High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/1453/1993dismissed

Bhagwan Dass Dawer. v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-01-29Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan4 pages

! !

! ! "#$%#&#''#%#(

)*+*+,&)( )('-'

*#*),.#(/#&##&0,*")('

)'1,&0)&*'

3 ()')&*

()')&*

( +(5 06,7#*).,(

( "#8+%#8 06,7#*).,(*")1)*+*+,&)(

(

-&+8 )"(# )&+,()1-*/06,7#*))&)(#8 #(/#&# 9:9:9:

9:9:9:

") 1)*+*+,&)(%",%#'')(6+&$#'+**)(&'*(-7*,(#* *")&0-'*(+#8(#+&+&$&'*+*-*) #&+1#*"#0+&'*+*-*)0*")+&'*#&* %(+* 1)*+*+,& +& *") /)#( #''#+8+&$ *") #7*+,& ,. *") ()'1,&0)&*2-*",(+*+)' +& "#6+&$ 0)&+)0 *, "+; *") ')(6+7) <)&).+*'*"#*%)();#0)#0;+''+<8)*,"+'=-&+,( &#;)8/ #>#(+

#7*' +& <(+). #() *"#* *") 1)*+*+,&)( %#' +&+*+#88/ #11,+&*)0#'+**)(,&#0",7<#'+'+&*")1#/'7#8),.?!2!+& *") &0-'*(+)' )1#(*;)&* ,. )('*%"+8) *#*) ,. -&=#< ,& @!

) %#' *")()#.*)( ')8)7*)0 #&0 #11,+&*)0 #' ,();#&27-;2 -1)(6+',( +& *") 1#/ '7#8) ,. ?!2 ,&

@ 1,& ()2,($#&+>#*+,& ,. *") *#*) ,. -&=#< *") 1)*+*+,&)(%#'#88,7#*)0*,*") *#*),.#(/#&#% ) .

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

@ BC,&*")#11(,6#8,.*") -<,(0+&#*)

)(6+7)' )8)7*+,&,#(0 #(/#&# "))&*+()7#')')*-1,&<)"#8.,.*")1)*+*+,&)(+' *"#* #>#(+ +&$" %#' "+' =-&+,( #&0 "+' ')(6+7)' %)() #8', *)(;+&#*)0-1,&*")78,'-(),.*")-(#8&0-'*(+#8)6)8,1;)&* )&*()' #&0 '-<')A-)&*8/ #* *") '*#$) ,. #0=-'*;)&* #>#(+

+&$""#''*,8)&#;#(7"#&0"#'<))&#11,+&*)0,&#"+$")( 1,'*,.11()&*+7)'"+1 -1)(6+',( *"#'<))&7,&*)&0)0*"#* '-7"#7*+,&+'0+'7(+;+&#*,(/#&06+,8#*+6),.(*+78)'#&0@,. *"),&'*+*-*+,&,.&0+##&0*")1)*+*+,&)(+'6)'*)0%+*"#(+$"* *, <) $(#&*)0 #88 *") ')(6+7) <)&).+*' #' "#' <))& ;#0) #0;+''+<8)*,"+'=-&+,(#>#(+ #6+&$")#(08)#(&)07,-&')8.,(*")1#(*+)'#*8)&$*"

#&0"#6+&$1)(-')0*")18)#0+&$',&()7,(0 *"+',-(*+',.*") 7,&'+0)()06+)%*"#**")78#+;(#+')0+&*")+&'*#&*%(+*1)*+*+,&+' -&*)&#<8) * "#' $,&) -&7,&*(,6)(*)0 *"#* *") 1)*+*+,&)( %#' ')&+,(*,#>#(+ +&$"*+88*")/)#(@%")&*")+(')(6+7)'%)() 0+'1)&')0 %+*" -1,& <)+&$ 0)78#()0 '-(18-' ,%)6)( '-<')A-)&*8/ #>#(+ +&$" %#' ')8)7*)0 #&0 #11,+&*)0 #'

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

&0)('-7"7+(7-;'*#&7)' *")78#+;')*-1</*") 1)*+*+,&)(</.+8+&$*")+&'*#&*1)*+*+,&+&*")/)#(,&*") 6)($),.'-1)(#&&-#*+,&,&*")<#'+',."+'')&+,(+*/1,'+*+,&*"#* ")80$,,0,&8/-1*,*")/)#(@+&7,;1#(+',&*,#>#(+ 7#&&,*<)#77)1*)0 1#(*.(,;*")78#+;<)+&$.,-&08#75+&$+&;)(+* *")

'#;)7#&#8',<)*)(;)0#'"+$"8/<)8#*)0 "+',-(*0,)'&,* .+&0 #&/ +&.+(;+*/ +& *") +;1-$&)0 ,(0)(' 0#*)0 ! #* &&)D-() ! #&0 0#*)0! !#*&&)D-() ! %")()</ '-7"78#+;'*#&0'()=)7*)0 (+*1)*+*+,&+'0+';+'')0 E F E F E F E F ! ! ! ! ! ! ! !

,*)

")*")(*,<)().)(()0*,)1,(*)(G)'H , ")*")(*,<)().)(()0*,)1,(*)(G)'H , ")*")(*,<)().)(()0*,)1,(*)(G)'H , ")*")(*,<)().)(()0*,)1,(*)(G)'H ,