High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6765/2009dismissed

(O&M) Anant Pal Singh v. State Of Haryana & Others

2015-05-27Mr. Justice J.C. Verma6 pages

!"#$%&'()* !%!' %+,!-( ...

/ /121 ,'%'

%/&%!%%! '( /1 ...

!'1

44444 /-2 5&"# $/, 2!%), !/ 6 %'

7'( $1%/6

!8%2/) 6 %'

/'( / $/ ,!-+%))%/&%!%%!

$/ %9 1(829%/))%/&%!% /'( !'1

(1 6+/ 61!3 ''!!6:!-123 /61/&;2/1 '! '(12/'2!

//'

+ '( !1''2'!! %(%15

!3/

5&'(

!-!-/ / %'

<!!

=2/

#*>3%11

2'!-2/')7( 5&'7%1( + '(%''(

(+ /1%/ +%5+ '/ 2! '( %92!'/

11!6 7'(

3/61!1,

'!?<*>%! ,

'!?<>'( @%! A21'!

')*B C<( !%'

// '%1'( '> '1 +%9 932-!

/'%:

1!'%

2!'

'2%+9%'/=!/'( + -%+31'! //

'+&'12/'( /3+ % '(%'

932-!

/1!

/6%+ !/+ -%+

? 2!1 +/'( !'1)!'( '( /(%! )(%6 2/- '(%'

/911'%'2'/&3/61!1%1%+1!6 7'( ;2 %+9%! %'

!D5+ ,23/ 2/'! %!

! "

" #$%) '( 3

(+ / (%

%129 1)) E#!

11/9/ !'#%! '(

/'(217%1+%5+ '/ 2! '( /9%& +%9% ;21'9 !'!

1251 !'3%&9 !'1)%!&) 2 /9'( ''(

/ C %/!-%/-29 !'1% / 5& 2!1 +/'( 3%/'

17(+

/21!-'( 3%3 /5:%! !1 /!-'( %''

! !-

1)'1 !'/ 132'

17'(/ -%/ ' ='

!' !''(

#(+ /'!'

1'!'( %92!'1'%'2'/+& 2 '(9/9'( 1 +%! 7!

/ (% 3/ % /

+%9!-

!(%!

!' !1%'!6 /%! %56 %92!'%7%/

@%! A21'!++

'/<@>A2%% A21'!(1+%! 5&'( ,'%'

%/&%!%( !1%'!7%1 !(%!

2/'F 1*BE# /1A2%/ &%/ (17%/ 7%1 !- ,'%'

%/&%!%!'(1 2/'6

B* BB0 '16 '**

?)'(12/'

(% 23( + '( 7%/ '( 1'/ '2 -

2/' /) '( 3

(+ / (% +

2'!

%33+ %'! 2/!-3 &7( (),'%'

%/&%!%(% + %33+ %'!

'!*CC //

6 /&'(

'%+%92!'3% !

+%9!-'(%'!'

1'13%&%5+ !+&!9%/:

'6%+2 '( % A2/ +%!

%! !'!'( % '!%+%92!'%! 1+%'297( (7 3%&%5+ 2!

'! ?<*> %! ?<> /

'6 +& '( ' ( +%9%!'1 (% 331 %33+ %'!'( ,'%'

%/&%!%''(%! !%+3+ % !-'(%'

%92!'3% 5&'( ''(

/(%1/1''5 %33/3/%'

'7%/ 1!'

1'%! !+&'( !'%!&'( 93!

!'1'( +%9 / %'

)'(

2'!-2/'(% ( + '(%'

2+%'!19% 7 //

'%! 1 ++&)/ 2! '(

%92!'7%1/ (

!- 1% / ! 6+/ 61!3 ''!5 / '(12/', ++&)/ /1 %'

?*%! 3%11

2'!-2/'7 1 '%1

%! '( %1 7%11 !'5% :// 1(

1! B 932-!

/)'(%15

!( + 5&'(

2'!-2/'

'(%'!6 7 &

)'( !'

1'!1+%'29 %92!'13 /9115+ !+&7 * * %'

3/!2!

;2 -9 !'!

()

*"+$*

$ +&'( '3%&9 !'9% !

11'(%!7(%'7%1 /9115+ 2!

/ '( 1'%'2'/& 3/61!1 %! ! '

/91 '( ;2 9%! %'

)72+ !' 5%/'( '- '5% :'(

11%92!'3% ''(

/@:!-/9%!'( /%!-+ )!2! 2 !/ (9 !' %!5

%++7 9 +&5

%21

113%&9 !'(% %+/ % &5

!9% ) '(2-('(

/7%1!' /' * ''(11'%- )A2 1'!%/1 1%1'7(%'1'( 9%!%!

3G!'

1'H%7%/ %5+ ''(

'!B'( '1 + 6%!'3/61!!1(/')!'

1'13%&%5+ !'( 9%/:

'6%+2 '(

% A2/ +%! 52'7( ( 2/1 1!'!

+2 D!'

1'D!1+%'29

/'* * %'

;2 -9 !'! &

** $ +&5

%21

113%&9 !'(%1%+/ % &5

!9% )31 % ' %!!'5 %

!1'/2 ' 5%/'( / +%9!- '1/ 2! ''% :'(

/! 2+%'!19%

2'!- 2/'1%+1912!

%'( /) 2+%'!19%

2'!-2/'

! '%+ !'12 //9%!&%2+'''(11'%- )'72+ 5

+ 6%!''/ /'3%/%CC &

7( !%'

211!-6%/21 %1 +%71)'( 3/31'!+%77'(/ -%/ )!'

/%+%)' /9115+'&!'

1'(%15

+%/ %11-6 !!'( !

='3%- "

! "!! #$%&$'()$*%+#,-*.,**)/&%%0$',+*$1 ,#1 ,#*.$'$1 02 %&+* $#3& %&)/& #% '$ $''$1 % +% #*+1$'+#/%&,%%&$()$*%+#,'+*$*+#4,'+)*3,*$*5$#1+#/+# )'%*,--4$'%&$3)#%'26.$5$'7+%%$13)#*$-%,11'$**)* #%&,%()$*%+# &,%()$*%+#+*.&$%&$'+#%&$-+/&% %&$ 1$3+*+#+#)#1$'8*)5',96%&$,.,'1$$:1$3'$$&-1$'.)-10$ $#%+%-$1%3-,+7+#%$'$*%#*-,%+)7+#$;$3)%+#%&)/&+%+* #%*5$3+ +3,--2/',#%$102%&$1$3'$$ %+*.$--*$%%-$1%&,%,# $;$3)%+#3)'%3,##%/0$&+#1%&$1$3'$$

6%&$'$ '$6%&$ 3-,+7 '+#%$'$*%#*-,%+)7&,10$$#7,1$,#1%&$*,7$&,* 0$$##$/,%+4$1$+%&$'$;5'$**-2'02#$3$**,'2+75-+3,%+#02 %&$<)1/7$#%'1$3'$$ %&$'$ $'$#3$3)'%' %&$,55$--,%$ 3)'%6%&$$;$3)%+#3)'%.+--&,4$#$3$**,'+-2%'$<$3%%&$ 3-,+7 '+#%$'$*%#*-,%+)70,*$1#)#1$'8*)5',9#%&$ /')#1%&,%%&$$;$3)%+#3)'%3,##%/0$&+#1%&$1$3'$$ )%+ %&$,.,'1 %&$'$ $'$#3$3)'%'%&,% %&$,55$--,%$ 3)'%1$*#%*5$3+ +3,--2'$ $'%%&$()$*%+# +#%$'$*%# *-,%+)7' +# 3,*$* .&$'$3-,+7 &,1#%0$$# 7,1$,#1 '$<$3%$1$+%&$'$;5'$**-2'+75-+$1-202%&$'$ $'$#3$3)'%'

%&$,55$--,%$3)'%6,#17$'$-2+#%$'$*%#375$#*,%+#+* ,.,'1$16%&$#+%.)-10$5$#%%&$$;$3)%+#3)'%%,55-2 %&$',%+ )#1$'8*)5',9,#1*,2%&,%%&$375$#*,%+# ,.,'1$1+#3-)1$**-,%+)7,#1+#*)3&,#$4$#%+#%$'$*%#%&$ ,7)#% 3)-1 0$ 1+'$3%$1 % 0$ 1$5*+%$1 +# $;$3)%+# %&$'.+*$6#%=$,-*3-,'+ 2%&,%*)3&+#%$'$*%#*-,%+)7 3,#0$3-,+7$1#-2+#5$#1+#/$;$3)%+#*,#1#%+#3-*$1 $;$3)%+#*,#1%&$$;$3)%+#3)'%.+--0$$#%+%-$1%5$'7+%+%* '$34$'2 '7%&$1,%$ %&$<)1/7$#%+#)#1$'8$5%$70$'

9,#1#% ',#25'+'5$'+1=$,-*3-,'+ 2%&,%%&+* .+--#%$#%,+-,#2'$,55'5'+,%+#' '$*&,55'5'+,%+#02 %&$ 1$3'$$&-1$' &+* .$ &,4$ +#1+3,%$1 02 .,2

3-,'+ +3,%+#,-*+#$;$'3+*$ )'5.$')#1$''%+3-$*! ,#1!

%&$#*%+%)%+# #1+,.+%&,4+$.%,4+1 7)-%+5-+3+%2 -+%+/,%+##%&+*()$*%+# * !1(/')3/31'!+%7 /-!-/9'( /A2'

3%/%-/%3(CC &

1%12!

<*> =

2/' %!!'-5 (! '(

%! 1) 1'!1+%'291!

-%'

) =3/ 11+&/93+ +& !'( 7%/ )'( +%9/!'

1'!1+%'291' ;

I <> !'( 7%/ )!'

1'!1+%'291!'/ 21

=3/ 11+& / 93+ +& %! 9 +& !'

1' !

!1%'!1%7%/ )'(

2/' %!

%33+&/%',2!

/D1 %1 %! !'(%' !'2%+'&)

2'!- 2/' %! /

' 3%&9 !' !'

1' !

1+%'29%+152'!''( /71 I <?> 7 /)'1!

11%/&'9 !'!'(%'"

<%> !'

1' ! 1+%'29 %! 5 +%9 !+& ! ! !-

2'!1%! !'! +1

2'!1I <5> %&9 !'!'

1'!1+%'2913 /9115+ !+&/9'( %'

;2 -9 !'!,2!

/D1 %1 * *%! !'/%!&3//3 / I%! ) < >/ #%33/3/%'!// 1(%33/3/%'!5&'(

/1!'3 /9115+ *? ')'(21) /- 1'(%'!'

1'!% '!%+%92!'1%++7%5+

!+&7 * *%! !'/'( / 3//''(%' *C !'( 3/ !' %1 )'( (% 9% 3%&9 !'1! /5+ '1%!

++&)1+%'29%! % '!%+ (%/- 1%+/ % &1' +A2 %'

3//' * *')'(21)++71'(%'!12 (%1'2%'!)'(

%!!'

+%9!'

1'!'( 93!

!'11+%'29%! % '!%+ (%/- 1 /* * * 1! 132'

/1 '1+%'29 %! % '!%+%92!'52''( 2' %'

1* *!'

1'1 3%&%5+ 3// ' '(1 %'

7%/ ! '(1 %1 7%1 3/!2!

5& '(

2/'!*** BB

3/ !'17%1

5&'(12/'!***

?(1

1!'(217%192 ( /'

! &

* J( !'(

7%1%!17 92 (3//' &

) '(

(+ / 7%1 ' !'

1' ! '( %92!' D1+%'29D!+&/'( / 7 * *%! !'/%!&3//3 / '

++71'(%'19 %92!'!'

1'(%15

!3% !

11'(

/9115+'&)'%6 2! 2 !/ (9 !'%! !'( /1'3/!

3+ 1+%7) 1+%5+ '2/!

/1'5 9% %6%+%5+ /% ;21'9

'7%/ 1'( /2'2/ !'5&'(

/1 *

2/'6 /&%5+&%! !'+&(%! +!-'(

!'/ 112 (% 9% '%+ 2+%'!1)7( /'(% ( + '(%'

1'!+&!%92!' 1*)?B)**E# !(%!

!1%'!) 7%13%&%5+ 93!

!'1+%'29%! % '!%+%92!' 1*)BB) *E# 7%1!''5 %/!'

1' /'* * +%/&)!'

1'!+&7 * *13%&%5+ !1(/')%92!' 1*)?)E#1'5 % ;21'

''( 1+%'29%! % '!%+%92!' 1*)BB) *E#%19 !'!

/ *B ! !

+21!)%1!?** BB!+&%!%92!' 1)CE# 7%1 2 %! 7%13%&%5+ ''(

/1'7%/ 13%&9 1+%'29%! % '!%+%92!') 2/1 )7'(2'%!&!'

1'=

%92!' 1)) E#/

/1/9'( 11 +%5+ 2!

/% ;21'

3!- ! 6 7 '( '1 %!

1 %1 9 !'!

/) '( 1 ! !/9'& ! '( 932-!

/ / %'

<!!

=2/ #*>3%11 2/'5 +7/9!-'( )'(1/ 61!

''!)5 !- 6 %!&9 /')1 1911

K%-2''L * J(

3/'

/1+ %+3%3 /19%&5 %++7 '1

;2 -9 !'M 1 J( /'5 ''(

3/'

/1/!'M ? J( /'( ;2 -9 !'1(2+ 5 3/'

!'( - 1'M 1