← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5452/2014dismissed

Raj Kumar v. Gurdwara Sangatpura

2015-10-21Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih5 pages

  

        



!" #"$%&%'( 



  )*+, - ."!%!%'"- /"-&+& +-#0 - 1 '2 !3+-  ."&3'#"'!  ( 4 51  55 -"&"'!( - &6%&6 22 -0 78 #9$ !" -!6"3"!%!%'"- :::

 ;6"!6"- -"3-!"-&   7$ 7 3 3"-& , < =" 770"# ! &""!6")+#2,"'!>  ="-"

"--"#!!6"-"3-!"-&-'!>1 ? ;6"!6"- !6" )+#2,"'! &6+7# =" -"3-!"# %' !6" #%2"&!> :::

 55 - 7 )"$!,"'!   !6" 3"!%!%'"- 0 & -#"-"# -, !6" #",%&"# 3-",%&"& %"  &638 9%#" -#"- # !"# ? @

8 -"'#"-"#=<!6""'!'!-77"-8 ,-%!& - &"9"'!6" 33" 7 3-"

"--"# 2 %'&!!6"& %#-#"- %7"# '#0 &#%&,%&&"#9%#" )+#2,"'! # !"#  ?

8 !"' '! %& ="

-" !6%& $+-! 9%#" !6%&-"9%&%'3"!%!%'

-%"

7<8 %' ' "9%$!%' 3"!%!%' %7"# =< !6" -"&3'#"'!8")"$!,"'! !6"3"!%!%'"-0 &&+26!',+7!%37" 2-+'#& &+$6 & ''3 <,"'!   --" -&   -"'!8 3-",%&"& ="%'2+'& " '#+'

%! -6+, '6 =%! !%'8$6 '2" +&"- '# 3"-&' 7 ='  %#" '""#   !6" -"&3'#"'! ! 0 & , %'! %'"# !6 ! !6" -"&3'#"'! %" +-#0 -  1 '2 !3+- 8 &%!+ !"# !   #8 66"6"-! 8 ,-%!& -8 6 33"'"# ! ="

  !6"7 '#7-# & 7&!6"0'"- !6"#",%&"#3-",%&"& '# !6"

%-& '#, ' 2","'! !6"+-#0 - 0"-"="%'2-+' =< #+7<$'&!%!+!"#- =6 '#6 A '#;"7 -"1$%"!< ' #"

"'$"8 %! 0 & #,%!!"# !6 ! -"&3'#"'! +-#0 - 1 '2 !3+- 0 &!6"0'"- !6"#",%&"#3-",%&"&

+! &-"2 -#&!6"=+%7#%'2="%'2+'

%! '#+'& " -6+, ' 6 =%! !%'8%!0 &&! !"#!6 !!6"-"0 &'$- $A&%'!6"0 77& '#!6"&63%'B+"&!%'0 & %!!$'#+$!=+&%'"&&+-!6"-8 !6" 3-",%&"& 0 & 7"! +! ! !6" 3"!%!%'"- ! $ --< +! $<$7" -"3 %-0-A& '#!6"& ,"0 &="%'2+&"# -!6"3+-3&"%! 0 & 7"! +! '& - & !6" 3"-&' 7 ='  %#" '""#   !6" -"&3'#"'!8%!0 & 9"--"#!6 !!6""C%&!%'23 && 2"7" #%'2! +-#0 -  0 & &+

%$%"'! '# !6+&8 !6" -"&3'#"'! #%# '! -"B+%-"!6"3-",%&"& - '<"C3 '&%' '  #+" '# $,3-"6"'&%9" $'&%#"- !%'   !6" , !!"- %' %&&+"8 '# !6""9%#"'$" ' -"$-#8=!6!6"$+-!& $'$+--"'!7<$'$7+#"#!6 !!6""9%$!%'3"!%!%'0 & %7"#=< !6"-"&3'#"'!!6-+26* &6,%-1%'26

;

8060 &#+7< +!6-%D"#9%#" -"&7+!%'C 3-9"!6 !!6"3-",%&"& %' B+"&!%' 6 # %'#""# ="$," +'

%! '# +'& " - 6+, ' 6 =%! !%'8 -"&3'#"'! "C ,%'"#  -, ' '# %9%7 '2%'""-E=+%7#%'2 "C3"-!

;?8 06 3-9"# 6%& -"3-! %' -%2%' 7 & ''"C+-"  '#!6"&%!"37 ' & ''"C+-"  ' ' 7<&%& !6"& %#-"3-!-" #& &!6+&(

?    

 

   

                            

      

               

  

 

           

      

 

 

                  

 

  

      

         

  

  

     

 

          

  

  !        

                      

 

         

  

  "

& 33&"# ! !6%&8 3"!%!%'"- '"9"- "C ,%'"# '< 0%!'"&& - =+%7#%'2 "C3"-! ! -"=+! !6" "9%#"'$" 7"# =< !6" -"&3'#"'! '7<  -"3-!   !6" 5$ 7 ,,%&&%'"-8 33%'!"# %' ' %')+'$!%' &+%!8 0 & -"7%"# +3'8 =+!"9"'  $3< !6"& %#-"3-!0 &'"9"-3-#+$"#'-"$-#=<!6" 3"!%!%'"- 9%#"'$" ' -"$-# 3-9"# !6 ! !6" =+%7#%'2 %' B+"&!%'0 &%' #%7 3%# !"#$'#%!%' '#6 #8!6+&8="$," +'

%! '# +'& " - 6+, ' 6 =%! !%' 9%#"'$" 7"# =< !6" -"&3'#"'!&60"#!6 !!6"3-",%&"&0 &7"!+! --+''%'2  =+&%'"&&   $<$7" -"3 %-& 6" 3"!%!%'"- #%# '! #%&3+!" !6%& 3&%!%'8 06%$6 0 & +-!6"- &+=&! '!% !"# =< !6" !"&!%,'%"&   ''" !6"- =+! ;

  ;  +! !6" 3"!%!%'"- 0 & $'#+$!%'2 !6" =+&%'"&&   0# 0-A& %' !6" 3-",%&"&8

 0%!6+! !6" $'&"'! '# 3"-,%&&%'   !6" -"&3'#"'! 7 '#7-#  '& - & !6" 3"-&' 7 ='  %#" '""# '# -"B+%-","'! !6"-"&3'#"'!8%!0 &$'$7+#"#!6 !* &6,%- 1%'26

;

 6 & &3"$% %$ 77< &! !"# %' 6%&

%# 9%! !6 ! !6" 3-",%&"& %' B+"&!%' 0 & -"B+%-"# - "C3 '&%' '# =- #"'%'2 !6" 3 && 2" 7" #%'2 ! +-#0 -  1 6%= 6" 3&%!%' !6 ! 0 & #+7< &+=&! '!% !"# %' !6" !"&!%,'< 

-0%'#"- 1%'26 - !&, '

;  '# !6" &%!" 37 ' 3-"3 -"# '#3-9"#=<6%,"3-9"#!6 !!6"-"%'#""#"C%&!"#'7<F

""!0%#"3 && 2" '#8!6+&8!6"& ,"-"B+%-"#"C3 '&%'! 6 9"  -"" '# $'9"'%"'! $$"&& ! +-# 0 -  1 6%=  -!%$+7 -7<8 -9"- 3"-%# !%,"8!6"'+,="- #"9!""& 9%&%!%'2 !6" %'&!%!+!%' 6 # %'$-" &"# '#8 =+! 

E

3%72-%,& 0"-" 9%&%!%'2 !6" %'&!%!+!%' "9"-< # < ! 3 < ="#%"'$" 1 ,+$6 &8 ")"$!,"'! 3"!%!%' 0 & %7"# =< !6" -"&3'#"'! "9"' 2 %'&! !6" !6"- !"' '!& '# !6" -#"-&  ")"$!,"'!0"-"3 &&"# 2 %'&!!6",6""9%#"'$"7"#=<!6" -"&3'#"'! ! &+=&! '!% !" 6%& ='  %#" '""# -", %'"# +'-"=+!!"#8 & ''"   !6" 0%!'"&&"& "C ,%'"# =< !6" -"&3'#"'! 0 & $-&&"C ,%'"# =< !6" $+'&"7 - !6" 3"!%!%'"- ' '<   !6" 9%! 7 &3"$!& ! "9"'  &%'27" &+22"&!%' 0 & 3+! ! '<   !6" 0%!'"&&"& & -"2 -#& !6" 2"'+%'" '#='  %#"'""# !6"-"&3'#"'!!-"3&&"&&!6" 3-",%&"& '#3"!%!%'"-9%-!+ 77<$'$"#"#!6"$--"$!'"&& !6"$ &" !6"-"&3'#"'! &-"2 -#&%!&='  %#"'"$"&&%!<

 5" -'"# $+'&"7 - !6" 3"!%!%'"- $+7# '! 3%'! +! & ! 60 !6" $'$7+&%'& !6 ! 6 # $'$+--"'!7< =""' --%9"# ! =< =!6 !6" $+-!&8 & -"2 -#& "9"' '"   !6" 2-+'# +3' 06%$6 !6" ")"$!,"'! 0 & ="%'2 $7 %,"#8 0 & "%!6"-$'!- -<!!6"3&%!%''-"$-#-&+

"-"# -, '< , !"-% 7%77"2 7%!< 6 ! ="%'2 &8 ' %'!"- "-"'$" %& 0 -- '!"# %' "C"-$%&"   -"9%&%' 7 )+-%&#%$!%'8 +'#"- 1"$!%'     !6"  &!+') =-= '"'!"&!-%$!%' $!8 @@"!%!%'="%'2 #"9%# ,"-%!%& $$-#%'27<#%&,%&&"# $!="- 8

  ) '  -+' 77% +#2"