← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/5573/2017allowed

Saraswati Iron Store And Another v. Dewan Chand Dhanpat Rai Bhatia Mill And Others

2019-09-30Ms. Justice Jaishree Thakur10 pages

  



        



   



 !

"

 #

!$ %!

'!

( ! )!* $ '& '   +' ,,

'!



&    

 

(!  !

-'

'

!"

.&/ 

!

!

0&!

2,"

.&/ 

!

 +,"

.&/ 

&

44444444  

  !,   

 !"

.,, $&

!2&

.5*! (6 (# -

! !&"

* 0

0* 5  

#$ !# 7' /, / *&!

.!, 

*

%& -8

',,8 *8&

!&!

&&

   $'! 2"

,,!

$&

,

$,, *8&

!&!

&&

     $'! 2"

-8

! &&

,,!

&!,2 5& /&

& *

/&8

!*2

!

, &&

% !"



!!!&

   *&!

9 (*0 :!  !  '

! ;' .;

8!

*&

 2

!"

!

*,&8 $,,

8!

*&

! , 2 8!&8 8!

*&

! , 2"

,, $8

,&&



 <  



                      

  

  

          



 

              

   

   

       

   



         

     

 



     

    





 



  



   

       



    

                !

       



 

  

     

!   





 

  

   

     



  



"   



 

                               #

! '! && =    8 '!



&&

,2

 & !2 !>*!

&,&, !& !0 &!

   ,&

-



"

8  <$%& $%   

      !  

 !

 '     

      

   

        

   ( & )*  *

   " # 7'!!"

,,!

!& *

  "



* 8 $''!

 ,

"

*

/ 

! 7'!!"



& ,&, ,2 . +' &!& ' 5 ' $2

&/ /& ' !

5 &!!&

? /*,,2 !

5&

 

7'!!"

& ,&, !& &&

&* 2 *!'!

/& *8' /!, &0 *!

9/*,,2"

 ="

&,&, !&

/&

, -8

&

! '! -8 8!

*& '8',2 &,2& /,* , !8' '& !*&

! '!

!

-'

'

!"

*,

!8

',

! '! !8*& ,,!

!!& $8 ,   2! #

'

!8

* ,  =

!* /,&

,& /& .88!/& 8 &

!&!"

'

, !, *

0*&8 !&!& .

5  

   



   

@    



!   " # $ %   

  #$  

&  '( ( )!    *



!   +

'    ,   

- (  ,    .

 "*/0 1 3   2 0  -   ,  .

!

..

.

0+ %, . 

  , 

..

.

*+ #(  , 3 



 .   

/++

..

.

"/ !,  

 ! .

 0/2 1 / 3   + * /

@

(!

!"

!

0&!

2, *,

!8

',

& !8* '!

!2

!&!

$8 &"

 

/!2

? !8*&

&,&, !& $



!

=.

8/8 &,

!"

'!

 '/ /& % ,

&&

!0*& $ *,& *&

! '! "

*'

$& % * & $', ,8

& !,& *



,"

'& 5& , 8

$ *,& !, &0 8 '

, 8&

& % *!'!

!8*&  ,,2  & <"   

 

 

                         # *,

, !, *

0*&8 !&!& ' !   , 

)  5 

. 5.

!8*

!*2

*8'

$& ,,!

- *

&2

,&8 "

/



,& 8!& /8&

 *&!

 % '/ '!& *,

! '/ , "

'!

"

 '!

*8'

,&8

= +2 $2

,8

, *&!

!&!

= *, ("

&,&, !& *8'



! &,

!"

'!

 '



!"

$! /&"

!&!

,& 8!&"

/8& *&!

, >* $''!

*8'

'/ $&

.

!*,

! '

$

! '!

   '!!"

-8

&&

,2 & !2 !>*!

9 (*0 :!  ! !0 &!

'! "

,28

"

,!&2 &*& /

7'!!"

* $! !&

  



&,&, ,2 . +' &!& ' 5 ' $2

&/ 95 (A B. 

/&

@ @   ' !

 5& &, !,/ >*  !8!&8

'

'



'

$! /& ! ' !/8 '!!

$!

*

' ' !

5 ,*&&

  .!

'"

&,&, !&

- @

!*

,*& '!

/&"

,*&8 * !

,

!*"

8 * 0

2

 %

,2 '!!"

, -8

 =

!

 2! #

'

!8

* /,8 ,  =

!*

,& /&

&"

*8'"

-

=

/! ,*

!&

! !8!&8  8

8!&

%&'%  (  )*'  !#  +&'  +,  -.-*  %+/'&)%'

/&

,&8"

&*& *&!

<   +       

 

       

        

     





         

      

 

   

    

 

 

& !    

   



          

 

    

 

   

       

!



      



   #

* "

,$

$

!

&

,&8 '!

,

"

&!8 !, /!2 $ '"

'

$/!

  "

!, &"

*'

$&"

*,

 

&* &,8"

!2 *,& !

,&8  !, &

% 0*&8 !&!&

  

 



   



..



0+ ' ?

; ,

* ! ',& *&!

 <"        



           



                 ,    

 



  

 

- 

      

   

      



    



           

        



   

     

   



             



      

  !

      



  

   

- 

      

  

   



    

 

 

 "         

     



  

   



        



  

      

  - 

          

          

                  



     # #

,$ !,8

,!,2 ,& $(

8 

  

/

 0/ $'! ?

; ,

* ! ',& *&!

 <$.'               





  

      



   

/       



    0  !



 

/ 1'* $2   +  

  

  

 '   

  - 

     

 3     

        

        !      

 -     !

      

   



     #

% '&"

,, $8 !, "

!

* !

!   90

  

  A! -8



6

&&

,2 & !2 !>*!

=

 

 0 &!

   8



$!

8 &&"

$', * 8  $!

8





,2 & !2 !>*!

& .&/



,&, ,2 . +' &!& 

/&

@ @  "

$'

 !

5 ,*&&

   7'!!"

&,&, !&

- @

!*

,*& '!

/& '"

,



 =  2! #

'

!8

* /,8 =

!*

,& /&

/  ! $,, &!/ '

,2

 ,* 8 '"

 $,, $' - $,&8

&,&, !&

'&

,&& 8!&

8!&8 "

/ -

!"

8 !&

&  

,8 '!

!0 &!

' "

!,/ >*  !8!&8

'



,&, !&

$! /& 

$!

*

(A . +' &*!8 ' !

 5 ,*&&

  7'!!"

!&!

/! ,* &!

/,* , !8'

& !*&

!"

,



#  ="

 2! #

'



!, $,, /,8 =

!*

,& /&"



! 8!&

:&!

' !*"

2 !'

8   & &  5!

&* &,8"

&,&, !& *,& ! &

,&8  !, &"

0*!& ,  * &"



,&8

$&"



!, 7' $ *,&  

/

&&

!&!

= *, (

0*&8"

!,& *

*,

& !   ,9 3  !

, ,

 / ,/& '&"

* & * !"

,

&& ,,!

!,2

8!

*&

, 8

/&  ,& 8 +* '&"

'! '8

!  ' &  &* &,8"

!>*!&

5!&

&,&, !&"

'2 *,& ! '

,&8  

!,"

$' 

!&

' 

! '!

&,&, !& !0 &!

'!

 /!"

 /,* , & !*&

!"

 

!&

8& :&!

' !*"

*8&

!&!

 2 !

,$ ',& .

5   

9 3  $( 3 

!

7'

&!& /$ 

,

-8



!

  8!&

$&"

,&, * 2 &  &* &,8"

8!&

*,& 

!& !,!

'& % /$

/"

*8&

!&! '! 2  &

&,

2"

2'8

!/&

& '

,2

*!



&&8  /, !/

',, '/

!8

!

0 

'23'45'%$  !"

  !   A''!

-8B! & CB

A''!

! , CB