High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/3537/2025disposed of

Rinku Sarna And ANR v. State Of Punjab

2025-02-18Mr. Justice Sanjiv Berry3 pages

!"#$!%&'&"() !"#$!%&'&"() !"#$!%&'&"() !"#$!%&'&"()*++ *++ *++ *++ &(,-./(($(" 0!/ +++! & &"(!/ '

1!/'-' . !"#-(23($(" 0!/ +++!'4"($!( '

) 56 +.

.1 .1 .1 .1 /!'!( ) /+.-'0( 02(7$8"% !#"/ 0!4! & &"(!/+ /+2&($!/.&(900 7++ +7-(23+ '+&8: -4 7$8"% !#"//!'4"($!( "++ .1 .1 .1 .1 7+ 7+ 7+ 7+ 6

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

++= ((!?-/! 4''!$3:>!/(!$.-3&8&'&"(>-$&%&> 9&' / !7!/''&@0!/!3:3&> "# 0!4! & &"(!/' @'%(%!>>!$ ($("(3&>3>!@//( '"#//!' @!/!&''-!$9&(' 0!4! & &"(!/'7 3!<-'0!$+ + 6!/(!$ . ! %"-('!> 0' (" $&'4- !$ 0! #"/!'&$ #% ->; /&?"# 0!%'!($'-3;& ' 0 0!4! & &"(!/'44!/!$"( =++3!#"/! 0!>!/(!$ /&> "-/ ($#-/(&'0!$/!<-&'& !3&> 3"($'+ =+

!/$+ + -/&(9 0!%"-/'!"# 0!4/"%!!$&(9'7#">>"@&(9"/$!/@' 4''!$"(++) A 0!&(' ( 4! & &"(-($!/.!% &"(*"#..770' 3!!( #&>!$ #"/ <-'0&(9 "# 0! &;4-9(!$ "/$!/ $ !$ ++=

((!?-/! 4''!$3: 0!>!/(!$-$&%&>9&' / !' >'' &(%'!3!/&(9"+ B & >!$C. !1!/'-'&(,-D&( "+ $ !$ ++ /!9&' !/!$ -($!/ .!% &"(' =7 "# +.+!/''&7..9/7-(23+ + &'7 &( !/ >&7 %"( !($!$ 3: >!/(!$ %"-('!> #"/ 0! 4! & &"(!/' 0 0!4! & &"(!/'7# !/3!&(99/( !$%"(%!''&"("#3&> &( ((!?-/! 70$3!!(44!/&(93!#"/! 0!>!/(!$ /&>

"-/ &( %'! 3!/&(9 "+ . "+ B & >!$ C. ! 1!/'-'&(,-! %+D($/!#!/' ""/$!/' ((!?-/!7((!?-/!= ($" 0!/E&;(&"/$!/'

&( 0&'/!9/$($'-3;& ' 0 0!%0/9!' @!/! #/;!$ "( +++ ! %"( !($' 0 0! 4! & &"(!/ 0$ 3!!(/!9->/>:44!/&(9@& 0"- #&>3!#"/! 0!>!/(!$ /&> "-/ 7 0"@!8!/7"(++=7 0!:%"->$(" 44!/ 3!#"/! 0!>!/(!$ /&> "-/ 08&(93!!( @/"(9>:(" !$ 0!$ ! >!$&(9 ">!/(!$ /&> "-/ %(%!>>&(9 0! 3&> 3"($' ($ &''-&(9 ("(3&>3>! @//( '"#//!' "# 0!4! & &"(!/+ !'-3;& ' 0 0!3'!(%!"# 0!4! & &"(!/@'(" &( !( &"(>' 0!:0$3!!(44!/&(93!#"/! 0!>!/(!$ /&> "-/ 0/"-90"- @& 0"- #&>+ !'-3;& ' 0 7&( 0!;!(@0&>!7!8!( 0!%";4/";&'!0'3!!(!##!% !$3! @!!( 0! -2-

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

#"/! 0! >!/(!$ /&> "-/ ($ #-/(&'0!$ 0!&/ /!<-&'& ! 3&>F'-/! : 3"($' %"('!<-!( " 0! "/$!/ $ !$ ++74''!$3: 0&' "-/ 7 0!4/!'( 4! & &"(&'>>"@!$($ "/$!/ $ !$ ++= ((!?-/! 7 @0!/!3: 0! 3&> "# 0! 4! & &"(!/' @' %(%!>>!$ ($ ("(3&>3>! @//( ' "# //!' @!/! &''-!$9&(' 0! 4! & &"(!/' &'0!/!3: '! '&$!($ 0!&( !/&; 3&> 9/( !$8&$!"/$!/$ !$++&'0!/!3:%"(#&/;!$+ + 0!! & &"(' ($'$&'4"'!

.1 .1 .1 .1 ->'! 0&

I0! 0!/'4!,&(9F/!'"(!$) !' " I0! 0!/!4"/ 3>!) !'

-3-