High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5301/2018allowed

Kuldeep Singh v. Sunil Kumar

2026-01-22Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja4 pages

$ ; $ ; $ ; $ ; *" $# *" $# *" $# *" $# $#4</ =1 $#4</ =1 $#4</ =1 $#4</ =1 .''$!

.''$!

44 44

44D

"'"'$!

&$!- !"

#$ #$

+5'"*!7@*!,-($.*" "% & "'"'$!

!7*- *5*,-($.*" #$

'( ) %*)+,-($.*" "% &$!- !"

CCCC , / *01 , / *01 , / *01 , / *01 $ 2 $ 2 $ 2 $ 23 $#442 $#442 $#442 $#442

$ "% *$! 5 !"'$! - '! "% *&&0'.*"'$!, "% *5 ' *00$@ @ - ..$5&*!6'!7- -$.+5 !"* "*) !$! .$-, +89 .""$*009+" :. &"'$! $ ;$# $ ;$# $ ;$# $ ;$# 4</ =1 4</ =1 4</ =1 4</ =1 >?

6 @*6$#& !"& "'"'$!#'0 -+!

!- "'.0 44A$#"% $!"'"+"

"'$! $# !-'*, .%*00 !7 %* 8 ! 0*'- "$ "% $- -*" - 2 4< &* - 86 0 *! - --'"'$ $!*0 '('0 +-7 / !'$ '(' '$!1, %*)%' *-', @% 86 *! *&&0'.*"'$! #'0 - *" "% '!"*!. $# & "'"'$!

B&0*'!"'## )'!7 & 5''$! "$ :*5'! *!-@ @'"'!7:& "86@*6$#*--'"'$!

!*0 ('- !. "*!-- .0'! - >4?

' #06"*"'!7,8* -$!*!*7 5 5 !""$ 00-*" -4 4@ @'"% & .""$"% & $& "6'"+*" -*"%*)%'*- -',"% & "'"'$! B&0*'!"'##8 '!7 "% ( !- #'0 - * +'" #$ &$ '$! 86 @*6 $# # & .'#'. & #$5*!. *7*'!" &$!- !"B- # !

!-*!"3( !-$ $! 4 42

&$! *&& **!. , "% &$!- !"B - # !-*!" #'0 - %' @'"" ! "*" 5 !" 86 - !6 6'!7 "% '7!*"+ $! "% *00 7 7 -

*7 5 !""$ 00*!-.0*'5 -%'5 0#"$8 *! '00'" *" & $!

% 0 (*!"& &** $ #$5"% @ @'"" !"*" 5 !"#'0 -8 #$ "% % 0 *! -'*0$+"' &$- +. % +!- 3 E

%*""% .$!" !"$#&**$ $#"% &0*'!"* @$!7*!-8* 0 * 5 !"'$! -, % !. - !' - " ' @$!7 "%*" *#" % *'!7 *!- +!- - "*!-'!7 "% *7 5 !" "$ 00 00 - # !-*!" &+" %' '7!*"+ $!

! '"

"% - # !-*!"'*!'00'" *" & $!

!*!-!$"0'" *"

G >?

+ + @ #*5 - 86 0 *! - '*0 $+" $! 42 * *!- "% *#" "% & &0*'!"'## 0 - "% ('- !.

! 8+""*0, "% - # !-*!" *&& * - - * F3*!-*7*'!

!- !' -%''7!*"+ $!"% *7 7 5 !""$ 00.0*'5'!7%'5 0 #"$ 8 *! '00'" *"

& $!

$@ ( 0*" $5 5 @% '! "% 6 * 4D, & "'"'$! B&0*'!"

'##@**80 "$0*6%'%*!-$!* *5$"7*7 - - 7'" -@'"% $##'. $#+83

7'"*,%*)%'*-'8 *'!7 *')*$ DA;4-*" -2 4 : .+" - 86 "% % &$!- !"B- # !-*!" '! # #*($+ $# "% ' !"*0 *!) $# $55 .

$$ $! "% *#" , "% & "'"'$! B&0*'

'!"'## 5$( - *! *&&0'.*"'$! 8 # #$ "% 0 *! -'* *0$+"#$ .*00'!7$#F3 % *'-&*6 @**00$@ -86 0 *! -'*0$ $+"*!-F3*7*'!*&& * -'!

!"% @'"! 8$:*!-"% 7'"

- 5$"7*7 - - -*" - 2 4 @*&+" "$% %'5, %$@ ( &$!- !"B- # !- -*!" *7*'! - !' - % %' '7!*"+ $! "% *'- 7 7'" - -$.+5 !" $! 4H 4 A 55 -'*" 06 "% *#" , "% & "'"'$! 3&0*'!"'## 5$( - *!$"% *&&0'.*"'$! 8 # #$ "% 0 *! -'* *0$+" )'!7& 5''$!"$0 *-*--'"'$!*0 ('- !. '!"% #$ $5 $#*!-@'"'!7 :& "$*"$( '#6"% '7!

!*"+ $# &$!- !"3- # !-*!" $! "% 7'" -5 5$"7*7 - --*" -2

% *'-*&&0'.*"'$!@*$&&$ - *""% '!"*!. $ $#"% &$!- !"3- # !-*!"*!- @*-'5' -86"% 0 *! - '*0

$+"('- "% '

'5&+7! -$- -*" -2 4 < 77' ( -"% $#,"% & !" .'('0 (''$!%* *8 !#'0 - >2?

% %*( % *- 0 *! - .$+! 0 #$ "% &*"' *!- 7$! "%$+7% "% &*& 8$$) #'!

!-+8"*!. '!"% +85''$! 5*- $!8 %*0#$#"% & "'"'$!

>;?

! "% 7'( ! #*." *!- .'.+5"

"*!. $# "% .* , @% '! &$!- !"3- # !-*!" %*- 8 ! "%$+7%$+" .0* *'5'!7 %'5 0# "$ 8 *! '00'"

*" & $!, %' *00 7 - '7!*"+ $! "% 7'" - - 5$"7*7 - - -*" - 2 4 /*')*$ DA;

41* I+' -"$8 ( '#' -*!

!-"*00' -@'"%%''7!*"+ $!

*7 5 !" "$ 00 -*" - 4 4 $ * "$ -$ .$5&0 " 9+"'. 8 "@ ! &*"' , & .'*0 006@% !"% &0 * "+&86"% &$!- !"3- # !-*!"'!%'@'"

"" ! "*" 5 !"*8$+"

8 '!7*!'00'" *" & $!%*& &'5*#*.' 8 .$5 -$+8"#+0'! @*) $# 7'"

-5$"7*7 - --*" -2 *)'!7'!"$*..$+!""% *8$ $( #*.", "% & !" .* .*!!$" 8 - .'- - 5 06 $! "% 8*' $# " .%!'.*0'

"' &*"'.+0*06 @% % ! "% & "'"'$! 3&0*'!"'##, & & # - *! *&&0'.*"'$! ) )'!7 & 5''$!"$0 *-*--'"'$!*0 ('- !. $*"$ :*5'! *!-@'"'!7:& "

! %+580 $&'!'$! $#"%'$+", :*5'!*"'$!$#* *!-@'"'!7:& "$*"$.$5& &* "% '7!*"+ $ # &$!- !"3- # !-*!"$!"% "@ @$-$.+5 !"'

"% *7 5 !

!""$ 00-*" -4 4*!-"% 7'" -5$"7 7*7 - --*" -2 4,@$ $+0- '!#*."% 0&"% $+""$*'( *"*9+"*!-#*'.

.$!.0+'$!

>D?

$ 5 '" .*! 8 #$+!- '! "% + +85''$! 5*- $! 8 %*0# $# &$!- !"3- # !-*!""%*"'!"% @*) $#& ('$ $+*&&0'.*"'$! )'!7& 5' '$! "$ .*00 *!- 3 :*5'! - # !-*!" $ * F3 %*('!7 8 ! *00$@ - 86 0 *! -'*0$ $+"$!4 4A,"% +8 I+ + !"*&&0'.*"'$!@%'.%@*#'0 - -$! 4H 4A #$ )'!7 & 5''$! "$ :*5'!

! *!-@'"'!7 :& " 86 @*6 6 $# *--'"'$!*0 ('- !. @* !$" 5*'!"*'!*80 ! "

"% #*." *!- .'.+5"*!. $#

'!"*!".* ,$!

!. "% .*+ "$#'0 & !"*&& &0'.*"'$!-*" -4H 4A ) )'!7 & 5''$!#$ :*5'!'!7*!-@'"'!7:& " $*"$.$5&* "% '7!*"+ $# &$!- !"3- # !-*!"+&$!"% *#$ 5 !"'$! - "@$-$.+5 !"*$ $!06*#"

% - !' -%''7!* *"+ +&$!"% 7'" -5$"7* *7 - -,@% 86*7*'! '" *"

"'!7 "% #*."+5$#% 8 '!7*!'00'" *" & $!*&&* !"068 .$5 -$+8"#+0'!"% @ *) $# 7'" -5$ $"7*7 - --*" -2 >A?

! +.%.'.+5"*!. ,'!$- "$ $-$+8"*!"'*09+"'. 8 "@ ! &*"' @'"%*!'

'- *"$+! *"%"% "+"%,"% & !" (''$!& "'"'$!'*00$@ -* *!- '5&+7! - $- -*" - 2 4< &* - 86 "% 0 *! - '('0 +-7 / !

!'$ '(''$!1,%*) )%'*-''% 86 "*'-

+0"*!"06,"% *&&0'.*"'$!#'0 - -*" "% '!"*!. $# # "% & "'"'$! B&0*'!"'## )'!

!7 & 5''$! "$ 0 *- *--'"'$ $!*0 ('- !. '!"% #$5$# :*5'!'!7*!-@'"'!

!7:& "*!-$'!"+83 7'"

"*, %*)%' *-'

' *00$@ - % *5 %*00, %$ $@ ( , 8 +89 ." "$ &*65 !"

" $# .$"/1$# ,B3"$8 &*'-86"% & "'"'$!

B&0*'!"'##"$ &$!- !"3- # !- -*!" $!"% -*" #': - -8 #$ "% 0 *! -'*0$+"

><?

!-'!7*&&0'.*"'$!/1,'#*!6%*00 *0$"*!--'&$ -$# / 1 / 1 / 1 / 1 *!+*6 *!+*6 *!+*6 *!+*644 44,44 ,44 ,44 ,44 "') D F% F% % "% & *)'!7B *$! - % "% &$"*80 B$ B$