Sohan Singh v. Punjab State Civil Supplies Corpn And An
!" "#$%$&' ( )
( *+ &*$&,+ "!$!$&"- .% +"/&0 1*! !"$2$3*/443$"%-4- !$&5$6$!"7 &7 &!+"- "%4&7"&!% ' 85 * *9* 5:
*9* 5: 5 !
"# "$ #$"% & ' ()& * +,-%+$./ & ) ) & & /0 /& (&) ##-( 1
2 )
3
*
* "#%$,#, "4
!
) &
(
+$ "$ ",,5 * 44$,,% -, ) 6"#7 657 9 ) ) *
2 +%#$$: & & (& .0 /&
*
2 "-,4#$$: & & ( 1 / ' $:
$"
#$$, ; ' ( #% $:
#$"# %
% & 0 / & < #% $:
#$"# & ' ( /
!
"
"
# $ "
" "# "
" # %&&'& $ " ( $ ) "
# $ $
" # *+ "
" #
"
"
;
,'+-.+&'
%/ 0 ; &
& ' () & ;/ ' ) )
#4 $% #$"# !
' ( "# "$ #$"%
& * +,-%+$./ &
/ 1 ) & & 0 /&&) =
) ! 0 ( /&0 1*! !"$2$3*/443$"%-4- !$& 5$6$!"7 &7!+"-%.%< -"5 3=
;
5; 0 ""
$:
#$"4 & ) ; & & &)3>&! (
< -"5 3> ? @ 3) 0 & & &
1 )
&'
&
0 )
) & 3>& ( 76 /%/&7- &7 &!+"-.%*! !"
6$3 7/ &7!+"-%=
; *;;=&$& &7$ .%6-$!5 3
>
&#+ &7 &7!+"-%=
> ; *(=*! !" -$%% .% 733$< %=
* ( *! !" 0 %!+ &.% &"%+$5 3=
? *;;
)
& & &3B& ( "" "# 0 &"%+$5 3B ? @ )
6-$!5 3 &#+ &7 B ? @ +733$< %B ? @) &
) /
1,
$
# " " 2
$ 3 $
(
# # ! $ 4"
* # ! 5
# $
" #
"
2
$ / #
+
#
6 78 " +
2
$ ! $
"
+
6 78 "
$ " #
6 78 4"
"
2
# $ #
9
# $ # $ "
"
4"
*
$
:
)
7;
< ; ; ;
= 72(, ->? ;) >@.8 A ( $
7 --> 7>8 ;)) @@8 2
$ #
" * $ # ! 4"
# $ 2
B"
( C " 7 -
8 2) @-& 7 8+ 3
# )
# 4"
"
"
+
#
$
$ $
: #
$
# # $ #
)"
+ # " 2 +
#
" +
" $ * # " # " 2 $ " 4
$
# " 2
$ 4 $ $ 3 ;
; D = (#+ 7
>8 ;)) .& ?+
&1)
$ $
$
$
) 3 5 " * "
$ #
!"
)
* $+
+ "#
"
# 4 " # "
! + # 4"
* # $ 6 $
( E ) D -&
2) .'. .> 8+ =
"
< 72(( 3, @ )/ F* " +
+ "
# # "
9 + ! # $
2 B"
# * " $
# # " 4 F
> ( "
G ) 7 -.
78 2 3, -@8 , 7 2 3, -./8+ F 25
$
( $ : : $ "
F = #+ ! ; "
D ;" 78 7 -.
9 ,
>
< 72(( 3, .@/ F " +
+
4"
( , ! $ 2 B"
F 2+
H ,$# H 7 -. 78 9 , &'.8 = < 72(( 3, .>
F* $# $
4"
# $
"
+ "
" 4
"
F
. ) " #+
"# " $
$
$
# #
& *
$ $
" #
"
< 72 I#"
)(*+ 2(, -> ;) >?
F3 $ "# $
"#
+
+ "
7 # )J8 # "
*
+ $
+ "
F FB
$ # "
4
+ # " $ "
?
# $ # =#
4
$
" 3 ;
A ( D 2" = + 7
@8 ' ;)) .&+ ?'/?@+ &/ ?F A )
) 0 & (& ( &) 8 ( )
& 5$ (( & )
! ( ) & &"# &0 ;
) & ) &0 & ( 3
( ' ( )) &
< & ( ' ( ) &) '
) ) 0
( 1 ) ' ( &
&
) & &
#% $:
#$"#& ( ) 2'
C &) & ' ( &
9
) ) () ' 0 ##- ( 1
;
& ' ( && & ) 2 )
(
&) ( )
& & ; &) & ) &
2 & * ) &
& ))
@ *9* 5:A #- $, #$"-
A
. D.2 A* & D.2