← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5864/2016allowed

M/S Hmm Infra Ltd. v. M/S Chaudhary Engineering & Fabrication

2018-05-14Mr. Justice Sudhir Mittal9 pages



      

 !"!#$   %&"%%#'

( ) 

!

!#'

*"

%&"+ ,)+ '-#.!#'!#./

0'!

!# "1#)#

%$

   



       

 



 

 !

   #$ %# &  * *

+'" ,'( "

(



%!

-)+( 

 - "   -

'"  +' "   .

"( /  + 0

/ 1 #%%##$  

,   "' , + 

" +"( +  -)+( 0

 , 2 3 %4#-.

5('" +  2 1#6%4#-.7

2 %####-.

, / + 2 116%4#-.

, ,   0 ,  

+  -  2 $1####-.

 "  -"  + -  

   -    + 2 % %###-.

 # #3 %##3 +

+ + 2 3 %4#-.

(

 " ( 

-  (  + "

 $9  + +   ""

"

"

: + 6!



-   = %  .

 





           

           !      

"  !

 

#     

    



 

     !  

           

 !      !   

"  $    

"   





        



          

    %      



  

    

 !

         

& '  ()( *    

 

  "                  

     





# 



  

       "  + 1!

  4!

* *

+'"  %# #< %# 4   = 4 &   .

, 

       

   



   

!

 

  

"    

#    

 

 #!

  

  -./



, !   $  '  ( 0.'

1   2

!

         

 

 0  $  '3 4

          1  

            



!      

# 



    

 



 #

     

# 



 

         56

#

 !     

 



           6  #    

  1    2   



!



         

#!  





     "    0

#         

    + &!

"

 ," , 

"",

  '  +

    + +    

  +    +

<!

% #1 %# &   ," ,  >   +   " "

+ "",    %1 #4 %# &  0+   >

,""

+

   ,  '

(    " "

  ' 

     %1 #4 %# &  

$!

"

 % #1 %# &

 +   ,( ," 

   

"

(

    

 

+ "

(



+ 

3!

+(   

+  #$ %# &  * *

+'"  "

(

'

  #!

? "

  

   " +

+

 %# #< %# 4 + "(

+

/

 +   / +

+(

 

    , 

 + /   + +

/  

  "( 0 

 !

? "

"

  # #3 %# 4 

)2 = 4$&& %# 6 " @  A @+ @      

""

('" 

   

@ 

 

 (+   ", "(

    .(+ / @ ," '"

 0   )  '

+ 0  ,

  2  +

    

 

 !  "#     $!#

%%!&'()*

 !#+,-.(+* (/'*010

 %!

+( '

 + ',

 "

 ' ,"

    '" 

 



 +( +"



 6!

? "

 "

  2!32 

 !#  "#  " 3&    

 !#    +,,4 '5-64 

+ ""

+ "(

  "

+"

 / +  

@'

2" 5 7 5%7 @'

5%7 /  +"

 &  / + 

     

   +

" '  +"

 / + & ""

+ "(

 

   +

" ,"  " 

 1!

;   " "

 '+ 

))  ( , +

"( '

/(  "(  +"( +(    

"(  +  '"

( 



 " "

'+  "     

  "(

=

   +



+

+ @   ,

   "  %# #< %# 4  4!

? "

 !  /!!"#

 "'-17- (*-+11 $ 8' #3"# 

!%  

 

 !  +,-,(-*   (/'*  -+1 

"

(

', ; 

 )

   

"

'  ? "

 '+    



"(

 

@  +

 +

B + +



+  +





 " C 

))

"  '     "



 = 6 +( 

 

+ ' " +"(    :



 ' +

  +

 &!

  " ,

2! $!#5# (#!* ," "(

    " ,

!

 /!!#5# (#!* $ 8' #3#5# (#!*  

 

+ / 

 +  +

 " +

C  

+  '  



 0



 <!

  "

' + ,

+  #$ %# &  * *

+'"       

 

  +

 '(

 $!

E    '  

"", D+  #$ %# &  * *

+'"

  =+"

/ "",

( 1 %# $ % 34 )

 

 >  - F-= > '" F-=