Indian Oil Corporation Ltd. v. M/S Goyal Oil Store

   

       

!"#$#%&'&() 
  ($&!( &* +,+!"&(-"$ #"&"&(#+ .#+'/'

' 0!* &*1"+#!($"2#+'

#',($#("'

)  3-  1 4 -1  +#'#(")5 +'2&'24!,+6$7%!"#6 +,#"&"&(#+ ++/(!('!*6$7%!"#6 ++#',($#("'

 82#"2#+"2##,+"#+'*%!*(#9',!,#+:!0;#!**9#$" '##"2#</$=:#(">
 ;#+##++#$""2##,+"#++("  82#"2#+"2#</$=:#("'2/*$;#+#,+"#$&("2#$&=#'"> 55 55 -1 

- :,/=(#$&(,+#'#("+#7&'&(&'+$#+$!"#$ ??
 6,!''#$ ;0*#!+(#$ &7&*/$=# /(&+&7&'&( 6=!67&$#92&%2!(!,,*&%!"&( /($#+  1#%"&(      +;&"+!"&(  !($  (%&*&!"&(  %"6  @@6  &*#$  ;0 $##($!("  "  +##+  "2#  :!""#+  "  "2#  +;&"+!"+  &(  "#+:'    $#!*#+'2&, !=+##:#("  $!"#$   @?
6  9!'  $&':&''#$  (  "2#  =+/($  "2!"  +&=&(!* !=+##:#("+$/*0%#+"&&#$%,0"2#+#2!'(";##(,+$/%#$ 2!7#2#!+$*#!+(#$%/('#*'+,!+"&#'!($2!7#!*'%!+#/**0 =(#"2+/=2&*# "%:#'/""2!" 0!* &*1"+#"2+/=2&"',!+"(#+'&*#$!'/&"

+,#+:!(#("&(</(%"&(!=!&('"$##($!("'++#'"+!&(&(="2#:+:"!A&(= !(0!%"&(!',#+'29%!/'#("&%#$!"#$ @B
 B+#=!+$&(="#+:&(!"&( +#"!&*/"*#"$#!*#+'2&,,*!&("&&+:!($!"+0&(</(%"&(9!'!*' '/=2"

5
5 ##($!("(!,,#!+!(%#&*#$!(!,,*&%!"&(/($#+1#%"&( "2#+;&"+!"&(!($ (%&*&!"&(%"6 @@6+#C/#'"&(=++##++&(="2# :!""#+"+;&"+!"+&("#+:' *!/'#@!=+##:#("$!"#$  @?
 2#'!&$!,,*&%!"&(2!';##($&':&''#$6!'$&'%/''#$!+#'!&$ (  ,/+'/!(%#  "  $&+#%"&('    "2&'  /+"6  ,+#'#("  ,#"&"&(#+ ($&!( &* +,+!"&(-&:&"#$2!',+$/%#$+&=&(!*$#!*#+'2&,!=+##:#(" $!"#$   @?
6  #D#%/"#$  ;#"9##(  0!*  &*  1"+#  !($  ($&!(  &*

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

("2#"2#+2!($6*#!+(#$%/('#*++#',($#("'62!'!+=/#$ "2!"!"#+!=+##:#("  @?
6 +#'2!=+##:#("9!' #D#%/"#$ ( !%%/("$#!"2':#,!+"(#+',*!&("&&+: 2#*#!+(#$%/('#*+,#"&"&(#+2!'$#(&#$"2##D&'"#(%# !(0'/%2+#'2!=+##:#(" 1!+!'!(0$&',/"#+#=!+$&(=7!*&$&"0 !=+##:#("+"2#+;<#%"&('6"2#'#!+#";#$#%&$#$;0+;&"+!"+/($#+ 1#%"&( +;&"+!"&(!($ (%&*&!"&(%"6 @@2#*#!+(#$%/('#*

55 +,#"&"&(#+2!'+##++#$"!%*!/'#&(!=+##:#("6!%%+$&(="92&%26&"&' ;&($&(=(-'"2#(,!+"(#+',*!&("&&+: (7&#9:!""#+6&:,/=(#$+$#+$!"#$ ??
 6,!''#$;0 *#!+(#$ &7&*/$=# /(&+ &7&'&( 6=!6&''#"!'&$#!($:!""#+&' +$#+#$";#+##++#$"+;&"+!"+&("#+:' *!/'#@!=+##:#("6 92&%2%:#'/($#+1#%"&(+;&"+!"&(!($ (%&*&!"&(%"6 @@

('#C/#("*06+#7&'&(&'!**9#$"'2!**!*9!0';#,#("+#',($#("'" +!&'#;<#%"&(!;/"7!*&$&"0 ( '!&$!=+##:#("!($#D&'"#(%#+#'2 !=+##:#("-#""+&!* /+",!''!,,+,+&!"#+$#++#=!+$&(='"!"/''/&" &("2#*&=2"+$#+,!''#$;0"2&' /+"-#";"2,!+"&#'!,,#!+;#+#"+&!*

/+"( 
 !" ) 1&(%#  :!&(  %!'#  2!'  ;##(  !**9#$6  "2#+#+#6  ,#($&(= !,,*&%!"&(6&!(06!*''"!($'$&','#$

-1   


  '<A' 82#"2#+',#!A&(= +#!'(#$ ) #'  82#"2#+#,+"!;*# ) #'