High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5905/2016allowed

Satyanarain Bhagwan Trust Rewari Th Bhagwan Dass Bindawala v. Hira Singh & ANR

2025-05-27Mr. Justice Vikram Aggarwal11 pages

! " #$%& ' (&" ) " " *+ ," " %$-"#$%& $%$-"#$%& ).

! " #$%& ' (&" ) " " *+ /" $0 $ ). 1%2!

" 4(1 (5 $. " "

/! " 4(1 (5 $. 666 #!&!5 $" /%0 (7.. " $5 " 4"" . " " '$%$(2 $"" . " " " 5. /%0 ( $ .. " . 5 $ 0 8$0$4 " " 4" "4 '$5 $44."0"4!2"50

$%$ $ 4 "4 % $ $

$44425

! " #$%& ' ( &" " " % 8$0$4( &$"$"" "4&!(&"

7 "$%2"4" %$" %0 5 $&$&"$ !" $8$0$4 $. $0" '$ . ". 4 & $. " $. 9

$.9

$" 5 5 $ :0" .0"; '$ . 2 " . " 5 $ 0" .0" " 4 % 5

+ .

0 $ '$ . " " 4 4 "

$ ' " " . " "

" 5 $,! <2 45 =" " 1 ( $" 5 5 $ : 1 ; 5 " " 5 $ . 50 $0".0" $544&" %% " .!0 5 > "" $0".0"$" %20 5 5" 5 $0 $2" " > """ . 4 2 5" ( $ . & $ 00 " " $8$0$4&544" %$ 54%" 54&5. %+ 44&$&"$ !" $ 8$0$4 '$ . " " 4 4( $5 & 04"$ $ $. $0 " 00 " 5 44 '$ " " . " " & .. '$ 4 " $". 5 4 4 4 $ 5 &0" 7 & " $ $.

&" 5 7 &4 " $ $ 0".0"$20 5 5" 5$0 $2" " 7 & 5 $ " $ $0".0"&?"5. 4 '$ @ & $ $& $?"0 " !( $ $$.$ 2 % $ $0".0"& 2" %% 4!&" $"& " $ 7 $ " " .

"( $ 544&" %"&50

" #

7 $ $" " . " " 5&$"$

"( $544&" %"&50

" # "4 $" . " " = "44!( $ . " " 4 4 B0" $ 44 00"" &$ $ 2 .." 2! $ (2"4" %B. ( $"C. "5 $ .4 5 $ &" '$ . 4 B0" B. 4 % &" $ 5& $ &" 7 $ " " . " " %" ," " %$

( $ 44(&""0" $" " . " " $ ..4 & 4 "0" 7 $ " " . " " %" /"

$0 $

( $ 44(&"44& $ " " . " " 2 $ " & " ..4 '$1..44 1 $" !( $5( @ $ 0 "& " 2 $ " $ . " " 4 4 D 45 $. "&$ 7 & 4! % 2! 4 4 . " % $ . " " 4 4 $ $ $ " "0"" % $ " " . " " 7 & % $ $ % 5 $ 0" .0" $" % 20 5 5" 5$0 $2" " . 4 &4!.2 $ $" " @ "& D 4 20" $ $$2 0.4 0"" %5" 4 $

A 5 $ D 4 5 $ 4 0 ! " 20" $ $" " . " " 244&

( 4 4 . " % $ . 20" $ $" "44%4" ! " $ "" 2! $ D 420" $ " $2 . $ $0" .0"&" 24 " " $ 20 5 5" 5 $0 $2" " 7 &20" $ % $ % 5. 4 ( % " &. . $ $5 544" $8$0$4$" 7 &% $ 5 $.( 4!A $.&%$ 2% (&$"$" 450@" 2 4 $ $ & 4 04! 2! % " % A $. ( $' &4 2" ." " " " 00 " 7 &20" $ " ( $5( . $ " & $ 4 2 & 4!

$0&"$"5 $. " " 4 4 % $0" .0" 7$%" 0! $%$ 54 " " $"" $ 7 $4. $.4" % $4 0 !

'$" " "5 $5 $ " "" 4/"" " ( 4 $ 0 $ 4" $ $ 5" " % 2! $ 44 $ 1..44 1 $" ! .( % 44!( " 5 "445 ,&($" %B0" $0 " "4( $" "5 $ "." " $ $$2 0.4 0"" % 0".." " 5 $" (4 $4& $2/

7 " 4 4& $ 4 4 " $ 2 /% 5 $" ?"0 " " 0 " " $ 4 4 7 $5 % &'

(

)

! "#$!%& !( $ .0 57 " " $"." ".4 F $(" $5* +, % &*-

% ! "#$'( ")*+$",%- .!(" # $5 $" (&$"44!" %. $/%0 5 $ .0 57 "" $ 5 % .($4 $ 4 4.4. 4 $&" 2B" .. 5$"+$( $4 4 2"24" 4 $ .42! $4 442 5 ( 245 "54 4 $&0 "4 $& $ $ & % " 7 $ 5 % /

& (0

/ ! "#$!0 &( $ .0 57 "" $ "." ".4> 1 2 % '

(

) $ 33345 ) 4 5 ! 4.)5 -

2 / .

$ 3345 ) 4 54.)5 -

4.5 7&% $18945 ) 4 5!83:11"4!5.)) !

- * 0 )

- 76 )

;

< -3

( 3

7 $ 6 )

;

)

;

6 ) $

6 - $

, $339 =

;

7 -

# 7 $5;.> &(+ .

(

% ! "#$ '( ")*+$"+12( $ .0 57 "$4 12 , 2- ) ? $41885 ) .)) $(@ & + $ * 4 6 A

-5 +

< *>

$ B.

0 $

0 B$ B

0 B $

$ B 0 - B >

C $ $

A D

$ -

- $

$ $

B 0 B

B B 2

$ $ 2

- - 3 2 / @

@ & ? $ 1145 ) !

4.)5$

>> ;;% $41915 .)) 9 $ - - B

0 B

- 7

- +

"0"44!( " $ 5 @ *- .

&E ; + %

2 0! 3435!201 .!(" &$42! " # $5 $"

+ . ; +%

$33145 ) 89

0 -

7 - = 0 7 +

F<<

F 0

- ;

% 6 .

$ 3384 5 ) 4)

5 1$ G

7 $

# 7 $ 5 % % & ..

% (

- ! "#$!%1(" &$42!" # $5 $" $ $ 5 $50"4!& 2 0" 2! $4 4 2! $ 7 $5; = ,&.>

% %! 3435!&2(" &$42!" # $5 $" $ &$ & /!" % $5" 5$".. !54 % "0 $ %" 2 "44! 2! &@" % $( $ $4 " " 4 $" 4 450 /!" % $5" 5 $.. !(."44!&$ " ". $ $ 5 $4 4"2 5"

7 " 4 &44 4 $ $ $4 2 % " $4 20&"$" 1% $" 5 $2"4" %$" %20 5 5" 5$0 $2" " ( $ 2 " /@ 504 " 4" $ 5442@. $. 5B. $ $" 4 $ 5 $ " $ 4" &$ $2"4" % 2" $20 5 5" 5$0 $2" "

" % $5 5 $( $"5 .!0 5 $ 20 " $ 0 $ 2 = $&"( $""$ 2 @.25 $"

0" % $ " 5 $ 0" .0" $" % 20 5 5" 5 $0 $2" " ( $ 5" 50 5 &$"$ " ?" 2 @ 5" $ (." 2! $" .4 =B 1G + ( $0".0" " %4. 5 $8$0$4 '$$. $0" $"2@" $8$0$4 '$0B. & B0" " 2 $ F $ . " " 4 4( $ 9 0 9%.4 .. 1GA 20" $" . =B 1GA+

, 4 . 025.$ %.$(&$"$$& $"4." " " 5 $0".0" $ 9 09%.4 .." $&" 2B 1GA , " ""4 = %" & %" &" $ ,<81 5 ."" ( "0 " "% & $" % ! 5 B." ,&4% 0 ..4 ,". 7

!3 , $ -

7 + -

- '

- +

- ; $ -

H6$ -

IJ;7;72@.' (>%.

5, $

- , H6$

$ - $ -

-$ -

+ -

- - $-

$ -

+ 4,

IJ;7;72@.' (>%.

E7 $ -

- - $- +- (

$ -

- 7

(

IJ;7;72@.' (>%.

- 1B7

- $

+- $

-$-

- +

# '$2 " 4" & >.H &;72@.7

$- 7-

7- H6 $ -

- E ( + - -

; $

+ 7

7 -

$ -

- . E

;

- )@)AJ.2@

$ 2

E $

- - #

,&B0" (&$" $&" $ $"% 1. 50 $5"&" (1G $ /! 4"@(1 (&$$2 .." 4400"" (20" $". (&$" $ $

$545 $0".0"&2 H5 24& $"4&! , " $ $ 4 " " 5 $0" .0" $" &! 2 42!.4" %40"$+& 2 ,( $5(& $5" 54 5 $0 2"4." ,45 $%$ $%$ @ &44 $4 " $ 5 1 02 5 .$ %.$&4.(&$"$$& $"4." " " 5 $0".0"

$ $$ ( $B. 2! $. & $

.4( &$ .. G '$%$( " $" B0" " " $"5( $ . $ $& = %" " %I 5077'(84$"(" $ B0" " ($0" $ $& $ "4= %" $ $" $ !".40 "5" 51$" ,(B. (" $" . 20" $ $0".0"&" 24 " " 7 " &44 @ & $ B. %" . " 5 5 $" & 4" ,&( " " $ 5 $ &"%$ $ 0 " 4" &$"$ . " % " $ 5 7 $ "." " 5 $" ( $ " B0" $""50 $ .. " 9 2 ( $ 0 % 5 2"4" % ." " " " 7 !

( $2"4" % $ "0&0 $ !4 #"@&" 4"00 (&$"$" 45$& $4 $ "? $" % 2 '$ & $%$ $%$ @ " $ 5 %." % $4 7 & $ %" ." " 5 $ B. $ $ 2"4" % 4544 ! "0 '$" "( $5(" 4" . $. %" 2! $ 9 09%.41GA 7 "( $5($4 $ $0" .

0" % $% 5. 4 " !(" &4! .2! $&" $ $5 544$" '$ @

"& $ " % $0$2 . 7 $ 2 2 " 0" $ " "8$0$4" $"4&! 9 ! $5 $ $!( $5 5440 $" '$ " 5&$." 0 2" 20&"$ 7 & $ 5 $ . " " 4 4 $ $! &4 % 44 $. (&$"$ $&"&4 2."24 '$!$ 0&$ '$!4 2B. &" 544 5 $2"4" % 44. 75 B0" $0 " " 4" !(" 54!2 4 $ $0".0"&?"2! $. " " 4 45" . 4

7 $&@5 $2( $" " $ 4" $ $"0.% " 24

'$ 2" % ( $ "" . " " 44& '$ .2! $1..44 1 $" ! " $" " . " " 44& '$. % &0 $ "0 $ $ ." 5 $0".0" $. " " 4 4 " %..4" " ("5 !($444 ".5 !

+*#*6#7",*# / &

& %% Whether speaking/reasoned :

Yes/No G$ $. 24

J+9