) ; !

=! ) ! 

"  ! ( %$$> 8

"

!    !!

!!"

  !

3 '  -:

 7$ (  - ? 9

> : 8

 !! "

@    

    

  

        

      

  

       

    

     







      

 



! !

   



"

 

 

 









 



 

  

  

       



         

   #

> :

3 # $9 %$# '  -:

 '

  '!

  $ $9 %$# ;

 

3

; ,$$$5@ 2

  2 >A

 (  ( 

.

8

!!"

"

2

(!

4!B

'

2 ; 97>79$5@



2 ; %$7$$>5@





 

 

!!

2    '  2(   !!

!!"

 22



  8



!!"  !

 "

  !!"

'  2!

 '  '"

 C"

2 '

" 

2 ; $%>$$$5@

 !  ("

 

2  "





$ $9 %$# 3 '  

!  2

 ; " " 



'@ ;"  + 

D

  

!!

  ' 2

!   ' D

     "



#

D

!



 %%

4  ( 

$ $9 %$#

(



"2 '

 0 0

  " = 2   $ $9 %$#

 0  0

 !( 2 D 

 

! 



 ( D  ( " !  2 -:

D  (

   (

  





( 

 < ) ; !

=! ) ! ;!  2



2  % > . , $

%%

 !! "

@ $ %   

   

 !         & '

(

$&)*

  

 +,'-

   

 

    ! 

 .     !

           



 !  

  " & && &&&/0    

    !     +,'



  



   

 

 

/

    



 !!    

    

%  1   

!   

 

  ")& && &&&/0 2

    2  

 

     

 

 

)3



    

4 %       

          

 ! ! 

   2

 5   



           



  !  %     





   6

       7  8       

    

 

 ! 1

  !         

 

 

       

    ! 



     %

( 9 %          ,   1   

      :

  1

 

  

  ; 

         

!







 

")& &&&/0

         )& % 1  , 1  

    



    

    



 

 <

  !  ) (  

!





!

   <        

  0   !    ! 

 !  

 

   

!     2

 ! !=   !



 !  <



         <  

 !    !       !   $$ 

  

 !          !  





    

 

  <

 ! 

     

 !      !

  

  !

 

   

 !

  ! 

!  

      

    !

 

 !    !    (!

 7  6 

 (

)994

& D  ( !

 ? /1 2

! 

 !

!! "

@   



       ,  9   (!



  6 

 (  )994     1

   :

  <

  ,



>

, ?

 ?

" '  ?

+ 

!

   " 

 

 !

    != 0

  !

 

#

8 !(

! !   ; $ C

   2

"!"

!

 > 

D (2 

2

2   '   

 %

"2 

22 2 $9 $9 %$#

$ :  !

'2

$ $9 %$#  2

 

"

 ;" 42 D 2 

! "   



! 

 ! :  !

 '2

 ? 9 : 8

! 

( /1 '     

( 

 :  !

"

9#3  :



      ""3":6  *";

  

   $%%0'/( 

 '# #*(  1$& 

! 

 ! ' 222

"    

!  C 

" D   -  !!

 !!

 "

3 2  0

% :  !

! !("

 "

9# 

   + # 

/222'/(

'# #*( &)%

  

 - "   

 '

 (   ' 

" ( " '

D'  

=   !  !

5   

"2 !  !





$ $9 %$#  "

'

 2

(

   ! 

2 ; $%>$$$5@



   2 '

 '  ;



"

 C !

'

  "

' 

:  !

! !("

 "

9# 

 /   

! 

 3

 

  ( 8 2!

 (





'"

'  2 ( "



 9#   #3#

 

+ -

#  + #4        $%%%    ' *"

(  $0/ !  !

 

  C

    "

( C 

"  3

>   !  !

!("

 "7

    ' 9(  

3  ."3   "7

    $%//'/( 

 '# #*(  $%<

  2 C"

 

( 2

  ' 2 E '! !

!(



$ $9 %$# '

2 "  3

.

  '2  !  !



#  C 3

$ $9 %$#

  

!!" !    ? 9 : 8

 

( /1 ' 8

    ? 9 : 8  

2 '  "





2 ; $%>$$$5@ D"

$ $9 %$#

!

2 !  '  

! 

 3

2

 

!

 4 !"

! 

     C 

" 4 C"



" 

2

"

!

 D 

"2  !  !

  9#3:

     / 

&  

! 

'!(  C

!

   !

  9 : 8 D   C 

"

    '



   '!( 8

(     C 

" ! 

  "  D ! "    2

(

 '

 

""

C

 "

(

8 2(  

 "  '     "   ' 

!

 ? %%

4 C"



2 3

%$ 8 

 

2   

  2" 

 

  D  

"!( 2 " %, %$&

# .$ (   F  C"5  G5? F  '! G5?