← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/6113/2011allowed

Bhim Sen Bansal And ORS v. State Of Punjab

2015-07-21Mr. Justice Rajiv Narain Raina18 pages

 

    

 !"!#$%$&'()*+,  



 

      ' -.

 /



 

    



     



    

   

!   " 

   ! # !  

$   



+ 1)

% #     &

'!     

   (

!

  ) 

 )  "  !



 

)  "  * #   "               %+ ,  -     %./.& 0 1'  

 & '  



 



)23 44546   %657 )  " & 

   ' #        !                        

)             ! ! )23 44546 )  " #          !

 "

#   

  !

  %8 *4895 

   %:   #    !

 )2  

8/%**884

"  

  5"   )  "       ! 5 5

 )2 !     ;   #   !

" "  5  ! %    *886   ;  !  

   <!

   3 %

"=    

9 3 #=

   %.>*    "

"    %*88 ; ! ;    )23 64

  %657 )  "  "   %> :8895  ?

"   

 ; =  

= @ !   !

  !    7

 "   /:   !

  !   

! != 

    



 

@

"

=  

=  @ ! A  7!       

!

!  

!

#

7

!

 ) =  

  !

     !     !

     <       

        

=

 !

"   !

 3

   @ 7  #  )2!

  ! !    ! ;   =  !

!

  

 )  "   !     "

  +/

)  "  #  !

        

"   )2  =     " : 

"!

;       

"  )2  ;  5  

!

!"   ! 

  !    "      + <

 5 

       

    " *886B 

    

"   C

<    "      

"; "  5 5  &)2'

"

 

" !    "

 

 "

3 % /      2               ! !        !            5    *     

  

)       

 !

 %8 *4895      !

    %:   #!

  

          )     

       

";    C <     #!

 " !   

"       "   !

9

"   )  "       

"   

! 

    

     "#

!    )2; !

       "    

   

   ; 

 

 ;      !



 5  / <   

     !

  C <  !"

!

   !

 "

 7

 



  !  !      !

   :  "    "

 " !

) 

 



  "   

    "    %> 

 *88.         

 "   !





   "  %.8:*8%% 4 #  

 "       !      " 

(

!  

  )  !

      ! !

"      & '           )   

!  !

;    6 <       

"

 " !

   > #                    ;; 



      "" "9      (

!  

      "  #

   

!

C <     )2 ; ! !

  " 5



    7

  

           (  

!        

! 

""  #

    

   "



=    

9 3 #=   

"    "

    )23 64   %657 )  "  ! 

"   %> :8895  !  

 "" 

  & '; 

    %8 *:895

#

         

    (  

  +/ )  "          ; 

!     (

!!    "  

#

   :    "

"

 )2;      

" 

= =   #       

   "  " 

(

!<         & '   .    

 )  "

      (

!  & '      

     ""        !

    

       (



!#

     !

9  

)  "      )2;   

 

   

 

   "   " !     "   & ' 



 !

9   -# )  "    

      

"

 

(

! %8 #    

 



       5    



    

            %%        

    

           !" 

 !

"    -#)  "        "



 "    $ E,= 2   52 

8+%%*88+

)  "     $  <   

  !   3   92   )2         "

    @<! 

    3   92 !     " 

    

9 ! " E 



9 = 

    

!5     



   

               

      

       

  

 

     

!        "#

$  %&'  ()'

  %

*%+++ !  ,#- ,#( 

  - 

*.++ ! 

 (

  */++ !  

  

  %

*.++ !  



 - 

*/++ ! 

 (

  *1++ !    

   

  

  3 #  4 0 '

          '     %* 2    



   ! !   3   92  !

  

 %+ < "   3   9 2  8+%%*88+ 

 

  

      "     

"        !

-# $         " = $ 

      "   

 

      



! $    "

    (                   

    

     ;   "   #

  

  

9    "     

 @         )   

  !"# $  % %&' $() $*  $*  + ,-(  % %) (.  $*/  0%  -,   (&  (.1

 1(. <  ! !

  "

  ; 

";     "



"  =      "          <!



  ;  

"  

    )       "    <!



     

  ) 

    ;  "  !

     =  

"         )             @    "  

 3   92    8+%%*88+          

2             

                  

  92     

!     "        !      " " "

 

  ! "

  

            #

  

3   92  8+%%*88+ 

     "     ) ;

     %/ 2     

! 0 10%- # 3)"3(&.1





1(. 2&! &1 4)% .< 

! 

 

!

 <!



 

  "             !

    "         <     ;





    

  5;   "     %: # 

       @ D =)   +,# 5 -(&1 "$()$1.(&.1 





1(.  / !       

!      

      -# )  "        

      5  

" "  !  

     # ,      -          &,=    )  " '  %.6/      ;   

  #  

 

 "         5  

" " ! 



!

"

   ;    @

     " ; 

        



 !  

   

   !  5                        ) 

    "

  %4 #  "  !      !

      (  

!  !

     

     

"    )2  3 44546      %657  )  "  !     

8/%**884       %.8/*886  ! 

  /F        #  

  "    

   

)2 "         

 ;   %6                            

 !! 

             "        

 

 

       " 

                E   

  

! 

 "    

      

;

          #    )2!     

 

,=% 8/%**884#

       "= 

   9 3 #=   

 )23 64   %657 )  "   "   

 %> :8895      %*88 ;  "

! ;    # 5    " %8 *4895              

 

)23 44546   %657

)  "    !      "

 

          !    "

    5        %+  #

    "  

      !        "                  

  < 

 

        =   

 "  

!     

 "! "           



      

 

 

        <    

 " !

 



"    !    "    & ';   #     

  

   

 

 !    

  5 #

       :    "

" )2 !

  ! ! =  

= @



  !   @ D =)  6 $.),11% % .- 7.&#  +-"* *%""





 1(. < 

!

"

  01  !  =    01      !

    <!



   "

 

  



 #      



"   %> #  " !  !

) 

!!

   "         )2;  <   (

!! !  

  ;     

 !

        

"

   #       (  

!  ! 

    !     "     ! 



"   "   C <  "   

    !

       

" 

C <    

"

!     

 )3 */+*65*>

*8%% "

 

    

  =5%&

'( 5( *88658>    =  

   *88>58.

*88.5%8  *8%85%%  2 



    

" 

$

 "

" 

)23 44546   5%6

)  " #  

   

 

5  #   = !    

  $

 "

"!

C < 

  G     )2  3 44546      %6  )  "    #  

    

               ;

  

    &

'     

        )2 ; "

          

!

             

   7

  

   #   

   

  )         &

' ) 2

                    

   

   "    

!

       ) 

 " 

    

      

)  



!  ! 

    " ) 

    

  !  %. # (

!       

   =  3 %   

     5        "    =     

 

= 

  ! !



 "

"        

 

       ;  <    (       ?5% 

     

5=                           3 * /  "  = 

= <           3 * / !  

!

    3 +

" 3 %

=   

 

            ;        



= 

 

   %.>*!   

"

 

)23 64   %657 )  "    9 3  #=    =   3 %

=

  

;  =  

!   

"<  

  

     

  

      =  



 

 # 3 %

"  "

 "    " =  



       3 * /   "  = 

= 

     

 " 

" 



 



   

;    

, 

    !

!   =  

    

!  "

"    

  =   

     

 

 

 ;   =   5   "      " ";

 

  =   

 "  

 *8 #    

                    *8%+ "    

"

""    

,   

   ! "

 



@  =5 /            #< <

       !  =            "    

,    

"  H*8%+2

                



< "          5     

   



"   

,   

 

;

 

         #

   

   

 

  "  ;    "!   

) #  



 

=5/

               "

      #

  "   "!   

 

    "   ) 

   %*

  "

   

 

    #  

 " " 

 

  *   <    "     #      !

    *886  !

 =5/   "  *8%+ "      

 

  

 "  ; 



  



        *% #    

                           (

!      

        

  

!

    <  ) 

!  

"

      

!

         ! =  " 

      ;    <     )2 

      3  

8+%%*88+ -#)  "  $  < 

        "  

  (

!       #     "      )2            #

    

  

 "= 

  

   

           )2  3 64      %657

)  " !   "  

     "  & '   

   ;  # (



! 

    

 =  3 %   "  = 

= ! 

! "

   !;"

=            

  

      =  " 

 #

  !  

   "  !   

"     <      !!     )2;  

    "   

 



 

   

 ; 

    !          ** #  

           

"  

 





 

    !    <

 

    

  ;  

! 9!       

"  <          !

!

@ D =)     -5

# 8 ' (&1 / 2  1(. #

       

  ) 

! 0(# 0(9($()/2



1(. < !

!   G    )  "      #     

    !

    G   <!



  !     !  !    

    " 

 

 

 



 

  ; 

 

  !

  @    

!

         *+ < "  

    

 <"  !

 "

(



!   ,         " 

 

  

  #     

  

  9

! 

*F   

   )   

!      

"  !       "     

      



()*+,      5