High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/195/2024allowed

State Of Haryana And Another v. Mohinder Singh

2024-09-19Mr. Justice Aman Chaudhary7 pages

#$%&'()&*+,+'-./ / %$%&'(0$12$-$$-)$-'%3&1 ///44&55$-%, 6&1,7, '3+-)&1+-83 ///&,4'-)&-% 9: ;<9= > ! ?1&,&-%. ,/6+@3$A&B$1+CDC0$12$-$/ ,/+%7?$%3$EC)F'*$%&GH&8$5+)I'7-,&5('1%3&1&,4'-)&-%/ JJJ

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`= >aNab cd NMeN]N N]f cagbM` h C ('55'B&) +- Nib`g gNOON _`= >aNab cd

\]iNj C B3+*3 5&$1-&) *'7-,&5 $44&$1+-8 ('1 %3& 1&,4'-)&-% B$, 7-$@5& %' *'-%1'F&1% '1 *+%& $-2 *'-%1$12 5$B/A3& 1&5&F$-%4$1$,'($Rk7R$1$-8$ ,741$ 1&$)%37,. l/ m&('1& $- &R45'2&& @&*'R&, &-%+%5&) ('1 %3& 81$-% '( 5&$F& &-*$,3R&-%C %3&1& 3$, %' @& $ 41'F+,+'- 7-)&1 %3& 1&5&F$-% %$%7%& 8'F&1-+-8 %3& ,&1F+*& ('1 &n%&-)+-8 %3& ,$+) @&-&(+%, %' $- &R45'2&&/ - &R45'2&& B+55 @&*'R& &-%+%5&) ('1 81$-% '( 5&$F& &-*$,3R&-% +-

IA/ Io?"V C)&*+)&)'- / / /

! "

# #$ %% %% %% &$ "

# #

" '

! (

' ( !

)

"# ! "

(

# ! ! $ %% %% %% &*$ +

(

"! (! # #

$ +#

! # ' #! "!

$ +

' # #

! (

# ! ,- ( $

( " "! . # / !'

"# ' ! ! " # #

# )

$ 0

" ! ! # ! "#$ 1 !' % # ! ( ( ' ( " # ' " # #

$ 0 # '

# ( ' ! (

" # #

' " (

-$ # 3" 4

# / !

(

' ( " "! . # / ! # $

' (

( "!

' ( ( $ -$-' !' (

' "# #

$ 0

$ 0 # ' (

(

# ! # #

5 (

$ -$-$ 6

-$ # 3" 4

/ !

(

# ' ! # #

$ %% %% %%

$ +

" (

(

' ( "

"# '

" ! # ! # ( # ! $

$ + ( #

( " '

( " "! . # / ! ( ' #

' # #

( ! ! "# # !

($ %% %% %%

! " #$ " %$ ! & $ %$ ! $% "' # !

&$ ! (

*! +

& , )!

*! +

&- *$$

.#! "

&$ /"" .#!

01 $ $% " 1( * '

" &&"

*$&$ $ 0 $! ' 1 0"-

$ $ !$"

! ! "' # !

&$& !

#$ !!"

$2 !

& # $%

&" 3 $ # " &$#

!%$- &"$ 2!$ !

" %$ ! $% "' # ! 4! "' &$ $ $% ! $ &

! *$$

.#! 2!

*! +

5 4! "" &$

"' # ! !

(# $% $ $% ! /"" .#!

$ $% !

# " 1( * '

" &&"

*$&$ $ 0

$! ' 1 0"-

*4 7 4! *$

&# % #""

" ! !

$% "' # !

! #8$ $% # "

# &"

&$#

! ! $& $ &

! ""! 9!8! :

! *$

! /"" .#!

# " ."

' $% ;1

$! &$

<* 7=

$ ) ) ! ! 1 ' 4! $% 9!8!

$! - > *4 7 5

09 $! ! *$ 2 $% $

!$"

! "' # !

&$& - !!$"

$% 2!

#!-

! # $%

$ " 2$"

& '

& $ %$ !

&$& !$ ! &$# "

! "2 4! # $ 2$"

$" $ $% #" $% ! *$ $ $% ,

4! " $%

" 2$"

& ' $ $% &

$ . !

$ $% "'# !

& &#"$% " 4! /"" .#!

1 0" # " ! "' # !

& " $ &"$ $2 !

& # $%

3 $ # " &$#

4! $"

# $

$ $ $% &"$ !

# $%

" %$

# :$2'- !

%%#- $ - "" $ " ! "#

%'$ $% !

"" !

" "" &$

$ ! "' # !

& $%

" - "

8 #

?" 1$'

/ ##$ $% &"$ - #$ !!"

! ' $%

" #

& $

' @ %$ "

A "' $% ! %$ 2$8 &%$

#! 2!

" '

$ 2!

01 $ $%

$ - ! /"" .#! $% !

*$ !"

! ! $ $% "' # ! 2!

& " $ &"$ - #$ !!"

$2 !

& # $%

&" 3 $ # " &$#

&"$ *$$

.#!- 2!

*! +

& 2 $

%$ ! ! $

! /"" .#!

01 $ $% - '

2 & $ 2 &% &$ $ ! &$'

$ " >

- ! ?$' ! ! $ !!$"

!"#

" $!" " "

" #% &

'! ( % )% # "#!

& & "# &

!"#

" $!" "

" #* '! (

+ ! " ,!- . " !

" # "

# #

% "

"#"

'! ( -! #

"& % )% ! "1 23""* '! ( .!" -! # %% * #" & & 4 5 ( (%% 6!

# !

""#

& # " $!" " "

" #

# #

% 8&"* "&

# ! ! )% ,!- . " !* 9!

:* ,":* .

" 9:::*

" " &

* ! ! ! & "!# .!"% . "# " * " " %% & " %)%

" & " "

"# " '! ( &&"; " "% : 5"% : " # * " "" & " &

# "

#"! !* !"#

" $!"% .!" " ! % % ,!- . " ! 9!

#"! &

! &

$!" " "!

! " &% : ! ! "1 2<)% : & "

* : " & !#

"" "# &

# " & "&#

# &

""* &

$!" " "!

! " &*!"*#"!&

%2 +++++++++ )% "! !* : &! ! ! "1

"# &

%0 ! "

"!* "%

6" &

#"! " " "" +

!"# $!"%

! !

#$ % & ' & (!

$ $

& ' & (!

& $

&" #$ $ *'

$ & &

+ +' ,

+ $ ! '

-! $ (! $ (!

#$ (!

(!$

! ' "

#$ !' ! $ ' $ (!

$ % & ! &

! $

". #$ !

) , $ !- & '

-! &" / & $ -! &) $ $ $ &!

$& ,$$ ,$ ) $ -! &) $ $ $ $ &!

$& ,$$ !

$ ' ' & & '

" #$ (! *& ,$$ $

$& $

& ,$$

& $ ''

!$ !

0" ""01!-"#$!

! 2 .0" 3 $ % & &'

'$$ &2 $$% &&'

4 *********

5,$ $ ! !

$ !$ &'

& ,$$ ,$ ' $ (!

$ % & &'

& !' ! ,$ ! !' ,$ '

& '

' $&) $ ' !$ !$ ) $ ' & & &

& $& ! $ '

$& ! $ '

) $ ,

& $ &! ,$$ -!& % & !) ". !

0" '

,$$ $ &!

$& ,$ '

6 & '

' &'

) $ ) $ &!

$& ,$$ & ! $ '

&!$&!" / 7"" %!'8

) $ ' , ' 19 $ ' ' & '

, $

$&" :$

!' $ ;!

7$-! &< "/$ $8 ),$ ! 2 .=" ; $

& ) $ ' !" #$

9 '

' $ ' $ &!

! " # $ %

# &' (

!$ )! # ( ! (( *$+ , -( *.

/( *0

( #! * 1 2! *0

($ 3 ". 3#- * 0

* 1 4 ( &$ 5(-# )" " ( . 6 (,. 5,. ) 6,,,

( 7 +$ !

" . ( &$ 5(-# )" " ( . 6 (,. 5,. ) 6,,, " ! #

! * * * !$ , (!. # ! ! #* "# ! ( * * . " *

" $ 8 (. *. * ! "$ 5!* - $+ , 1$$ /(0

( 2! *0

(. !

( 9*. ( ! 3!. *" #! ( $ : ( *( ( &$

#(* )( $ !. /( *0

(. ( &$ #(* )($ , " .

-( * # 4

" *" #! 5(-# )" " ( *( ( $ , . (

:$& -( * 2$ , *0

(. /" *

! ( ( $ % #( ' (($ , ( :$

*(! # $ % # . ! # "

(* ! ;(!$ !. (

" " "! /"

( *(!

($ % . -( * 2$ , *0

(. # ! ! " *

! * # !

* # $ % !

* # (#- # ( . !$ . ( &$ "

" . # !. (. !.(

#" (# $+

"# $ $

% &#!

" "# "$ "

"# # '

# () $

* " # "

#! (#

" "(# + $" # *

( "# !

! "#* # "#* *"#

"(,

!""#

! "#* # () " $ $"

" "*

( - " . *(#

% &#!

"#*

#! (# !## $"

+ $ "$ #

"#!" $+

#! (# # ()+ $ "

!"#* (# ! "#* !"("# ! "#*+

", "(# + !# $"

()

# #

# "

(

!#!"#

! "#* // // //

! !) *

$ " !" "#* " # 2 !

"# !

"# * "#* *# #! (# $ "$ ' )

% &#!

"# 3) 42 !

$ # *

# "!

!# "

" 1 $ (" "# "#*

"# " # 2 !

) # " "#* " #! # !#!"#*

"# !

"# #

*# #! (# " )

5#(# 6)#

(

"( $

"$ "# 3) 42 !

)

% &#!

+ # "#! !# ! )

"# #

" . *(#

!"(

# "

#! (# +

* # "*" #

*#"#*

"! $ "# !

"# " )

5#(# 6)#

(

"( "("#

"* // // //

"*# "# # "

"!+

( " "# ! "("

( "! $

#!+

"! #

+ # # "

" "!+ $ "!

+ !# / #

# () "# #) (## # #) /! "# " ( )

5#(# "#

" * "#

,"# !

"# - +

!"(

*# #! (# "# !

"!+ $ "!

" "("

( "!+ " #

$" # ("# "# # " " .!

7# "$

# !! - . *(# # !

$ 1 9+ !! "#*) " :

;<=><=?>?@:

A:BCBD:EFBGHFBIJ:K:

L :

MGHNO:

L"#*,# Q R,S P

Q R,S