High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-CW/18/2023dismissed

Dharam Pal And Others v. State Of Haryana And Others

2023-01-31Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur9 pages

#$ % % % & $ %&'#(' # ) * & +' #

* , '#( ' &"

, '-' &) & '#(' " ' #. / &#'#(' &""% 0 ( $$$$ % & 1 %2 ""% '& + 3 #3 & ""%

4 5 +"%## " ) " & 3 " 6#

7 & "

) 5 )" ## & ""% ( 3& + # "

# 5## % ( # # 8%9::

&& ""

&#& % ## 3

# ""% 1:$9.$:;$ 2&#4

## <) ## & &#%%3#&"

/ (

& 5

* 5&&)3%#44 #4)&# 1: ( %2 =88$ =89. %#

' " 5 4 & "

+ :

<-: # # &""% 0 ( 5 &&

## 9> 3& & + 4

# 5 5 ?

( + %%)<*3 #

- %: 1<-:2

" 53& & 3 ) +* 5 ) & "" + #'

& '& & '3&&#

#&"" + 4 #( 3 & * 5&&)3%#44 #4)&#

&+ 1 "

2' "%) 5 #" & : & ' & ) )"" + 4 5+#4) 5 ( 5 )4 "

% *&"

3&&(% +#& 4 & # '& ##

4% #'& ' ( 3& 5&:

%""

5 4&% & ( 3%#*& & 5& ( %&

:; " 54 & ( &

& 5' 3%#4""

3 3& & &(%#&"

5& 5&4 ( 3# 8 & '( # ##9> '&# %%3#? ( '()(*+',--.,'/0,1231 () +) 3)31,-

, # # 1<-: & 2&"

& ( %#& ? ( #3

% & 5 ) * 5"" + & # 5

#( + .'##. : "

'3&3 55 (#5

? ( ' %%3#'

$ $ ""

&#& ( & ( 3 "

'3& &%#& "

& ##99"

#4)& ( && :;@=8. #&

# '# 5&& +"5 4 5 ( &

%( " & "

$ A

$ %

& ' (' & )

& ) * A + )

& &

' '$ ,

& -

' , )

)

' , #

$ .& $ %

) ' '

/ 0 $1 2

) &

& ' (' & $ 3

' +

) '

$ $$ 4$ & &

' &

$8$ & & 3

#4)& ( & @@@

:;=88@'3& & #

$ A6 $ 7$

+ 5$ 5$!$+

+ )

$ $8$ 4

)

4 4 4$ 5

$1 & %%3 5 3

&4 &:;@9@@

.> $ A0

+ & &

$$ 8$ 3 4$4$ 4 &

6$ 9::

& ;

$ %

&& <

$ & &

' &

$1 :;=88@'& 3 &%% 5 ##@@@ 4)3) @@ #& +4# +

>@3& 4)& + )3 +# = & / ' 3%#% 4""

" &&

( #

# =.&#+# + %

(

5 "" + <-: # # 3& &

3 &%% 5#4 & 5&: -/ #& #

$=$

3 # & &%% 5#&

& -/ 5&: 3& &+4 5 # 1: ( %2 =88$ =89. %#

' 3& & C %) &( 4

5 # : ( %""%>=8.0>=.>.& 3 & &3

#4)& ( && 5& 3& %"

##99

+ %

3 % #)" 54 &

+: 5 5&(% # )& %%3 5 (

<-: # # 4) & -/ ' & # #

+%)' = :;9.9>'3&3 55 (#&

#4)& '""

&#& "

" 5 & 5&: & "

+: 4& #% 53 &&+ % #)" 5 1 "

2 & #

" 3 %%3# 9 # #4 & #3 &: ( %""%>=8.0>=.>. %#

. 3 ( 54*&"

# & 5&: ' & + +' +4"

# @=@ :;@=8 . %#

3& ##99

:;@=8.3

+# # *' ##99&#"%# +4 5 ) "" + 4 5 +#

5 & & + %

0 &#4 *#3 4)& #& + 3" 5 & "

+: #4)&+# ##

$.$ @=@'& 3 " + #+"%& % "

#& "" + "

& #( + 3& & "

&# 4

5& 993 & # & %% & +4 ' 3& / #' 3%#

* 5&&)3%#44 #4)&+&# & + " 54 & "

##@=@'

+ 4

# 4) & .@ 5 %%

# #" + +"% & % "" + "

"%% 3& 4) % "

993 & " # 4 %## &

"" + % & +4 3%#44 #4)&+& "

# " 54 & "

+: &""% %#4)&

+ %

9 & # " #:; 94)* 5 &

#4)& ( & @=@'& C

#4)& %'3& &' +#'&(

4 &%% 5# #&

& "

+: #4) &:

%< &

!"!!

##$%#&'("&

4 & #:

%< &3 # + &(% # )

#+ #+ &:

B # 3& & + 8> 3& 4) % = # . & :

B # &#4 + ##4)## 53 3% :% . %=3 &6"% #:% . %.3& 4)

$9$ & & 4 +"3

( # +6 ++?

( & + %%);*

2 D

& & &#%# 1 :

2' &#%# 4 1 2 # $:

+) ) & & <*3 # :%

& + 3 %##

" 5 "&

#& ( #&+ #+ 3 "&%#B&

4 &%#&&'

) ,

> & &

& ' +

5 9?:@+ 9?9@

A?:@ 3

&/#5+

) * + %%+

%# 5&"

# ) * + #

" ,) * +3 #4* " %# " %'4 ( #4) #/#5+ '

& &#4 *" 4) " 5# &:

%< &&

5&+

4) ## @> # @ @ & 5' %

% ""

5 4&% &

( 3%# 4+ & #'( &5&& /#5+

#4)&:

%< &

) * + "&%# & (% # ) & + #+ +# % = # . & :

B # " + 5 (

' &

&%% 5 &

#4)& ##

$@$ 9> &

#4)& &() 4 3 &# #'& ' ( 35&4%%3#& 5+

"4%& "

+ %) & &( & 5&&

: 3 +#3 &&& 3 "

" 5'

&3( '& "

+ %)"

#4)& (

< &##@=@3& 4)& &#4 %%3#+"%&

% "

3& &&#4 #"

##99 #&

C %)

# .@3& &

&%% 5& % "

# &"

3 " 3

# ."

&#( +

#%%

% # " 4)

% & ( "

& +# ## @=@& + 5 ( 4)&#(- %'

.=>3 %) % + #" #:

C %)'& #%%3& ( C ( 3 > ( 3""% % 53 &&& + ""%

%# 4)& ( +"%#+ ' ) ### %( # +

! & ""% +# ## &# 4 #/

# " ( ""%

& ( 3) &"

'&""%

" # + #* " &

5#) %

$>$ &

5& & ## 4 % % # "" # +&& #'&""%

%%3#& +# # "

)# 5% & 6

/( ;&& "* # ! 0 ;&& " 4%

! 0