← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/473/2024dismissed

Medical Superintendent, Guru Gobind Singh Medical College And Hospital , Faridkot v. Dharam Raj Garg And ORS.

2024-03-12Mrs. Justice Ritu Tagore10 pages

 1  

                                      

!"#$%%  

&'()* +", "

",-)+)!." ("/0

&'!''

/    &" !1*,&'- &+ 2!,                         3

,,!"

+1       4 +1)1  0&+&5 &6&+/&" !,0 +1         

1*!"

",1  #  78 ( (      

   

 !"# $"   %"

  &&'

 !"# $" %"  "(    ))))

  -% +&'

 (  

&    !"  "   "   (

* +  "   (+( * , % -.

  " ! / & 0" 1!" 2 3"  4*#" " ", "$ (+   51 6 7 8& 9 0 "$ 7-  " 5 #&   /1%" " #"6% . '  7 &6  #  (+(+ * ( & & %.6 "$  " -$ "$ #6 %"6""  #"66 %" "$ %"  "(  : #" $"   %" #"    %"  "( $    $" # "      "  "    . 6" "$  -$ % -.   %" $"6    "$   6 

  "$ %.6 '  ; (< % 6 =   ' #  %% %$ & 7 &6 

 2 (+(+ * ( -.   %" ' 6 !  7 &6  (((> *  =  %"  "(  $ $   4*#" " ", "$ (+ -$"  " ! / & 0" 1!" 2 3"  : #" -6     %"  %  ,( +? " %"  "(   $

. #"6%  '  #  (+(+ $$6 -. 7 &6  #  (((>  @  -6 -.   #"  # # " %"!  -. %"  "( # 6&  A +,?   "&  '"& 

 4*#& " *#   7 #" -. #&   %" " %.  " -$ #  #6 %"6""  #"66 %" '

# ' " & -.   "   7 &6  (+(+ =  #"     "   7 &6  (+(+  #  . #"  '" $$  $B   $ "$ & "$  "  .  -$   & "$  $ "$ #6 %"6""  #"66 %" ' "  "    -$ @ %%" "$  % 

 #" $ "    $ & -.  "  7 &6  (+(+ + : #" -. % #&  # "   "-!" 6  -. C"5-    %* "  #                 

   !

"#  #  $%

# &#  ' () *+          %"" "$ '   4*#& " #" &" -."   # &  -6"

 #"    4*#& " '"& . %   7 &6 "$ "  6   %. "

     6%& "  , "

 #" $" %"  "( -6 

 3 "    # 

&  !   7$  : 4*#& "  & . %   7 &6 "$   "  (+(+

$$6 -.

 %%

 " !  7 &6  (((> =

 #"    -"  " - "'

&  " 

 $ &! "   %"  "(  1#" C  26 . D $ 7-   &

06      % " "$  $$ !  +   6    ; A< % 6  - # #  " # . %.6  $   6   A, +A? # #  -. #"# E  " - % "

%"  "( =  #" #"       6" ! "   "$ "-   %"  "(    $"    " 

 $  %6  %%" . "  &    6" "  %"  "(   & 6  F. $& " 7 &6  #  (+(+

 #" &  "  #  . &  ; A< % 6 $"6     "$ #  $   ; ,< % 6 

#  G" =    - & " 

 -$    $!" "$ %"  "( : 4*#& "  " -#   7 #" '

  &!&   #" "   %"  "  /1 "

&!  "  -$  %.  6  " 6   %"  #  % # "    ".   , -. 

 

 /%. $

. &    *0

  % > @ !   #" $"   %  ! &" "&  %% -""3    "#6 % # " #" $$ ! "$ 1     &"  "$ %%  A @  "  %   %"  "( $   #!  $" # " 3&  ; (< % 6 #"6%" "  .

 4 %.6 "$   -$  -$ "$ '" 6& #6 " #E& &   #" % % #6  #"66 %" & 0 "$ 7-  "& 0#.

1%6 "$ C  26 .

D $B 1#" C  26 . D $ 7-   & B 1#" #



 #

4 #"

7-

  &

 #

0%  880  # "

&  C"%

2 3"  ##" 8

7-   &

$  -$" 

" $ #"   ' # !  7 &6  #  (+(+ * (  %% %$ -.

 # 0%   # "

&  C"%

2 3" ' 6 !  7 &6  (((> *   6 .

" #" %% ' $ &   7 &6  #  (((> @   "  6 "$ #"   %"  "( $  *#" %" * +  " %& "$ 6%& "  * +  , ( @  %%"  " %" #    $ "&  -. %"  "(     $  -.

6 '

#        

       

     



  

  



   

      

                        

 

      

        

 

   

  



  

    

    !" # 

 

$  

      

  

   

          %          

              

  &"'"($ 

     ) *  )   

%

     ++   

%

   

           

         

            

 

&"'"($          

       

%

 

 "

",","*+-   ,","*+.

 5       

           

   ,")-   -"   



    

     

     

 

  

   

    

               

 

/ &0   1     

     

      

    

     



   



      

      

    

 

     

 

   

 



      

  !" # 



$  

   

 

       

  &'($     )*  )   

%

 

          

%   &'(      

        

   

   

               ,")-    -"     





 

       

   

  

    

%

 

   "

",","*+-    ,","*+.   

   

  

      

 

  

   

  

         

 

/  

 1

"2 (( 2"6   %  & "$   %

" $6  $"

"'&  H(3 

     

    

  

       1   

 4 ((  "55555 6"55555 )"55555  7"8  2 (   '&  "(

  " "-!   

 6 5555

%

    

 

  %

      :

";

     

*

           

 



     -

 

/ "' 

  0 "



 %      

  "2 (   '&  "+   " "-!    1)% 2  3  4

7";%

    

    

     

   

  

  



     

         

       8"*

          

  -







/ "9  

 



      



  

  



      

      

 



   )* ) ++   

%

    

 

  

    

%

 

 "

",","*+-     ,","*+.     

     ,")-     -","

 

   



 

       

  

 "2  (  "$ 7 &6 "$   %%

 " *  " "  #   . %#$# %  " "-7#" '  -.  %%

 & & & "$  "   -$ & -.

" "   &"  "$ %%  # " =  %%

 " $$6   $ & "$  " -. "-!&    6";%

  %      %







         

       

 

 '      

  <

 

     <

   0 ") 



     =   

        

 

<    

1   



 

  



'  



 %







           

 

   

  



  





   



    



'      

 

" 

 7 )"&

       

1   

 

7",.",7

   

> '   

    

     <

   0 ") !

  

 

 ##!

 '  ?9 @  =    





  "



 





"> '      

 

        1          



"2 (+ @   & "#   4*#& " #" &"

-    #   *#" "  $" #"&  #

 4*#& " #   %%"% # 3 " #" "  %  &  ##6#    '"  6% ".    7 &6

 & % "   # @ 0&9&"4&6&&" !,0 +11)*+&

C"5-   0%6 " "$ @  "-!   ;       :

           



 :

 "A

           

 

"@   

          =   

    

    

       

" ;

            

  

  

   '        

   



 

     

       

" >         :

  '       '     

   

  :

  1    % 

 " > 1      :

 '  

        

 = 

 



"2 (, !& "   %. #   %       "'  %"  "( "&  # "      " &  "   . %.6 "$  -$ % -.   $  $"6    "$   6 

  "$ %.6 ; (< % 6 #"6%"  $  # "      " &   -$ "$  6& #6 " #E& &   #"   " " $" #6   . % -.   $  %6   "$   -"!   "

 8   "   -$ "$ % % #6  $ #"6% " "$ E . "$ !#    %6    " & %"6"" $ &&   -$ "$ % % #6 $"6      "

  " &   -$ "$ #"66 %"  "& '  #"E  '  ; (< % 6 #"6%" $"6   "$ ## 

 G"   # $" 6 ". 7#" #&   $  " %.  ; (< % 6 #"6%" " 

 -$ " '

#

     " %.  #"E  '

 ; (< % 6 #"6%" $"6    "$ ## 

 G" (  !   *% # $"6    $ # 

 

" #    "$   %"  "( % $$ -$"   

" ' #" (>  "#  %" #  %# & %&%    " '

   -& "    "$ 

%"  "(   " ; A<  ,<  %#! . =  #"# "  '

   $ #      .

  &  "$  $ 3 $"

""! #" &   $#    "$   % $$ %"  "( ' #  & 6 " 

  $   $

#" " &&    % $$%"  "( ' " &!   -$ "$  "  "  $ (A

# -$  &!   $

"    & "$  "   &  $ C  % # "   '   "$  % . =  4*#& "  & .

%    "$ '" 5$ 5 $  & ' & "$  " " #"6%" "$   -$  "  . %.6 "$  -$ -.

"-!&    " "  -$   " - &    6

 9 6 =  %6  "& 1#" C  26 . D $

$  " -$"    "   6   A, +A? " # #  -. %6  " -   "  %"  "( =  #"" "  -.

 #" $"  %"   $$ ! "$ 1     1#" C  $6 .

D $ 7-   &

 - &!   '"& 6%" "   $$ !  " - & "   %6 #" - #"#  @  " #   . # # $#" ' ! &! -.   %6 " -.

 %"  . %" "$ 6  =  #". 6& "$   '" I$ J  5  "5    7#!  '" I$ J 6 I " &J C    % #

  "  '" 5$ 5    7#! " I J " $   $ '

#   .  &  %!" # "$  7 &6 F.  &   7 &6 "$  "   .   #"* "$   %  & "$   %   $ "&  -.   % $$    -" 6  -.  " "    "$    &  "$ %. 6  -.   % $$ " & 6  " 

-$ %. $"  & "$    $ -.  "   "$   '" I$ J    #"* "$    $ & 

 & " 63 %   #

! " 6 "$ "-   4*#& " & . #"  %   7 &6  # % -. " - "' (   % " "$   $" #"   " 6   !"  6  -. 6      & %% #" $ .

 "   %" "$ ##" & .  "%. "$   "  -  "    " $"

 10 #"6% # = " - "$      " .    % *#"                 $%% 6%

  %3&?"  K?"

     %"-  K?"