High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5487/2018dismissed

General Manager Ntpc Apcpl Jharli v. Surajbhan And ORS

2026-04-07Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja5 pages

: '

: +%#'& +%#'& +%#'& +%#'& ;4'&3; <

;4'&3; <

;4'&3; < #/**'$ #/**'$ #/**'$ #/**'$34 3 3

#%*%*'$#"

#)'$-#$%

"##$% "

&'" "

! ! ! !

*A+

*$8(,-.'/+%# %(#)#%*%*'$#"

(+(+",-.'/+%# %(#"#)'$-#$%

0(*$+.!+1*+, ,+"2+$ $+ BBBB , "+1

, "+1

, "+1 '

34 '

345 '&33 '&33 '&33 '&33

"+ +2#" 9+-# *$ %(* +))1*/+%*'$ * &'" "#/+11*$8 '& %(# '"-#" -+ +%#- 4 3 33)+ #-02%(*'6"% '% %*/#'&%(#+))1*/+%*'$7+*6# #-%'%(#$'$5+))1*/+$%D"#)'$-# #$% '$ 33

.*$8 (#+"- 1#+"$#- /'6$#1 &'

" %(# )+"%*# +$- &'" %(# "#+ '$ 9#$%*'$#-*$%( (#+))1*/+%*'$,%(#+9#*+11'7 7#- "-#"-+%#-4 3 33)+ #- 02%(*'6"%* (#"#02"#/+11#- 3; <

3; <

3; < '

:;4'& '

:;4'& => 2 7+2'&)"##$%)#%*%*'$,/(+11#$ $8#(+0##$1+*-%'%(#'"-#"-+ +%#- 3?

3;)+ #-02%(#1#+"$#---*%*'$+1* %"*/%6-8#,(+@@+"5/695E#/6% %*$8 '6"%,7(#"#02 %(#'0@#/%*'$)"#&#""#-+%%(#* *$%+$/#'&)#%*%*'$#",'))'*$8 )"+2#"9+-#02 %(#"#)'$-#$%51+$-'7$#"+0 0'6%"#1#+#'&#$(+$/#-+9'6$% %'&

/'9)#$+%*'$*$ $%(#*"&+.'6"*$%#"9'&-#/**'

'$-+%#-3 3C)+#-02% %(* '6"%*$

3'&3,%+$--#/1*$#-

=> ' 0# )"#/*#, "#)'$-#$% '

, 7(' 7+ +""+2#- + )"'&'"

"9+ "#)'$-#$%*$

3'&3-#/*-#-02 2%(*'6"%'$3 3C,)"+2 2#- &'""#1#+#'&#$ $(+$/#-+9'6$%'&/'9)#$+%*'

'$++##-02%(*'6"%*$ +&'"#9#$%*'$#- +))#+1F G,33,33D5)#"+/ /"#0#*-#'%(#"%+%6%'"20#$# #&*% +$-*$%#"#%027 7+2'&&*1*$8#E#/6%*'$)#%*%*'$0 0#&'"#%(#1#+"$#-E#/6%*$8'6 6"% =?> (# # '0@#/%*'$ "+*#- '$ 0#(+1& '& %(# )#%*%*'$#" 7+ %(+% * $/# "#)'$-#$% '

7+ $'% %(# +))#11+$% *$ %(# # +0'.# 9#$%*'$#-

+$- 7 7+ +""+2#-'$12+ +)"'&'"9+"#)'$-#$%,+6/(, (#'"(* 7#"#$'%#$%*%1#- &'" "#1#+#'&%(#/'

'9)#$+%*'$+"#5+##-+$-# #$(+$/#-02%(*'6"% => (# #1#+"$#-E#/6%*$8'6"%.*-# *9)68$#-'"-#"-+%#-3?

3 3;, "#@#/%#-%(#'0@# #/%*'$)"#&#""#-+%%(#*$%+$/# '&%(#)#%*%*'$#"7(*1#('1-*$8% %(+% -#)*%#"#)'$-# #$%'

0#*$8+)"'&'"9+"#)'

'$-#$%*$

3'&3, ,(# 7+#$%*%1#-&'"

""#1#+#'&0#$#&*%'&#$(+$/#- -/'9)#$+%*'$++##-02% %(* '6"%.*-#*%-# #/**'$-+%#-3 3C #$/# #%(#)"##$%"#.**'$)#%*%*'$ =:> ( (+.# 1#+"$#- /'6$#1 &'" %(# )+ +"%*# +$- 8'$# %("'68( %(# )+ +)#" 0''A =C> ' -'60%, "#)'$-#$% '

(#"#* *$+0'.# 7+ +""+2#- + )"'&'"

"9+ "#)'$-#$%'

*$%(#9#9''&)+"%*#&*1#-*$

3'&3H('7#.# #",+ )#"6+1 '& %(# +-@6-*/+%*'$ 9+-# 02 %(* '6"%, /1#+"12 ('7 %(+% +11 1+$-'7$#" *$ %(# +*- +))#+1 7#"# (#1- #$%*%1#- %' "#/#*.# %(# #$(+$ /#- /'9)#$+%*'$F F G,33,33D5)#"+/"# (# "#1#.+$%)'"%*'$&"'9%(#-#/* *'$ -+%#- 3 3 C 9+-# 02 %(* '6"% *$

3 '& 3 * #E%"+/ /%#- (#"#6$-#"5

K'$*-#"*$8%(#)#/61*+"&+/% +$-/*"/69%+$/#'&%(#/+#$'

'%#- +0'

'.#, /'6)1#- 7*%( %(# "#+'$ +& +&'"#9#$%*'$#-, %(* '6"% * '& & %(# /'$ $*-#"#-.*#7%(+%%7'+))#+1&*1# 1#-02%(#0#$#&*/*+"2-#)+"%9#$%, * # "+ +.+1* '7#" '9)+$2 "*.+%# *9*%#- (+.# 0##$ &'6$- 7('

('112 9* /'$/#*.#-,0#"#&%'&9#"*%+$-7*% *%('6%+$260%+$/#,%(6,%(##%( (## 96 6% &+*1 +$- %(# +9# +"# (#"#02 2 -*9*#- (# +))#+1 +$- /"

"' '0@# @#/%*'$&*1#-02%(# 1+$-'7$#"- -##".# %'0#)+"%12+//#)%#-+$- - %(# +9 9#+"#(#"#02+11'7#-%'%(##E%#$% $%*$-*/+%#-+0'.# (#1+$-'7$#"

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

"#)'$-#$% (6,"#)'$-#$% '

-#)*%#0#*$8+"

""+2#-+)"'&'"9+"#)'$-#$%*$ $

3'&3*#$%*% %1#- &'""#1#+#'&/'

'9)#$+%*'$+%%(#+9#"+%#++ +7+"-#-%'%(#+))#11+$%%(#"#*$ $ =;> .# #$ *$ %#"9 '& "-#" 61# '& %(# '-# '& *.*1 "'/#-6 6"#, G3;, '$/# + ) +"%2 * *9)1#+-#- + + )"'&'"9 9+ "#)'$-#$% *$ %(# #861+"

*"% ))#+1, %(# -#/ /**'$ )+#- %(#"#*$ 7*%( "#) #/% %' %(# #$(+$/#- /'9)#$+% %*'$ #$6"#%'(*0# #$#&*%+7#11 6/(,"#)'$- #$%'

"*8(%12&*1#-%(##E#/6% %*'$ +))1*/+%*'$

#&#"#$/#*$%(*"#8+"-9+20#9 9+-#%'%(#'"-#"-+%#-3 3 3 )+#-02%(* '6"%*$

;?'&37 7(#"#*$*%7+(#1-%(+%'$/#+@'

'*$% -#/"##*)+#- -,%(#0#$#&*%%(#"#'&#E%#$-%'+ +11/'5(+"#",#.#$*&'9#'&%( (#9 7#"# *9)1#+-#- - + )"'&'"9+ "#)'$-#$% (# # "#1#.+$% )+"% '& %(# +*- '"-#"

" * #E%"+/%#-(#"#*$ $+&%#"5

L( +1#1*$8(,( 60(+(, (,( +9#(!69+"+$-(*@#$ $-#" *$8 $8(7('+"#%(#'$'&( +1( (+$-7#"#@'*$%'7$#"'&%(#)"')# )#"%2 7(* (*/(7++/I6*"#-02%(#%+%#'& +"2+$+ 11%(#0"'%(#"$'%#-+0 0'.# &*1# #- + @'*$% +))1*/+%*'$ %' %(# '11 1#/%'" 6$-#" #/%*'$ ; '& %(# +$- /I I6**%*'$/%,;G,7*%(+"#I6# %%'"#&#"%(#9+%%#"%'%(#'6"% $ 0#*$ $8 "#&#""#-, %(# #&#"#$/# '6"% "% .*-# +# '

G?4 '& 3 33, -#/ /*-#- '$ ?3 3 3:, )+#- + /'

'99'$ @6-89#$% -#/*-*$8 %(# @'

@'*$% /1+* *9'&+11%(#0"'%(#"( 60(+(, (,( +9#(!69+"+$-( *@#$ $-#" *$8 $8(&*1#-+$+))#+17(*1#( +1# #1*$8(+))#11+$% 7+*9)1#+-#- -+ )"'

'&'"9+ "#)'$-#$% + (# 7+ $'% '% +.+*1+01# &'" *8$*$8 %(# "#I6* 6*"#- -'/ /69#$% (#+))#+1&*1#-02%(#+ +&'"#+*-%("##0"'%(#"7++11'7 7#- (* *+))#+1(+0##$&*1#-02( +1# 1#1*$8(/1+*9*$8%(#+9#+9'6$ $%'& /'9 9)#$+%*'$ $ &+/%, %(# /+# '& % %(# +))#11+$% +1"#+-2 %+$- -#/* *-#- +1'$ $87*%((*"#9+*$*$8%("##0"'%(#"

#" $/#+@'*$%"#&#"#$/#)#%*%*'$7 7+ &*1# #-02+11%(#&'6"0"'%(#",7(*/(7 7+-#/*-#-02%(# #&#"#$/#'6"% "%02 +/'

'99'$@6-89#$%,%(#$,%(#+))#+1 +1,#.#$*&&*1#-02'$12%("##0"'%( (#", (+ +11 #$6"# %' %(# 0#$#&*% '& %(# +)) ))#11+$% (#"# 7+ + @'*$% -#/"## # *$ &+.'

.'6"'&&'6"0"'%(#" %*$'%%(#/ /+#'&%(#+))#11+$%%(+%7(*1#&*1 *1*$8 +))#+1 02 (* 0"'%(#", %(# "*8( (% '& +))#11+$% 7#"# "#1*$I6*(#- - '" 6""

""#$-#"#- $6/(+*%6+%*'$,*$%#"

#"9'& "-#"M 61#'&%(# '-# '& *.*1 "'/#-6"#,G3;,%(#+))#11+$ $%(+110#-##9#-%'0##$%*%1#-%' ' %(# +9 9# +9'6$% + )+2+01# %' %(# "# #9+*$*$8 %("## 0"'%(#" *$ %#"9 '& @6-8 -89#$% )+#- *$ #861+" *"% ) ))#+1 '

:; '& 3C, %*%1#- + L LD +%A %A+"%+ #+1%'"

%- %+%#'& &+"2+$++$-'%(#"L =G> %9 9+2+1'0#$'%#-%(+%%(#"#5+ #9#$%9+-#02%(*'6"%.

.*-# -#/**'$-+%#-3 3 3C7+60#I6#$%129'

'-*&*#-02%(#'$N01#)#E'

'6"% %' : 1+A( )#" +/"#, +$- "#)'$-#$% '

(+ +-9*%%#-12 0##$ "#1#+ +#- /'9)#$+%*'$ + +% %(# +*- "+%# &'" (* +/I6*"#- - 1+$- '"#'.#", *% * ##$%*+1 1 %' #$6"#%(#0#$#& &*%'&*9*1+"9+"A#%.+16#%'"# )'$-#$%'

++##-*$&+.

.'6" '&%(#+))#11+$% *$

3'&3'+ %'6)('1-%(#)"*$/*)1#'&@6%+ +$- &+*"/'9)#$+%*'

'$*$&+.'6"'&%(#1+$-'7$#"+8 8+*$%%(#*"+/I6*"#-1+$-

=3> $ 6/( /*"/69%+$/#, %(#"# 0#*$8 8 $' *11#8+1*%2 '" )#".#"*%2 *$ &*$-*$8"#/'"-# #-02%(#1#+"$#-E#/6%*$8'

6"%,$'*$%#"&#"#$/#*/+11#-&'"

"*$ %(# *9)68$#- '

'"-#"

//'"-*$812, %(# )"##$ $% )#%*%*'$ %+$- -*9*#- 0# #*$8 -#.'*-'&9#"*% =>

#$ $-*$8+))1*/+%*'$ ,*&+$2(+11 +1'%+$--*)'#-'& ! ! ! ! )"*1 )"*1 )"*1 )"*134 34,3 ,3 ,3 ,3C %*A

(

( (#%(#")#+A*$8D"#+'$#- # (#%(#""#)'"%+01# # D'