High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/505/2023disposed of

Rajesh Kumar v. Jai Chemcals

2023-01-25Mr. Justice B.S. Walia4 pages

!" #$%$!&'((

) %*+,- . / $$!& . 0 .%,% $ * -$# 1% /( %2!&3 &

-' !&451 .(,%$# (6(7 1$ . % &'

.(.$) %*+,- .830!# "!. .(+,%* 9 . !:

18 30!# "!.* 2 $$!& .( ;;; (6(7 1$ 8( .

( .

: . $& * 2 $$!& $% "!. % $&9 %$3 !.3 . && <,. 3((=* . 5:* :$&9 < #,$!&2.!# 3$&9% = %. ) # 3( ( .& 3#!,&% 1#!& &3%* * <2 . ),39- & &33 #. 3 ((? = % 2 %% 3 $&% * 2 $$!& . 5: * 1 $0$1 ,39 .( $0$%$!& 3 &3 * 2 $$!& .* 3 "$1 3 $!& ,&3 . .3 . ,1 "!. % $&9 %$3 * < 2 . ),39- & &3 3 #. 3 3((?$&* :

.8$&=*$#*21 3$&9% . #!-21

&3* $!&$%"$< 3"!. 0$3 &# !&((( ( .& 3 #!,&% 1 #!& &3% * * $!& "$1 3 5: * 2 $$!& . "!. % : !" < #,$!& = % 3$%-$%% 3 !& * 9.!,&3 * * 2 $$!& . * 3 5 & % .0 3 &!$# $& * #$0$1 %,$ =* . " . * = 2.!# 3 3 <2 . !&(@(? &3$= %&!* 21 !"* 2 $$!& . * * * 3& 0 .5 &% .0 3 &:&!$# ( !. !0 .8* . = %&!% :!" * !.3 . !" * !,. =*$#* * 3 2 %% 3 * ),39- & &3 3 #. 3 3 ((?(

A( .& 3#!,&% 1#!& &3%* * "$&3$&9%$&!.3 .&& <,. * * 2 $$!& .* 35 &% .0 3&!$# $&* #$0$1%,$= %"

#, 11: $&#!.. # &3* 2 $$!& .* 3& 0 .5 &% .0 3&!$# $&* #$0$1%,$

&3* $%* 5 %$%!&=*$#** $!&&& <,. B= %-!0 3( .& 3#!,&% 1#!& &3%* !&# *

$%2 &3$&98 < #,$!&2.!# 3$&9%!,9*!* 0 5 &% : 3!.$&*

1 .& $0 1 % 3 " .. 3 "!. .

%!& 51 2 .$!3 !" $- ! & 51 * 2 $$!& .!-!0 :!" < #,$!&5 "!. * 1

$0$1,39 .($0$%$!& 8 3(> .& 3#!,&% 1. " .%!

(* % - $%. 2.!3,# 3 %,&3 .' C

( * #!,.!=*$#*

3 #. * %5 &% &"!. < #,$!&%* 118,2!&%,""$#$ &# ,% 5 $&9%*!=&8% :* < #,$!&!"%,#*3 #. "!. .

%!& 51 $- 8 ! & 51 * ),39- & 3 5!. ! 221: ! * #!,. 5: =*$#** 3 #. = %2 %% 38!.! &:#!,.* 0$&9 22 11 ),.$%3$#$!&$&. %2 #!"* 3 #. !.* < #,$!&* . !"8"!.

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

%*!=&8% :* < #,$!&!"%,#*3 #. "!. .

%!& 51 $- 8! & 51 * ),39- &3 5!.! 221:!* #!,.5:=*$#** 3 #. = %2 %% 38!.!

&: #!,. * 0$&9 22 11 ),.$%3$#$!& $& . %2 # !" * 3 #. !. * < #,$!& * . !"8 "!. .3 . ! % : < #,$!&8 !. "!. &: !* . !.3 . . 1 $&9 ! * 3 #. !. < #,$!& =*$#* -$9* * 0 5 & - 3 5: %,#* #!,. !" "$.% $&% &# !. 22 11 !,. $" < #,$!& * 3 5 & $%%, 3 * . 5:8!.$" $!&"!. < #,$!&* 35 &- 3 * . !( ?( .& 3 #!,&% 1 #!& &3% * * 1 .& 3 < #,$&9 !,. =$*!,#!&%$3 .$&9* 21 !"* 2 $$!& .!"*$%&!* 0$&95 &% .0 3 &!$# $&* #$0$1%,$ &3!"* 2 &3$&95 "!. * 1 .& 3.$ 1 !,.83$%-$%% 3* :!" < #,$!&8$&% 3$%%, 3#!&3$$!& 1= ..

&%(> .& 3#!,&% 1% %* $& * #$.#,-% &# %8 * 3! % &! 2. %% * $&% & 2 $$!&5, 2.

:% "!. 2.! #$!&"!. 1$-$ 32 .$!3!"$- ! & 51 *$-!-!0 $!& "!. % : !" < #,$!& 5 "!. * 1 $0$1 ,39 .( $0$%$!& 8 3$& .-%!" ( B( G$&9$&! ##!,&* %,5-$%%$!&!"1 .& 3#!,&% 1"!.* 2 $$!& .8& - 1:!"* 2 $$!& .&!* 0$&95 &% .0 3&!$# $&* #$0$1 %,$. %,1$&9$&2 %%$&9!" <2 . ),39- & &33 #. &3!"* 1 < #,$&9 !,.* 0$&9. #!.3 3!* #!&.

.:8& - 1:!"* 2 $$!& . * 0$&9 5 & % .0 3 &!$# $& * #$0$1 %,$ 5 %$3 %8 * $!& ,&3 .

2 &3$&9 3),3$# $!&5 "!. * 1 $0$1,39 .( $0$%$!& 38 - !" * #!&%$3 . 3 0$ = * 5 "!. $%%,$&9 #!&3$$!& 1 = ..

&%8 * 1 .& 3 < #,$&9 !,. !,9* ! * 0 9.

& 3 .

%!& 51 $- !* 2 $$!& .!$&0!G * ),.$%3$#$!&!"* 1

$0$1 !,.=*$#** 32 %% 3* ),39- & &33 #. "!.% :!" < #,$!& $&0$ =!"* % &3!"1 .& 3#!,&% 1"!.* 2 $$!& .* &!&!$# * 3

5 &% .0 3!&* 2 $$!& .$&* #$0$1%,$82 &3 &#:!"

.3 . ,1 &3 &! $!& "!. % : * 0$&9 5 & -!0 3

1!&9=$** ( @( ##!.3$&91:8 $& * 1$9* !" * 2!%$$!& &! 3 5!0 &3 =$*!, 2,$&9 * . %2!&3 & ! &!$# 5: $%%, &# !" %,--!&% &3 * . 5:& # %%$ $&9$&#,..$&9!",&& # %% .: <2 &% &33 1 :8* $&% & 2 $$!& $% 3$%2!% 3 !" 5: 9.

&$&9 1$5 .: ! * 2 $$!& . ! -!0

5 "!. * 1 $0$1,39 .( $0$%$!& 8 3=*!* 32 %% 3),39- & &33 #. 3 3((?8 =*$1 3$. #$&9* $11((8!.3 .&& <,. $%%,$&9#!&3$$!& 1 = ..

&% $&%* 2 $$!& .I),39- &3 5!.%* 11&!5 # 3,2!&(& # % &: $!& $% -!0 3 5 "!. * 1 $0$1 ,39 ,&$!. $0$%$!& 8 35:* 2 $$!& .8* % - 5 #!&%$3 . 3 &33 #$3 3 $& ##!.3 &# =$*1 =(&"!.# 5$1$:!"#!&3$$!& 1= ..

&%$%%, 30$3 !.3 .&& <,. " .((=!,135 3 2 &3 &,2!&* !.3 .% %% 3 5: * 1 $0$1 ,39 .( $0$%$!& 3 !& *

$!&-!0 35:* 2 $$!& .( ( $%2!% 3!" 5!0 ( ( &0$ =!"* . E, %- 3 8 #!2:!"*$%!.3 .5 ",.&$%* 3! .& 3 #!,&% 1 "!. * 2 $$!& . ,&3 . * %$9& ,. % !" * &#* 6 #.

.:( (( 2%