Shiv Bhatia v. State Of Punjab
!"!
#$%%
&'( !#)$%%
$ *+ % , ,
+ - #$ !
"
## !
"
$ % &!' ..... ,
+/%0 +1 (
"
)
* " # "
+,- . #
"
/0 .12
(1311311 " # "
1114 .&!"
(4,5
# "
& "
!) 1 6
) /0 7
"" # /0
.&!"
# " % -833 9 "
# * "* ## #%" )
"
""
- : "#
" % " (1311311 : "#
)
)
% .& !"
") # * " "
) "
: "#
# # % # # "
: "#
"
"
) -%
5) 6 # # % + :
"#
%
##
"" # #:
"# )
% "
-2 .& !"
) ) :
"#; # "" " %" "
(13-1318 < * "
;" 5 0
"#
# #" 8 6
* (1311311 *
* "
" ## * 183413116
#(+
" *
"
* " 9
9 ) ##
6
#"
#
##
"
" #6 < )
#
#"
# ) " #.
# *
# ;#
" ) " " * "
"
8( 6 # "
##% "
! " %" "
(13-1318 # %
#
"#
#
% "
"
-% 5) (1
% * # % /0="
0 * )
) "
-2
.&!"
# # ! "#1( <
0
81 6 < )
1315>??<>331845@ #% ) ?A# )< ? B
?)"%
(4,3(<<,(@! # ) ! # .
% ;(441(<<115@$
'# ).
;
131+- < < ) # +4+@ # ) C ?
.<6 &# 131- 0.< -((@ < ) #!
#.1+5=1313
32311313
D<
* !# 6
E #F@D.
!
;
%C
6
E #F "
# :
!
# <# .55-3 1311
113,1311
D ))
#) ?
; 6
'
F@< ) #!
#.((841311
353,1311
'
B
C'
#) G 0
!;< %
%
131++<< ) #(21@ # > D
!"
# $%
&
3
& "
& ' & "
' ' ( '
" )
' *
+
" '
,
'
+
&
#
"
"
-&
&
,+.
&
/*( #
%012
&
'
3 /*( #
%01
4
'
3 /*( #
%01 5 '
!
"
67
"
#
' '
3 /*( #
%01
#
38 #
)
/ !
#
!
2
3 /*( #
%01 ' "
( "
'
" &
4
-
&
3 /*( #
%01
+
&
3
/*( #
%01F
8- 0
#%
"
)
#
" # #6 <
8,4 131-* ) 1,((131-!9 -?* ; * % " ")
" "
##% ; * 9 "
" # < "#
#%"
#!
#" "
)
) <
!
" # ! @#
*
> D%9 #
: +
4
67 ;
"
++
4
67 4
4
+++ ,
4
67
4 4 &
'
4
67
67
& +< /
&
4 ='
-
"
4
67 < +
4
67
&
4
67+
4
4
67
F " %
# * " ")
" 2 0 *
((
# # # #= %
:
"" # < =& %
?*
"
) % ) % "" #< =&
##) % ##* "
> 6
## ) # % 6
##
) * %
" #
")
% # 6
## )# %
# 6
## ")) %"* # # 6
##
% * < 6
## "## ) 0
"=?"" # "
## " "##
) *
) #< =0##
6
## %) % # # 6
##) *;
% % )
"" #< "
# ")) % " # #0"
# %" # # /0
*
)
) * "##
#* " " ##
"
)
6
, 0"
" %
"
* " ) % ) % "" # < =& %
"
* % " "
=") # ##
# ) "
"##
#
4 "" #% (3 .
##" 9 ) (( " ) "
"
) "##
# "
% ## #
0,
+1 %% / E ; = > H=. E
#> H=.