High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5813/2015disposed of

Naresh Enterprises & ANR v. Radhay Sham

2015-09-16Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih3 pages

!"# $#%&'&() * +

!,#'-("#,.,&'#'!($!("-#, /#"&"&(#,' 0#,'1' !$-#23-!4 /#'.($#(" ) 5 6 3 66 ,#'#(") , (17!1,!8 $9%!"# ,"-#.#"&"&(#,' , 4!( !-,&8 $9%!"# ,"-#,#'.($#(" ::: ;-#"-#, ,#.,"#,' <%!< .!.#,' 4!2 =# !<<>#$ " '##"-#71$?4#("@

=#,# #,,#$""-#,#.,"#,',("@

;-#"-#, "-# 71$?4#(" '-1<$ =# ,#.,"#$ &( "-# $&?#'"@ :::

66 ,!< ( 3#."#4=#, +8

8 "-&' %1," -!$ .!''#$ "-#

<<>&(?,$#,) A!9&(? !,?1#$ "-# 4!""#, !" '4# <#(?"-8 <#!,(#$ %1('#< , "-# .#"&"&(#,' !&,<2 '1=4&"' "-!" "-# .#"&"&(#, =# (<2 !

,$#$ (&(# 4("-'5 "&4# " 9!%!"# "-# $#4&'#$ .,#4&'#'8 !' -# $#' (" >&'- " .,#''"-#.#"&"&((4#,&"' "&%# 4"&( , * +

,%#'' $!'"& !' >#<<8 >&"- ! <&=#,"2 " '#,9# "-# ,#'.($#(" "-,1?- -&' %1('#< =# ,# "-# #B#%1"&(? %1,"C!..#<<!"#!1"-,&"2 3"!"1'D18!'&"#B&'"'"$!28'-!<<=#4!&("!&(#$ "&<<"-#!$71,(#$$!"# -#!,&(? =#'->(&("-#1,?#("<&'"E

, 4!( !-,&8 $9%!"# -!' %!1'#$ !..#!,!(%# ( =#-!< "-# ,#'.($#(" !($ '1=4&"' "-!" -# $#' (" ..'#"-#.,!2#,"-!"-!'=##(!$9!(%#$=2<#!,(#$%1('#<

,"-#.#"&"&(#,!($<#"(&(#4("-'5"&4#=#?,!("#$""-# .#"&"&(#,'"#(!("'"-!($9#,"-#9!%!(".''#''&( "-# $#4&'#$.,#4&'#'""-#,#'.($#("<!($<,$ 1,"-#,8<#!,(#$%1('#< ,"-#.!,"&#''1=4&""-!" !' !("-#, .#"&"&( &# **F

8 ,#?!,$&(? !''#''4#(" 4#'(#., &"'=2"-#!..#<<!"#!1"-,&"28&("#, '# "-# .!,"&#'8 D1! "-# $#4&'#$ .,#4&'#'8 &' <&'"#$ ,

8 "-# '!4# =# !<' $&'.'#$ !<(? >&"- "-&' .#"&"&( " !9#," !(2 %4.<&%!"&( %%,$&(?<28 "-# ,#%,$ "-#'!&$,#9&'&(-!'!<'=##(,#D1&'&"&(#$

($8 "-# .#"&"&( &' $&'.'#$ &( "-# <<>&(? "#,4') & .#"&"&(#,'"#(!("' '-!<< %("&(1# " %%1.2 "-#$#4&'#$.,#4&'#' ,!.#,&$ (&(#4("-' ,4"$!2 &#1." *

*G && "-##("&,#!,,#!,' ,#("8& !(28'-!<<=#.!&$ =2 "-# .#"&"&(#,'"#(!("' " "-# ,#'.($#("<!($<,$ >&"-&( ">>##H' ,4"$!28 !&<&(?>-&%-,#'.($#("<!($<,$'-!<< =#!"<&=#,"2"#B#%1"#"-#,$#, #9&%"&( ,"->&"-G &&& .#"&"&(#,' '-!<< %("&(1# " .!2 "-# 1"1,# ,#("C4#'(# ., &"' =2 F"- #9#,2 4("- " "-# ,#'.($#(" <!($<,$ ( "-# #9#(" #9#( ! '&(?<# $# !1<"8 ,#'.($#("

<!($<,$ '-!<< =# !" <&=#,"2 " #B#%1"# "-# ,$#, #9&%"&(

,"->&"-G &9 .#"&"&(#,' '-!<< $# ,!2 !<< "-# #<#%",&%&"2 !($ >!"#, %-!,?#' , "-# .#,&$ "-#2 >1<$ %%1.2 "-# $#4&'#$ .,#4&'#'G 9 .#"&"&(#,' '-!<< 9!%!"# "-# $#4&'#$ .,#4&'#' !($-!($9#,&"'!%"1!<.-2'&%!<!($9!%!(".''#''&(8 ,##

,4 !<< #(%14=,!(%#' " "-# ,#'.($#("<!($<,$8 ( , =# ,# "-# '"&.1<!"#$ $!"# &# *

*8 !&<&(? >-&%- ,#'.($#("<!($<,$ '-!<< =# ,## " #B#%1"# "-# ,$#, #9&%"&(!($="!&(.''#''&(G!($ 9& .#"&"&(#,''-!<< 1,(&'-!(1($#,"!H&(?&("-# !=9#"#,4'8=2>!2 !(!

&$!9&"8>&"-&(!>##H ,4"$!28 =# ,# "-# #B#%1"&(? %1,"8 !&<&(? >-&%- !?!&( ,#'.($#(" <!($<,$ '-!<< =# !" <&=#,"2 " #B#%1"# "-# ,$#, #9&%"&(

,"->&"- 3#."#4=#, *8

!7!( ,1(!<<& 1$?#