High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5308/2014dismissed

Anand And ORS v. Ajit Dahiya

2015-02-10Mr. Justice J.C. Verma5 pages

! "#$#%& '() (* +

% %!,($ - .&

( $ %& /(#0 1(#+!-"

+ (/ 2 ##% ($

3( 45& %/ #(%% %" + 672 ( ! "( !

9 $ $$ ! #%$/ !

%$7 %$+2 ##% ($/ ( #%% #% $:- !)%! ((! (;)4 ( !9#/ "#% '*/

%7!

%$+ 2 ##% ($ / ( #%+ $ 4$ '* ( $2%! %

32( (:

( $2%! %59/ ( #%/ */ !$)1/$ #%1 $#! / $ #! 67 ( ! "( 4$(! ($!

%! 9/ ( '*/ */ ' %2(" ! ! 672 ( (4# (2 $$#%1 / 672 ( ! "( / : <#! (! (!

+/#$2 ##%)%! ((! (;)4 ! 9#/ "#% / !

%$ 9 $ !#$:#$$ ! / %$ / ! )%$)"" $$ )44* "/ 44 %1 ! /#$ (! ( '

( / #($

")( )!1: % / !!##% 4 #$(#")!1 +)(1 %#%

4#$

*9 * / 2( $ %( -#$#%2 ##%+"%")(( %

#%!#%1$ #%$/ 2 ##% ($#%'// =)!1: %$ ( )%! ("/ 44 %1 #$"4 #: !'*/ 2 ##% ($/ / 49 (")(/ !1#- % $/( !=)(%: %$)%! (/ #%

4) %" / 24

+%9( $2%! % + %!( 2( / 2(" $$$ (- (( 1 (!#%1$ (-#" %!( )$ 4 /

%$ 4$ #%$!

% %! $ (-#" '* :)% !# %!

#6 #% #%$ !

%$ ( 9 $ 2(")( !% #$"4 #: !/ 4%19#// :

#%$)#+ #%)%! ( (! ( ;;;; )4 7 9 $ 4$ 2 %!#%1 !=)!#"

#% 9/ ( %$9 ( ( >)#( ! (')9 ( $/9% $/ -#%1' %$ (- !

/ ( #% $9 44+ %!%/ #(%%7 %" +/ *9 ( 2(" ! ! ( #$"4 #: !/ %#( 6 ("#$ '*/ 49 (")( 4$'*/

")( ( - 4$ / / "%(#- %" / 24

+ "% $#%1 ( $2%! %/ ( #%+9#// 2(" $$$ (- (/ $' %":24 4*- (4? !

'*'// ")($ ()$ 4 / 2 2 ( '? !)(#%1 / ")($ (1): %$

!!( $$ ! '* )%$ 4 ( / 2 ##% ($ ( - 4$ / /#$ 2 ##% "/ 44 %1#%1/ "%")(( % / (# 4")( $9 44 $ #($

")( -#! (! ( !

( $2 "#- 4* #$ %/#%1') % ')$ 2(" $$ / ")( 2( / 2(" $$$ (- (( 1 (!#%1$ (-#" ( $2%! % +%/ '

$#$ 9/#"/ 672 ( 2(" !#%1$9 ( ? % #%$/#: ( /#$%% %" % %!$ (-#" '*:)% !# %!

#6 #% ( 1 (!#%1!

%$ ( +#$"4 ( %!"

1(#"

4/ ")(/ !1#- %!

#%# #%!#%1( 1 (!#%1$ (-#" !

% @ ?/# : %!/ %/#$%% %" +/ 9 $2(" ! ! #%$ 672 ( %

/ ")(/ 4$'$ (- !/ !

%$ 9 ( - !#%1$ (-#" %!/ ")(/ )(/ ('$ (- !/ / #(2( $ %" 9 $ / %$)1/' 2(")( !'*$)'$#) !:! # +'*9 * :)% !#

#6 #% (9/#"/2(" !#%1$9 ( !=)(% ! %!/$ -#%1' %$ (- !'*$)'$#) !:! $ (-#" +%/ #(%%

%" +9 ( 2(" ! ! #%$ 672 ( % / (

(+/ ( 2(" !#%1$ #%$!

%$"%#%) !9/ %/ 24

+%9 ! "( /4! (/ !' %4 !#%1/#$ -#! %" )(#%1/ ")($ 4 !#%1

-#! %" '*/ 24

+/ ")(/ 4$:

! 22#%: % 4"

"::#$$#%#%$2 "/ $2 %!)" / !

%$#$"4 ( - %

(: 2(" !#%1$ / 4"

4 "::#$$#% ' "

)$ / ( $ 9 44+ / !' %24 *#%1/ 1 : /#! %!$ ? %!/ !' % ? 2#%1 * (:/ ")(2(" !#%1$! $2# /

"/ / *9 ( #%

"#- ?%94 !1 / "#-#4$)#2 %!#%1 #%$/ : #$9(/%#" / / 4"

4"::#$$#%/ !1#- %%#" / !

%$/ !

!' % - !#%1$ (-#" /)1/!

% @ ?/# :9 $$ (- !#%2 ($% / $%9/ ( "4 #: !/ /#$ $#1% )( $ #/ (%/ $)::%$ (/#$ %" % (% : : %" 2( 2 ( !'*/ 4"

4"::#$$#% (/#$ %"

(4"

4#%$2 "#% / $# #%!#$2) 9 ( (1 !( )!)4 % / (+#( %$2#( $/ / !

-#%1' %2(" ! !

( +"%#%) !"%$()"#% / $2! $2# #%=)%"#%(! ($ (:

/ ")(+9/#"/ "#% / !

%$#%2 (#")4 (/ ! - %% " $$#

22#%: % 4"

4"::#$$#%')/ ( 4$/ */ !!!1 !/ 4"

"::#$$#%! $2# / #($ (-#" ( %" $/ *!#!% ( #$#%1 "%$()"#%'*/ !

%$! $2# (! ($ / ")( / :9/ %/ */ !%' % (#%1 %!/ !/ %' %2(" ! !

#%$ 672 ( +/ !( $)4 !#% #4#%1 / 6 ")#% #% / :

( $(! (!

")( !#$:#$$ 4 #%)%! ((! (;)4 / !

%$+ %92 ##% ($+ %!( $2%! % / ( #%#$"%" (% !+/

")(/ $%%4* %!($ !/ / 49 (")(')/ 4$1% / 6 % '$ (-#%1/ / 2(" $$$ (- (/ !:

! ( 2($ ( $2%! % 4$ #%$( $2%! % #%/ )$) 4")($

/#$')$#% $$ %!#%/ %(:

4!#$"/ (1 !)# $ %!/)$- ( "#* $)"/

( 2($")4!%' >) $#% ! / ")(9 % - % )(/ ('$ (- / 44/ %$ ( "4$ '4! ( 4 #%$ %! !

% / -#%1 ' % 2 ($% 44* $ (- ! 9/ ( $ !

%$ 9 ( $ (- ! /()1/ :)% !# %!

#6 #%+ # #$ % 24 )$#'4 / / * 9 ( % / -#%1 ?%94 !1 2 %! %"* / $)# %!(! ( ( $( #% #%$/ :

#(:#%1/ / 49 (")(%/#$ $2 "+'$ (- #%$ /

#($ ")( ( $ 449$&7 A

!" #

$ %& '

(

)' *

) ' ' + / ( #$ )(/ ( #%!#%1

"( "(! !'*/ #($

")(/ / !

- %' % '4 $/9 %*$)

#"# %"

)$ 9/#"/2( - % !/ : (:=#%#%1/ 2(" !#%1$#% 4449#%1 '$ (- #%$#%2

/ #:2)1% !(! ( #($ ")( - (* 2 %!$ 4$/

/ !

%$&7 A,' ( '

* '

- &. /0/1 ''

- &. '

'' )' *

' + 0 2#%1#%-# 9/ 4#*

"$ %!"#("):$ %" $ 4$

/ !

#4 !!#$")$$#%:

! #%/ #% (

") 4:

(#6 %!/

%!#%1 "#("):$ %" $ '* '/ / ")($ ' 49 "%")(( %4* %$+2 ##% ($ %!2( (:

( $2%! %% / ( #%+/ ( #$% : (##%/ ( -#$#%2 ##%#$/ ( '*!#$:#$$ !#%4#:#%

2 ' ''

3 2

' 3 2 *

' , 3